Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: melod-ian on April 29, 2009, 07:04:56 PM

Title: Blowing Reeds
Post by: melod-ian on April 29, 2009, 07:04:56 PM
Hey Forum

I have a 2 row honer Erica.. had it for about twenty years now.. been a bit rough with it in the past, these days im a bit more careful with it

 i seem to be blowing reeds WEEKLY....

I take it most reeds have a shelf life... and if they're all the same age, are they all going to go at the same time?

Is it about time I brought a brand new set ?

Ian
Title: Re: Blowing Reeds
Post by: Theo on April 30, 2009, 08:42:21 AM
I would not have thought that reeds have a "shelf life".  Maybe a playing life.  What number of reeds have you blown?  It is usually the most frequently used reeds that go, especially if you play at full volume all the time.   Hohner reeds are particularly prone to breaking, so if you do decide to replace the lot then Italian reeds, even the basic macchina grade, will normally last longer.
Title: Re: Blowing Reeds
Post by: Quebecois on May 01, 2009, 03:47:00 PM
Hohner reeds are particularly prone to breaking
I am sure you speak by experience, but I am bit surprised hearing this! I have come across many old Hohners that are 50+ years old (including my father's) and have been played extensively during all those years, been tuned a few times and yet have never had any broken reed...
Title: Re: Blowing Reeds
Post by: Lars on May 01, 2009, 05:28:22 PM
Hohner reeds are particularly prone to breaking
I am sure you speak by experience, but I am bit surprised hearing this! I have come across many old Hohners that are 50+ years old (including my father's) and have been played extensively during all those years, been tuned a few times and yet have never had any broken reed...


Well, depends on the life of the box! I've got a box with italitan reeds from the 20's, and despite that they've played a LOT they still sound great and have good response. On the other hand, I've seen hohner reeds break very easily, even though the box appeared to have had a good and comfortable life with very little playing since the 30's.

If the reeds are played a lot at FULL volume, meaning the absolute max they will pull (if only for a few notes during the tune to give more thrust to dancers or a session) it does not take much to get the thing all wobbly. A little rust, a wrong setting in the slot, or a flaw in the steel will cause it to break.
Title: Re: Blowing Reeds
Post by: Theo on May 01, 2009, 05:49:28 PM
I frequently get asked to replace broken reeds.  I probably average one or two broken Hohner reeds a month, can't remember the last Italian one I replaced.   Of course many of those Hohner reeds come from Morris players who tend to play hard, but there are plenty of Italian boxes being played for Morris these days, so it seems to me to be a fair comparison.
Title: Re: Blowing Reeds
Post by: Accordion Dave on May 03, 2009, 05:34:13 PM
I have dozens of ancient accordions and have never seen a broken reed.
 
On an old box I typically see curled leathers and crumbly beeswax, perhaps some surface rust on the reeds of boxes that were stored in a damp cellar.

Do the reeds physically break? Do they come loose from the aluminum reed plate?
Title: Re: Blowing Reeds
Post by: Theo on May 03, 2009, 05:48:28 PM
The reed tongues actually break off. They develop a crack first which causes the reed to go seriously flat, like a quarter tone or more down, real car horn stuff, then eventually the tongue snaps off.
Title: Re: Blowing Reeds
Post by: waltzman on May 03, 2009, 07:40:33 PM
I have dozens of ancient accordions and have never seen a broken reed.
 
On an old box I typically see curled leathers and crumbly beeswax, perhaps some surface rust on the reeds of boxes that were stored in a damp cellar.

Do the reeds physically break? Do they come loose from the aluminum reed plate?

I would guess that most ancient accordions have actually been played very little over their lifetimes (lots of good intentions out there to learn to play instruments) and reed fracture is probably a metal fatigue problem requiring lots of playing to occur.
Title: Re: Blowing Reeds
Post by: Accordion Dave on May 06, 2009, 02:43:49 AM
How hard do you folks play your instruments? Maybe this is a case of melodeon abuse.
Title: Re: Blowing Reeds
Post by: melod-ian on May 07, 2009, 10:17:46 PM
How hard do you folks play your instruments? Maybe this is a case of melodeon abuse.

i played in a punk band a while back.. that was a case of melodeon abuse.. lost a few reeds then. I used to have 2 Hohners.. I've nicked so many reeds out of each one, that I now have just the one thats playable !.. and now thats given up.

 I don't play that loudly, I play in acoustic groups now, and its far too loud to play at full volume.


Title: Re: Blowing Reeds
Post by: IanD on May 09, 2009, 11:49:41 AM
How hard do you folks play your instruments? Maybe this is a case of melodeon abuse.

When Smiffs used Hohners for morris we used to blow reeds all the time, but these were hammered pretty hard -- the team owned two and we replaced one a year, so they lasted two years before being sold off -- knackered -- to budding musicians to learn on. The last straw was a booking where a reed went on one so I switched to the other and then a reed went on that -- result, two boxes neither of which was usable.

When we replaced one with a Castagnari Studio I think it was over a year before we had a reed go.

I guess my Oakwood loses a reed about every couple of years, and it's played pretty hard for both morris and band work.

Ian
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal