Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: simonj on October 21, 2014, 07:24:48 PM

Title: Primo Scholar
Post by: simonj on October 21, 2014, 07:24:48 PM
Hi Melnet,

New user, my name is Simon. I've been lurking for a while.

I've yet to own or even play a melodeon, but have my heart set on it. I've played the guitar (not very well) for almost 10 years, with a bit of Irish tenor banjo before that. Having had a "barn dance" band for my wedding reception a year ago, I have really been enjoying English folk music, and the melodeon looks like a lot of fun.

Obviously would be looking to buy a D/G melodeon. I know the general advice is "Hohner Pokerwork", but I'm not completely sold on the sound or looks of them. I have seen the Primo Scholar on the Music Room's website, and feel that this could be a good bet, considering TMR's good reputation here.

I've noticed a few people here have said box, and wondered if anyone has any particular opinion of them? Good or bad, your thoughts would really help. Or please tell me if I should really just get a Pokerwork and stop moping! I won't be buying until after Christmas.

Thanks in advance for any advice!

Si.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Anahata on October 21, 2014, 08:00:01 PM
I've never played one, but I must say Jon's demo makes the Primo look and sound a good alternative to the Pokerwork. If you prefer the sound, I'd say go for it!
The only very slight reservation I'd have about that vs. Pokerwork is how well it will keep its value if you ever decide to trade it in for something else in the future.
But hopefully someone who actually owns one will come in with a better informed opinion...
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: TomB on October 21, 2014, 08:26:44 PM

I, neither, know anything about the Primo but I read this comment found on an accordion forum (whilst waiting for more comments from users) :

it`s Chinese and if its a Melodeon (the Primo Scholar) it`ll have Italian Reeds - Imported by the Music Room - the Melodeon is basically the same as a Scarlatti Nero - one step above a basic Scarlatti .. they can be good value if bought used for £100 but at the £400 or so RRP, get a used Hohner instead....... I've not seen a Primo PA . I doubt one would have Italian reeds (their CBAs don`t have as far as I know) , they only seem to do that with the Diatonics where reed response is far more critical.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: squeezy on October 21, 2014, 10:09:44 PM
The Primo Scholar definitely didn't have Italian reeds when I worked for The Music Room - I don't think that's changed ... Sandpipers do use Italian reeds - but they're a league above.  I have to say that I really don't like the build quality on any of the cheapest badged Chinese boxes - and I would advise a used Hohner of equivalent price every time.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: pikey on October 21, 2014, 11:02:31 PM
IMHO you'd be better off with a Black Diamond than a Primo Scholar. They are much better made.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Bob Ellis on October 21, 2014, 11:31:51 PM
I am another who has no experience of the Primo Scholar. I usually recommend new starters to choose either a Pokerwork or an Erica. The only differences between them are cosmetic, the reeds and mechanisms being the same in both instruments. Buying something cheaper as a beginner can be a false economy because cheaper boxes tend to be more difficult to play than Pokerworks and Ericas, which also produce a better sound in my opinion. These are two good reasons why many good musicians stick with these instruments or, in some cases, return to them after having flirted with more expensive boxes.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Helena Handcart on October 22, 2014, 12:18:59 PM
IMHO you'd be better off with a Black Diamond than a Primo Scholar. They are much better made.

If you are really set against getting a Hohner then I would concur with Pikey. I tried out both pretty much side by side in the music tent at Sidmouth while looking for a first box for a friend.  Personally, I found the Black Diamond easier to play and more responsive than the Primo. My friend bought a second hand Erica though, and it is lovely.

Your first melodeon really does have a big impact on your early learning. I settled for a second hand Delicia Popular Deluxe (aka the Decidedly Unpopular) because it was cheap and available.  It was heavy, slow and muffled and for four months I struggled with it, bought my Pokerwork and suddenly everything became easier  :|||:

Old Hohners also have the added advantages of holding their value if you decide to resell although as Bob Ellis points out many players return to Hohners after moving to more expensive boxes, newer cheapie boxes tend to gather dust or get sold on.

Whatever your choice, I hope you have a fun melodeon adventure.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Theo on October 22, 2014, 12:40:35 PM
Also worth considering a Weltmeister 86W.  Post German reunification Weltmeisters are very good, and are a bit more refined than Hohner, but easier to play than any of the Chinese makes.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: fiddleboxdavey on October 22, 2014, 01:58:00 PM
My first button box was a new Weltmeister (model: Monika 406) and I would highly recommend one as a starter instrument. I had mine for 2 years before I could afford a good quality box. I really enjoyed learning on it. It was the best quality instrument that I found for the money. Here's a link to the model I started on-

http://www.thomann.de/gb/weltmeister_monika.htm

This seems to be a good price too...!
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: triskel on October 22, 2014, 02:14:32 PM
I'll add my two ha'porth, which is that I'd consider the Chinese made button boxes/melodeons with Italian (Cagnoni) reeds, like the Primo Scholar, Black Diamond, Scarlatti Nero/Rosso, Dancemaster, McBride's and Wren (etc., which are all pretty-much the same box) to have lots of advantages over new Hohners (which are also made in China but cost a lot more), especially for a beginner - in that they do away with a lot of the problems/issues that new Hohners have always suffered from, seeing that they already have packing under the keys to stop the buttons sinking in and are tuned tighter/sweeter (more to the modern taste, whilst the sound off the Chinese Hohners is very piercing), the wind key is easier to use and they usually have a thumb groove in the edge of the treble keyboard, they also include a gig-bag or case in the price and often have a stop to remove the thirds from the chords.

An older, German made, Hohner may be a different story, but (if going down that route) a beginner would be best-advised to buy one that has recently been fettled to a good playing standard.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: triskel on October 22, 2014, 02:18:23 PM
http://www.thomann.de/gb/weltmeister_monika.htm

This seems to be a good price too...!

Only it doesn't say what key it's in, so most likely it'll be German C/F system...  :(
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: deltasalmon on October 22, 2014, 02:53:43 PM
My first button box was a new Weltmeister (model: Monika 406) and I would highly recommend one as a starter instrument. I had mine for 2 years before I could afford a good quality box. I really enjoyed learning on it. It was the best quality instrument that I found for the money. Here's a link to the model I started on-

I have almost the same experience except a different model. My first box was, like Theo suggested, a Weltmeister 86W and I think its a great box. I've been playing it for just over two years. I have upgraded to a nicer instrument but have no plans yet on getting rid of the 86W yet.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: simonj on October 22, 2014, 04:38:40 PM
Wow, thank you all for the great responses!

There seems to be no escaping the fact that a quality used Hohner will win over a beginner's Chinese box every time. I would assume this means a German-made Hohner though?

And for everyone who has suggested Black Diamond, I have had a look or two at their site, and it does look interesting. If they really are worth ~£500, I would be happy to pay it (just seen Daddy Long Les has a video-review of one). I will also look into Weltmeister, more food for thought.


Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 22, 2014, 05:15:40 PM
There seems to be no escaping the fact that a quality used Hohner will win over a beginner's Chinese box every time.
Definitely, in my opinion.

Quote
I would assume this means a German-made Hohner though?
Not necessarily. The newest Chinese-made Pokerworks and Ericas are absolutely fine. There would appear to be a good quality control now in place which has pretty much solved the initial problems (principally spring breakages) which occurred when the manufacturing was first outsourced to China.

The main criticisms are:
(i) the tuning straight out of the factory can be a bit wild in terms of tremolo. It's worth getting the tuning adjusted after a few months and the instrument can sound much nicer as a result.

(ii) the bellows tape is stupidly thin and flimsy and can wear quickly unless contact with belts and buckles is avoided as far as possible.

(iii) the RH buttons still tend to disappear down the fingerboard holes like cows down old mine shafts.

All these criticisms can also apply to the later German-built instruments too - it's not just a Chinese thing. Fortunately, tuning can be touched up, bellows can be re-taped (use the proper stuff, not insulating tape or duct tape) and button travel can be modified.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: boxer on October 22, 2014, 05:51:20 PM
I have been told that Hohner has its own plant in China that it set up itself and initially staffed with a proportion of experienced European people who helped train the locals in Hohner's methods.

If that's true it may account for the quality of Hohner's Chinese boxes.




 
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: triskel on October 22, 2014, 06:34:45 PM
The newest Chinese-made Pokerworks and Ericas are absolutely fine. There would appear to be a good quality control now in place which has pretty much solved the initial problems (principally spring breakages) which occurred when the manufacturing was first outsourced to China.

I must confess I haven't tried one recently (having been completely put off them), so they may well have improved - let's face it, they should after making them for something like 15 years in China!

But I've always found Hohner springs to be brittle and inclined to break (and usually it's one in the middle of the keyboard that entails removing the axle for half the keys and springs :( ), whilst the biggest problems I experienced with Chinese Hohners were (because of poor quality glue) with the reedblocks falling apart in them when they were delivered - that's much more major than a broken spring...  >:(
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: DaveD on October 22, 2014, 07:51:25 PM
Bought a new Primo Scholar as a second box, after weeks the air button metal strip / spring broke so returned it. Bought a new Dino Baffetti BPII, yes you can't compare the two boxes but the additional expense was well worth it.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: simonj on October 22, 2014, 09:38:44 PM
Oh dear, the two people who have had their hands on the Primo seem less than impressed. I think I will have to suck it up and plump for a Hohner. I do like the ascetics of the Erica, and I suppose I could like the sound (but not the higher cost over a Pokerwork). Such trifling things such as looks and sound should not matter to me, a complete novice, anyway; a box that can be played without too much effort and won't fall to pieces in my hands is probably what I should be looking for.

I really should learn: buy cheap, buy twice. I have had enough dismaying experiences with buying parts cheaply, only to have to chuck 'em and buy the proper kit. I should apply this principle to more things in my life, including melodeon shopping!
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Helena Handcart on October 22, 2014, 10:11:48 PM
Bought second hand an Erica need not cost any more than a Pokerwork and will probably be more comfortable to play for your left wrist. 

At the risk of sounding like a right old fart, if I'd known then what I know now I'd have plumped for the Erica. 

As it is I have a Pokerwork and a collection of leather wrist straps dotted all over the house.

Good luck in your quest for the perfect first box  :||:
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: pikey on October 22, 2014, 10:29:27 PM
That's where you're going wrong, wrist straps should be on your wrist, not dotted  (:)

Btw I prefer a pokerwork to an Erica every time, the bass buttons are much easier to operate, and you soon get used to wearing a leather wrist band / thick watch strap / sweat band.

If I were you, I would either get a decent German made pokerwork, or a new Black Diamond. IMHO Primos are a waste of cash, the button action is appalling, even if the reeds are OKish.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Suppards on October 23, 2014, 06:22:56 AM
Such trifling things such as looks and sound should not matter to me, a complete novice,

Welcome to the asylum Simon.  I am really only a beginner myself, but surely looks and sound are hardly trifling things even if you are a complete novice.  I believe that you have to like your box to be able to enjoy the many hours you're going to be spending working with it. And if you dislike the sound it makes or how it looks that's not going to encourage you to pick up the thing and play it.   

Handling the instrument you are interested in and playing it (even if its only a simple scale) is, I think, a really sound (no pun intended) plan.

Hope you find the box that "floats your boat".  :||: (:)

Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 23, 2014, 08:36:10 AM
My advice can be summed up as "don't buy 1st box new"

if you don't take to this wonderful instrument you'll see a 30% loss on selling on. If you get the bug, you may move on to a higher quality box quite quickly, 5 months in my case. Then you just end up subsidising some other, wiser neophyte.

the second hand market is robust and (barring accidents) you will commonly sell on that starter box for what you paid for it, sometimes even a tad more. Not bad for a year or so's fun?
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: nigelr on October 23, 2014, 08:48:07 AM
Such trifling things such as looks and sound should not matter to me, a complete novice,

Welcome to the asylum Simon.  I am really only a beginner myself, but surely looks and sound are hardly trifling things even if you are a complete novice.
Hi Simon.  Maybe I'm shallow, but looks and sound were pretty much all I was interested in when looking for my first melodeon (Sandpiper Curlew D/G).  I trawled YouTube endlessly looking for a sound I liked as Hohners are a bit too wet for my liking (reeds tuned further apart rather than close together).  However, the Sandpiper range seems to be getting smaller and the prices are creeping up, so if I were making the decision now, I would probably go for a Pokerwork.
Also, I would recommend checking the tuning - ask if the box has low notes or accidentals.  Most of the tutor books are written for boxes with accidentals, so in hindsight I would have gone for this.  Not sure if this helps, but good luck with your search and in joining this select band of nutcases (:)
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: simonj on October 23, 2014, 09:29:12 AM
I was being a little factitious when I mentioned not caring about looks or sound..! Of course I do care about these, otherwise I wouldn't have wasted everyone's time with this thread.

General consensus is Pokerwork then, and I will probably go second-hand too. Like I said, I probably won't buy until after Christmas (buying anything for myself in the three months leading up to Xmas seems selfish for some reason), but I will keep my eyes open and probably jump if the right box comes along. Thanks for the help!  :D

Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Helena Handcart on October 23, 2014, 10:07:31 AM
That's where you're going wrong, wrist straps should be on your wrist, not dotted  (:)

Oh yeah, maybe I was confusing wrist straps with hornpipes...?

simonj - are you able to try out a range of boxes to see what suits you?  It can be a bit daunting going into a music shop to try out an instrument you can't even play yet but it may be possible for friendly melnutter to let you have a go on a couple of melodeons, maybe at a local session, depending on where you live of course.

Also - a further thought - have you looked at the Hohner Morgane?  http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/products_id/4339 - not  my cup of tea but if you really aren't keen on a Pokerwork or Erica it could be a good bet. These come up second hand from time to time. 
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Theo on October 23, 2014, 10:15:47 AM
General consensus is Pokerwork then, and I will probably go second-hand too. Like I said, I probably won't buy until after Christmas (buying anything for myself in the three months leading up to Xmas seems selfish for some reason), but I will keep my eyes open and probably jump if the right box comes along. Thanks for the help!  :D

And look for Ericas too, many people play these very happily.  The bass buttons are just different from a pokerwork, if you've not got used to pokerwork style buttons they will feel perfectly normal.

Tuning - yes Hohners are usually wet tuned, but this can be changed to whatever degree of dry/swing/tremolo that you prefer.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: simonj on October 23, 2014, 10:51:55 AM
Helena, I think I will have to try a few melodeons before buying. The nearest shop that I know f is the Crawley Hobgoblin (I am in Winchester), but that is still a fair trek, and I don't really know what they have there. I should look around for a local session though, thanks.

Theo, I would chose an Erica over a Pokerwork if it weren't for the price difference. Perhaps the second-hand market lessens this gap between the two? I also had no idea the bass buttons were different... I have a lot to learn!
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 23, 2014, 11:06:45 AM
Assuming you have done your homework I wouldn't apply that "after Xmas" too strictly, nor haunt any particular retailer, who'll quickly get to know your budget. You want to be in position to  recognise a bargain when it appears, and pounce on it (carry cash?)

Incidentally my own favourite box was "tried hard" to arrive for Xmas, got to me at 5.45pm, 24th December ::) (pre-order/commission)
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Theo on October 23, 2014, 11:13:28 AM
There's not so much price difference with secondhand Erica and pokerwork.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Helena Handcart on October 23, 2014, 11:16:42 AM
Helena, I think I will have to try a few melodeons before buying. The nearest shop that I know f is the Crawley Hobgoblin (I am in Winchester), but that is still a fair trek, and I don't really know what they have there. I should look around for a local session though, thanks.

Aha - then you're not a million miles from Alton then?  About half an hour's drive or so I reckon.  You will find more melodeons than you can shake a stick at at the Alton Steady Session on the first Tuesday of the month: http://altonsteadysession.wordpress.com/

Edit: if you can make it along to Alton PM me and I'll bring my  Pokerwork for you to try out. If Erica-the-Red is back from the Wendover hospital for poorly melodeons by then I'll bring her along as well.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: invadm on October 23, 2014, 12:52:45 PM
Helena, I think I will have to try a few melodeons before buying. The nearest shop that I know f is the Crawley Hobgoblin (I am in Winchester), but that is still a fair trek, and I don't really know what they have there. I should look around for a local session though, thanks.

if you come to London for Xmas shopping or something  ;D  I'm in north London just off A406. and have large collection of Hohners including erica's and pokerworks so on..you are more than well come to try and play...cattle is on the boil constantly  :||:
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Bob Ellis on October 23, 2014, 02:17:47 PM
cattle is on the boil constantly  :||:

By heck! You must have a big stove!

Altogether now....Boiled beef and carrots, boiled beef and carrots....  >:E
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: malcolmbebb on October 23, 2014, 03:49:32 PM
Helena, I think I will have to try a few melodeons before buying. The nearest shop that I know f is the Crawley Hobgoblin (I am in Winchester), but that is still a fair trek, and I don't really know what they have there. I should look around for a local session though, thanks.
There are two Morris sides near you - Winchester and Wickham, prob others - who would I'm sure be pleased to help.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: invadm on October 23, 2014, 04:04:01 PM
cattle is on the boil constantly  :||:

By heck! You must have a big stove!

Altogether now....Boiled beef and carrots, boiled beef and carrots....  >:E
:D  well.. the tea pot & kettle is on the boil, but BBQ can be arrange too when it stops raining  >:E   I hate this touch screens without a key board & right click for spell check :-\.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: triskel on October 23, 2014, 06:28:32 PM
Theo, I would chose an Erica over a Pokerwork if it weren't for the price difference.

Then you might want to check out The Music Room, because though their Pokerworks (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_562/products_id/641) are priced at £700, they're doing a Special Offer on Ericas (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_562/products_id/642) for £637.50...
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: suparrott on October 25, 2014, 01:25:10 AM
When I was looking for a secondhand Pokerwork or Erica in D/G last year, they were quite scarce, and often what seemed expensive to me at the time.
I had not found Melnet at the time - so was limiting my search to music shops. I did not know how to play - so couldn't test-drive one - and didn't know anyone to ask. I just knew I wanted to learn to play a melodeon!

In the end I ordered a Black Diamond - having never played one. It was £100 cheaper than they are now and so not a bad price for a first box.
I have to say I was really impressed with the customer service and have never regretted my purchase.

It is easy to play and quite well made. I have played it practically every day since I bought it and although I do covet a drier-sounding box now, I can't afford to upgrade yet and so I will stick with the Black Diamond for the foreseeable future.

That's OK. My playing has not out-grown it yet!!  ::)

Hope you enjoy whatever it is you decide to buy!

Suzanne

Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 25, 2014, 08:14:20 AM
It is easy to play and quite well made. I have played it practically every day since I bought it and although I do covet a drier-sounding box now, I can't afford to upgrade yet and so I will stick with the Black Diamond for the foreseeable future.
You don't need to 'upgrade' your instrument just because you want a box with less tremolo. Just get it re-tuned with the tremolo you prefer. It will cost you far less than a new instrument. There are several tuners/repairers inhabiting this forum, including Theo the owner.

More info here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,shops_repairers.html).
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: simonj on October 25, 2014, 12:20:12 PM
Thanks fr the suggestions, Helena I will let you know if I am going to the Alton sesh, sounds like a good evening! I'm actually in Alresford, so even closer to Alton.

Thank you also, Invadm, if I am ever in your neck of the woods, I will give you a shout.

Triskel, I saw the price on the Pokerworks had jumped back up. Interestingly the "Starter Pack" Pokerwork is still priced at £548.18. Wonder if this is just a peculiarity of the Music Room's pricing system, or if they are planning a blow-out Xmas mega sale or something?
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 25, 2014, 01:15:07 PM
I suspect that a phone call "Oh dear, I seem to have just missed your offer .." might see the period extended by enough days to close the sale ;) I don't get a sense of many special purchases going on, basically dealers trying to move stock and stay above water until things improve in the Economy department. Good luck.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: exiletaff on October 25, 2014, 03:23:50 PM
I'm with Wickham Morris but live in Gosport so a little further from Arlesford than Alton. You're welcome to try my Pokerwork if you wish. I've been learning for a little over 18 months and am going to Witney to listen and learn everything I can.
The Pokerwork now has many hours on it and the bellows are just about right. I have listened to lots of more expensive boxes but found nothing I like as much as the Pokerwork. I'm sure it's potential will far exceed my ability although I would now like it tuned and changed to fourth button start so as to play some of the tunes I fancy. How much that would cost I don't know, but it will surely be far cheaper than changing boxes.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: suparrott on October 27, 2014, 11:09:44 AM
You don't need to 'upgrade' your instrument just because you want a box with less tremolo. Just get it re-tuned with the tremolo you prefer. It will cost you far less than a new instrument. There are several tuners/repairers inhabiting this forum, including Theo the owner.

More info here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,shops_repairers.html).

I will ask about that when it gets 'fettled' - which I'd like to get done sometime to even out the tone between the D and G rows.

But - Are there melodeon fettlers out there who will take on non-Hohners and fancy Italian boxes?!   ;)
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Theo on October 27, 2014, 11:36:06 AM
Yes of course.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 27, 2014, 11:50:52 AM
.
   A certain "fettler"  ::) has done English Italian, French
   and Dutch boxes for me .. and all quite nicely, thanks  :|glug
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Lester on October 27, 2014, 11:54:18 AM
Yes of course, I even repair Pi@n0 Acc0rdi0ns.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: deltasalmon on October 27, 2014, 12:21:17 PM
It is easy to play and quite well made. I have played it practically every day since I bought it and although I do covet a drier-sounding box now, I can't afford to upgrade yet and so I will stick with the Black Diamond for the foreseeable future.
You don't need to 'upgrade' your instrument just because you want a box with less tremolo. Just get it re-tuned with the tremolo you prefer. It will cost you far less than a new instrument. There are several tuners/repairers inhabiting this forum, including Theo the owner.

More info here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,shops_repairers.html).

When I took my box to get a quote for it to be retuned for a drier tremolo it was quoted $10/reed. With a 2-voice instrument that's 2 push reeds and 2 pull reeds per button multiplied by 21 buttons came out to $840. I guess there is the argument that if the accordion is in tune to begin with, to dry it you would only need to retune half the reeds but the box alone was worth less than $840 so I thought it would be a better decision to buy a new accordion with the tuning (along with other customizations) that I wanted.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Lester on October 27, 2014, 12:25:46 PM
It is easy to play and quite well made. I have played it practically every day since I bought it and although I do covet a drier-sounding box now, I can't afford to upgrade yet and so I will stick with the Black Diamond for the foreseeable future.
You don't need to 'upgrade' your instrument just because you want a box with less tremolo. Just get it re-tuned with the tremolo you prefer. It will cost you far less than a new instrument. There are several tuners/repairers inhabiting this forum, including Theo the owner.

More info here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,shops_repairers.html).

When I took my box to get a quote for it to be retuned for a drier tremolo it was quoted $10/reed. With a 2-voice instrument that's 2 push reeds and 2 pull reeds per button multiplied by 21 buttons came out to $840. I guess there is the argument that if the accordion is in tune to begin with, to dry it you would only need to retune half the reeds but the box alone was worth less than $840 so I thought it would be a better decision to buy a new accordion with the tuning (along with other customizations) that I wanted.

For that price I would almost be able to do a home visit to tune it for you if I could get a reasonable transatlantic flight price. It seems outrageously expensive to me but may be I'm just cheap cost effective.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Theo on October 27, 2014, 01:28:33 PM
That is just a "go away" price.  I can't imagine anyone paying that rate for tuning.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: suparrott on October 27, 2014, 04:54:52 PM

Roughly how much are we talking about - to tune and adjust the sound of a DG melodeon like mine?
I don't have any idea how much this would be.

Suzanne
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Owen Woods on October 31, 2014, 03:07:33 PM
I would think it would be less than £100.
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: simonj on November 10, 2014, 03:26:57 PM
Quick update. Received my German Pokerwork earlier today and had a quick go before shooting back to work. Managed a very shaky William and Nancy on the treble side (the push-pull, pull-push changeover halfway along is a little confusing), and had a play around the the bass buttons. Looks like it's going to be a lot of fun! Thanks for the suggestions and advice, I'm very glad I went the Hohner route  :||:
Title: Re: Primo Scholar
Post by: Suppards on November 10, 2014, 10:29:07 PM
Good for you Simon. Nice to hear that you've met your box.  I wish you many happy hours together!  (:)  :||:
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal