Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Mcgrooger on December 18, 2014, 01:05:28 PM

Title: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Mcgrooger on December 18, 2014, 01:05:28 PM
I know it's the season of goodwill and all that but I'm going to have a bit of a moan about something that's been bugging me for a while.
Whenever anyone asks for advice on box keyboard layouts, learning techniques or tunes, playing outside the home key, finding tutors or a host of other questions they're often rewarded (?) with lots of advice.  I often feel how much better it would be if that advice, where appropriate, was backed up with video or sound recordings illustrating how the advice works in practice by those giving it.
I've no problem with those who don't like to post their own playing but have lots of fab advice about repair, or anything like that. Theo's not a prolific tune poster but his contribution to, and running of, this site is invaluable. At the other end of things brilliant players like Anahata and Clive being willing to post tunes month after month including slowed down versions etc. is fantastic.  But there are some (and I'm NOT naming any names) who are happy to tell others how to play but seem reluctant to demonstrate their own playing.  RIght - I'll get me coat.
Rant over. Happy Chistmas and New Year to all. (:) :-[ :|bl ;)
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Stiamh on December 18, 2014, 02:14:04 PM
Not asking much, are you?  >:E

In the old days you'd have had to go to someone for lessons, and probably pay them good money. Or at least corner someone in the folk club or pub and politely ask for advice, at the risk of being told to take a hike.

Now in the internet age lots of people give advice freely - but it seems that's not enough. To be entitled to give advice freely you think they should equip themselves, take the time to make videos, have a YouTube or similar account, and post clips to prove to you that they know what they are talking about?

 (:) Just playing devil's advocate there. I know what you mean - I do wonder myself whether the pontificators really know what they are talking about. And sometimes I find examples of the playing of people who post on this and other forums and say to myself, ah, I needn't take too much notice of their opinion in future!  :|glug
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Grape Ape on December 18, 2014, 03:27:27 PM
I have been on this site for two years and have found most of advice received here to be of great value. It does sometimes bother bother me when offered opinions or speculations in place of the answers I seek, though.

What is funny to me is the status of "respected sage" I have obtained. Having only been playing for a couple of years, I should be neither respected nor elevated to the status of sage, at least not insofar as melodeons are concerned. Most of my posts end with a "?" and are not intended to be taken as advice by anyone!
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on December 18, 2014, 03:59:30 PM
Respected sage you are Frank, and there's no getting out of it.  8)
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Anahata on December 18, 2014, 04:07:44 PM
What is funny to me is the status of "respected sage" I have obtained.

Based purely on number of posts, not quality, of course.
The forum software lets the owners chose the designations for number of posts; perhaps "Hero" and "respected sage" should be replaced with "garrulous blabbermouth" and similar for the high volume categories so there's less to be proud about  (:)

On concertina.net you're a "heavyweight boxer" over some number of posts.
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Theo on December 18, 2014, 04:08:53 PM
The category names can easily be changed, to something more lighthearted perhaps?
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Anahata on December 18, 2014, 04:14:13 PM
Thanks, by the way, to McGrooger for the honourable mention. It is nice to know that one's efforts on YouTube etc. are appreciated or useful, and I feel a bit guilty for failing to post much recently, and not always for good reasons.

Season's greetings to all!  :|glug :|glug :|glug

Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: arty on December 18, 2014, 05:07:35 PM
McGrooger, I don't want to disagree with you because I see exactly where you are coming from.

Speaking as someone who was an absolute beginner 2 1/2 years ago, I have asked several questions on many topics here and got all manner of differing replies from good hearted and helpful people. Advice that didn't really help me has been given at times and I feel that trying out those things, only to find them unhelpful, has also helped me to learn. More often than not though, I have had queries answered very positively and quickly. I have never felt that someone kind enough to answer my question has been 'tutoring' me, it is more that they have been sharing their experience and trying to help a fellow, enthusiastic learner. And lets face it, probably 99% of the regular people on this site are still learning. Even people like Squeezy, who most of us look up to, will learn something every time they pick up the box - and by the way, he's been very helpful to me with advice in the past, so thank you!

On one occasion, I asked for help about 'how to make the basses sound more interesting', and I was astounded the next day, to find that Ollie had made a video and posted it in response to my question, showing me and others how he did it. I must have watched that video 50 times and it has helped me greatly I feel. How generous is that! Nowadays, I find that my greatest learning tool is listening to and watching really good players on You Tube, over and over again.

I think, if anyone goes to the trouble of trying to help a fellow player, they do that with a good heart and I thank all those who have given me advice, good and bad, for helping. It's one of the things that makes this site so brilliant, that and the limericks of course!
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: squeezy on December 18, 2014, 05:37:06 PM
It seems like a very strange thing to have a rant about myself.  Before melodeon.net we had to buy Mally's books, pay to go to concerts and workshops, if you were really lucky you might find someone nearby who would be willing to give you a lesson or two.  If you had a question about the instruments you either had to go to a local session and politely ask the old bloke who played after making the effort of getting to know him or maybe you would phone up Hobgoblin and bother them for a bit.

It's unbelievable quite how much easier getting the information is since the development of the internet - and especially here on melodeon.net which is frankly one of the best and most generous community of enthusiasts that I've ever come across.

With that in mind - I would say that we are all very lucky for the information we receive when asking a question about anything.  Recording a video and then uploading it to YouTube is fairly time consuming compared to writing a couple of paragraphs.  If we have had videos from some particularly generous people in the past then that's absolutely great ... but I think assuming that somehow it's an entitlement is taking it a step too far ... and specifically shaming people who are tutors (presumably who are trying to make a bit of money out of their expertise) is absolutely ridiculous ... why on Earth should they give away their skills for nothing?

You wouldn't go on an accountancy forum (if such a thing exists) and get cross if they don't do your tax return for you for nothing.  As I said at the beginning ... we're very lucky with what we've got today ... and we should all be gracious about it.
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Mcgrooger on December 18, 2014, 06:01:07 PM
Squeezy, I certainly didn't set out to shame anyone. And I'm not criticising anyone who charges for tutoring. I think we box players are tremendously fortunate to have this forum and players, especially of your calibre, willing to give advice!  I've got plenty of opportunity to be able to put anything you say into context by listening to your CDs, seeing you live etc.  There are others who offer advice on the forum though who I've rarely or never had the opportunity to hear anywhere. They're probably great players too - it'd be nice to hear 'em.
I've probably learned more from you than from anyone in all the time I've been playing - by listening to you play!
Think I'd better shut up now as I seem to be upsetting people which I regret.
P.s. I've edited my OP and removed any reference to tutors as it was in danger of being misunderstood.
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: squeezy on December 18, 2014, 06:30:02 PM
Thanks for the kind words McGrooger (and Arty ... yes I am still learning all the time which is why it's still a fascinating instrument.)

I'm not upset ... sorry if it came across too prickly ... I am simply genuinely perplexed by the first post in this thread.  Maybe I've missed something and people are now entitled to expect in-depth video evidence of a bit of advice they gave on a forum - in which case I'm lagging far behind in the technology and etiquette. 

Either that or I must have mis-read your opening post as meaning you were annoyed that people didn't do this and that certain members offering themselves as tutors were particularly guilty of not providing these videos you would like after they've given some advice.

To be honest ... I'm still mis-reading it that way and I'm still perplexed.

Edit: except the tutors bit which you've now changed. So I've crossed that bit out.
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: xgx on December 18, 2014, 07:29:56 PM
(...) But there are some (and I'm NOT naming any names) who are happy to tell others how to play but seem reluctant to demonstrate their own playing.

That's a little too Troll-like for me, especially the bit about  "I'm NOT naming any names". 

In common with others on here I've taken advice and help, without questioning the source validity, tried it to see if it works for me and if it enhances my knowledge and playing then it's a good 'un!

Thanks McScrooge for the opportunity to say THANK YOU to those who've freely shared their knowledge and expertise, Cheers folks!
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Grape Ape on December 18, 2014, 09:05:00 PM
What is funny to me is the status of "respected sage" I have obtained.

Based purely on number of posts, not quality, of course.
The forum software lets the owners chose the designations for number of posts; perhaps "Hero" and "respected sage" should be replaced with "garrulous blabbermouth" and similar for the high volume categories so there's less to be proud about  (:)

On concertina.net you're a "heavyweight boxer" over some number of posts.

Hey! Thanks Anahata! I was thinking more along the lines of "relative beginner with more questions than answers" but if "garrulous blabbermouth" works for you.......

And let's redirect a bit this thread.  There is no better place for answers to ALL THINGS MELODEON THAN MELNET. PERIOD THE END. For some of us, it is the ONLY place.  There, per another thread you've all got me shouting then. Without melnet I would be lost.
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: pikey on December 18, 2014, 10:47:57 PM
I happily invite anyone on this forum to watch my numerous Youtube videos, which include a slowed down version of a well known tune....

http://youtu.be/oeTZc7rSnK4
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 18, 2014, 11:28:18 PM
The category names can easily be changed, to something more lighthearted perhaps?

I liked being a greybeard ... about equivalent of a lance-corporal .. and lasted about as long in the battlefleld  ::)

[ed] @Pikey - several (..five, at one time) of my friends are Actuaries. The job for people who find accountancy too exciting!
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: pikey on December 18, 2014, 11:47:04 PM
Is there really an Accountancy forum😫
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: squeezy on December 18, 2014, 11:49:15 PM
Is there really an Accountancy forum😫

I sincerely hope not!
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: summerstars on December 18, 2014, 11:58:52 PM
Is there really an Accountancy forum😫
As always, google "is your friend"

http://www.ukbusinessforums.co.uk/forums/accounts-finance.55/

Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Broadland Boy on December 19, 2014, 12:30:14 AM
Re reading the OP perhaps the sense in which it should be read is that with those that are video or soundcloud posters or 'recording artistes' then it is easy to grasp their meaning by the way they can be seen / heard to play but it is not so easy when the poster hasn't got a recorded 'footprint' to refer to??

Its not only the playing side where folks are free with their advice and info, some of the most fascinating items on Melnet and Youtube are from the box wranglers who have posted items on diagnosis, repair, tuning, customisation etc. in clear and often illustrated ways so that the inexperienced of us stand a chance of understanding or fixing something without having to send their box away.

To all* those who post their advice or experience and music for the benefit of the rest of us, Thanks  :|glug

* I must in all concience exclude from this whoever it was posted that link to Nellie the Bl*@dy Elephant the other day, If I can't get it out of my head by next Thurs then its a DIY Black & Decker lobotomy for me  :o and much as I enjoy your recordings Mr McGrooger, if it comes to this you will just have to imagine the procedure, Bogside-on-Bure is only just coming to terms with handcranked moving pictures :||:
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: stevejay on December 19, 2014, 03:48:02 AM


On one occasion, I asked for help about 'how to make the basses sound more interesting', and I was astounded the next day, to find that Ollie had made a video and posted it in response to my question, showing me and others how he did it. I must have watched that video 50 times ...

Can you point me to that link?
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: arty on December 19, 2014, 06:24:44 AM


On one occasion, I asked for help about 'how to make the basses sound more interesting', and I was astounded the next day, to find that Ollie had made a video and posted it in response to my question, showing me and others how he did it. I must have watched that video 50 times ...

Can you point me to that link?

Hopefully, you'll find it here stevejay: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,15000.msg184875.html#msg184875
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: pikey on December 19, 2014, 07:58:15 AM
"I'm struggling with my accruals at Christmas. Can any other accountant advise on what I should do ? "

 >:E
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 19, 2014, 08:03:11 AM
It (they..) really do exist, Kevin. Do a quick google  >:E
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: arty on December 19, 2014, 08:12:46 AM
"I'm struggling with my accruals at Christmas. Can any other accountant advise on what I should do ? "

 >:E

Probably got your straps too tight Pikey.  :o
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Mcgrooger on December 19, 2014, 09:08:21 AM
Re reading the OP perhaps the sense in which it should be read is that with those that are video or soundcloud posters or 'recording artistes' then it is easy to grasp their meaning by the way they can be seen / heard to play but it is not so easy when the poster hasn't got a recorded 'footprint' to refer to??

BB thank you for that - that's all and exactly what I meant in the OP - wish I'd put it as nicely. (:)
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Broadland Boy on December 20, 2014, 12:43:39 AM
that's all and exactly what I meant in the OP - wish I'd put it as nicely. (:)

Hindsight is the only precise science  and no charitable act goes entirely unpunished ...................

Now, where's that "unsend after 24 hours" button gone  ;D
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: Sebastian on December 20, 2014, 05:06:03 AM
there are some … who are happy to tell others how to play but seem reluctant to demonstrate their own playing
Yes. I was often wondering about this, too. Sometimes I just want to look at and listen to what someone is only writing about, so that I could put it into perspective for myself.
Title: Re: Show us yer chops!
Post by: The Blues Viking on December 20, 2014, 04:12:49 PM
But there are some (and I'm NOT naming any names) who are happy to tell others how to play but seem reluctant to demonstrate their own playing.  RIght - I'll get me coat.

Then of course there are those of us who lack the ability to make videos. As I did until recently, when I got this old Mac with a built-in camera...but I find that I still lack the inclination. And the ego. And the talent.

TBV
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal