Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Chris Brimley on February 10, 2015, 12:07:45 PM

Title: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 10, 2015, 12:07:45 PM
Someone talked to me recently about blues harps, and it sort of sent me thinking - Cajun players have the odd flat 7 note in their repertoire like blues harp players, but actually not much else.  So......  why not design a layout for a D/G/Acc box specifically for playing the blues?  It would be dead easy to program a Roland FR18, and you could switch in a trice to the blues layout.

Chris R, I think maybe you're the guy to do this, but of course, other contributions very welcome.  So, picture a D12/G13/12Acc 18 bass layout - over to you! (Sorry to do this to you!).  Mebbe not everything on the pull though?)
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 10, 2015, 12:33:20 PM
You need at least rows a semi tone apart - and with a repeating pattern so that you can roll the scales without undue thought. The F# blues scale rolls on a D/G, all pull and a sort of 'knights tour' or 'L" movement up the keyboard. I've put this on here several times

To experiment try medodeon explorer http://chrisryall.net/chords/ and select (or type in) box you want to try, set up 'blues scale' which is under the pentatonics, try various key centres for what works

Attached is C#D 2-row screen shot with B blues selected. Looks promising to me. Apush D/Erock F/F#rock and back onto B. It's mostly push (:)

But the test is that it is fluid in play as blue is not about thinking the notes! Another fruitful area would be to explore layouts with easily available minor pentatonic scales (basis of da Blues ;)) - the #4 can then be dabbed in as you feel the need for it. Though I'd miss the occasional E/F/F# clash were these notes not same way - a classic motif!  8)
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: brazilian.BOX on February 10, 2015, 12:41:55 PM
Very creative idea, to think in a box to follow blues scales... the sound can get very innovative, following a blues trio for example. Nice.
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 10, 2015, 12:44:28 PM
Another thought is about getting at the 'altered' scale - which (based on C) runs C Db Eb Eb Gb Ab Bb C. In practical melodeon terms these scales tend to lie a tri-tone apart. So that's commonly cross rowing between G and C# rows on my C#DG.

The catch 22 in this is that meodeon rows are diatonic, whereas blues scales are based on three dominant tonal chords and so classed as 'synthetic'. But our 'built in' F# blues shows there is a point of meeting, albeit by abandoning left end chords.

Ukebert has been looking at diatonic scales a tone apart, and also a 'Jazz Ceilidh' movement - be interested in his experience?

Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 10, 2015, 12:52:23 PM
Wow, sorry not to appreciate what you've already done!  My concept however was (probably foolishly?) based on the D/G two-row basics, because that's what I and many others know, rather than a semitone layout.  Is my basic idea not going to work, do you reckon?  Or amongst what you've sent, is this covered?
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 10, 2015, 01:07:03 PM
For a D/G the truly easy scale is F# as per above. As it is the relative minor of A one of its modes (3rd) is A major pentatonic with a bebop C/C# in there. As such it plays nicely over A7 chord, very commonplace in D melodies, but not very 'out' and - well it gets quite sameish if you use it too much.

Em pentatonic is a very good basis as most of it  lies naturally on the 2 rows. Just omit F# and C (or C# thinking dorian) and rock the D/E.

Stick in the #4=Bb passing note and you are there. That's why I like my Bb acc as pull - the rest of this scale is pull. You can ten improvise same scale over A, or use A mixolydian (whole D row)  or A dorian (whole G row) depending on the style of the blues.

It's V=B lets it down a bit but provided you have Eb acc on push to get a B major right end, it passes muster.

[ed] off to work. Have sent you a PM 8)
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: baz parkes on February 10, 2015, 01:43:04 PM
The 8) blues ain't nothin' but a fairly average box player gettin' confused... 8)

Baz...fresh from watching Blues Brothers 2000 which I'd always dismissed as a lame follow up until I was reminded of that last 20 minute jam... :Ph
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 10, 2015, 01:47:06 PM
I've been toying for a while with the idea of converting one of my knackered previously cherished 1040s to "Kniri" tuning  http://www.kniri.ch/de/bluesaccordion.aspx (http://www.kniri.ch/de/bluesaccordion.aspx), but not yet found the time to give it a try.

Graham
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 10, 2015, 01:57:07 PM
Some very interesting stuff here, so thanks - but not quite what I was thinking of, which is based on the D/G basic concept:  never mind other keys, if you stick to D and G and a sensible 18 bass layout , how would you arrange row 3 on the RHS to play the blues?  Or is this a silly question?
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: rees on February 10, 2015, 02:53:47 PM
Blues on a standard D/G layout in the key of A major or F# minor. You have blue notes G and C natural. Never done me no harm.
Chris will (no doubt) post the diagram for this.
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: The Blues Viking on February 11, 2015, 12:40:40 AM
I've been toying for a while with the idea of converting one of my knackered previously cherished 1040s to "Kniri" tuning  http://www.kniri.ch/de/bluesaccordion.aspx (http://www.kniri.ch/de/bluesaccordion.aspx), but not yet found the time to give it a try.

Graham

I've asked here before regarding the Kniri tuning, http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11718.msg144797.html#msg144797

... but as I recall I didn't get a response. So I'll ask again:

Anyone have any experience with, or opinion of, this tuning?

TBV

Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 11, 2015, 09:26:00 AM
Opinion? Well, quick look, it looks very interesting blues-wise. 

   http://www.kniri.ch/de/bluesaccordion.aspx

For a start you get the standard major blues G7 D7 and C7 chords, the latter on draw, and mixolydian scales on G,C. Both standard blues technique. On D they tend to play more far out things. 'altered' isn't there. It's same notes/mode of C# melodic and the notes don't do that far. (would be squeaky anyway) but plenty to go for.

The flattened notes seem to be in upper octaves. That might work too - "out" notes are often played there, essentially as extensions to the base chord. it might not be quite blues as we know it, but "there ain't not rules 'xcept don't play a major 3 on a minor chord"

Minor blues are catered for on the pull. It'd be a challenge to sort a bass end for it (unisonorics?) but I like the way you can play in C, F or Bb in the higher octaves.  Very clever.

Thus endeth the theory stuff, but as Baz suggests, blues is more about attitute! Had a great night on the Shropshire canal once 1989 with a whiskery canal bargee. i was on a DG Lilly and he liked playing guitar in E*. Somehow it worked :o. (nowadays I'd simply invite him to put capo on fret 1)!!

[edit] PM sent!
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 11, 2015, 09:59:43 AM
Can't find the F# one here Rees, but here's the equivalent D blues scale on a BbEb, posted elsewhere. Fingering exactly the same. Pignol insists you roll the (all pull) scale only with fingers 123, but I bet its different up in Wales ;)

[edit] @chris, yes you move the three fingers up/down each time
          @Rees, I cheat little finger that the end too. Thanks for the tip on
         using G as a Blue not (b9), I'd consdidered C(#4) and E (b7) as
          those, but G is nice and "out" and resolves sweetly when you change
         it's bass
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 11, 2015, 11:02:25 AM
Quote
Pignol insists you roll the (all pull) scale only with fingers 123,

And move position for every first finger note, is that right, Chris?

A shame the most useful LH chords for that key are unlikely to be there on most boxes, I suppose. 
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Clive Williams on February 11, 2015, 11:32:33 AM
How would a blues harmonica be typically tuned? Is it standard, or does one or two notes get flattened?
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: rees on February 11, 2015, 12:16:35 PM
Yes, I would roll it with 3 fingers but hit the very top note with my little finger.
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 11, 2015, 12:29:11 PM
Just to report thet my favourite luthier and I are discussing some really wacky ideas!

We'll see what might work and report back
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Harmonicatunes on February 11, 2015, 12:34:51 PM
Blues harmonica is generally played in "Second Position", that is, blues in G is played on a C harmonica. The flat 7th is already in place, the flat 3rd and 5th notes are reached via bending techniques.
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 06, 2015, 09:48:08 AM
The final layout has now gone to Theo (post Whitby as he'd requested)

    F♯/G   A/B      C/D     E/F      G/A  Bâ™­/C  D/Eâ™­  F/G  Aâ™­/Bâ™­ C/C♯ Eâ™­/F
F/F♯ Aâ™­/Bâ™­ B/C♯ Eâ™­/E   F♯/Aâ™­ A/B  C♯/D  E/F♯   G/A     B/C     D/E    F/G

rodec: (paste it into Melodeon Explorer (http://chrisryall.net/chords/))

push
→→ ºF♯ ¹A  ¹C  ¹E  ¹G  ²Bâ™­ ²D  ²F  ²Aâ™­  ³C ³Eâ™­
→ ºF ºAâ™­ ¹B ¹Eâ™­ ¹F♯  ²A  ²C♯ ²E  ²G   Â³B  ³D  ³F
=
pull
→→ ºG   Â¹B  ¹D  ¹F  ²A  ²C  ²Eâ™­ ²G  ³Bâ™­ ³C♯ ³F
→ ºF♯ ¹Bâ™­ ¹C♯ ¹E  ¹Aâ™­ ²B  ²D  ²F♯  ³A ³C  ³E  ³G

After some deep thought in the summer I chickened out of tri-tone apart rows (more chromatic, but for that, why not buy a CBA? ::)) in favour of a (loosely B/C) semitone system. This offers much more chording and implements a philosophy that good "impro" is essentially chord based.

its [tone-tone-semitone] x N interval repeat along each row makes the box's base chords "on row" 7's, or min7, at the price of throwing scale onto pull in its upper octave. I hope :P to pick it up this month in time for Adderbury Blues weekend … and look forward to handing it to Nono Pignol to play next year >:E
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Jack Campin on September 06, 2015, 11:17:21 AM
What about reeds?  Should it be something like an XB-40 moothie?
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 06, 2015, 12:41:46 PM
I understand the carcass is a CC#, plus whatever Theo has in his boxes. This is totally experimental, don't even know what colour I'm getting, except that blue seems "unlikely" ;)

[ed] been experimenting - it has all maj7, min7 and 7 chords on the right end, and of course associated triads. Often three, and nearly always 2 voicings, generally push and pull in some way. Dm, Em and Gmaj7 seem to be its weakest but even these exist (and will work better with a bass)

The important pentatonics mostly need a bit of push/pull but generally that's rocking on single button rather than an awkward change bellows and finger at same time.  :P
Title: Progress notes on designing a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 09, 2015, 12:11:57 PM
discussion with Theo and a bit of spreadsheeting show there are just two kniri patterns. Here are [TT½] xN row patterns, beginning with C,B and Bb

C/D   E/F   G/A   Bb/C   D/Eb   F/G   Ab/Bb C/C#   Eb/F   F#/Ab  Bb/B   C#/Eb  E/F#   Ab/A   B/C#   D/E   F#/G   A/B

B/C#  Eb/E  F#/Ab  A/B   C#/D   E/F#   G/A   B/C   D/E   F/G   A/Bb   C/D   Eb/F   G/Ab   Bb/C   C#/Eb F/F#   Ab/Bb

Bb/C   D/Eb   F/G   Ab/Bb C/C#   Eb/F   F#/Ab  Bb/B   C#/Eb  E/F#   Ab/A   B/C#   D/E   F#/G   A/B   C/D   E/F   G/A  { Bb/C D/Eb }

I've extended the Bb row to show repetition, and that its octave 4 C mixolydian scale really is the same as the start of the inner row. With rows of this genre as a basis kniri offers all 7, major7 and minor7 4 note chords on the right end. Generally chords occur twice or more, and in both directions. You can of course also voice chords as inversions, for more patterns.

Kniri  scales repeat over 5 octaves (as you'd expect from using a 5 semitone pattern over a 12 note scale).  See above

For practical melodeon design you could therefore sensibly set up 2 kniri rows that are ½, 1½, 2½ etc tones apart - it would be a matter of how you wanted the chords to fall under the fingers.

My previous idea of 3 tones apart was actually a 'bad' idea as it effectively used the one of the two templates twice. That facilitated chromaticity in play … but wasn't nearly so efficient at generating chord patterns.

I've asked Theo to go for semitone apart, as I'm already used to flattening notes at will by dropping to outer row on my C#DG layout.

There is then a choice to be made as to what note to start rows on. While a 5 octave kniri box eventually offers all possible scales/keys we only get three octaves on melodeon.

Some patterns will lie in the higher notes, so I've ask for him to start on the lowest notes for which he has reeds lying around available ::) in order that  'dusty end' will contain  useful range. As a result I 'don't know' what key the box will be in. But D, G, C F etc will be 'somewhere' on it (:). Watch this space: [link made in 21st Century Box thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7840.0.html)]:|glug
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 10, 2015, 09:22:55 AM
This video of was posted up last month http://youtu.be/fnhWjv4ej_8 I think it is inventor Kniri Knaus himself in local Blues jam or similar, on a modified "kniri 221" Hohner one row.

Kniri mouth organ (feb) http://youtu.be/x_7mLI2k_z4 seems less useful. These guys bend all the notes anyway?

Listings of one row scales and chords http://www.kniri.ch/de/bluesaccordion.aspx
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: TomBom on September 10, 2015, 12:38:05 PM
This is how he performed in the 70s: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iV7LtxrVJp4
I remember them from watching TV as a child.
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 10, 2015, 04:11:13 PM
Well spotted!
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: stevejay on September 12, 2015, 02:12:37 PM
I'd think a B/C would be easiest, or a semitone apart. It's the basses that could be altered, but you'd lose some keys. You could then use chromatic harmonica blues players as inspiration.
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 13, 2015, 08:30:18 AM
Kniri himself seems to be a harmonica player, and has tried various off planet layouts. I have spreadsheeted various combinations, but (stupidly) did not appreciate that kniri splits the "possibles" into 2 (only 2) layouts that then repeat every 5th octave. There will be some maths in that - possibly interaction between 5 semitone pattern and 12 note chromatic scale. I suspect perhaps it is that six kniris happen over the 5 octaves, and semi tone up finds the other 6? But I'm at a festival just now …

So 1, 3, 5 semitones apart will advantage both patterns, and certainly finds a lot of chords. Semitone keeps the notes adjacent, bit like a semitone diatonic. 5 and 7 semitones apart correspond to our quart and quint layouts with similar notes staggered. The chords are still there, but "different" and wider fingerings

Tritone spacing, my original idea, or 2 semitone for that matter uses the same kniri pattern with one "shifted along". Seems to offer less chording, but opens up "off piste" notes to a greater extent. Shall we say jazz rather then blues.

So there are choices, and it may (as ever) depend on what you play. I've committed to semitone, as you advise too, but as I write am still waiting for a Theo slot. Seems there are many poorly melodeons in his hospital at present, and a pallet has just fallen off my van der Aa >:(
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 15, 2015, 08:56:46 AM
Basically, I use a temperature-controlled soldering iron (readily available) and don't bother with a heat sink. Wax melts at around 180-200°C depending on the exact composition
Gosh, that's very hot! In another context tin/lead eutectic used to solder electical components melts at (google… ) 188oC. I'd naively though that boiling water would melt melodeon wax?
Yes I think that figure is on the high side.  Pure beeswax melts at around 65C, rosin at a little over 100C, so the combined melting point should be something between those figures.

 8) For a moment there … this little project was looking seriously "uncool" :Ph
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 12, 2015, 10:22:24 AM
   'Bin nine long months now since my babe was conceived
   Now the ol' doctor tells me that it's my time to grieve
        Jobs fill the pipeline … the last one is mine
   Please, who's gonna fettle my sweet baby in time?


Defo got the blues this week … Ah well, it could be worse  :-\  … So

ADVERT I am seeking a melodeon fettler/tuner with some experience  (this doesn't seem something suitable as a first project to do myself, though that's my fall back)!

Scheme is to take a decent box carcass, probably a Hohner, and tune the reeds down as necessary. Kniri* scale runs tt½, tt½, tt½ forever (standard diato = tt½ttt½, repeating). Should that leaves a  gap at the squeaky end … no matter.  We would try to preserve low notes "cos dat's what Blues is 'bout"

 *In C that's  C D E F G A Bb C D Eb F G Ab Bb C Db
  (with similar 2nd row, based on B or C# whatever)

Bass end will probably go unisonoric in due course, but that can wait. The 2 rows will be half tone apart (there are only 2 kniri patterns); an old BC carcass might be ideal?

Actually … turns out I need a carcass too, please. Only half the reeds in a 2 voicer will get retuned, the rest masked off or used to substitute breakages. "keep it simple" So … does anyone have a BC, C#D or similar on which "about half the notes don't work", ideally with OK bellows and mechanism?  :Ph
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Brimley on November 12, 2015, 10:02:49 PM
Chris, just a thought, but if that's what you want to do, why not try it all out on a FR18?  You can pick them up cheaply, and then developing your ideas and changing earlier mistakes would be a doddle.  I tried out Atzarin RHS on mine, it really didn't take long.
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 13, 2015, 10:27:12 AM
Don't actually like the tone quality of electronic boxes, Chris, and … blues is also about note bending? I think something like that would be great for layout experimentation but in the Kniri case the row layout is already well sorted. You just rise up push/pull in a tone tone semitone repeat forever. NB this throws the octave note from push to pull!

My only innovation has been to spot that Kniri pattern repeats itself over AFAIR 5 or so octaves and that C and C# Kniris therefore cover all the possibilities. While 5 octaves doesn't sound very "melodeonic" - the scales have an earlier repeat at 2½ or so (push becoming pull). A 10+11 2-row offers chording in most keys, major, minor and 7s. I did it on a spreadsheet.

So a poor old box that's seen better days for me. And that's "what it's about" too ;)
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: bellowpin on November 16, 2015, 11:10:54 PM
Don't actually like the tone quality of electronic boxes, Chris, and … blues is also about note bending? I think something like that would be great for layout experimentation but in the Kniri case the row layout is already well sorted. You just rise up push/pull in a tone tone semitone repeat forever. NB this throws the octave note from push to pull!

My only innovation has been to spot that Kniri pattern repeats itself over AFAIR 5 or so octaves and that C and C# Kniris therefore cover all the possibilities. While 5 octaves doesn't sound very "melodeonic" - the scales have an earlier repeat at 2½ or so (push becoming pull). A 10+11 2-row offers chording in most keys, major, minor and 7s. I did it on a spreadsheet.

So a poor old box that's seen better days for me. And that's "what it's about" too ;)
     

just a silly question..        are you designing a "standard" Keyed layout (C or B for example).   with the key note repeated on the push every 4th button ,like most familiar diatonic boxes.   Or have you considered a continuing "spiral" of notes ,that seems to be implied by Kniri ?     just a thought. what are the pros and cons.  having all of one note on the push does limit some chord making possibilities for example.
  to be clear .   CD EF GA CB ED GF CA EB GD CF   
       or           CD EF GA BC DE FG AB CD EF GA                am i making this too complicated?   im sure you know what you want and thats all that matters,  hope the idea comes together for you..      brian
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 17, 2015, 01:03:57 AM
Basically, and harmonically, a trichord is notes 1,3 5 of a scale and the melodeon keyboard then repeats … exactly those notes, again. So it doesn't extend beyond tri-chords. Working beautifully with the tri-chord bass. That is good  (:)

Kniri - and the more I look at it the more I see in it  - replaces the octave repeat with a minor 7 - already we have more colour in the chord. Then … well the reed plates on row are essentially simply turned over in the second octave making a "row full handful" … an extended chord with notes 1, 3, 5. m7, 9, 11 and b13 of the scale expressed. Notes b13=b6 in the lower octave. So some nice blue notes in there?

There are lots of other forms of harmony, and in particular the chord extensions into octave 2 can be  flat, natural or in some cases sharp, harmonising the various aolean, dorian and phrygean modes of the diatonic scale. Kniri selects just one of those. But with a second row semitone away you can select some other options.  "Full" chording becomes available on just 2 rows (there are only 2 kniri scales).

I have no idea where this experiment  will go, but have just "taken the risk" buying a B/C 23 button this afternoon. I intend to kniri both rows. I anticipate that the main reward will be in "playing in chords" (extended chords!) but who knows?

Simulation on http://chrisryall.net/chords suggests a low end chord, major, minor, min7, maj7 and "7" is then commonly available for most tonics. Generally (Db and Ab are weak here) a second voicing is then available in opposite direction in the upper octave.

So great potential - I am excited in this project 8)
sx
Specifically on your layout above: not quite right. Diatonic is a TT½TTT½ tone pattern. It repeats the octave every 4th button. Kniri is  TT½TT½… forever. 7th note (4th push note) becomes a blue b7 and the octave moves to become a pull note. Minor thirds and b6 notes appear naturally an octave up, with further options from shifting a finger to the other row. Much to explore!
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 18, 2015, 10:30:19 AM
?
   Scarey!
Title: Re: Design a Blues Box
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 22, 2015, 09:29:33 AM
Just to try to detangle this from Sandy's intonation thread :Ph (mea culpa)

My poor, unsuspecting, undefended BC :'( is currently on the operating table - and I think I'll stay with =temp for now. I really don't know what keys will work, which not...

You're probably best-off doing that for now, until you've tried it out and seen how it works - and, of course, a B/C is (at least in theory) much closer to a chromatic harmonica than a blues one, and chromatic harmonicas are always tuned ET anyway.

This is proof of concept after all. To do that I'll need to get in some sessions - and these Bluesers can set of in … any key frankly.

But there is also a fundamental Kniri property here. There is no C kniri! I have gone for C in the middle (less tuning needed) but the TT/TT/ forever pattern puts that into G in the lower notes. Above middle C it is in F, then Bb. Think of a piano with all the black notes in pairs

Quote
Quote
I may well go "just" later on - it seems a tweak rather than a major retune issue

Just is only really suitable along a single row, so not really suitable for a "normal" B/C (unless, like some of the oldtime players, you are going to play it only "along the rows" in B and C).

But Meantone might work for you, depending on what keys you want to play in - for example you can tune a B/C box to play beautifully in C, D, G and A, but it'll sound horrible along the straight B row...  ???

The other constraint for me is that I sing, and therefore like to play on chords. Turns out there are 2 kniri setups, semitone apart, that together cycle though all possibilities. I am going with this too, and halftone arrangement substantially enriches the chords available - eg you can flatten any inner row note be moving a finger, without thought (as can a CBA). Yes, this is a bit bonkers.

Meanwhile … back in the Knirionium mines the gnomes and I spent a good hour filing at a reed end last night and it hasn't "gone sharp" at all >:( What are we doing wrong?
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal