Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Matt on January 13, 2015, 12:49:27 AM
-
Hello hello,
Firstly, my apologies if this question has already been answered -- I have searched around on this matter, but unearthed little. (But then, I'm told I'm pretty bad at finding things. Great at losing them, mind).
Anyroad, I'm currently engaged in the predictable folly of attempting to build a miniature concertina, and I'd like to voice it with a nice new set of melodeon-type reeds.
My first port-of-call was Charlie at CGM, who has sold me an accidental reed or two in the past, but apparently many the pitch-pairs I enquired after are not to be found amongst his stock.
So, to eventually get around to my question (sorry), does does anyone have a good list of (other) places or persons one might successfully purchase reeds from, either stockists like Charlie, or the manufacturers themselves? I don't even know who the manufacturers are.
Also, does anyone know if any of the manufactures are likely to entertain the idea of supplying me with the measly 12 reed-plates my miniature (single-voiced) instrument requests?
Many thanks, sorry for being a bit of a gasbag and all.
Matt
-
It is quite a frequent question, and there aren't any easy answers!
Most of the Italian reed makers have a minimum order quantity of reed sets.
Some people have found the Czech company Harmonikas to be helpful.
I've bought reed sets in the past from Michael Usui at Irish Dancemaster in Florida.
PM also sent.
Cheers,
Tom
-
Your easiest solution may be to retune close melodeon pitch-pairs, or get somebody to retune them for you.
-
Hi Triskel,
Charlie at CCM said something similar -- he advised that one might buy the closest available pitch sharp of the note required, then adding solder to the tip of the reed to flatten it.
I suppose this keeps the alteration reversible, which is handy, as I'm bound to balls it up the first few dozen tries.
Cheers,
Matt
-
Had you considered using real concertina reeds for your instrument ? Concertina reeds come as individual reeds so almost any odd pair combination is possible. Most long established concertina repairers have boxes full of second-hand reeds; mostly from "too expensive for commercial repair" Lachenal concertinas.
What peculiar note combinations do you need ?
Inventor.
-
Hi Triskel,
Charlie at CCM said something similar -- he advised that one might buy the closest available pitch sharp of the note required, then adding solder to the tip of the reed to flatten it.
I suppose this keeps the alteration reversible, which is handy, as I'm bound to balls it up the first few dozen tries.
Cheers,
Matt
Solder weighting is handily reversible, but the original dimensions of a reed tongue are chosen carefully (within limits of cost and production engineering!) The solder weighted reeds I've done have been ok to plug a gap, but they're not the best sounding reeds. (Though they also weren't top quality reeds to start with.)
On tuning in general, taking it slowly and carefully there no reason why anyone shouldn't do decent work from their first reed.
Tom
-
Inventor, I rather prefer the sound of melodeon/accordion reeds to concertina ones, and their overall availability (this thread notwithstanding) is an advantage when I break them. I also dislike the thought of making the fussy little slots concertina reeds are usually poked into. Nevertheless, the ability to mix and match is enviable.
As you ask, the scheme under discussion was to build a small 12 button box to play in one of either D or E harmonic minor. The reed combinations for the E harmonic minor box would be:
LHS: ( E-3 / B-3 ) , ( C-4 / D#-4 ) , ( E-4 / F#-4 ) , ( G-4 / A-4 ) , ( B-4 / C-5 ) , ( D-5 / E-5 )
RHS: ( C-5 / B-4 ) , ( E-5 / D#-5 ) , ( G-5 / F#-5 ) , ( B-5 / A-5 ) , ( D-6 / C-6 ) , ( E-6 / E-6 )
Charlie didn't mention which reed pairs he couldn't supply out of those I asked for, but he indicated that there isn't much demand for piccolo reeds, so he doesn't stock many of those.
(Incidentally, I believe on a piano "A4" is the one pitched at 440Hz, if I'm not mistaken (I often am). Is this the same system used for naming melodeon octaves?)
Tom, I agree, tuning a reed is a careful science not a dark art. I've obtained predictable results in the past through careful filing. Unfortunately, however, not always on the right reed.
I had anticipated the ballsing-up of the sort of big changes under discussion however, because a semitone seems like rather a lot of careful filing.
-
Incidentally, I believe on a piano "A4" is the one pitched at 440Hz, if I'm not mistaken (I often am). Is this the same system used for naming melodeon octaves?
Yes, A4 is A=440 Hz. The octave numbering system is the same for any instrument, including melodeons.
... tuning a reed is a careful science not a dark art. I've obtained predictable results in the past through careful filing.
I would say that tuning is a mixture of (1) careful science, (2) careful filing and other reed/valve manipulation backed up by experience, (3) a good ear and (4) being prepared to disregard the careful science and rely on the good ear when carrying out the final test: reiterative playing, listening and making minute adjustments as necessary.
It's the combination of all these things which makes tuning not exactly a dark art, but a very fine craft. Tuning free-reed instruments is pretty much always a compromise, given all the potential variables which affect pitch during the course of playing, especially bellows pressure and rate of change of bellows pressure, and to a lesser extent, ambient temperature and humidity.
The science/acoustics/physics (whatever you want to call it) is always there, but usually the parameters become so complex and interactive (and hence almost impossible to quantify) that ultimately it is best to rely on the ear/brain combination, which is extraordinarily good at analysing and concluding whether the tuning is right or wrong in a real-world playing situation.
-
If you only need a small number of reeds you could try and contact either a repair workshop or an accordion builder that you know need to order new reeds from time to time. Of course you might end up paying a little more, but it's an easier and most often faster way to get hold of a small number reeds from an Italian manufacture, and might just be the only way to get a small number of reeds from top reed manufactures like Binci or Ciccarelli.
I've for instants got hold of small numbers of Binci reeds from Aaro Luukinen in Finland and via third person getting hold of some Circcarelli reeds through Van der Aa. And most likly some one of the melodeon repairers on this forum could help you out if they are about to make an order anyway.