Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: waltzman on April 11, 2009, 10:55:37 PM
-
I'm tuning a Pokerwork D/G using 'Dedic' tuning. In working through the G row on the fifth button draw E I have tuned one reed + 6.5 cents and the other -6.5 cents which results in a pleasant tremolo to my ear but the resultant note is 5.5 cents flat with both reeds sounding together. I started tuning at the low end of the G row and none of the other (lower) notes have done this. I can't for the life of me figure out why the two reeds sounding together are flat when the reeds are tuned exactly the same distance from the true note. Is there a trick I'm missing?
Michael
-
I'm tuning a Pokerwork D/G using 'Dedic' tuning. In working through the G row on the fifth button draw E I have tuned one reed + 6.5 cents and the other -6.5 cents which results in a pleasant tremolo to my ear but the resultant note is 5.5 cents flat with both reeds sounding together. I started tuning at the low end of the G row and none of the other (lower) notes have done this. I can't for the life of me figure out why the two reeds sounding together are flat when the reeds are tuned exactly the same distance from the true note. Is there a trick I'm missing?
Michael
Are they +/-6.5 cents with the reed block in the box, or outside?
Is the -5.5 cents with both sounding in the box or outside?
Do you get the same tremolo rate with the reeds inside and outside the box?
Ian
-
I'm tuning a Pokerwork D/G using 'Dedic' tuning. In working through the G row on the fifth button draw E I have tuned one reed + 6.5 cents and the other -6.5 cents which results in a pleasant tremolo to my ear but the resultant note is 5.5 cents flat with both reeds sounding together. I started tuning at the low end of the G row and none of the other (lower) notes have done this. I can't for the life of me figure out why the two reeds sounding together are flat when the reeds are tuned exactly the same distance from the true note. Is there a trick I'm missing?
Michael
Are they +/-6.5 cents with the reed block in the box, or outside?
Is the -5.5 cents with both sounding in the box or outside?
Do you get the same tremolo rate with the reeds inside and outside the box?
Ian
All of it was 'in the box'. Actually I looked at it again this morning and noticed that one of the reeds was set with a larger gap than the other and was slower to speak. When I corrected that the note from the two reeds together settled right back on target! If I'm not careful I learn something every day. :)
-
All of it was 'in the box'. Actually I looked at it again this morning and noticed that one of the reeds was set with a larger gap than the other and was slower to speak. When I corrected that the note from the two reeds together settled right back on target! If I'm not careful I learn something every day. :)
Just a small point but after resetting the reed height did you find that you needed to re-tune the reed again? I find that simply moving the reed around can upset the tuning and it'll sometimes need re-doing.
AL
-
All of it was 'in the box'. Actually I looked at it again this morning and noticed that one of the reeds was set with a larger gap than the other and was slower to speak. When I corrected that the note from the two reeds together settled right back on target! If I'm not careful I learn something every day. :)
Just a small point but after resetting the reed height did you find that you needed to re-tune the reed again? I find that simply moving the reed around can upset the tuning and it'll sometimes need re-doing.
AL
Yes it did need retuning after resetting the reed. The interesting thing to me was that a small difference in the reed height changed the way the two reeds interacted so much.
-
Yes it did need retuning after resetting the reed. The interesting thing to me was that a small difference in the reed height changed the way the two reeds interacted so much.
yes - I see what you mean. Another factor of course may well have been the fact that more pressure was needed to make the reed with the larger gap sound. The extra pressure may also have been affecting the 'good' reed perhaps? An interesting conundrum - I'm really interested in this stuff. Wonder if there's a reed tuning course one could go to rather than have to learn ad hoc? ;D
AL
-
As it has been described on this forum in various threads, two reeds sounding together will sometimes "suck" the pitch together, making them sound unison even though they are tuned a few cents apart. This is the reason that it's VERY hard to tune a tremolo with less than about 5 cents - the reeds will suck the pitch to unison. On the other hand, this makes it a little easier to tune bone dry, as you will clearly hear when the reeds close in together. I find that this varies with pressure - if the reeds are not of the best quality, or has been retuned a lot, they will suck together when played loud. I was tuning some reeds a couple of months back that had been tuned up about 40 cents (from the original low pitch - 20's box), and it just did not sound 'right' with tremolo. Then I tuned them all dry (MMM 3 voice) and suddenly the box had a lot more power - they closed in to unison very easily, and 'worked together'.
I find that the same goes when just one of the reeds are less than perfect quality - has been retuned from another note, is not set right in the slot, valve not opening correct etc. etc. The 'strong' reed will have a tendency to suck in the weak reed. This is just what I've experienced - perhaps someone with more theoretic knowledge or practial experience has another point or two on this matter?
-
<snip>I find that the same goes when just one of the reeds are less than perfect quality <snip>
It shows the importance of getting good reeds! Unfortunately it seems that many chinese-made reeds lack manufacturing precision and differences between two reeds producing the same note can make them hard to tune or sound "right". From my limited experience anyways.