There were Baldonis with square keys Ted :
Is that the one that Anders has now? (I think it was being sold on eBay by somebody in Texas a while back.) If so, I was looking at it only a few weeks ago, and was a little surprised to find there are no dividers between those rectangular buttons, so you can finger straight from one button to the next one, unlike Joe Derrane's Walters which has a more normal keyboard with dividers:
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/WaltersJDerrane2.jpg)
I think it likely that both of these instruments were built by the same people (probably Iorio?), whilst the external workmanship of the Superior ones looks different (cruder in fact, rather than "superior"), so they may well have been made by Ottavio Curione instead. For that matter, the rectangles of the buttons on both the Baldoni and the Walters are oriented top to bottom (when the instrument is held in a playing position), whilst on the Superior they are right to left.
Square (or rectangular) buttons seem to have been a fad with American (and other) builders at the time, - I've seen them on chromatics and helikon boxes too.
They both have the 1950's Walters grille and the keyboard is extended unlike the Superior's. The extended keyboard although blank on Joe's, allows space for the Baldoni engraving.
Walters reused that design of grille in the '50s, but the style of these rectangular-buttoned instruments would seem to date them all to the late 1930s.
It's interesting that the Joe Derrane one never got sent to Augusto for engraving, but apparently it was old, unsold stock when the Walters business closed down.
By the way, there is a great picture of Joe's Walters in issue 32, winter 1995 of Concertina & Squeezebox mag.
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/joederrane2.jpg)