Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: upmine3 on February 21, 2015, 01:56:16 AM
-
I love the look and weight of my Hohner Pokerwork not to mention the tone so i want to do an out right conversion to B/C on treble and Bass side and was just wondering how hard or expensive this might be?
I have looked at the Hohner parts site and they dont seem to list B/C reed blocks for Pokerwork it's all D/G and C/F.
This makes me think it's not a practical conversion or is it just not usual and the cost would outweigh the project?
Has anyone else here done a total Pokerwork conversion to B/C?
-
Hello,
Well I have experience with these convertions...
All my "noise boxes" I need to convert at specifically this tuning here:
BASS buttons:
push/pull:
Out row: G/Dm - G/D - C/Bb - C/Bb
In row: E/A - E/A - F/F - F/F
TREBLE buttons
push/pull
In row: F/A - G/A - C/D - E/F - G/A - C/B - E-D - G/F - C/A - E/B
Out row: C/D - E/G# - A#/F# - B/C# - D#/E - F#/G# - B/A# - D#/C# - F#/E - B/F#- D#/A#
The closer variation of it, that comes originally in melodeons nowadays, and since always, would be exactly the B/C that you are aiming.
So, what I can tell you about tuning conversion? Well, you should find a nice professional, that have been working with it since sometime before.
I believe you could try before BUY the set of reeds... contacting Hohner before. If they are not presenting the set that you need in their website currently, so send an email, and present what do you really need to them. In their website they describe this service about maintenance and also customization. If the reeds are not available as you describe, they will make it for you very probably... but charging any price as a customized service.
And it wouldn't be the same same price as you could find a complete set of reeds in C/F for example.
But the 1st step for you, I believe, before search for a professional that would do this conversion, it would be try to find the orginal set of reed in B/C with Hohner, cause the produce currently some instruments originally in B/C, so if the didnt present it for you as parts and pieces as a normal option, for sure they can sell for you if you try a contact with them I believe.
-
It's perfectly do-able, or you might be able to find a ready-made B/C without going to all the trouble of converting one - seeing that Hohner have made Pokerwork B/C boxes...
-
Yep, got mine from Hobgoblin in Canterbury. They always seem to have a few whenever I have looked.
-
could be as cheap buy a second hand BC double ray rather than pay for conversion of pokerwork. The double ray, Erica and pokerwork have the same reeds &reedblocks and sound much the same.
another way would be to aadvertise for double ray reedblocks with reeds as there mayu be somebody who has done a conversion the other way.
Charlie Marshall will be able to supply reedsets
george
-
Yes it is quite do-able, but quicker and probably cheaper to do a trade. The older black double ray was made in the same size and shape as the pokerwork, and of course the modern double ray is the same body as an Erica and might do the job for you. If you prefer the pokerwork style then you could buy a double ray, swap the reed blocks and then you have a saleable DG box!
-
George, Theo, the o/p already has a Double Ray B/C - it says so in his signature...
And he already has a nice old Pokerwork that he asked another question about yesterday, though he doesn't mention what key it's in or if that's the one he's thinking of converting.
-
If your Pokerwork has D/G reed blocks, I can swop for a good set of B/C with modern Irish basses.
-
It's in C/F.
-
My Double Ray is the de-lux with 12 bass so that's why i wanted the Pokerwork in B/C for the lightness of the 2 voice.
-
George, Theo, the o/p already has a Double Ray B/C - it says so in his signature...
And he already has a nice old Pokerwork that he asked another question about yesterday, though he doesn't mention what key it's in or if that's the one he's thinking of converting.
Yes that's the one Triskel but it's in the not so popular C/F if anyone's interested in C/F reed blocks? :-\
-
I've done the conversion of a pokerwork to B/C a some 15 years ago, using hand made type Binci reeds.
I also fitted it with new bellows (they were re-made using the original frames, at a price that could be now around the 50 Pounds), and remade the keyord in wood.
The only problem were the reed-blocks for the basses, there wew roo large to fit, but i was lucky enough to have a luthier among my friends. He did all the dirty work for me!
My five cents: buy a new instrument... not a Hohner!
-
I have looked at the Hohner parts site and they dont seem to list B/C reed blocks for Pokerwork it's all D/G and C/F.
If you look under parts for Erica you will find reed blocks including HC which is German notation for BC. Erica and pokerwork reed blocks are identical.
This is the page:
http://www.hohner-cshop.de/en/Accordion/Diatonic/2-row/Erica/
-
Thanks Theo. :D
-
... it's in the not so popular C/F if anyone's interested in C/F reed blocks? :-\
Then you've already got C reeds that could be switched over, or are they on zinc plates in your old-style pokerwork?
-
Try and find a nice set of suitable B/C blocks and reeds from the period when Hohner reeds were at the top of their game. My B/C pokerwork is so endowed. The reeds use air frugally, speak very readily, and are as loud as anyone could wish. It's a great box.
-
Try and find a nice set of suitable B/C blocks and reeds from the period when Hohner reeds were at the top of their game. My B/C pokerwork is so endowed. The reeds use air frugally, speak very readily, and are as loud as anyone could wish. It's a great box.
Yes but does that mean i have to still find a "matching" set of B reeds from the same production era or can i obtain a recent set of B reeds and mix them?
Theo are the Erica reeds on the link you supplied of better quality being as they are manufactured in this day and age or is it a case as Boxer said and root out a set of B/C reeds from a desirable period when they were made superior?
-
Modern Hohner reeds are louder and brighter than the older type on zinc plates. I would hesitate to say one type is better than another, but there are differences. It all depends on how old your CF pokerwork is, and what kind of reeds it has.
-
I've ordered new set of G/C reed block from Hohner 2 days ego to convert a C/C* pokerwork.I personally like and prefer newer and louder reeds,they are also not as heavy as the older ones if I'm not mistaking? ordered some other little bits form Hohner and all together price is more than reasonable to me..go for it ...if your c/f block are in tune and plays good I am happy to pay the half of your new set :||: you can PM me if you want ;)
-
The reeds sound good to me. Maybe some leather valves need replacing i think.
-
Theo i'm no expert but i think they're steel reeds.
-
The reed tongues will certainly be steel. The reed plates could be aluminium or zinc.
-
How do i tell? :o
-
If you look under parts for Erica you will find reed blocks including HC which is German notation for BC. Erica and pokerwork reed blocks are identical.
Perfect! So they HAVE the B/C available in all the models of reed blocks selling in the website. I didn't know also what was this H/C. Nice to know! (:)
So, I believe it would be the most simple way and also preserving maximum of the quality and fidelity of the sound. You would just change the reedblock, and maybe can re-sell the old in any website.
-
Which is what i'll probably be doing Brazillian_Box. I'll get the Treble and Bass ends from Hohner and sell the CF Reeds. The only problem i have is my bass on my Castagnari Kriss III is set up Joe Burke style with the extra D and it's flipped (mirrored) from Joe Burkes style too. I cant personalise the bass side when ordering fro the website so will be stuck with the default layout that Hohner use on B/C.
-
Which is what i'll probably be doing Brazillian_Box. I'll get the Treble and Bass ends from Hohner and sell the CF Reeds. The only problem i have is my bass on my Castagnari Kriss III is set up Joe Burke style with the extra D and it's flipped (mirrored) from Joe Burkes style too. I cant personalise the bass side when ordering fro the website so will be stuck with the default layout that Hohner use on B/C.
Any competent fettler will be able to rearrange the basses to your required layout.
-
Any competent fettler will be able to rearrange the basses to your required layout.
Goody Gumdrops!
-
As i put on another thread i've decided to use my Bandmaster's aluminium Pallets since they already have padding. I cut them down with a hack saw by hand (since i don't even have a work bench or vice) being as they came off a 4 voice instrument that wasn't getting used.
-
Not bad at my first attempt at it if i may say so myself.