Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: David Pike on April 28, 2009, 10:04:22 PM
-
I've recently acquired an A/D/G with low notes rather than accidentals. However I notice that one of the notes on each row is duplicated ie the G row goes BD DF(sharp) GA. Thus there is no low C. This appears to be the norm according to the charts on this forum. Am I being totally stupid or is there any reason for this. I've come across at tune that requires the low C - any suggestions please.
Thanks
David
-
I've recently acquired an A/D/G with low notes rather than accidentals. However I notice that one of the notes on each row is duplicated ie the G row goes BD DF(sharp) GA. Thus there is no low C. This appears to be the norm according to the charts on this forum. Am I being totally stupid or is there any reason for this. I've come across at tune that requires the low C - any suggestions please.
Thanks
David
It is so that you can play the dominant seventh with the lower four notes on the pull. It is a bit of a pain, but the pull D can be very useful for runs.
As for suggestions, I'd play an E instead and see what happens :P
-
.....Thus there is no low C. This appears to be the norm according to the charts on this forum. Am I being totally stupid or is there any reason for this. I've come across at tune that requires the low C - any suggestions please.
This lack of a low C is a general problem on standard 2-row D/G melodeons too. I get around it by playing the low C on the left-hand C bass. Usually the low C bass has 2 or 3 reeds tuned in octaves and it helps if you have a stop to remove the lowest reed from the set, but it's not essential.
A certain amount of dexterity is required to be able to suddenly switch the melody from RH to LH (English concertina players will have little difficulty here ;) ) and the change of sound origin from RH to LH side of the box is not as noticeable to the listeners as it might be thought.
-
Both excellent suggestions - either use bass note C or 'shuffle' around the low c by playing the e or other note within the triad CEG or a combination of both. It's what folk is all about really I think? having said that my cheap and nasty Primo from the Musicroom came with a Low C on the D row as new from the shop. Can't think that anyone would've wanted to have a special op done on it? Strange - but it does come in very, very useful indeed, and means less shuffling around ;D
AL
-
Here is what I suggest as a D/G low note layout:
G row B/C D/F# G/A etc
D row G/A A/C# D/E etc
You loose the low F# which is not very useful except if you want a very low D chord, and you lose the pull D on the G row so no D7 chord.
You gain a complete scale of G going up from low fiddle G
If you want accidentals too then you just need to move everything up one button to a 4th button doh
-
I replaced the low A on the pull on the first button of the D row with a C natural. I wanted to have the C on the pull, so I had to either do that or lose the D on the first button of the G row. There was no contest as I rarely use that low A, but for me that D on the pull is much too useful to be without.
-
I think i would prefer:
G row B/D D/F# G/A etc
D row G/C A/C# D/E etc
-
I think i would prefer:
G row B/D D/F# G/A etc
D row G/C A/C# D/E etc
That's what I've got, except that I've still got an F# instead of the low G, but I agree the low G would be an improvement.
-
Yeah, I can't remember ever using the low F#. Of course now that I've said that I probably will remember some obscure tune, but in general I would use a low G and a low C a lot more.
-
The low notes on my DG box are:
G row B/C D/F# G/A etc
D row G/B A/C# D/E etc
I've been playing with this arrangement of low notes for a couple of years now and I find the low B on the D row really handy and the low C on the G row works well too. Good for playing irish fiddle tunes but I'd really like a low F natural as well.
-
but I'd really like a low F natural as well.
ideally what row would you have it in - G row?
AL
-
but I'd really like a low F natural as well.
ideally what row would you have it in - G row?
AL
If you want accidentals too then you just need to move everything up one button to a 4th button doh
Then you could have the low F on either row, and some other useful accidentals too
-
I don't like alll these accidentals down the bottom....give me a 2 1/2 row (with the accidentals where I can reach them!) any day.
-
I'll second that . Try the accidentals on a G/C with small hands . ???
-
I don't like alll these accidentals down the bottom....give me a 2 1/2 row (with the accidentals where I can reach them!) any day.
Fine, but what about the accidentals on a 3-row, which is what started this thread?
You're right, it was.
My 3 row has an inside row of just accidentals!