Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Tunes => Topic started by: butimba on March 07, 2015, 09:45:37 AM

Title: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: butimba on March 07, 2015, 09:45:37 AM
Hi all,

I'm just starting to think about putting tunes together to make a set and have been wondering if there are any guidelines for doing so, in terms of how similar the two tunes should be? (E.g. how should they be related in terms of key signature/time signature/dance type/anything else?) Is there anything that it's generally best to stay clear of doing, like pairing a 3/4 waltz with a 4/4 reel or similar?
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 07, 2015, 10:36:36 AM
If you are making up sets for dancing, then you almost invariably want to maintain the same type of tune/time signature (2/4 polka, 6/8 jig), etc. otherwise the dancers will get confused. If you feel like changing key as well, then choose one which isn't harmonically far away and which can give a 'lift' to the dance. So D major going into G major nearly always works well, as does Em into G major.

Having said that, personally I hate medleys of tunes for dancing and I like to stick to one tune to one dance if at all possible. 

Otherwise, there are no rules, especially for a performance set. If you find a combination of tunes/keys/time sigs. which you like and which seem to work well together then go for it. Use your musical judgement, which I know you have. 
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Stiamh on March 07, 2015, 03:37:19 PM
As most of you know, I am mostly involved in Irish music circles, where playing sets of tunes is the norm, both in sessions and for dancing. Out of laziness I am pasting in below a reply I wrote a while ago to a similar question on thesession.org.

Quote
When thinking of the next tune to play on the fly, in a session, I mostly stick to key changes that I know work well.

If I am working out sets more carefully to play in a band setting I sometimes add in consideration of the connection between the last note of a tune and the first of the next. Going up (or down) a tone or a semitone can add some interest or tension. Or going from a tune that ends on a very low note to one that starts on a very high note can be very effective.

Things to avoid, IMO anyway: 1) pairing tunes for nonmusical reasons - e.g. because their names are similar, or related, or antithetical. This often leads to very lame choices. 2) putting together tunes where for example the turns or b parts are similar - this is courting disaster as you can very easily go into the wrong turn, or back into the wrong tune.

It’s a mixture of art and science! Don’t worry about rules - get stuck in and try things.

While I appreciate the musical and aesthetic reasons for not changing tunes in a dance, I can't see it happening at the Irish ceilis I play at, and sometimes contradances and québécois dances. In some québécois sets the dancing lasts 15 or 20 minutes nonstop - sticking to one tune would doubtless lead us all into some altered state of consciousness!
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on March 07, 2015, 04:26:52 PM
sticking to one tune would doubtless lead us all into some altered state of consciousness!

When John Kirkpatrick wrote about medleys all those years ago, this was one of the very points he made, I've heard him voice the thought in person too.

And I agree ... but evidently only sort of, because I generally don't stick to a single tune in dances  :D

However, I never do more than a pair of tunes in a dance, and rarely more in sessions.

It feels right to pair tunes in sessions and that's what seems to be done around these parts at any least. The poor things seem a bit lonely out on their own.

I think Stiamh's guidelines for pairing tunes are good.

I'd add a couple of thoughts. One is that sets can be a great way of introducing new tunes or lesser known ones to a session. Play the new one first for everyone to listen to and experiment with and follow it up with a popular one that "releases the tension".

Another is not to worry about it too much, if it seems to sound right, then it almost certainly is. It's just a couple of tunes after all. However, don't be surprised at being steamrollered occasionally by some sets. I know it shouldn't happen, and I for one always listen (well, I try too), but if you are going to a session where there are really established sets that you wish to break up, then approach with caution, or is that confidence 'cos people will have fun mixing it up a bit. All depends upon the session I suppose.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 07, 2015, 06:58:48 PM
I too have heard JK refer to this, and chatted to friends who played with him when they played 'Sir Roger de Coverly' tune and dance for well over an hour, dancers and musicians substituting into the dance.
The gleam in their eye shows something wonderfull happened, they still rave about it.
John still advises you to play a tune for an hour to see what happens!
I have attended talks on a couple of occasions where the Hardy family was discussed both the later to be novelist Thomas Hardy and father were good fiddlers. At the time they *did* commonly play the same tune for 20 mins or more until the lady and master of the posh house danced all the way to the bottom of the longway set and returned to the top.

At this point you realise the simple tunes used allowed improvisation. The tune at the end of the dance would have mutated from the one started. The tune was a basic scaffold to hang your twiddles or deviations on as the dance progressed. It's taken us a long time, since the English revival of the '70's to understand that English tunes were more than what was just written, and playing one tune for a time allows this exploration.
Q
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 07, 2015, 08:08:26 PM
Adding a few comments to the points already very well made:   'lift' is often effective if you go up a tone - for example if you play a jig in G and then go to A (for say Athol Highlanders), or if you play a run down in semitones from D through C# and C to B, thus changing key from D to G as Steve says.  And second, tunes with some similar but slightly different phrases in them can be very effective together - they sound like variations, but somehow change to new and unexpected melodies.  And also, there are occasions when changing rhythm deliberately can give certain dances a real new interpretation, which is great to dance to - but that needs practising with the particular dance concerned to make sure it will work.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: robotmay on March 07, 2015, 08:09:28 PM
I've been getting into drone-y music lately and simple tunes being altered whilst playing them repeatedly over and over, so I certainly agree with what Q said. One of my favourite groups to listen to at the moment is Wod (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9xvD22TSSk), who can sometimes play one or two tunes for up to 20 minutes at a time. Andy's tunes are both really quite straightforward (though King's Barrows is a pig in Gm if your accidentals are around the wrong way like mine, so I play that on the mandolin), but if you sit and play them for a while you can really get into it and find so many different ways to mess around with it.

Often if I'm trying to record something for ToTM etc I sit down for 2-3 hours at a time and just keep playing it over and over until I get to something I like. It helps me develop a tune while learning it a bit better, and I can hear what I've done ;D
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on March 07, 2015, 09:05:17 PM
I too have heard JK refer to this, and chatted to friends who played with him when they played 'Sir Roger de Coverly' tune and dance for well over an hour, dancers and musicians substituting into the dance.
The gleam in their eye shows something wonderfull happened, they still rave about it.
John still advises you to play a tune for an hour to see what happens!
I have attended talks on a couple of occasions where the Hardy family was discussed both the later to be novelist Thomas Hardy and father were good fiddlers. At the time they *did* commonly play the same tune for 20 mins or more until the lady and master of the posh house danced all the way to the bottom of the longway set and returned to the top.

At this point you realise the simple tunes used allowed improvisation. The tune at the end of the dance would have mutated from the one started. The tune was a basic scaffold to hang your twiddles or deviations on as the dance progressed. It's taken us a long time, since the English revival of the '70's to understand that English tunes were more than what was just written, and playing one tune for a time allows this exploration.
Q

All very true, it can be an interesting thing to do and there's a point there of course.

But, sorry, I ain't going to play a tune for an hour at the next wedding dance booking (16 to 18 minutes is possible depending on what the caller is up to), or at a session, or play in the social settings of Thomas Hardy. I dislike long medleys too, I like tunes to have breathing space and variation (yup, I think most of us get that without having to play a tune for an hour non-stop  :P ).

Thomas Hardy didn't play in pub sessions, and if I tried to play a tune for 20 minutes in a session people would think I'd gone nuts and was being very rude and inconsiderate ... and they'd be right. Playing for long sets with people going all the way down and back? Well, OK, it's true, that's English country dancing then, this is now. People tell me that traditions change, I think we can identify this is as one of those changes.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 07, 2015, 09:33:47 PM
As you say, play one tune continuously at a wedding and it'll be your last booking!
I also take the point about pub sessions and being rude is not to be encouraged at all either.
Yes times have changed but I think we can give a nod to our musical heritage if the occasion's right.

I think there's a mid ground here that we can take, and I'm thinking of my local session. We don't adhere to 'twice through and change'. It's an English based session, and if someone starts a good tune we all like and love we keep playing until we feel we've given it due airing! There's no rush to stop, or maybe change to the other tune if a set. We give it a good play.
It's definitely not 'twice through change, twice through change....'
Q
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on March 07, 2015, 09:45:12 PM
As you say, play one tune continuously at a wedding and it'll be your last booking!
I also take the point about pub sessions and being rude is not to be encouraged at all either.
Yes times have changed but I think we can give a nod to our musical heritage if the occasion's right.

I think there's a mid ground here that we can take, and I'm thinking of my local session. We don't adhere to 'twice through and change'. It's an English based session, and if someone starts a good tune we all like and love we keep playing until we feel we've given it due airing! There's no rush to stop, or maybe change to the other tune if a set. We give it a good play.
It's definitely not 'twice through change, twice through change....'
Q

Oh flip, twice through and change would not get my support or happiness either.

Actually, I never count in sessions or dances. I keep a tune going and then change it when it feels about right. Works well in sessions, and others in my local session seem to take the same approach. It's OK for dances (I do watch where people have got to in the set/progressions). For a concert band it can be a bugger since I forget to notice where we are in the proscribed number of times through a tune. Then again, who cares, if it feels right, it's right.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 08, 2015, 08:57:26 AM
I confess to strong views on this, and find abrupt changes of rhythm particularly unpleasant. Even within the same rhythm you can make mistakes.  At a spot in Chester Festival I put two mazurkas together and they just didn't meet. Later i worked out that one was a trad 3/4, the other a 'slung' 9/8 in the more modern style.

So it's an art. But I'd encourage you to also explore playing a single tune through say 6 times, developing it, inverting phrases, using different basses, substituting right hand chords for melody, breaking rhythm "within itself" finessing a few blue notes in there … the list is endless.

I'm essentially with John. We don't embroider our tunes enough, and in the end a quick "twice through" one tune then switch to another doesn't "add" anything to either of them?  :|glug
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 08, 2015, 09:34:10 AM
Andrew mentioned this in another current thread, and I think it has relevance here.

" One of the issues with the Sharp inspired English dance revival was the use of many Irish and Scottish tunes in EFDSS educational publications. I wonder what effects that had? I know that one of them was the conscious revival of a "southern English" style...."

The sleeve notes on the seminal Old Swan Band's 'No Reels' album said that it was produced as a reaction to the 'twice through and change' culture probably hugely influenced, as Andrew says, by EFDSS publications. They dug into English tunes from the last traditional players of the time, and from this stance, against the ideas of the time, started us looking again at our music.
We started to realise in times gone by one tune would be played for a long time and investigated, not constantly changed as with other traditions and as EFDSS publications implied.
As Chris says, the mid ground now seems to happen, and nowadays 6 times through and getting into the tune is deemed ok.
Q
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on March 08, 2015, 10:07:07 AM
I confess to strong views on this, and find abrupt changes of rhythm particularly unpleasant. Even within the same rhythm you can make mistakes.  At a spot in Chester Festival I put two mazurkas together and they just didn't meet. Later i worked out that one was a trad 3/4, the other a 'slung' 9/8 in the more modern style.

So it's an art. But I'd encourage you to also explore playing a single tune through say 6 times, developing it, inverting phrases, using different basses, substituting right hand chords for melody, breaking rhythm "within itself" finessing a few blue notes in there … the list is endless.

I'm essentially with John. We don't embroider our tunes enough, and in the end a quick "twice through" one tune then switch to another doesn't "add" anything to either of them?  :|glug

But the rules are there to be broken as well. I was once at the old Bridgenorth Folk Festival (before it moved to Shrewsbury), watching and listening to the Dartmoor Pixie Band, when they made a change, I think from a polka to a jig, I gave a quizzical look to the person standing next to me who happened to be Sheila Mainwaring, she smiled and said, "yes I know, but it works wonderfully doesn't it". And she was right, it did.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on March 08, 2015, 10:18:13 AM
Andrew mentioned this in another current thread, and I think it has relevance here.

" One of the issues with the Sharp inspired English dance revival was the use of many Irish and Scottish tunes in EFDSS educational publications. I wonder what effects that had? I know that one of them was the conscious revival of a "southern English" style...."

The sleeve notes on the seminal Old Swan Band's 'No Reels' album said that it was produced as a reaction to the 'twice through and change' culture probably hugely influenced, as Andrew says, by EFDSS publications. They dug into English tunes from the last traditional players of the time, and from this stance, against the ideas of the time, started us looking again at our music.
We started to realise in times gone by one tune would be played for a long time and investigated, not constantly changed as with other traditions and as EFDSS publications implied.
As Chris says, the mid ground now seems to happen, and nowadays 6 times through and getting into the tune is deemed ok.
Q

I have a record, Jimmy Shand plays English Country Dancing (summat like that), with Morris dancers pictured on the cover. I suppose the record company didn't know the difference. That is the epitomy of once or twice through and change, change, change.

I'm not about to knock the quality of Jimmy Shand's playing, far from it. It's a wonderful recording in many ways, but a bit of a car crash in others. It's a thing of its time.

I wonder how much the Scottish revival was influenced by EFDSS practices, rather than our assumption down south that the influence was one way?

... happily drifting off with thread.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: butimba on March 08, 2015, 11:11:32 AM
Just to say thanks all for the replies. Glad to hear that (when not worrying about dancers) it's mostly just a case of what sounds good - now to start experimenting!
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 08, 2015, 12:11:28 PM
I suppose the unifying idea is - do whatever makes it more interesting for the listener or dancer.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 08, 2015, 12:41:04 PM
Andrew - yes I'd forgotten how important Mr. Shand has been in the past. Have recently re-learnt a couple of his cracking tunes. As you say it all headed in one direction with his and EFDSS's style 'back in the day' .

Thanks for bringing it back Chris. As you rightly say, whatever we do it has to be for the benefit of the dancers. That's what you're there for after all!
I think the drift has really been along the lines of 'you can change tune or possibly work the tune more' and get into it's nooks and crannies, again, remembering it is for the benefit of the dancers.
Q
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 08, 2015, 01:06:31 PM
Thanks for bringing it back Chris. As you rightly say, whatever we do it has to be for the benefit of the dancers. That's what you're there for after all!
I think the drift has really been along the lines of 'you can change tune or possibly work the tune more' and get into it's nooks and crannies, again, remembering it is for the benefit of the dancers.
Q
This is all true. But just to widen things a little, Butimba (the OP) didn't specifically mention playing for dancing. There has been a lot of assumption along the way that this is only what she meant.

I just want to point out and remind everyone that for performance sets anything goes. The limit is only one's imagination and musicality/musicianship. If it works, all well and good. If it doesn't, nothing is lost, just try something different.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 08, 2015, 01:57:02 PM
Ahhhh fair enough. Thank you Steve for reminding us.
As you say, if dancers are not involved it widens your scope considerably.
Q
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: IanD on March 08, 2015, 05:09:46 PM
About number of times through playing for dancing, the same rule applies as playing in a session -- if a tune's worth playing, it's worth playing at least four times through. Absolute minimum. For tunes with more space to do things with, play them more times through. Depending on length (down to the caller) for most dances in England two tunes seems the best, or one tune if it's an absolute corker and you're still finding new things to do with it even after eight or ten times through. I think the longest single tune arrangement we had in the Committee Band was 17 times through, and it only stopped then because that's how long the dance was called...
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 08, 2015, 09:17:44 PM
Just to say that the Auvergne people will commonly do a medley of two when it's for dance. That's both around Clermont Ferand, and Fred Paris and his merry men. But the music is "arranged".

The Grenoble cliique never medley, and will drop back to simple chording (or supportive notes on melody instruments) when someone solo's. In dance band mode the solos are agreed beforehand. At the teach-in sessions it can be everyone for himself though people don't play tune when someone improvises. I once started "15 tons" as a blues … they were still playing 25 minutes later! Gives "aah woke up in da mornin" a whole new meaning!  ;)
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: forrest on March 09, 2015, 07:00:36 AM
Some simple key changes that work well would be to modulate up a fourth, or sometimes down a fifth. You can always jump from a tune in a major key to one in the relative minor of that key, and vice versa. As far as rhythm is concerned, best is to experiment, and find what works for yourself. There really are no rules. Some folks make them up, and others ignore them and prosper anyway.  (:)
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: oggiesnr on March 09, 2015, 07:46:49 AM
Context is everything.  In my case I'm usually playing at open mikes where I'm the light relief from a procession of singer/guitarists. So 10 minutes or so to work with which is two or at most three sets of tunes.

Ignoring any instrument changes I may make I need some variety and I need to depart on a high note.  I'm also playing to a non-traditional audience who don't know how the music should be played (speeds etc) but, usually, are fairly open minded.  I think it's in Kathryn Tickell's tune book that she talks about the piping tradition of playing medleys of different paced tunes and I've found that works really well for me.  Sometimes it may just be a key change and change of tempo on one tune (Canal in October works well) or even the same tune (Felton Lonnen can be played as air, jig and hornpipe/reel).  Other times it will be a distinct shift (Stranger on the Shore into Bec a Bec) and across genres/geographical areas.  It's very hit and miss and depends on trial and error, if I don't like the way it sounds then I'm not going to play it in public, if the public don't like it then back to the drawing board.

There are tunes that will hold the attention without needing any companions.  Either because of their own make up (Princess Royal) or because you can do so much with them that you can retain an audiences interest, Shepherd's Hey is one of those which you can have great fun with.

It's very horses for courses, my way isn't the purist's way but then I'm playing in a different environment.

Steve
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on March 09, 2015, 08:46:06 AM
I confess to strong views on this, and find abrupt changes of rhythm particularly unpleasant. Even within the same rhythm you can make mistakes.  At a spot in Chester Festival I put two mazurkas together and they just didn't meet. Later i worked out that one was a trad 3/4, the other a 'slung' 9/8 in the more modern style.

So it's an art. But I'd encourage you to also explore playing a single tune through say 6 times, developing it, inverting phrases, using different basses, substituting right hand chords for melody, breaking rhythm "within itself" finessing a few blue notes in there … the list is endless.

I'm essentially with John. We don't embroider our tunes enough, and in the end a quick "twice through" one tune then switch to another doesn't "add" anything to either of them?  :|glug

I too have strong views on this topic.
I had the misfortune to be president of of the Institute of Bookbinders and Allied Trades some time back. It was a social evening, "the ladies night" how sexist the printing industry was. Anyway a disco was hired and the idiot running it was clueless. After playing something from Status Quo, he then went on to play Demis Roussous. It killed the whole feeling of " up and dancing" and at the end everyone was just sat down drinking and chatting and ignoring the "music" completely.
It can't be that much of a rocket science to get people leaping around and enjoying themselves.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 09, 2015, 08:59:29 AM
A rhythm change that can be effective if it's done confidently and with dancers step-hopping is between straight and dotted hornpipes (or even between different degrees of 'dotted').  Although it's pretty much the same step and tempo for the dancers, the feel is just so completely different that it makes them smile.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Hugh Taylor on March 09, 2015, 07:54:53 PM
I think that in a session/concert setting, a change of rhythm can be quite effective. A group of us play the slow reel Trip to Pakistan written by Niall Kenny, followed by the Rosbif Waltz. Great stuff. Playing for dancing is something else though.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: TedK on March 18, 2015, 12:44:29 PM
Re: playing for dancing:

I play guitar with a Ceilidh band, and our fiddler has brought in several sets that mix time signatures; not something I would ever have previously thought of doing.

I was pretty skeptical about this at first, but I actually think it can be very effective. For example we go into a reel at the end of set of jigs for "Strip the willow". There is a brief moment where the dancers are out of synch until they pick up the new beat, but this actually creates a real sense of excitement and gives everyone a real lift into the final stages.

Obviously it needs to be used sparingly, and at a point where the dancers are totally confident with what they're doing.
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Theo on March 18, 2015, 12:52:26 PM
It is pretty much standard round these parts (NE England) to change rhythm for strip the willow.  Some bands alternate jigs and reels, some start with hornpipes then jigs, then 9/8 jigs, and several other variations. 
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: TedK on March 18, 2015, 02:18:40 PM
That's interesting Theo, our fiddler has spent some time in the NE so that may be the source.

I haven't done that much playing for dancing, so it may be more widespread that I realised, but it was a surprise to me that it could work so well and I thought was an interesting counterpoint to the other extreme of "only play one tune for the entirety of the dance". It seems like there are very few hard and fast rules...
Title: Re: Guidelines for putting tunes together
Post by: Theo on March 18, 2015, 02:25:24 PM
I think the ability to make one tune work for a whole dance either requires a really great tune, like Roger de Coverley, or you have to be a superb musician.  I think it is significant that this idea has been popularised by JK, one of the most talented English players ever.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal