Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: vielleuse on April 25, 2009, 02:15:00 AM

Title: Good point from my insurer
Post by: vielleuse on April 25, 2009, 02:15:00 AM
Cor, it's been ages since I've looked in here... Anyway, I've just had the renewal reminder notice through from my insurer. Enclosed with this is a short leaflet warning that recent big changes in exchange rates have altered the value of instruments significantly and we may need to adjust the amount of cover in order to be able to replace the instrument if necessary.

It hadn't occurred to me that all the recent economic turmoil would have affected the value of my instruments, but thinking about it of course my Castagnari originates from a Euro area. Well it would have been a lire area at the time because it's second-hand, but you get my drift.

I'm going to give the insurance company a ring, but before I do, can anyone comment on what the second-hand market is like at the moment? Has it changed much? It looks to me as though new instruments have gone up a lot, but what about second hand ones?
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: pete /acorn on April 25, 2009, 08:23:20 AM
Hi,
I brought this up previously on this forum but a point to be careful of is are you insured like for like or new for old.
When we went through things with broker we changed insurers,instruments covered on household policy,to AXA,
their Exclusive policy covers personal items with value up to £10000,previously only items up to £2500 covered.
I think this may only be available through broker.
This policy was also cheaper and less hassle because previously photos etc had to be submitted.

Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: vielleuse on April 25, 2009, 12:21:32 PM
Actually I'm not entirely sure of the difference between like-for-like and new-for-old. Because mine was second-hand originally I've always had it insured for what it would cost me to buy another Benny or similar second hand* (as opposed to new) - have I been doing it wrong? The leaflet says I'm insured for new-for-old.

*I suppose what I need to establish is what that is now.
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: pete /acorn on April 25, 2009, 12:48:19 PM
Hi,
My interpretation of new for old has always meant new replacement and in fact my insurers have always asked for new replacement cost and actually recently have asked for copy of an advert etc to verify.Obviously because of recent price hikes and that melodeons and accordions are probably not their usual items for insurance it is always best to give them as much info as possible,and have photos on file of your own box or boxes then there is little for them to argue about if claim to be made.
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: Andy Next Tune on April 25, 2009, 05:16:13 PM
The challenge is valuing older instruments which cannot be replaced 'as new', such as my Hohner Liliput or Lachenal Anglo concertina.

I try to price an equivalent replacement 2nd hand instrument if I wanted to buy one today. But is that the right approach? Should I be looking for the nearest new equivalent?

Andy
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: HallelujahAl on April 26, 2009, 09:23:06 AM
Quote
I try to price an equivalent replacement 2nd hand instrument if I wanted to buy one today. But is that the right approach? Should I be looking for the nearest new equivalent?

Andy, I'm not at all sure that the 'new to you' argument is necessarily one that is appreciated by the insurance industry. It's one that bothers me a bit as well as I have a number of concertinas (Lachenals & Wheatstone) that can obviously only be replaced by another vintage model. I'm going to contact my insurer Monday as I've been bothered for a while about this issue.
AL
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: Howard Jones on April 26, 2009, 10:21:23 AM
I took my instruments off my household insurance, because they wouldn't insure them at all for professional use.  If you get paid for playing, even only occasionally, you might find that you're not covered.  Insurance is a contract of "utmost good faith", which means that if you don't tell the insurers something which might be relevant then they don't have to pay out.

I now insure them through Musicians Insurance Services, who have a specialist policy for folk instruments and seem to understand what's involved.  I had to provide evidence of current prices or get valuations when I first insured them, but since then they seem to be happy to accept my own reassessments of value.  Most importantly, they've paid out when I've had to claim.
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: theSmoiler on April 29, 2009, 08:05:27 PM
I too have used Musicians Insurance Services, and just had to tell them what my assessment was of the worth of each - no hassle.

Diane
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: vielleuse on May 13, 2009, 04:42:25 PM
Time to reassess my level of cover then, as my insurer (Brass Band Insurance Services) says I should be looking at cost of a NEW replacement model. So I'm trying to look up prices of a new Castagnari Benny, but they seem to vary wildly from £1795 (Sounds Interesting) to £2950 (accordion.co.uk)!!!! That's a pretty big difference... Any advice?
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: pete /acorn on May 13, 2009, 06:44:09 PM
Hi,
I think you will find that the sounds interesting site is very old,I believe ,I may be wong, that it had something to do with John Turner before he took over Music Room ,you will not find new boxes now for that price.
Hope this helps
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: vielleuse on May 13, 2009, 07:05:01 PM
Aha! That also accounts for the low prices on thriftmusic I think.
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: Andy in Vermont on May 14, 2009, 01:01:27 AM
My understanding has been that instruments should be insured at the amount of money it would take to _replace_ them, not their value on the used market, unless that value is at a premium level higher than new instruments.
-Andy
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: ganderbox on May 14, 2009, 10:04:19 AM
Aha! That also accounts for the low prices on thriftmusic I think.

Yes,  I too was amazed by their prices until I noticed the website was last updated in July 2007.
I have also tried emailing them a couple of times, with no result.
Are they still in business?
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 14, 2009, 08:15:59 PM
Aha! That also accounts for the low prices on thriftmusic I think.

Yes,  I too was amazed by their prices until I noticed the website was last updated in July 2007.
I have also tried emailing them a couple of times, with no result.
Are they still in business?
I spoke to Jon Fitzgerald, owner of Thrift Music, at Melodeons and More in Mendlesham at the end of March. Yes, he is still in business - just, but things are very slack and hard for him, and I wouldn't be surprised if he stops dealing in melodeons altogether and concentrates on his guesthouse business. He is the UK agent for Bernard Loffet's melodeons, but I think he is finding that most people are ordering  direct from Bernard himself. I believe he has similar experiences with people who want Hohners and Castagnaris too.
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: vielleuse on May 15, 2009, 04:24:12 PM
That doesn't surprise me in these days of internet shopping - but the Castagnari website doesn't have an option to buy from it, so how are people doing it?
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: Andy in Vermont on May 16, 2009, 03:54:05 PM
That doesn't surprise me in these days of internet shopping - but the Castagnari website doesn't have an option to buy from it, so how are people doing it?

Write an email, get a quote, send a check.
-Andy
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: Hello on May 27, 2009, 04:29:57 PM
Aha! That also accounts for the low prices on thriftmusic I think.

Yes,  I too was amazed by their prices until I noticed the website was last updated in July 2007.
I have also tried emailing them a couple of times, with no result.
Are they still in business?
I spoke to Jon Fitzgerald, owner of Thrift Music, at Melodeons and More in Mendlesham at the end of March. Yes, he is still in business - just, but things are very slack and hard for him, and I wouldn't be surprised if he stops dealing in melodeons altogether and concentrates on his guesthouse business. He is the UK agent for Bernard Loffet's melodeons, but I think he is finding that most people are ordering  direct from Bernard himself. I believe he has similar experiences with people who want Hohners and Castagnaris too.


Perhaps he could combine the two and become the first melodeon brothel. Spend the night with a melodeon of your choice with no risk of any STD's.  There is however a very real risk of catching MAD for which there is no cure!
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: Owen Woods on May 27, 2009, 06:07:11 PM
Aha! That also accounts for the low prices on thriftmusic I think.

Yes,  I too was amazed by their prices until I noticed the website was last updated in July 2007.
I have also tried emailing them a couple of times, with no result.
Are they still in business?
I spoke to Jon Fitzgerald, owner of Thrift Music, at Melodeons and More in Mendlesham at the end of March. Yes, he is still in business - just, but things are very slack and hard for him, and I wouldn't be surprised if he stops dealing in melodeons altogether and concentrates on his guesthouse business. He is the UK agent for Bernard Loffet's melodeons, but I think he is finding that most people are ordering  direct from Bernard himself. I believe he has similar experiences with people who want Hohners and Castagnaris too.


Perhaps he could combine the two and become the first melodeon brothel. Spend the night with a melodeon of your choice with no risk of any STD's.  There is however a very real risk of catching MAD for which there is no cure!

That is an incredibly good idea :P
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: Ellie on May 27, 2009, 06:11:19 PM
Quote from: Bisoronic Bloke
Perhaps he could combine the two and become the first melodeon brothel. Spend the night with a melodeon of your choice with no risk of any STD's.  There is however a very real risk of catching MAD for which there is no cure!

 :o ;D  :|||: (don't need any words to express my sentiments here!)
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 27, 2009, 07:27:35 PM
:o ;D  :|||: (don't need any words to express my sentiments here!)
So why did you use nine of them?  ;D  ;)
Title: Re: Good point from my insurer
Post by: Ellie on May 27, 2009, 08:36:39 PM
Some people round here are too clever by half...  ::)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal