Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Nick Hudis on March 03, 2015, 09:36:04 PM
-
Another reality check around changing the layout on my 3 row G/C Loffet.
Having grown up, so to speak on Clubs, I miss the possibility of being fully chromatic on the pull. I'm one of those players who seems to play mainly on the pull. The missing note is Eb pull. I could get the Eb above middle C by replacing the chin end button on the G row (which I have never played!) with an Eb pull/F push accidental (The F would be useful too), but there is more of a challenge for the next octave up.
It does occur to me that I never use the A pull/G push on the C row (that would be E/D on a D/G box) as I have accustomed myself to always take these notes on the G row. I was wondering about replacing the A/G with an Eb/F. It would break the continuity of the C row for sure but would make something useful out of a button I never use.
Does that sound like a daft idea?
Any advice on actually obtaining the new reeds. The existing ones are Antonelli TAM. Would the replacements need to be the same maker?
-
Not being a particularly experienced box player, I have also found myself leaving behind the redundant notes on the middle row of my three row box. I would say that if it makes sense to you, go for it! If you have G and A reversals on your accidental row, you could also consider doing a dutch reversal on the middle row, swapping the A pull / G push to G pull / A push. That frees up the space in the accidental row for your Eb and F and maintains some continuity in your C row. The later option depends on your layout though.
Again, this is only from a theoretical standpoint, as I am only beginning to play the melodeon myself. I mention it because the dutch reversal idea (getting rid or redundant notes on the home rows) is very appealing to me and is a main factor in the layout I am working on in the thread "New 3 row 18 bass layout (D/G/Acc based)" in this same topic area.
I looked in to getting some new reeds to attain the layout in that thread, but it was a little too expensive for me to justify it, but I was also looking at changing out more reeds. I am also located in the US, which may affect things. My understanding is that Antonelli charges a substantial surcharge on small custom reed orders, though others here may well prove me wrong or have more information on the subject.
Thanks,
Baron