Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Tunes => Topic started by: Paul Young on February 11, 2015, 10:02:01 PM

Title: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Paul Young on February 11, 2015, 10:02:01 PM
Just wondering if anybody has any suggestions for a list I'm putting together of the most widely known/played tunes in keys that can't be straightforwardly played on an ordinary D/G without accidentals. By widely played I suppose I mean anything you'd often hear coming up in sessions, or common ceilidh band repertoire. Thinking mostly English, Irish and Scottish, but also any imported tunes that are commonly played in English, Irish and mixed sessions rather than only in specifically Euro or American sessions.

My list so far:

A major (and requiring a G#)
Stool of Repentance
Handsome Young Maidens
Margaret's Waltz

D minor
Tam Lin/Glasgow Reel (also in A minor)
Peacock Feather Hornpipe
Crested Hens

E major
Calliope House
MacArthur Road
Balls to Hall (B part)

G minor
Catharsis
Seanamhac Tube Station
Dowd's Favourite


Can anybody suggest anything that's fairly widely played in C, F or B flat? I'm sure there's a reel I've heard a few times in B major as well but can't remember what it is. Any other suggestions much appreciated.

I've been thinking of these tunes partly because I'm about to have the layout of my 2.5 row changed and want to learn a bunch of tunes to get me familiar with the new layout and partly as a teaching resource for teaching pupils how to deal with tunes in different keys (other than by just moving them into easier keys).
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: smiley on February 12, 2015, 03:18:52 AM
hi Paul

I have a 19 button D/G with low notes instead of accidentals on which I play some of those tunes you listed. But anyway the first tunes that came to mind for learning to use the G# accidental on a 2.5 row D/G are the Mason's Apron and The Breakdown (both in A major) - and the 2nd part of the Bluebell Polka. Humours of Scarrif (Dm) is another fairly common reel around my area. There are a lot of well-known Paddy Fahy jigs and reels that need an F natural. And the Broken Pledge is a popular Dm reel with a strong F natural too.

On the jigs front, the 2nd part of Arthur Darley’s needs F & Bb and of course there's Jump at the Sun in Em with that big Bb note.
There's a lot of other Scottish tunes the fiddlers play in A major that work ok on a D/G, e.g. Sweetness of Mary, Blackthorn Stick jig
Most Cmaj tunes I play using an alternative for any F naturals, but novelty tunes like Teddy Bear's Picnic in Em/C are useful exercises.

Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 12, 2015, 07:05:56 AM
ONCE in my life I launched into Teddy Bear's Picnic, a chromatic tune that sits nicely on the box in Em … all went well and it seemed popular as ever. Quite often quite ordinary folk in the bar will start up in song to this tune!

Not his time. A chap with (no other term for it) greasy hair, and a very large piano accordion came in and played across me (and frankly, anyone else joining in) in C minor.

While he may have been entirely right historically, I confess to a direct and assertive plan for anyone doing such again. (There are some places that Picnics shouldn't go) :|glug

[ed] Bb/Eb sessions are completely absolved in this  ;)
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: pikey on February 12, 2015, 08:12:05 PM
Bluebell Polka , third part in C !
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Theo on February 12, 2015, 09:51:07 PM
Bluebell Polka , third part in C !

Dead right Pikey! The way it should be played.

And talking of the way it should be played, Athol Highlanders, which can be played with all the right notes in A on a DG box without accidentals, but so many box players insist on playing it in G where you don't have the important F natural note and F chord in the fourth part.  :'(
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on February 13, 2015, 01:29:52 AM
But you do have the basses, which is probably why quite a lot  of these melodeonist fellows play in the wrong key.  >:E I seem to be the only person I know in our sessions, apart, probably, Paul, who ever tries to play in A.  :neigh:
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 13, 2015, 08:05:13 AM
And talking of the way it should be played, Athol Highlanders, which can be played with all the right notes in A on a DG box without accidentals, but so many box players insist on playing it in G where you don't have the important F natural note and F chord in the fourth part.  :'(

I first learned Athol Highlanders in G on the Northumbrian Smallpipes in sessions in Morpeth. It's a good key for NSP because it falls nicely in the range of the pipes and you do have the constant G drone. So for me it stuck in that key in my head for years and to now play it on the melodeon in A seems 'foreign'. But I acknowledge that A was probably the original key.

And before anyone mentions it, yes I know the actual sound of the standard NPS will be in F-ish (unless you have a G chanter) but the notation for the F-ish pipes is still written in G.
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: oggiesnr on February 13, 2015, 10:40:18 AM
Give me your Hand - requires F natural in the last part.
St Anne's Reel - G# in the B part
From Playford there's a whole host of C and F tunes.
Jump at the Sun needs A#
Mist over Malham is in Am
Loch Leven Castle is Am but uses both F# and G# as well as the naturals.

Steve
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Jack Campin on February 13, 2015, 11:16:34 AM
E flat:
The Dean Brig of Edinburgh
The Weeping Birches of Kilmorack

C minor:
Roslin Castle (ok, it doesn't need to be in that key and was originally in E minor, but you often hear it that way)
Lament for Will Starr
Miss Gordon of Gight (usually misplayed as a dirge, should be manically flat out).

F minor:
Mr Ronald Crawford (ok, maybe not that popular, but I play it)

F# minor:
Twist Ye Twine Ye Even So

F# dorian:
The J.B. Reel
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: IanD on February 13, 2015, 04:31:19 PM
Atholl Highlanders in A sounds *far* better on a D/G, and fiddle players love it once they've cottoned on :-)
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Jack Campin on February 13, 2015, 04:51:24 PM
C major:
The Braes of Auchtertyre (ok, maybe not that popular but it's a great tune)

F major:
John Stephen of Chance Inn
Auld Lang Syne (it's the best key for singers)
Carnie's Canter
Hull's Victory
Fisher's Hornpipe
Jean's Reel (wimps play it in G)
Pottinger's Reel

D minor:
The Sailor's Wife
Julia Delaney

G minor:
The Ewie wi the Crookit Horn

Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Theo on February 13, 2015, 05:17:26 PM
Atholl Highlanders in A sounds *far* better on a D/G, and fiddle players love it once they've cottoned on :-)

Thanks Ian,  I'm glad I'm not alone!
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Anahata on February 13, 2015, 05:39:10 PM
Atholl Highlanders in A sounds *far* better on a D/G, and fiddle players love it once they've cottoned on :-)

Thanks Ian,  I'm glad I'm not alone!

I've always played it in A (from 37 years ago); it never occurred to me to do any different.
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Stiamh on February 13, 2015, 06:10:16 PM
List of popular tunes - popular with whom, Paul?

I was going to say, I play so many tunes with accidentals I wouldn't know where to start listing them. But on second thoughts, these might be popular in old Blighty: The Wonder Hornpipe and the Trumpet Hornpipe.

The reel in B major you have heard about might be Road to Errogie. One of the settings at https://thesession.org/tunes/5270 gives the key as B mixolydian, not B major, but since there's nary an A in the tune the choice is hard to justify, except that it declutters the key signature.  (:)
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Jack Campin on February 13, 2015, 06:21:57 PM
B major:
Seton's Ceilidh Band

A major/E major:
Maple Sugar (a lot of Ward Allen's other tunes are in odd keys)
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: IanD on February 13, 2015, 09:28:31 PM
Atholl Highlanders in A sounds *far* better on a D/G, and fiddle players love it once they've cottoned on :-)

Thanks Ian,  I'm glad I'm not alone!

I've always played it in A (from 37 years ago); it never occurred to me to do any different.
Now all we have to do is to get people to play it at a proper pipe march speed instead of racing off with fingers bursting into flames...
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Jack Campin on February 13, 2015, 09:59:27 PM
Two common ones in D going briefly into A and needing the G#:
Miss Susan Cooper
Da Slockit Licht

Mickie Ainsworth's version of "The March Hare" was in G minor and C minor.  More often played in A minor and D minor.
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: george garside on February 13, 2015, 10:34:37 PM
playing Scottish pipe tunes on a dg box in A provides the same pipe scale   as does the hohner highlander  moothie  i.e an A scale with a flattened G#.   

That opens up a vast list of tunes including of course Athol highlanders   which I agree sounds nicer in A than G , but if everybody else is in G    in a session then G it has to be

One of my favourites is 'The Thistle of Scotland' in A preceded by Scotland the Brave in D giving a nice key change.  An  easy set , all in A, is Cock of the north, 100 pipers and Bonny Dundee.
 
As to the the 3rd or 'c' part of the bluebell polka in the key of C  it won't really work without an F natural as that note occurs 13 times making 26 Fnats if the C part is played twice through!  On my Lilly I have a link to the chin end Fnat so it can be operated next to F# on the G row So the box is in effect a 2 row with one 'button' on a 3rd row  This makes the C part of the bluebell polka very easy to play.

george



george
 
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 13, 2015, 10:48:42 PM
Atholl Highlanders in A sounds *far* better on a D/G, and fiddle players love it once they've cottoned on :-)

Thanks Ian,  I'm glad I'm not alone!

Certainly not alone. It's just one of those things, it's in A, and sounds great on fiddles in that key as many Scottish tunes do.
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Theo on February 14, 2015, 09:58:28 AM
List of popular tunes - popular with whom, Paul?

I was going to say, I play so many tunes with accidentals I wouldn't know where to start listing them. But on second thoughts, these might be popular in old Blighty: The Wonder Hornpipe and the Trumpet Hornpipe.

Of course The Wonder "should" be in Bb.  Some of my fiddle player friends prefer it there.
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Stiamh on February 14, 2015, 11:26:36 AM
Of course The Wonder "should" be in Bb.  Some of my fiddle player friends prefer it there.

Not sure if I'm glad to know that Theo - but I'll take it as this month's challenge to play it in the original key (on the box)!  :|glug
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Theo on February 14, 2015, 12:39:46 PM
Good luck!
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 14, 2015, 01:31:46 PM
Re Atholl Highlanders, I've always played it in A on the D/G/Acc box - the snag if anything is finding enough push notes on some of the sections to snatch an air button burst to close the bellows.  This is particularly true of the first section of the music, and really the only way I've found to do it is to play a push B bass note on the push for the E7 chord, rather than a pull E chord.  I could in theory apply a push A, but the C# RH then gets well in the way of a nice drone A chord, which is the beauty of the bagpipe tune, and which gives it the 'one-tone up' lift to the music, generally making the dancers whoop.
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: IanD on February 14, 2015, 04:32:09 PM
Re Atholl Highlanders, I've always played it in A on the D/G/Acc box - the snag if anything is finding enough push notes on some of the sections to snatch an air button burst to close the bellows.  This is particularly true of the first section of the music, and really the only way I've found to do it is to play a push B bass note on the push for the E7 chord, rather than a pull E chord.  I could in theory apply a push A, but the C# RH then gets well in the way of a nice drone A chord, which is the beauty of the bagpipe tune, and which gives it the 'one-tone up' lift to the music, generally making the dancers whoop.
In the A music you can also put "gaps" in the bass A drone chord to get some RH notes on the push, and/or go from the E to the A via a push G chord, and/or use a push G instead of a pull E.
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Paul Young on February 14, 2015, 08:05:29 PM
Thanks all for the contributions, especially Jack who's been pretty thorough. Thanks especially for reminding me of The Sailor's Wife - an absolutely brilliant tune and probably the first one I'll be having a go at when I get my altered box back tomorrow.

Stiamh, yes, I think the one I've heard in B is Road to Errogie, so thanks for that.

In looking up The Wonder, I also discovered The High Level Bridge, also by James Hill, also in Bb.
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: boxcall on February 14, 2015, 09:39:24 PM
red haired boy ( jolly beggerman) in A you'll need G# a few times the tune uses Gnat. as an accidental.
Title: Re: List - Popular tunes in unpopular keys
Post by: Jack Campin on February 14, 2015, 11:51:30 PM
Another one I should have remembered with the other Shetland tunes: Michael's Mazurka.  G major modulating into G minor and back.

Hard to find good notation for it last time I looked, so here's mine:

Code: [Select]
X:0
T:Michael's Mazurka
C:Michael Ferrie
M:3/4
L:1/8
Q:3/4=40
K:G
D2   | G4    A/B/c|B2 BA GF   |EG  GB AG   |   FG  FE    DF |
       G4    A/B/c|B2 BA GF   |EG  GB A/G/F|   G4          :|
K:GDor
D2   | G3  A Bc   |d2 dc BG   |A^F AF DF   |   G>A B/c/d g2 |
       G2 GA Bc   |d3  c BG   |A^F AF DF   |   G4          :|
K:G
A/B/d|:g6         |d4    cB   |A2  a3  g   |   fd  cd    ef |
       g4    b2   |g4    d/c/B|A2  a3  g   |   fd  cA    FD |
       G2 AB G2   |A2 Bc A2   |B2  cd B2   |   c2  de    c2 |
       d2 g4      |f3  g a/g/f|g3   f ga   |[1 g3   d    Bd:|\
                                            [2 g4          |]

I've never heard it played on a bisonoric anything.

And while we're in Shetland, two in F by Aly Bain:
Louis's Waltz
Andy Broon's Reel
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal