Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => News and Events => Topic started by: george garside on March 25, 2015, 12:12:50 PM
-
I will be at Whitby this year and will be doing my usual series of DG melodeon workshops for beginners and probably a couple of 'well known tunes at a steady pace' sessions . Location & times to be confirmed but likely to be Middle Earth.
george :||: :|glug
-
I'll be there
AGAIN !!
John
-
Great ;D , looking forward to the steady tunes sessions :|||:
;D we'll be around all week too, have bought season tickets for the first time ever so we can drop in on anything that takes our fancy when we're not out with the "Infamous Scratch Morris" >:E :|||: :M :|glug
Will post useful links to car parks, buses, Dr's and tide times etc. nearer the date but so people can have a taster of Whitby here are links to Quayside Webcam (http://whitbyweather.com/Quayside%20Webcam/Quayside%20Webcam.html) and Sandsend Turnstone Gallery (http://whitbyweather.com/Turnstone%20Webcam/Turnstone%20Gallery%20Webcam.html) webcams
-
Sadly, I won't be there; last year was my first visit to Whitby for 14 years, and though it was lovely to find how little the town has changed the same, unfortunately, can't be said for the festival. Don't get me wrong - there were high spots, and I thoroughly enjoyed all the sessions I managed to get into; and the Spa Theatre concert with The Wilsons and The Mighty Doonans was something I'll still be talking about till my dying day. And Doc Rowe's lectures were absolute magic. However, compared with times past I really felt I'd been short-changed and I won't be forking out for another season ticket. If I still lived in the UK I'd go to Whitby and not buy a ticket, but living 2000 miles away makes it rather uneconomic. And finally, I REALLY don't like the current interior of The Middle Earth......it used to be such a nice traditional session-friendly old pub......
Sorry George - I'd have loved to have been there and met you, but it ain't going to happen!
Graham
-
Middle Earth had to change, due to the flooding.
John
-
Middle Earth had to change, due to the flooding.
It's OK upstairs, but I agree that the new downstairs layout with its fixed settle-style benches is not too good for a big session.
-
Tickets bought. Cottage booked - last Whitby FW! ;D 8) :P :-* :||: :M etc (Could we have a smiley for Longsword please?)
Chris B.
-
There will be the Traditional Melnet session Thursday pm in the Elsinore. For all players, no matter what standard.
-
I'll be there in the first part of the week, playing for Fool's Gambit and doing a few gigs. Rumour has it that I might even be doing a workshop...
-
I'll be there all week as part of Dearman, Gammon & Harrison. No details of our performance commitments yet, but in the past we've usually chaired a couple of sessions as well as doing concert spots etc. Hope to see some of you.
Cheers
Steve
-
I'll be there with ABU for the Monday night ceilidh...
-
Our penthouse appartment is booked! :Ph Best of all it has a lift, a rare beast in Whitby. I expect the Euro/French sessions will be at the Yacht Club again.
-
I am hoping to be there with my motorhome for at least part of the week, but it will depend on how much Sidmouth and a few weeks in the Orkneys have taken out of our finances and my wife's health. We will have to leave it until the last few day to decide and hope that there is still space on the Moor & Coast site at the school.
Like Tufty, I am looking forward to the Euro/French session in the Sailing Club, something that Sidmouth lacks.
-
I'll be there with Albireo for the Saturday night ceilidh, with Martyn Harvey calling. Really looking forward to it, I haven't been to Whitby for years.
-
If anybody's still looking for accommodation...
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,16479.msg202713.html
-
I will also be there - looking forward to meeting you George.
Colin
-
Welcome back George. Same offer as last time…
Yes, Folk Week evolves. I was on the staff of the very first 1970 sending out tickets and on doors (before that it was a weekend). A stalwart through the 1980s, but we fell out 1989 when they closed the creche and cut street stuff after a loss. That took my familiy to St Chartier 1991, and the rest is history.
In 1990 for the first time we failed to buy a season tickets 'as a protest' and paid on the doors - saving more than half! But that's not the point. No season tickets, no festival, no sessions for the likes of us, so nowadays I buy them essentially as a charitable donation.
-
No season tickets, no festival, no sessions for the likes of us
I don't understand that. What did they have that was better before? Aren't there now all the melodeon-friendly sessions anyone could want?
-
We'll be there with Rivington, which means commitments here and there during the day and probably one evening too, but will try to get to some of the sessions.
Mike
-
Mein Gott, if you don't get to a session I will tell all about the cricket match........ ;)
-
No season tickets, no festival, no sessions for the likes of us
I don't understand that. What did they have that was better before? Aren't there now all the melodeon-friendly sessions anyone could want?
Jack, I think Chris means that if we all just sit in pubs and don't buy a festival ticket, there won't be a festival.
-
Mein Gott, if you don't get to a session I will tell all about the cricket match........ ;)
Maybe it should involve the Ebor army surplus mobile curry kitchen, though it may burn the pub down of course.
-
No season tickets, no festival, no sessions for the likes of us
What did they have that was better before? Aren't there now all the melodeon-friendly sessions anyone could want?
if we all just sit in pubs and don't buy a festival ticket, there won't be a festival.
Spot on. Having "been to" very little in 2013, last year we bought a single ST and I paid entrances. That's an optimisation point, but I felt a bit mean by Friday and will make my usual "donation" this year.
I also think it's weird in other festivals when an official or act visits a session pub and doesn't collect. At least twice I've had a tenner out for the bag, but it was never passed my way. Whitby's easiy in this respect. There's always a collecting team outside the Station Hotel as one leaves for the chippie.
Are we to repeat the Bb/Eb Thursday spot this year? I thought it offered some of the best music of the week last time (:)
-
I thought we did the flats on Wednesday? Let's do it again !
-
OK, will approach same venue for Wed afternoon. Please encourage 'other instruments" :|glug
-
Maybe it should involve the Ebor army surplus mobile curry kitchen, though it may burn the pub down of course.
[/quote]
I've obviously missed something - I didn't know we had one. Do tell! :o
-
Eb / Bb eh? Me and my 6 sided box that wants to be a melodeon when it grows up are up for a challenge!
Joy
-
Is the idea to play G/D tunes at a different pitch, or to play tunes that were originally written in two or three flats? Like this?
X:4
T:The Weeping Birches of Kilmorack
S:Scott Skinner, The Cairngorm Series no.2 (copyright 1922, Bayley & Ferguson)
B:NLS MH.v.133
M:4/4
H:Above the Falls of Kilmorack on the River Beauly is the Pass called the Dhreim
H:when the river runs through a very deep gorge, and most romantic surroundings.
H:The Birches growing on the river banks are very fine, and are the near relations
H:of those further up the river, at Cannich and Glen Affric, so often painted by
H:MacWhirter.
H:A Traction Engine, with two trucks, fell from the road a hundred feet into the
H:gorge, causing the death of two men. Curiously most of the Birches within
H:thirty yards of the scene of the accident died, and at the time of Scott Skinner's
H:visit they stood leafless, decaying, and covered with fungi. He suggested they
H:died from fright, and immediately proceeded to put his idea of their emotion into
H:the language of music. Hence the Weeping Birches of Kilmorack.
G:Pastoral Melody
N:Slow, with deep feeling
Q:1/4=60
L:1/8
K:Eb
B,/A,/|G,>>B, E>>G =A/B/c/d/ e>c | BG G>F EC CB,/A,/|
G,>>B, [G,E]>>G =E/F/G/=A/ Be | dB f=A B2- B_d |
cA ed/c/ BGEB | AG {G}FE B2 BB, |
C>>E D>>F E/e/d/c/ BA | G<E G>F E2 E ||
B |e/d/c/B/ =A/B/G/E/ B<G G>E | B,>>E G,>>E B,E GB |
e/d/c/B/ =A/B/G/E/ B<G G>E | F<B =A<f B2 B^B |
c/d/e/c/ A/B/c/A/ B/d/e/B/ G/A/B/E/| AG {G}FE B2 B^B |
cA/F/ BG/E/ AF/D/ {FED}EB,/G,/ |{B,A,G,}A,>>C B,>>D E2 E |]
The only person apart from me that I've ever heard play it used a multiple-diatonic moothie.
-
There are 2 philosophies. I like to go for Bb tunes, and songs in Bb (Eb not so fluent on my kit) or the related Cm. I'd also (had I a BbEb 2 row) explore the very useful D blues scale, which is it's "built in"one.
Suggested such on the user group, struck down on flames! A lot of folk see this as a way to play their DG session tunes - in different keys. That's OK, and is actually great for bringing brass instuments in as per my invite above.
So there are two views
-
Another E flat slow strathspey (easier):
X:1
T:The Dean Brig of Edinburgh
Z:Jack Campin: "Embro, Embro", transcription (c) 2001
F:04places/abc/DeanBrS.abc
S:Middleton's Collection
M:4/4
L:1/8
Q:1/4=88
K:Eb
G|B>cB<e B<G~G>F|E>F E/F/G/F/ E<B, ~B,2|(C>E)(B,>E) (A,>E) G,2 |C<F~F>E D/E/F/D/ B,>G|
B>c B/c/d/e/ B<G~G>F|E>F E/F/G/F/ E<B, ~B,2|(C>A)(B,>G) (A,>F)(G,>c)|B>cB<D E3 ||
f|g<ee>g f<dd>f |e<cc>=a b<BBd | c<AA>c B<GG>=B |c<FF>E D/E/F/D/ B,>F|
G<EE>G F<DD>F |E<CC>=A B<B,B,>E |(C>A)(B,>G) (A,>F)(G,>c)|B>cB<D E3 |]
That one is fairly familiar to Scottish fiddlers. I can play it as written on the alto flute, but with a roomful of melodeons I might as well be miming.
-
Joy, you'd better start practising ;)
-
Joy, you'd better start practising ;)
You're SO right!!
J
-
Lol ! ;)
-
If I had two flats at Whitby, I'd rent them out.
John
-
If I had two flats at Whitby, I'd rent them out.
John
It's only natural.
Pretty sharpish, I would think, too.
;D
It's OK, I'm looking for me coat...
-
Have another one. There are a couple of oddities...
X:1
T:Buck Layers
S:NLS Acc.12304(A), notebook of James Robertson, 1796, p82
N:upbeats marked as B/c/ in the MS
M:C|
L:1/8
K:G# Minor
Bc|d(BB)(d c)(AA)(c| B)(GG)(B A)F D2 |G2(AB) cAGF|G2GG G2 :|
Bc|d(bb)(a a)(gg)`f|Tf2 (gf) Tf2 (gA)|B2 cd e2fg|fdcB A2(GF)|
B(AA)(c c)(BB)`c| d2 (eG) TF2 (ED)|G2(AB) cAGF|G2GG G2 |]
He copied the title wrong - it's in other sources as "Brick Layers", and in mid-18th-century books as "The Brick Makers Reel". I think it was originally a guild or trade tune of the brickmakers of London. I think the reason for the weird key signature is that he was transcribing it at a semitone-flat piano from a violinist using standard pitch. So, just change the signature to G minor.
Another tune from the same manuscript seems to show the same piano problem, but this time the intended key is not the flat one:
X:2
T:The March of the British forces upon leaving Philadelphia
S:NLS Acc.12304(A), notebook of James Robertson, late C18-early C19
M:C|
L:1/8
Q:1/2=66
K:Eb
E>F|G2 G>G G2F2|EGBe c2B2|c>eB>e A>eG>e|F2 F>F F2
E>F|G2 G>G G2F2|EGBe c2B2|c>eB>e G>Be>f|g2 f>e e2 :|
g>a|b>ag>a bbag|f>ga>g g2f2|E>EE>F G>GG>A|B2 c/B/A/G/ G2F2|
g2 g>g g2f2|e>gB>e c2B2|c>eB>e G>Be>f|g2 f>e e2 :|
Presumably taken from a fluter playing in D.
-
So that's settled
anyone with two (pr three) flats: => Golden Lion, 3pm Wednesday
-
Great see you there (:)
-
Is there likely to be a session for those whose machines have only one effing flat, or even those who have melodeons imported from East Anglia by the C? Or do I have to find an underused pub (can anyone suggest how to find one in Folk Week?) and sit in it on my own, like Achilles sulking in his tent? O tempore! O mores! :(
Chris-the-feeling-left-out-a-bit-'cos-I-don't-have-the-right=sort-of-flat-box :'(
-
I have key/colour synaesthesia. So it seemed to me that the obvious solution was to hire a bunch of beach huts for the week.
http://www.whitbyapartment.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/whitby-beach-huts1.jpg
Left to right:
A G D C A G D C ...
We'd need to repaint some specially.
F is orange and B flat is brown. E flat, I don't have a definite colour association for; maybe metallic gold.
-
Is there likely to be a session for those whose machines have only one effing flat, or even those who have melodeons imported from East Anglia by the C? Or do I have to find an underused pub (can anyone suggest how to find one in Folk Week?) and sit in it on my own, like Achilles sulking in his tent? O tempore! O mores! :(
Chris-the-feeling-left-out-a-bit-'cos-I-don't-have-the-right=sort-of-flat-box :'(
Chris, Whitby is by the C, so I suggest you go to the Jolly Sailors and play an ode to Sir Humphrey Smith, and get thrown out.....
-
There is only one eff, in flat.
John
-
Is there likely to be a session for those whose machines have only one effing flat, or even those who have melodeons imported from East Anglia by the C?
Oh yes. There are usually some good English style sessions for throwbacks like me who haven't a clue what note I'm playing and are still living in those long gone days when you just picked your instrument up in a pub and simply played it to entertain people. >:E
Mike
-
WOW!!! I'll second that one Mike. ;D
-
Name the pub. Preferably one on Whitby ;)
John
-
Elsinore , Thursday 1pm onwards , we usually collapse about 4:30
All Melnetters welcome , no experience required !
-
Is there likely to be a session for those whose machines have only one effing flat, or even those who have melodeons imported from East Anglia by the C?
Oh yes. There are usually some good English style sessions for throwbacks like me who haven't a clue what note I'm playing and are still living in those long gone days when you just picked your instrument up in a pub and simply played it to entertain people. >:E
Mike
;D
g
-
Is there likely to be a session for those whose machines have only one effing flat, or even those who have melodeons imported from East Anglia by the C? Or do I have to find an underused pub (can anyone suggest how to find one in Folk Week?) and sit in it on my own, like Achilles sulking in his tent? O tempore! O mores! :(
Chris-the-feeling-left-out-a-bit-'cos-I-don't-have-the-right=sort-of-flat-box :'(
There are Euro sessions in the Sailing Club every afternoon, where tunes are played in a wide range of keys. Could be ideal for you, Chris, since I know that you have been expanding your European repertoire recently.
-
Single flatters should defo get in with the French style bagpipers and gurdy players - where Dm is a common key. F is also popular in Northumbria (and Whitby is North of the Humber?)
I'll also do a classic D blues for you …
Woke up in the morning, feeling kinda deaf
room … swaying in Bb, Ah'm all alone in F
(Bb King, 1956)
-
For the Euro sessions I take D/G, G/C and C/F. Just need a wheelbarrow to carry them!
-
For the Euro sessions, I take one of my D/G/acc. boxes, which can play in all those keys (I just wish that I could!) I leave my wheelbarrow at home. ;)
-
Essentially the same - C#DG here - handles all of them. I once carried 3 boxes up to the night dancing at St Chartier. Learned a lot about 'practicality'.
-
Mike Gott, we must be related....
-
For the Euro sessions I take D/G, G/C and C/F. Just need a wheelbarrow to carry them!
Gob irons...just sayin' is, I believe the expression... >:E
-
But think of the poor melodeon dealers who you would all put out of business. Us MAD sufferers are the only group keeping the economy going. I see it as my civic duty to buy as many melodeons as possible, only the vulgar detail of cash limits my contribution to this worthy cause. ;)
-
Hi
To help all you sufferers of this MAD affliction we would like to announce that our special MAD clinic will be open at the festival.
We will open every day for the whole week in the Leisure Centre and would hope that we can help with a temporary cure for this terrible affliction,We will be bringing lots of new and pre owned Castagnari melodeons and Manfrini accordions for you to try or just drool over but we request that in the latter case you don't stand too close,
We are sure our special therapy will be effective for a little while at least.
Jill and Pete
www.acorninstruments.co.uk (http://www.acorninstruments.co.uk)
-
OH NO !! If I tell SWMBI about this, she may sabotage my camper
John :||:
-
So that's settled anyone with two (pr three) flats: => Golden Lion, 3pm Wednesday
Martin Whyte has just posted this "unusually lyrical" (http://youtu.be/Tk-5RVMerfI) little motif in Bb onto the FB Bb/Eb users group and I hope we might extend in the usual improvise manner in the Golden Lion. Ably assisted by the little hostelry's excellent real ale, of course
-
The local Carlin Peas may also help here.
-
(:) It's getting closer :|||: The programmes are on sale down town and we've started going through ours with a highlighter marking everything we'd like to see/ hear/ do ...... oh for a tardis ;D
Some hopefully useful links....
Local bus time tables (http://www.northyorkstravel.info/search-results/?s=Whitby) , for pet emergencies Clevedale Vets near the West Cliff (http://www.clevedalevets.co.uk/WhitbyVeterinarySurgery1500.html) , there is also the Beck Veterinary Practice on High Stakesby Telephone: 01947 603269 (couldn't find a web page for them), for humans the local Medical Centre (http://www.whitbygp.com/Making%20Appointments%20in%20Whitby%20Group%20Practice.html) and Whitby Hospital Minor Injuries Unit (http://www.nhs.uk/Services/hospitals/Services/Service/DefaultView.aspx?id=257751) and if you're camping at Airy Hill School I can recommend the Railway Chippy (http://www.railway-chippy.co.uk/) just a short walk away, opposite the First In Last Out pub (very good beer ), Eddie Hewison's, the butcher on the other side of the pub,who will cut your bacon as thick or thin as you like it and Mr Hussain at the little grocers shop further along back Park Terrace who has bread, milk and most other things you may need :D
-
One thing I would find useful: a laundromat within walking distance of the centre. There used to be one near the Endeavour but it closed a couple of years ago.
Most rental accommodation has a dishwasher instead of a washing machine - not a heck of a lot of use.
-
Dunno - your blazer buttons should come up nicely ;) I just take adequate shirts and hand wash smalls if necessary. google for "whitby yorkshire laundromat" will get you at least 2 hits though
-
Larpool Lane Ind Estate appears to have one
John
-
One thing I would find useful: a laundromat within walking distance of the centre. There used to be one near the Endeavour but it closed a couple of years ago.
As John posted there is Whitby Launderette and Service Wash Unit 2E, Larpool Lane Ind Est, Whitby YO22 4LX 01947 820442 (http://www.whitbylaundry.co.uk/6.html), it's a little way out from the centre over the New Bridge but it seems to be the only one left in town now.
-
You could always go commando for the latter part of the week, Chris. :neigh:
John
-
I knew about that one. No use if you don't have a car.
-
Bus?
>:E
-
.....Most rental accommodation has a dishwasher instead of a washing machine - not a heck of a lot of use.....
Now I finally undestand why I had so much trouble doing my laundry last year, though I was impressed with the way something called "Finish" made my shirts sparkle.
Mike
-
.....Most rental accommodation has a dishwasher instead of a washing machine - not a heck of a lot of use.....
Now I finally undestand why I had so much trouble doing my laundry last year, though I was impressed with the way something called "Finish" made my shirts sparkle.
Mike
I bet you also had problems with broken crockery in that strange dishwasher which had a rotating drum. ;D
-
I will be at Whitby all week, but like last year I will not have a stall in the trade fair. I will have a few tools with me if anyone needs an urgent repair. I can be contacted by email of vie a forum pm. If you have an instrument that needs more extensive repair or tuning you can leave it with me to take work on after I get back home.
I will be at the trade fair between 11am and noon each day at the Barleycorn Concertinas stall.
-
That's good to know, Theo. I hope I won't need your services, but it gives me peace of mind to know that they are available if required. If I don't see you at the trade fair, I am sure our paths will cross in the Euro-sessions.
-
I will definitely be a regular at the Euro sessions, dancing more than playing I expect, so looking forward to some delightful music!
-
Tufty and others will provide the delightful music; mine will be more pedestrian. However, I might première a nice Italian mazurka called Principessa that I am in the process of learning.
-
Oh good, is it slow and slinky
-
I just got my stewarding schedule, and it's going to truncate my Wednesday afternoon Melnet meet. I'm working till 3 PM at ther Con Club :(
John
-
Oh good, is it slow and slinky?
I try to make it so. Hopefully, you will be able to judge for yourself. Constructive criticism on its danceability would be welcome.
-
Cugioc! The meet is THURSDAY, so you may not need to miss it. :||:
-
Wednesday is the week's flat keys session, John. To get to Golden Lion from the Con club, just go downhill, towards the swing bridge. The pub is on the right, up the ginnel and can be seen from quay.
So that's settled
anyone with two (pr three) flats: => Golden Lion, 3pm Wednesday
Could people please put this about in other forums. Importantly I don't envisage (or want!) a "melodeon only" session. Brass instruments, clarinets, guitars even are particularly welcome.
-
Everything I had pre-planned, is on Wednesday. Bb/Eb. Melnet Meet Elsinore, second harmonica workshop. Endeavour Silly Shirt Day.
I will have to change my stewarding rota, if possible.
John
-
Euro sessions at the Sailing Club:
Bob - are these on every day? What time do they start please?
Thanks,
Steve
-
Euro sessions are I believe each day 3-5.00.
-
Euro sessions are I believe each day 3-5.00.
Thanks!
-
As eborfiddler said, Melnet Elsinore meet is THURSDAY (:)
-
Despite earlier posting, may yet go mysteriously absent from one of Rivington's dance spots and call in for a while. On the Saturday we start dancing at 12:15, dance throughout the afternoon, do the parade, then appear at the Spa ceilidh at 10:30pm. Quite a day, I think they can do without me for an hour on Thursday.......
Mike
-
Stuck in Thirsk this evening, on my way to Whitby. Anything local tonight?
John
-
Seeing as there are lots of official melodeon friendly events between 1 and 3 on Thursday , I suggest that we have the Melnet meet in the Elsinore from 3 to 5
What do you think ?
-
Suits me. :D
-
Done then ! Pass the word around , I've updated it in here and will do FB
-
Seeing as there are lots of official melodeon friendly events between 1 and 3 on Thursday , I suggest that we have the Melnet meet in the Elsinore from 3 to 5
What do you think ?
Suits me. :D
Suits me too. Thanks Pikey!
-
And just in case you aren't squeezed out by then, Vic Gammon, Annie Dearman and I will be running a session at the Fisherman's Rowing Club, from 5-7 on the Thursday. Hope to see some of you.
Cheers
Steve
-
Is there a Fishermans Argument Club as well ? ;)
-
Is there a Fishermans Argument Club as well ? ;)
I think that might be in Loggerhead Yd (https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/Whitby,+North+Yorkshire+YO21+1DL/@54.4854701,-0.6149669,17z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m2!3m1!1s0x487f17704f8e8119:0x3f3bc64706d36022).
-
Wednesday is the week's flat keys session, John. To get to Golden Lion from the Con club, just go downhill, towards the swing bridge. The pub is on the right, up the ginnel and can be seen from quay.
So that's settled
anyone with two (pr three) flats: => Golden Lion, 3pm Wednesday
Could people please put this about in other forums. Importantly I don't envisage (or want!) a "melodeon only" session. Brass instruments, clarinets, guitars even are particularly welcome.
Hmmmm, been phoning the Golden Lion all week but it just rings out ... I'd be surprised if the pub has closed but you never know in Whitby. Will do a visit in person tomorrow - could Bb/Eb'ers please check here for confirmation of venue. (Default backup plan would be same time in a different pub) ;)
[ed]
Golden Lion are fine for Wednesday… and promise to have more beer in than last year :|glug
-
Will do
-
Well - we've got settled in. Dance and music, here we come! :M :||:
-
We'll be in Whitby for Tuesday night onwards and looking out for melnetters...
-
We're in Whitby and generally Hanging Out. Suggestions for sessions not on the actual festival programme very welcome, having pitched up 30 minutes early to the Dolphin only to see the house full signs go up.
-
The Station has lost it's better sessioners in my view, several have been seen in the Elsinore, which seems to be much more inclusive than before; there are even empty seats!
Others have moved to the Golden Lion wihich is still looking surprised at brcoming a venue. i was singing in the front yesterday, but the quality of music coming from its back room was excellent. It's hosting the Eb/Bb this afternoon. Granby had mainly Irish, mainly fiddles. and there was another diddley-dee session on the fish dock, didn't go in
On East side Black Horse is mainly song again this year. Board is still a top venue, but a couple of the top sessioners settled in there last year don't seem to have come. Yesterday it was reported to be "8 melodeons" - I much prefer a mix (melnet bunfight excepted, of course). Endeavour has been solid song as usual but was actually "closed for bereavement" yesterday. We wandered on to the Far Earth, but music there seemed a series of solos with no one atuallly listening/supporting others,. A fiddler did 7 tunes in a row! We … didn't stay.
A so called "blues jam" back in Baxtergate was the same. Most attendees seemed to talk loudly as others did their spot. We didn't get past the door. There's also the official, shepherded sessions as per programme (eg Dolphin) -. take yer pick. But that's my reconnaisance. Tonight may be different, of course.
-
A friend has pointed-out I'm running a session at The Middle Earth, 5-7pm today. Suppose I'd better go and do it then. I had asked, well, demanded, that any future 'sessions' I run be titled 'tuneswap', and tomorrow's is just so, so I suspect because (a) they didn't tell me about tonight's event, and (b) it's called a session, that this is a typesetting error where they've forgotten to delete it from last year's programme!
-
The event listings are very uninformative. Many sessions are listed simply as 'music session' with no clue what style of music to expect. You can sometimes deduce that if you know the person running the session, but if you don't recognise the name there's no other clues.
I've been to Whitby a number of times over the years, although this year I was only able to be there for the weekend, to play for the Saturday night ceilidh. Even after several visits, I've never felt I've got to grips with it. I don't know where to look for sessions, and it's an exhausting place to wander around on the off-chance. The programme doesn't offer much help. The obvious comparison is with Sidmouth, where I feel I have a much better idea of what is going on - the events listing is far more detailed and is put on line in advance, and the programme also tells you what music to expect in the various pubs. Whitby is still a mystery to me.
-
.
Sorry, I forgot Frank's tune swap, (thought it was tomorrow).
One of the best - designed to get people to listen to others (:)
The most under rated skill in music? :|glug
-
. The most under rated skill in music? :|glug
Couldn't agree more.
Graham
-
thirded!
g
-
Oooh thanks folks, my Tuneswap IS tomorrow, but this extra one has appeared on the programme, and as a 'session', so I had better do wot it says on the tin eh? ..... and run it as a session, encouraging folk to talk loudly if they don't know the tune, and play different versions of the same tune simultaneously, not forgetting speeding-up the originator of course! >:E
-
...not forgetting speeding-up the originator of course! >:E
Yes, seems to be of primary importance...
I once even was stopped before having completed the first run through the "A" music (by a PA player if this matters), and being told that "this tune" (Planxty Irwin in fact) required about twice the speed (I'm neither spinning that out or exaggerating nore was I playing the tune exessively slow on that evening), and out you go!
-
Following with great interest whitby postings having fond memories of childhood thereabouts and early introduction to folk music there, and at least two visits to fest with a well known border side I used to be with years ago. I keep thinking of a return visit as a punter - but stories and experiences of the fest seem quite mixed ! I know fest aint over - and everyone will have different views - but is it really worth a trek from shropshire next year ...I hope there prove to be at least some 'sessions' where a) beer is at least drinkable b) you can actually get in c) there are neither too many boxes ( yep it is possible)or fast Irish reels only apply d) the music isnt treated as a race and finally e) people are at least moderately friendly and are prepared to listen to each other.Hope everyone at Whitby is having a great time !
-
Well. I made the trek from Cyprus last year, having been a Whitby regular pretty well every year from about 1974 to about 1998. Did I enjoy it? Well. yes - but that was partly because of the pleasure in finding how little Whitby had changed and partly because of the sessions I was able to get to and the pleasure of meeting a number of melnetters in the flesh. Would I buy a season ticket again? On the strength of last year, no. There were a few highlights - Doc Rowe's lectures, and the absolutely FABULOUS Wilsons/Mighty Doonans concert, for instance - but on the whole I found it a little lacklustre, and unlike previous years when we couldn't fit in everything we wanted to do we found ourselves scratching about for something worth going to. Just my personal feeling; I might consider the journey from Shropshire or a similar distance if I happened to be in the UK, but I wouldn't fly 2000 miles each way just for Whitby as it is now.
Graham
-
Did the flat key event happen? It clashed with the Eurosession, but I dropped in to the Golden Lion prepared to do E flat instead if it looked promising. Nobody there at all.
-
You got it Frank!!
-
advertised 3-5pm, Jack. I got there about 2.35 so that we could get seats in a group. 9 were there 2 violins, a guitar, 2 concerinas, 3 melodeons and a chap who didn't get an instrumentq out. "Pikey" sent txt'd apologies on the day (poor fella is having a hard time at home; filial duties).
music was … all in flat keys yes, but with no brass and only 2 Bb/Eb melodeons turning up it was pretty mixed. There was a fair bit in Gm or Cm - IMHO a disappointing absence in pervious sessions. We left about 4.45 as it was petering out.
The Eurosession afternoon clash was … difficult to avoid as that wasn't in the programme, and seems to run every afternoon? As with all sessions, the chemistry is completely dependent on the mix of ingredients
-
... but I wouldn't fly 2000 miles each way just for Whitby as it is now.
Luxury ... only 2,000 miles each way. In my day
-
shame, Smiley. Maybe we can meet up nearer you then? Will be passing last week in October, on my way … back to here (it's more or less half way). Any sessions on?
-
I know I'm playing devil's advocate here and will probably be shot down BUT....Having read the above posts, does anyone think that the time of big festivals is over?
Wimborne was wrecked, Sidmouth was appalling and I dread to think what Bromyard will be like.
Too many people ( who don't listen, just want to do their bit) and greedy Publicans and Landlords everywhere.
Maybe it's time for back to grass roots. I know I'm an ill old git but that's my feeling, so there. >:( >:(
-
I know I'm playing devil's advocate here and will probably be shot down BUT....Having read the above posts, does anyone think that the time of big festivals is over?
Wimborne was wrecked, Sidmouth was appalling and I dread to think what Bromyard will be like.
Too many people ( who don't listen, just want to do their bit) and greedy Publicans and Landlords everywhere.
Maybe it's time for back to grass roots. I know I'm an ill old git but that's my feeling, so there. >:( >:(
Judging from the feed back I read on various platforms this years Sidmouth was outstanding??
-
My experience was the year before Lester. My first return for over 30 years. What a change.!
-
I have to confess to having had one of the more depressing musical experiences of my life at Whitby this year. "Canal en Octobre" played in a large session at breakneck speed, no swing and even less feeling. Mind you everything in that session was too fast, have people forgotten how to play slowly or with any feeling for tune?
Steve
-
My experience was the year before Lester. My first return for over 30 years. What a change.!
Something I fondly remember through 30 year old rose tinted sunglasses is different now ;)
-
True, I admit. (:) but you are agreeing with me somehow.
-
As ever, there were parts of Sidmouth that were outstanding ( obviously referring to our beer we served in the Blackmore Bar ;D) , and there were parts that weren't. It is after all, a week event so it does ebb and flow.
I felt it did thin out after the first weekend, which is normal, but seemed a bit more sparse than in previous years, but is that again wearing those rose tinted glasses?
Funnily enough, we met just last night to discuss how things went on our Blackmore Dance Tent Bar, how to improve it etc. and one of the feelings expressed is just as NCB said - is a week too long now?
I have friends currently enjoying Whitby, and my daughter up there for the first time too muttering about sunburn, and fantastic times she's having (whilst I'm wallowing in torrential rain........ ) so maybe any festival is just what you make of it.
Q
-
Whitby has been great this year.
We've been in a couple of good sessions at the Fisherman's Rowing Club - admittedly the first was our own, but the quality of the musicians who come is what makes the session. Second was Dan Quinn and Gareth Kidder this afternoon which was not too crowded and good fun.
We put our heads round the door at the Elsinore, but (like Microbot a few minutes earlier) didn't stay. I hate to have to say this here, but the melodeon is not an instrument that works well for me in large numbers.
-
Whitby has been great this year.
We did from Friday to Tuesday and had a splendid time...including a cracking LNE on Monday
We put our heads round the door at the Elsinore, but (like Microbot a few minutes earlier) didn't stay. I hate to have to say this here, but the melodeon is not an instrument that works well for me in large numbers.
I am of this opinion...I usually carry my gob irons...which is a blessing given my hip and Whitby's hills. On looking I am usually of the opinion that the session doesn't need a 24th melodeon.... >:E
-
Unless it's the Melnet gathering obviously... :|bl
-
Maybe time for another discussion topic- setting quotas for different instrument at sessions. Do two one-row boxes equal one two-row ( but how to assess quality of playing...) hours of fruitful (?) discussion ...
On a general point - maybe there are just too many festivals. I enjoyed Sid last year and this, after a gap of around twenty years. Different to previous experience because now I'm a punter - but I thought for me there was a good mix of good performances , great dancing,interesting sessions and loads of fun things to learn. But everyone is different and has various expectations.
-
In at Whitby as I write this. It seems to me there are more inexperienced players at many of the sessions, which is a good thing, but does tend to mean the quality of playing is, shall we say, mixed. It's especially difficult in bigger rooms where it can be almost impossible to hear properly. Some of the smaller sessions I've been to have been great with sensitive playing and people following the style of the person leading off a tune. The only official session I went to was much less good with a lot of rushed playing. But hey sessions are always hit and miss affairs depending very much on who is there.
The big dances in the Whitby Pavillion have been less well attended than a decade ago. I went to a wonderful concert last night led off by the New Deal String Band which include the legendary Tom Paley and his son Ben. Superb.
-
If there is variation between session venues there is often variation within regularly run sessions
My monthly local session can vary immensely depending on who turns up in the night, which goes to re-Inforce the comment that sessions are hit and miss.
Interesting observation that ceilidhs are less well attended. That seems to be a trend not only at festivals, but at those regular ceilidhs such as the ones we run throughout the winter. Sadly this year we're cutting right back as attendance is utterly variable and always down on previous years despite using nationally recognised bands and there's a limit to our ability to subsidise them.
Q
-
I hate to have to say this here, but the melodeon is not an instrument that works well for me in large numbers.
Although four melodeons can produce a lovely sound (in the right hands) https://soundcloud.com/boxtet/foul-weather-call
-
To me the function of a session is to provide mutual enjoyment for the participants ( and hopefully for any ''non participants '' present.
At the big festivals there are enough sessions led and spontaneous for everyone, exept perhaps those who have an inherent moaning disposition to, find one that suits their musical taste.
If its a 'fast Irish' session that's what it is and if its a 'steady pace' English(ish) or a Bflatish session that's absolutely fine provided participants adhere to the unwritten 'rule' of fitting in rather than trying to drag it into something different.
Just a couple of examples. At one of my 'well known tunes at a steady pace' sessions' whilst the majority were happily if a little plodily playing winster gallop a gang of 4 smartarses tried to whip it up to something resembling fast Irish speed - they were told to bugger off!
At a very good English(ish) lead session with a North East ?/Scottish(ish) flavour which most participants were very happy with what was going on - but alas- one bright burk butted in with an overfast Irish jig and despite the dirty looks went into an uninteligeable rendering of Cock of the North at warp speed. Sensibly most people just stopped playing and continued with dirty looks. Thereafter the session returned to what it was supposed to be.
So why go to a session that plays stuff you are not keen on and then moan about it!
george >:E ;)
-
We had a good mix most of the week at The Board, but there was a hard core of friends who play together relatively often (including a certain Spectacled Warbler of this parish) which I think helps to start a session off well. We had everything from two or three mxxxxxxns to bass clarinet and ocarina (sp?). Some good nights. :-*
Oh, and I completely agree with George!
-
I confess to a little lost sleep in the lead in to Melnet Thursdays, the sheer dominance our one (loud!) instrument is … a bit daunting? I felt that we were much more together this year though. At one point someone somewhere behind me who'd pushed the pace to being about a quarter bar ahead of those in front was assertively *overruled by the room ::)
Next year I'd appeal to any introducing new tunes (:) to keep (please) arrangement simple. With 3+ fingers in action and folk trying to join in I couldn't tell what was tune in one case.
Guess that's to say that in massed play one has to think as much of others, as of what you're doing yourself. "Listening" … is quite the most under-rated musical skill :|glug
*Just spotted George's similar experience. While Formula 1 style play may sound great, solo, or at home, in a large group it turns the tune into musical porridge.
-
*Just spotted George's similar experience. While Formula 1 style play may sound great, solo, or at home, in a large group it turns the tune into musical porridge.
I would describe it more as musical SHoneT!
george ;)
-
… porridge goes straight through me too, George ;)
What makes "beautiful notes" stand out is the space between them ::)
-
…
What makes "beautiful notes" stand out is the space between them ::)
Indeed! Sir Jimmy Shand described it very aptly as 'playing long and short notes'
george
-
At the big festivals there are enough sessions led and spontaneous for everyone to find one that suits their musical taste.
That's true, but finding them is another matter. Your 'well known tunes at a steady pace' session is one of the very few in the programme to have any clues, most are simply described as 'music sessions'. Add Theo's point about a large number of inexperienced players and it is perhaps unsurprising that some do not understand the finer nuances of session etiquette.
It is apparent from many of the posts here that the better music sessions have taken place outside the scheduled programme, in unofficial venues. Again, this is unsurprising. The problem for someone unfamiliar with the festival is discovering these. I dare say those 'in the know' are aware of which pubs tend to host sessions most likely to be to their taste, but unlike some festivals Whitby seems reticent about publicising these. It is not an easy place to wander around at random, especially when carrying heavy instruments.
-
Lest I give the wrong impression, I've always enjoyed Whitby, but I always come away feeling I could have got more from it if I only knew where to look. Especially where sessions are concerned - I've never managed to find a particularly memorable session there. Despite making at least 4 or 5 visits to the festival over the years I still don't feel I really know my way around it. Perhaps its just me.
-
We're just on our way home now (a long long drive) from a very enjoyable Whitby. We enjoyed several of the organised sessions; in fact I don't think we went to a bad one. We also were in a spectacularly good session in the Golden Lion on Tuesday that Chris alludes to up thread. Got to the Mel.net meet but it was too full and possibly a bit too melodeony (is that possible?) so we had a drink in the bar instead. Lots of good workshops and other events too.
Whitby's ceilidhs would be a bit better attended, at least by us, if they put electric bands on in the main evening dance spot. Two years ago we tried one of the earlier "ceilidhs" only to find ourselves at an OAPs tea dance. But because we were camping at Moor & Coast, and getting up for 10am workshops, and walking all round town carrying boxes, we were fit to drop by 11pm most nights, so couldn't stay awake for the LNE. We did get to Random who were fantastic, but overall I think they're making a programming mistake here.
-
what are 'electric' bands?
george
-
Alison's complaint mirrors my earlier post about the lack of information in the Whitby programme. It's written in code - you need to understand that a "dance" is a different thing from a "ceilidh", or you need to recognise the bands and callers to know what to expect. In fact, apart from the Saturday night opener which started at 7pm with King Contra followed by Albireo from 9pm, they don't seem to have any early to mid-evening ceilidhs, they all seem to be "dances", with the ceilidh bands only coming on for the LNEs. Perhaps they assume that ceilidh-goers are all energetic youngsters - maybe true 30 years ago but not now.
There doesn't seem to be much else on at all for ceilidh dancers, apart from the family ceilidhs (which can be great fun but which don't necessarily suit adults without kids).
-
what are 'electric' bands?
george
I'm actually using it as shorthand here, because not all high energy bands use drums and bass guitar, and some slower paced bands do. But I am looking for bands whose music is at least informed by the popular music of the last 60 years. And it's as much about the calling style too -- I don't want to wait 20 minutes while the caller satisfies himself that every single person in the room knows every step of the dance; I'd rather we did the dance an extra couple of times through instead.
And King Contra wasn't ceilidh, at least last night, although I agree it was billed that way -- the crowd was a 'dance' (ie walk sedately) crowd, not a ceilidh crowd (and absolutely not a contra crowd!) and the music, while pleasant enough, wasn't going to raise the roof.
Howard is right about a shortage of ceilidh and (especially) Euro dance events at Whitby. It's kind of the opposite problem to Towersey, where it's possible to do fantastic dance workshops and events all day long but interesting instrument workshops and sessions are always thin on the ground.
-
I attended the Dartmoor Festival for years, long before I began mistreating a melodeon, and always had a good time. The programme was clear and understandable and the events and stalls more or less all together, much like a county show. How any one manages to organise a festival in a town, where local knowledge of the terrain is pretty well essential I can't imagine. Do the Whitby organisers issue a map with events clearly marked, along with the programme? From reading this thread it seems that one needs a degree of insider knowledge to know what's happening and where.
-
speaking as an ex ceilidh dancer ( due to angina) I agree that the events billed at Whitby as 'dances' can be a bit on the grim side unless you are a dedicated EFDSS type 'country dancer' who enjoys doing it 'correctly' and expects the caller to ensure this is so!
These dances are not particularly well attended and therefore could be held in a smaller venue leaving the spa for more energetic but less precise stuff from say, 8 to 11pm perhaps followed by the LNE.
Both types of social perambulation have their enthusiastic aadherents so its about venues and horses for courses
george
-
I . Do the Whitby organisers issue a map with events clearly marked, along with the programme? .
Yes!
g
-
I know I'm going to be accused of rose-tinted glasses syndrome, but Whitby really isn't a patch on what it used to be. There may be many good socio-economic reasons for this, and I'm intelligent enough to expect things to change and move on, but the old vitality and variety is definitely missing. Onwards is not necessarily upwards. Last year we popped into a number of dances/ceilidhs/whatever at the Pavilion and to be honest, I'd rather have gone to a PTA barn dance. I've been a dancer since my mid-teens, and as I said to my orthopaedic surgeon last week when discussing a knee replacement, "If I have to give up dancing I might as well give up living". How many dances were we moved to get up and do at Whitby last year? Precisely none. We didn't even bother to go the final ceilidh, something we'd never have missed in years gone by. I don't know where the fault lies, but something's not quite right somewhere.
Graham
-
How any one manages to organise a festival in a town, where local knowledge of the terrain is pretty well essential I can't imagine. Do the Whitby organisers issue a map with events clearly marked, along with the programme? From reading this thread it seems that one needs a degree of insider knowledge to know what's happening and where.
Actually the map's pretty good, though it doesn't have contour lines on! Now, after our second Whitby, we know which are the flattest routes from one place to another. They are still Not Flat. And it doesn't show the pubs or other fringe events, you kind of have to know. There's a hard-to-find daily news sheet that has a lot of useful info of this kind in (memo to festival organisers; it takes *two minutes* to post these to your website! And then everyone can read them).
We do lots of festivals on greenfield sites, but it's really nice being in a town that's a holiday destination in its own right. I do like the fact that every festival is different.
-
Graham,
can't judge on what you're saying except that the mere existence of a thing like RTGS doesn't mean that in a given case there couldn't be advancements in a bad sense to be complained of...!
Best wishes - Wolf
-
what are 'electric' bands?
george
Guilty as charged m'lud... >:E
-
I spotted a car rear window sticker in Robin Hood's Bay today that I'd love to have on an instrument case at some sessions: "I'm Speeding Because I Need To Poo".
-
Brilliant! a supply of such stickers to craftily stick on the cases of speeder uppers would not be a bad idea
george >:E :D
-
This has been my first Whitby and on balance it has been good fun. I have avoided sessions and stuck to workshops though. Earlier in the week I went to the Middle Earth and it was dreadful - a session downstairs, a different one upstairs and a bunch of people outside doing their own thing, all competing with each other. We left and headed back to our digs. As we passed the Elsinore, we were drawn in by the music to discover a small impromptu session of 6 musicians with Saul Rose and Dave Mallinson being 2 of them. It didn't last long but was sublime!
-
Was at Whitby from Wednesday morning and left late afternoon today. We decided to go at the last minute, having felt deprived of playing opportunities at Warwick...
We enjoyed the time overall, but would echo some of the earlier comments. In terms of sessions I went to four, and they were mainly great. The two with JK and Alistair Anderson were the best ever, and I am grateful to have been to them. The discipline and timing really helped, no racing or inappropriate speeds. Incredible. And I think the better for there not being too many melodeons. Another good one was led by Steve Harrison and Vic Gammon and was very pleasant. I arrived more than halfway through at another one in Mid Earth today and encountered racers for the first time in the week, as well as some who found it fun to start in the F1 manner, imho murdering the tune. Not all of them though, and I think Pete Coe was trying to haul them back... The fact that the room was almost entirely filled with melodeons (not literally) may explain this! I agree with Anahata and others that massed melodeons are not necessarily the recipe for a good session.
I enjoyed meeting a few more faces at the Melnet meet, inc Dr Chris, Pikey (smiling), Nick, Myra, Malcolm and others, as well as people I have met before. Thanks for remembering that tune, Nigel! Was sorry to have to leave early.
Off to EAMT trad day next weekend. (:) PS didn't go to any dances. Great gig on John Clare by Gordon Tyrrall.
Mike
-
Ive been at Whitby 45 years now, on and off including LNE's Family celidhs, heavy metal a capella in what is now called the Station Hotel, trad and jazzed up sessions, melodeon only(!) ones, scratch morris, and even a Tea Dance (with Blowsabella ::)).
the festival has definitely evolved in that time, for me most of the fun always lay in its fringe, albeit I did get to 4 concerts for my £168 ticket donation. And there's the almost constant, random encounters with old friends, some not seen in decades :D
The festival itself has a faded elegance and air of slow decay, frankly I think they need to take more risks, and yes, embrace new technology. All cultural entities either renew, or perish?
Yes those dances are evily dull - 20 minutes walk through for 10 minutes of action was never my recipe for fun, but sadly they were still doing that at the LNE I got to. In Belgium a "modern" formula has evolved of an hour of tuition before a "Boombal" dance starts, minimal didacticism from the stage during it. It works! 250 young people up for a gavotte, FFS! But would EFDSS types cope with that after "walking through" so many times already?
-
Really interesting views from all.Definitely sounds to have changed a LOT. I Don't think I'll be heading for Whitby fest unless I go with a mindset of being in an interesting place with opportunities for paddling, building sandcastles and eating lots of Fortunes kippers ,with the odd bit of music thrown in if in the right place. I wonder what proportion of festival attendees buy full tickets as opposed to buying the odd ticket for concerts , dances ( sound missable) and then stagger round the crowded pubs for music. But I'm posting from home in Shrewsbury before dragging myself back to a little local festival... :|||: :|glug
-
one advantage Whitby has is that being a very nice seaside resort it is easy to combine the festival with a family holiday, particularly if not all the family are particularly 'folk orientated'. Also with the 'fringe' being in many small venues i.e. pubs there are many more free sessions taking place at the same time for both singers and musicians.
There used to be on all week a kids ceilidh run by Lisa Austin which for a very moderate fee enabled mum and dad to have a couple of hours in fringe pubs every evening. Way back with young 4 kids I found this very helpful and its reintroduction would be worthwhile
But at the end of the day so to speak Whitby is an excellent and unique festival with a vast number of 'events' It is therefore very much what ''you'' make of it!
george
george
-
To all those who attended our therapy clinic at Whitby we thank you and hope treatment was successful but would like to warn you our treatment may only be temporary and further sessions may be required.The clinic will be open again at Melodeons at Witney where therapy will be available,however if remedial treatment is required please contact us,we are sure we will be able to offer something to calm this terrible affliction.
Jill and Pete
www.acorninstruments.co.uk (http://www.acorninstruments.co.uk)
-
Chris your remarks about dull ceilidhs struck a chord. I had high hopes of last night with 422 playing. For me they are the most exciting dance band around at the moment. Unfortunately the evening was ruined by bad choice of dances and rather grumpy calling from Barry Evans. Many complex and unfamiliar dances, long walk throughs and short dances. It was a desperately disappointing end to the week. The band were frustrated too that they were unable to really get things going. Unfortunately Barry Evans is the Festival Director with responsibility for social dance.
Concerts that I went to were very good with a healthy proportion of performers new to Whitby. And there was lots of opportunities for spontaneous dancing at the euro session.
-
Reply 112 ! I rest my case. :'(
-
there are a good number of 'traditional' ceilidh dances that are known to and enjoyed by most regular ceilidh goers and which are easily 'picked up' by those who don't know them as many in a set will be able to help them/shove them around etc.
So why do many callers have to invent arty farty dance formations just to show how clever they are. A callers job is to facilitate and encourage not to teach. The same can be said about bands that have to think up new arty farty tunes when there are loads of well known tunes that traditionaly fit well with certain dances and that contain the essential 'lift and thump' to propel dancers efartlesly round the floor.
george
-
Absolutely agreed
-
there are a good number of 'traditional' ceilidh dances that are known to and enjoyed by most regular ceilidh goers and which are easily 'picked up' by those who don't know them as many in a set will be able to help them/shove them around etc.
I once responded to an official Whitby festival request for new ideas. I suggested a ceilidh without a caller for one night. There are more good dancers per square yard in Whitby than just about anywhere. Give them an evening of great music and well loved dances and everyone would love it. More dancing time, and no walk throughs. It works in Scotland, and Ireland and plenty of other places too.
The reaction to my suggestion was almost entirely negative.
-
Just got back from whitby. I feel it is not one festival but many that go on almost independent of each other: singers, players (English, Irish and other), morris, social dance - two people could be there for the whole week and never see each other! I cannot speak about the social dance but the playing sessions, organised and fringe were good as were the dance displays and workshops that I attended. I first attended back in 1976 and for me it is better than ever but then I don't go to concerts or social dance events.
-
The knees have kept me out of ceilidhs for the last year, but before that I had noticed a trend towards more complex dances. At first it was refreshing, having a social dance background I could cope quite easily >:E and doing some of the social style dances with a bit more oomph was good fun.
But for the me the fun of ceilidhs and barn dances is charging round doing relatively simple dances that can survive the inevitable cockups.
I can also point out that social dancers do not, by and large, like long walkthroughs. They are there to dance. At workshops it's different. I suspect a lot of callers confuse interesting and complicated. I suspect most dancers are too polite to say so, and most callers are too polite to just Go without the set that really hasn't got it.
-
I'm following this discussion with interest...I think the bit I found most intriguing was sitting in the social dance prior to our LNE on the Monday...floor reasonably full of social/EFDSSy/proper (insert description of choice enjoying the band (Stradivarious I think...) and the caller whose name escapes me...American chap...played a bit of tina and recorder...something to do with Early music I think.
At one stage he called Cumberland Square 8 which the crowd embraced with a will...I do wonder whether they would have done so had it been a caller from the eceilidh side of the spectrum...or would there have been tutting and sitting down?
And Theo.. a caller free ceilidh would be a brilliant idea...
-
I have to admit I'm still not really sure what "eceilidh" actually means. From what little contact I've had with it seems to consist of a lot of unnecessarily complicated dances bearing little resemblance to traditional English social dance, done, mainly to indifferent music, by young(ish) people unfettered by any sense of rhythm or style and unrestricted by any dance technique - or is that the current crop of "Border" morris? I'm not sure I can tell the difference........
I'll get me coat.....
Graham
-
'eceildh' certainly should not mean complicated dances. In contrast with the more sedate social dance which was the backbone of the EFDSS until recent years, e-ceilidh ("English Ceilidh") is supposed to be about simple dances, dancing with more energy but perhaps less precision. On the music side, it seems to favour polkas more than reels, and louder bands. Not necessarily electric, as mentioned earlier, because the Old Swan Band is a supreme example and has no electric instruments. The social dance bands also tends to have piano accordions where e-eceilidh has melodeons.
See also http://www.fendragon.co.uk/eceilidh.php (thanks to Steve Mansfield for the wonderful text I've quoted with permission there) and less facetiously http://www.webfeet.org/eceilidh/Overview.html
Barry Evans is definitely from the social dance world, and from what I've heard, has tended to book the same bands every year, but has been under pressure from festival management to be more adventurous in recent years.
Whitby still has this curious double dance every evening at the Spa, with old-school social dance in the earlier evening followed by something more like E-ceilidh later. Two years ago English Rebellion actually did both dances in a row, with different callers, which was an interesting experience.
-
Hello All,
I'm back on-line again after my week at Whitby. (I don't do these new-fangled mobile phone/smart phone things, so no internet/e-mail access while at Whitby, which may or may not be a good thing...)
Sorry to learn that some folks have been disappointed, but it was not our experience. As usual, my wife and I had a great time. Perhaps we're are easily pleased...
It was lovely to meet up with old friends and to make new ones. I agree with Tufty that Whitby Folk Festival is like many festivals all happening in parallel, and it is all too easy to miss people. But it is so nice to have the choice of events and activities.
I'm pleased to report that I've had some gratifyingly nice feedback from my workshops: three days of Beginners' melodeon (standing in for George Garside) and a couple of days for my own intermediate melodeon workshops. On top of that, some splendid sessions (thanks especially Ken Watson and Chas Marshall!!) and concerts. One particular highlight was the one Yacht Club Euro-session which I was able to attend and had the great pleasure of learning some new tunes, playing with a really friendly group of musicians, and accompanying Theo's and his wife's most excellent dancing. I would have liked to get to more of them, but other things got in the way.
Another highpoint was Frank Lee's tuneswap which I think worked really well and produced some lovely sensitive playing and joining in. People were really listening. It was slightly unfortunate that the Middle Earth was a bit over-full and noisy for the early part of the session, but nevertheless it was a good event and I hope it happens again next year.
Sorry I didn't make it to the melnet session, Chris R; again other commitments emerged during the course of the week which prevented me. But it was nice to see you and chat at the Euro session. Great to see other regulars too - Anahata and Mary, Bob Ellis (thanks for all your session leading!), Paul B, John Cugiak, Pikey, etc.
Finally a big congratulation to Pete and Jill Ward of this parish, running their Acorn Instruments stand so successfully. It's nice to know there are some proud new Castagnari owners out there. ;)
Cheers, all...
(tired, but happy Steve)
-
I have to admit I'm still not really sure what "eceilidh" actually means
(Crossed with Anahata) The intent is rather the opposite, and the practitioners of "English ceildh" - name devised since barn dances became ceilidhs and those still called barn dances seem to attract rather more Yee-hahs and pink Stetsons rather than feet on the floor - endeavour to obtain lively, energetic dances to a good standard, with detectable stepping and decent bands.
The demographic, like so many others these days, is leaning to the right but not as far as any other folk activities and the dances seem to be attractive to the young, but those who can dance.
Having lurked on the edge of this for some time, a dance recommended by the eceilidh cognoscenti would reliably be a good evening.
However, considering your alternative possibility, I hesitate to go there but... >:E
-
Finally a big congratulation to Pete and Jill Ward of this parish, running their Acorn Accordions stand so successfully. It's nice to know there are some proud new Castagnari owners out there. ;)
I am one of these, being the proud owner of a G/C Tommy named "Ethel" after my Mum who recently died. My inheritance paid for the new box and it will be a lasting reminder for me. Acorn Instruments really have really got their act together, providing good service, keen prices and deserve to do well.
-
'eceildh' certainly should not mean complicated dances. In contrast with the more sedate social dance which was the backbone of the EFDSS until recent years, e-ceilidh ("English Ceilidh") is supposed to be about simple dances, dancing with more energy but perhaps less precision. On the music side, it seems to favour polkas more than reels, and louder bands. Not necessarily electric, as mentioned earlier, because the Old Swan Band is a supreme example and has no electric instruments. The social dance bands also tends to have piano accordions where e-eceilidh has melodeons.
Well, yes - that's what I would have thought, and I would have counted the last two or three bands I played in before leaving the UK under that umbrella; but in practice it seems to have morphed into something else. Most of the posts, for instance, on the e-coli e-ceilidh online message board refer to dances I've never heard of (may be my fault, of course) which seem to be so complex that it hardly seems worth the effort - complication for the sake of it. And I still stand by my opinion of the undisclipined, arrhythmic and inelegant "step-hop" (as I believe they call it, though in my book it's a single-step) that pays no attention to the comfort or convenience of other dancers on the floor - and that often includes partners, never mind other couples in the same set. Whatever happened to that good old core of traditional ceilidh dances? The true delight of traditional social dance for a real dancer is the opportunity to improvise on, for instance, Dorset 4 or Cumberland Square. Complex dances for the sake of it simply revisit the EFDSS "Playford Rules and Everything Else Is Inferior" attitude that our generation had to fight against in the 60s and 70s. I clearly remember a local EFDSS know-it-all in the Midlands in the early 70s, when I was running a monthly ceilidh series with my band at the time, saying "Well, I suppose if you can get people to come to your events we can always teach them to do it properly later on", or words to that effect. If you're a dancer it doesn't matter how simple the dance is - it ain't what you do, it's the way that you do it.
I admit I'm out of touch with the current UK situation, and I'm reliant on what I can glean from t'internet, but that's the way it seems to me. I'm happy to be proved wrong, if indeed I have misinterpreted things.
Graham
-
I have to admit I'm still not really sure what "eceilidh" actually means.
Graham
Old Triumph would have fitted in perfectly... :|glug
-
I have to admit I'm still not really sure what "eceilidh" actually means.
Graham
Old Triumph would have fitted in perfectly... :|glug
Thanks Baz - that's the nicest thing anyone's said to me in a while! A couple of pints if and when our paths next cross!
Cheers
Graham :|glug :|glug
-
I never realised there was such a divide between (e)ceilidh and "social dance". Here in the northeast we just have ceilidhs/dances/barn dances, and the names are pretty much interchangeable. Callers mostly call well know dances, so walk throughs can be quite brief, and the dancers have a lot of fun. If the want to step, skip, rant or walk, nobody really minds as long as it fits the music.
-
In the south, and you can include Birmingham in that - although I suppose you would, anyway - "social dance" (AKA Playford") is the domain of the 60+ age group who walk or shuffle their way around fiendishly complicated dances with everlasting walk-throughs, and who tut furiously at any anyone who dares put a foot out of place or finish a move a millisecond late.
Ceilidh goers are blythe free spirits who skip, hop, rant or polka around the floor paying no attention to care or worry, and even less to the caller.
Unfortunately, neither is completely untrue.
-
the domain of the 60+ age group who walk or shuffle their way around
Careful!! 20 or more years ago that might have been the case. Unfortunately these days it seems in folk dancing 60 (or even 40!) is the new 80....... Don't forget it was we baby-boomers who spearheaded the anti-EFDSS, pro-real English dance movement 40+ years ago, and many of us are still waving the flag even though we're into our seventh decade! Over the last few years I've met a number of so-called dancers and musicians whose attitudes are very firmly those that you describe, Malcolm, only to discover they're 5, 10, 15 years younger than I am. When I stop feeling 18 and bolshie it'll be time to put me in my box............
Graham ;)
-
... and a couple of days for my own intermediate melodeon workshops.
Which were excellent! Thanks. N
-
to me the essence of a good ceilidh/barn dance or whatever you want to call it is simple easily remembered dance formation, well known tunes preferably played simply with minimal arty farty additions but with lots of drive, lift and rhythm and each to his own as far as steps are concerned. Some bands seem to forget that their prime/sole purpose is to provide foot tapping rhythm for the dancers and instead play their own complicated ''clever compositions'' that often lack the essential qualities for dancing
Jimmy Shand kept things very simple with only himself and the fiddler playing the melody. The second box piano double bass and drums provided the ''dunt'' ( his word for the rhythm) Eg for the Virginia reel he played Coming round the mountain, Let him go let him Tarry Maggie and Im a yankee doodle dandy. I think there is a video of this set on you tube as it was recorded on the DVD dancing with the Shands.
-
Like, Steve, I have just returned from a 'full on' week at Whitby and, while I did have an internet connection there, I was much too busy enjoying myself to spend time on melodeon.net!
My personal experience was that it was one of the best Whitby Festivals for many years and all the people I spoke to about it agreed. The concerts and workshops I attended were all excellent, especially Steve's intermediate melodeon workshop and the concert performances of Moirai (including Mel Biggs of this parish) and John Tams and Barry Coope. I didn't attend any programmed dances so I can't comment on them, but the overall atmosphere was very vibrant and positive. No doubt the good weather helped.
Thanks to those who attended the sessions I led and for the many positive comments I received after them.
With regard to the 'fringe' sessions, it is difficult for any festival to indicate in the programme where and when they take place or anything about the sort of music that is played because things change from year to year. Sidmouth tries to indicate where and when some of them happen, but they were still listing the Loose Knit Band sessions as being in the Sailing Club this year, despite them moving to the Balfour Arms four years ago.
The nature of a session depends very much on who attends. For instance, I spent several evenings in the Board and the atmosphere and range of tunes was different on each evening. Some were relaxed sessions where everybody seemed 'in tune' (no pun intended) with everyone else and others were a bit more frenetic because tunes were speeded up by one or two 'racers' (it only takes one!)
Somebody commented earlier in the thread about the lack of Euro-dance and music on the programme. I agree that this is an unfortunate omission, but it is one which we may begin to address for 2016. I have been approached to lead a Euro tune and dance session next year, although the organising committee will have to confirm this before we can say that it is definitely going to happen. If it does go ahead, Simon Dumpleton has indicated that Bright Season would be willing to contribute to it, if they are at Whitby next year.
For several years, there have been unofficial Euro tune and dance sessions every afternoon in the Yacht Club, in which it has been a joy to play for the dancers, who usually include Theo. Next year, there will be a clash between the Folk Week and the regatta, which will prevent us from using the Yacht Club on the Sunday. We are hoping that the programmed Euro session will be on Sunday afternoon to compensate for the unavailability of the Yacht Club.
-
Many thanks for your support and endorsement of the Tuneswap Steve. There was other good feedback so I'm hopeful it'll run again. (If only because they forget to delete it from this year's programme, as they did with the first of mine this year!). The Tuneswap certainly seems a case of Q.E.D! I'm used to the idea that I can sit in sessions for hours on end and never hear anything new, but, as in a previous tuneswap, about 3/4 of the tunes were new to me, and as you say, were well played too! When it's a Tuneswap, rather than a session, it becomes obvious that the number and breadth of tunes in folks' heads is of another order of magnitude compared to that of the common 'session tunes'.
-
Eg for the Virginia reel he played Coming round the mountain, Let him go let him Tarry Maggie and Im a yankee doodle dandy.
I'm nicking that.
I'm also having this for Virginia Reel - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ev8CFsApKlo
-
Perhaps people take different approaches to sessions, some will play tunes they know will be unfamiliar in the hope of making them better known while others will stick to familiar material to maximise participation. One evening a very good player started a tune but gave up when it became apparent that nobody knew it, she was uncomfortable playing solo in a session. It is also worth noting that different areas have very different session standards. I play quite a few Bob Cann tunes and at Dartmoor lots of people joined in but at Whitby there were far fewer takers. I often start a tune that I think is a standard, only to find myself playing a solo! For me the ideal session is about 75% tunes that I have at least heard before, so can have a bit of a go and 25% new stuff. As I don't get much chance to play in sessions for most of the year I don't want to sit while everyone plays their most obscure material. A tune swap is quite different and very valuable. The important thing is to know what you are letting yourself in for to avoid disapointment.
-
That Scottish dancing seems to be a serious business......
-
......these days it seems in folk dancing 60 (or even 40!) is the new 80.......
Dunno. After a week walking around (i.e. up and down) Whitby it feels like my 56 is now 80....
And I'm still a bit unsure, even after al the dialogue, what an eceilidh is, but I know that over here near Manchester they always used to say "E's are good", but that might have been something else.
Mike
-
Yes, I agree with all that Tufty. For my part, though, I'm more of a listener than a participant, but that's just my two penn'orth. The idea was that at a festival like Whitby, where people gather from all over the country, it would be great to hear some of the tunes other folks play in their sessions, or even tunes they daren't play, because they feel it incumbent on them to play tunes from the common repertoire. Included in the 'obscure' category are some of the most beautiful tunes, and tunes which don't lend themselves so well to being played by large groups in an impromptu fashion, but they're part of our heritage, and shouldn't have to wait until (insert big name) has recorded them before we take any notice. Recording technology is much more widely and cheaply available now, and we can use smartphones and cameras as reservoirs of tunes to learn, and thus spread the music gospel. As I'm sure I've said here before, hearing the tune 'Three around Three' played in four consecutive pubs on my way home from The Board at Whitby, seemed to confirm my suspicion that what was happening was a shrinking, rather than an expansion of the common core.
-
I agree entirely with Tufty and Frank's comments. A 75%/25% split between 'common repertoire' tunes and more obscure tunes makes for a great session, in my opinion. Listening to (and then maybe learning) new tunes is as interesting a part of a good session as joining in with tunes I already know.
I would also like to see more of Frank's tune swaps. Perhaps Sidmouth might be interested in programming one or two? Sorry, Frank that I didn't get to your tune swaps at Whitby this year due to a clash of commitments.
-
I'm just back on melnet after my 23rd Whitby where I had a great time. Of course there were some sessions where the music was played too fast and with far too many melodeons but what do you expect at a large festival where everyone wants to play ? If you want quieter sessions come at the end of the week when its quieter - or go to Frank's tune swap.
The Harrison / Dearman / Gammon sessions were excellent - having a few songs thrown into the session seems to bring the volume and tempo down . Damn - I wasn't going to mention my favourite session in case they get too busy next year.
I organised an anglo concertina players get together where one person played at a time and that was an excellent antidote to massed sessions.
And the prize for the worst session of the week - the melnet gathering ! You're all splendid chaps but hearing people murder the Bear Dance - faster and faster and louder and louder is not my cup of tea even if it was meant to be "fun" and not sheer musical illiteracy ( I would put an emoticon here but not sure which to choose) .
Hope to see you Whitby-goers next year - but not at the melnet gathering unless it turns into a more Frank-like one person palying at atime gathering
Paul
-
And the prize for the worst session of the week - the melnet gathering ! You're all splendid chaps but hearing people murder the Bear Dance - faster and faster and louder and louder is not my cup of tea even if it was meant to be "fun" and not sheer musical illiteracy ( I would put an emoticon here but not sure which to choose) .
Just to (again) note that the 'B' part of sessionoid 'Bear Dance' is rather different from what is is played in the original Belgian version (and elsewhere within continental Europe).
Brits (and Canadians ::)) repeat 'A' bars 9-16 … whereas the real tune does something different. I suspect this to be a 1970's mis-remembering. But 'flat out' the resultant 'average note' is the same :|glug
-
Realize having read about Frank's tune swaps that I would have enjoyed these. Will look out for and prioritize them when we come again. Unlike a lot of people what are said to be " standard" session tunes don' t figure much in the list of tunes I have chosen to learn or are played in the sessions I go to. Interestingly I keep a list of " starters", about 30 tunes I am happy to launch into or play solo, and when I showed it to a melodeon playing friend from another part of the country, there was an overlap of only one or two tunes.
I never realised there was such a divide between (e)ceilidh and "social dance". Here in the northeast we just have ceilidhs/dances/barn dances, and the names are pretty much interchangeable. Callers mostly call well know dances, so walk throughs can be quite brief, and the dancers have a lot of fun. If the want to step, skip, rant or walk, nobody really minds as long as it fits the music.
Thank goodness for this, which reflects the dances I have been involved in around this area.
M
-
Paul's point about the melnet session is well made and mirrors my view about it and about the second melnet session at Sidmouth. In both cases, there was a lot of ambient noise from the bar, so opportunities for conversation or for listening to one or two people playing were limited. In contrast, the first melnet session at Sidmouth took place so early in the festival that there was hardly anybody else in the Sailing Club bar and little ambient noise. Consequently, there were opportunities to talk in a relaxed atmosphere and to listen to each other play.
For the above reasons, I am considering moving the Sidmouth melnet sessions next year to a different venue where other musicians don't go. Watch this space for further details.
It might be worth doing the same thing at Whitby. A possible venue might be the Yacht Club, which has Euro sessions every day from 3.00 until 5.00 pm, but doesn't appear to be in use at other times. Depending on our other commitments, a lunchtime session there might be feasible, provided we finished around 2.30 pm. In addition to having a bar in a light, airy venue with lovely views across the harbour mouth, they sell sandwiches, pies and very nice home-made cakes. The Yacht Club is also a much larger venue than the cramped Elsinore, so we would be able to sit in an open circle, which would be much more conducive to conversation and to listening to each other play. What do folk think?
If this is thought to be a good idea, I could ask the Yacht Club whether they would allow us to use their facilities through Katie, a fiddle player who is involved in the management of the Club.
-
There was at least one other event in the Yacht Club - a mediaeval dance workshop which I think preceded the Euro session.
-
I like Bob's idea of using the yacht club as the melnet venue. In the pub we are limited to just another session, in a different venue the would be the chance for a real chance to discuss/compare notes. Not much chance of that with PIANO ACCORDEONS blasting in your ear!
-
hearing the tune 'Three around Three' played in four consecutive pubs on my way home from The Board at Whitby, seemed to confirm my suspicion that what was happening was a shrinking, rather than an expansion of the common core.
I don't think I've ever heard it played in a session in Scotland, so getting it firmly in my head gives me something exotic to try now I'm back home.
You seem to get a "Tune of the Year" phenomenon at festivals. It was "The Fiery Clock Face" at Whitby the first year I went. At one of the Edinburgh fiddle festivals it was "Paddy's Leather Breeches", which got so obsessional that when I was going home on a night bus in the rain, the squeaky windscreen wipers seemed to be playing it.
-
hearing the tune 'Three around Three' played in four consecutive pubs on my way home from The Board at Whitby, seemed to confirm my suspicion that what was happening was a shrinking, rather than an expansion of the common core.
Correlation does not imply causation ;)
-
Thanks to Paul (pbsalt) and Mike (oysterboy) for positive comments about the two Dearman/Gammon/ Harrison sessions at Whitby. The speeds were always appropriate (in our view) and , as Paul suggests, it may indeed be that our objection to musical apartheid (ie the separation of songs and instrumentals) has a role to play in this. It may also be that having someone 'running' a session makes a difference too, even if that seems somehow undemocratic. I attended Pete Coe's session (as did both Mike and Paul) which was pretty much OK until the formal end when Pete left. As I was packing my box away, some of the remaining musicians started playing much faster than they had while Pete was there.
Cheers
Steve
-
hearing the tune 'Three around Three' played in four consecutive pubs on my way home from The Board at Whitby, seemed to confirm my suspicion that what was happening was a shrinking, rather than an expansion of the common core.
Not entirely surprising - as the set of players becomes more diverse, so the extent of commonality might be expected to reduce. For some players, the opportunity to lead a tune, or indeed play solo, is a key element. For others, the attraction of a session lies in the ability to join in, incognito, under the shelter of a common tune.
Given players from a range of backgrounds, one might expect more pressure on the common core from the latter group and therefore to hear those tunes more frequently.
-
It may also be that having someone 'running' a session makes a difference too, even if that seems somehow undemocratic. I attended Pete Coe's session (as did both Mike and Paul) which was pretty much OK until the formal end when Pete left. As I was packing my box away, some of the remaining musicians started playing much faster than they had while Pete was there.
This happened almost exactly in the same way after Ken Watson's mainly English tunes sessions, particularly the final one in the Middle Earth on the Friday evening. We'd had a lovely couple of hours playing all sorts of hornpipes, jigs and polkas at a nice lolloping pace. Within 5 minutes of Ken and most of the rest of us packing up our instruments, there were a couple of fiddle players, a guitarist and a piano accordionist (who'd all been there all along) launching in to Irish reels played at 100 mph, blurring all the notes into a fortissimo mush. What is the f***ing point? That's not how Irish music is meant to be played... (is it?).
I don't know what happened after that - we left them to it and went to gerrus chips.
-
Quote from Malcolm Bebb:-
Not entirely surprising - as the set of players becomes more diverse, so the extent of commonality might be expected to reduce. For some players, the opportunity to lead a tune, or indeed play solo, is a key element. For others, the attraction of a session lies in the ability to join in, incognito, under the shelter of a common tune.
Given players from a range of backgrounds, one might expect more pressure on the common core from the latter group and therefore to hear those tunes more frequently.
[/quote]
.....and this is exactly what happens of course, whereas, unfettered by the word 'session' and all it implies, the opposite happens and we get to hear a huge range of music. Most of the sessions I hear at Whitby are little different from any other session I've been to. Not what I'd hope for, but it is what I expect.
-
Re Franks's tune swap. I suspect that this would work better in one of the "Workshop" slots than the "session " slots of 1-3 or 5-7 as Frank would have much more control over what went on and people would be more prepared to listen in a workshop environment and there'd be less risk of it being hi-jacked or people misunderstandng what it was all about. Of course Frank might not be able to be attend then as he'd be playing for a dance team .
As others have commented both Pete Coe and Ken W had good strategies for running sessions. Both co-opted a string session to help keep time and Pete's technique of varying the type of tune played - so that there wasn't a continuous stream of 4/4 tunes worked well. Also requesting one or two "strings only numbers helped .
The references made to post session running away with tunes - involved a piano accordion ( insensitively played) in both cases.
Its interesting how different participants in a large session come away with different views of it , largely depending on who is sitting around you - so a sensible strategy at Whitby is sit near someone who's a reasonable player and doesn't play too loud
Thanks to all those who ran the sessions - must be a deafening and thankless task sometimes - especially Steve D who must have drawn the short straw in having to host a Sunday session when conditions are at their noisiest and busiest.
Off to deal with my mountains of notes and recordings now. See you next year - unless any of you make it to the Aberdeen Squeezebox event in November.
Paul
-
a couple of fiddle players, a guitarist and a piano accordionist (who'd all been there all along) launching in to Irish reels played at 100 mph, blurring all the notes into a fortissimo mush. What is the f***ing point? That's not how Irish music is meant to be played... (is it?).
No it isn't. (Eire input needed here please). It seems to be a peculiar British (English?) perversion of what is a pretty fine and proud tradition. I saw none of this in West Coast Ireland, nor in sessions in Europe (many places) or New Zealand. Canada was on the brisk side, but they do have Québec influences.
Yes it is awful. Unless you are REALLY good (and the culprits usually aren't) the notes all blend into a an everchanging mushy chord. There was a fair bit of this in the melnet session (further critique noted above ::)). I tried to hold the room together with a drum beat on bellows, "usually" it responded.
The key issues in my view are
1. Listen
2. Keep reminding yourself to play quietly. loud
volume is a true killer of quality, 6+ contestants?
3. Rhythm is also critical. Respect it. Don't play bossanova over a polka, jig across a bourrée. These are all cultural entirties in their own right, dances, respect them.
4. listen. Try to be sensitive. Listen again. Adjust to the room.
Above all, respect session tunes' link to dance. Without it there is no tradition left. You just killed it
-
The speeding up or playing too fast is interesting. There might be an element of showing off, but it's usually by the relatively inexperienced player who has learned a decent degree of manual dexterity to get the notes all in the right order but not the next stage of learning the more subtle skills of developing the ability to play with a good groove. Sometimes you can hear the speed rising at particular places in a tune, often a sequence of fast notes, or a run up it down part of a scale. It's a hard thing to control, but sometimes a determined, but very steady, stamping of the foot! I played in a band with one such for a while, and we eventually fixed it by myself and the guitar player standing next to each other where we could keep a lid on the tempo.
-
Nerves make me speed up, I have to make a real effort to control playing speed every time I play in public, even sessions!
-
I remember an old chap sitting next to me at the Cumberland Arms in Byker. The youngsters were playing the tune I call 'The Relay Reel' which usually consists of 20-30 minutes of breathless fiddle sawing. 'They're not old enough to play slowly' he observed.
-
Re Franks's tune swap. I suspect that this would work better in one of the "Workshop" slots than the "session " slots of 1-3 or 5-7 as Frank would have much more control over what went on and people would be more prepared to listen in a workshop environment and there'd be less risk of it being hi-jacked or people misunderstandng what it was all about.
Great idea. Would def go.
Mike (:)
-
Was at Whitby from Wednesday morning and left late afternoon today. We decided to go at the last minute, having felt deprived of playing opportunities at Warwick...
We enjoyed the time overall, but would echo some of the earlier comments. In terms of sessions I went to four, and they were mainly great. The two with JK and Alistair Anderson were the best ever, and I am grateful to have been to them. The discipline and timing really helped, no racing or inappropriate speeds. Incredible. And I think the better for there not being too many melodeons. Another good one was led by Steve Harrison and Vic Gammon and was very pleasant. I arrived more than halfway through at another one in Mid Earth today and encountered racers for the first time in the week, as well as some who found it fun to start in the F1 manner, imho murdering the tune. Not all of them though, and I think Pete Coe was trying to haul them back... The fact that the room was almost entirely filled with melodeons (not literally) may explain this! I agree with Anahata and others that massed melodeons are not necessarily the recipe for a good session.
I enjoyed meeting a few more faces at the Melnet meet, inc Dr Chris, Pikey (smiling), Nick, Myra, Malcolm and others, as well as people I have met before. Thanks for remembering that tune, Nigel! Was sorry to have to leave early.
Off to EAMT trad day next weekend. (:) PS didn't go to any dances. Great gig on John Clare by Gordon Tyrrall.
Mike
Thanks Mike ! It was a good Melnet meet, I counted 21 melodeons ! (:)
-
Re Franks's tune swap. I suspect that this would work better in one of the "Workshop" slots than the "session " slots of 1-3 or 5-7 as Frank would have much more control over what went on and people would be more prepared to listen in a workshop environment and there'd be less risk of it being hi-jacked or people misunderstandng what it was all about. Of course Frank might not be able to be attend then as he'd be playing for a dance team .
I agree, and had asked for a quieter venue than The Middle Earth, but as you say, I'm often playing for dance teams so there isn't much flexibility re time-slots. Obviously they like to keep re-jigging the programme year-on-year to a minimum, so I guess 5-7pm is where it'll stay, whether or not I'm otherwise engaged.
What machinations take place in the programming office is a complete mystery to me. This year, having been told I had one Tuneswap to run, I arrived to find I had a tuneswap and a session. The landlord at the Middle Earth had not been informed of the session either, and turned into the devil incarnate when I arrived. My wife, Corrie Schrijver, on the other hand, had agreed to run two violin surgeries, but bought a programme and found she had only one. Alongside that were spaces in the programme where folks were invited to submit ideas for additional workshops! (So long as they had nothing to do with violin maintenance one presumes!)
-
The Bb/Eb on Wednesday was offered to the newsletter in writing as "Flat keys session" but came out as "Flat keys workshop" ::)
Meanwhile Frank's "tune swap" was reverse edited back to "session" :o There is clearly no logic in this?
-
I think its pretty amazing that with the number of individual events (700ish?) at Whitby spread over a dozen or more venues that in fact most of the published details are correct. (:)
-
I think its pretty amazing that with the number of individual events (700ish?) at Whitby spread over a dozen or more venues that in fact most of the published details are correct. (:)
You beat me to it, Theo! I think that generally the organisers do a fantastic job of solving potentially horrendous logistics problems and are to be congratulated on getting just about everything right nearly all the time. Organising a big festival like Whitby is definitely a Forth Bridge painting job. You can be sure that having just finished this year's festival, they are already organising next year's.
-
Theo and Steve, all this is absolutely true of course, but when, like Corrie and me, one is facing a firing squad of dissatisfied (actually VERY angry) customers, and trying to keep one's cool and do the oil pouring when things do go wrong, how well the festival is run is probably a little further from one's mind than perhaps it should be. In fact Cosmo the Fairly Accurate Knife Thrower comes to mind! But I'm not going to make an official complaint, I run events myself and get things wrong, probably next year there'll be a different set of cockups which may, or may not affect us. They do their best.
-
Theo and Steve, all this is absolutely true of course, but when, like Corrie and me, one is facing a firing squad of dissatisfied (actually VERY angry) customers, and trying to keep one's cool and do the oil pouring when things do go wrong, how well the festival is run is probably a little further from one's mind than perhaps it should be. In fact Cosmo the Fairly Accurate Knife Thrower comes to mind! But I'm not going to make an official complaint, I run events myself and get things wrong, probably next year there'll be a different set of cockups which may, or may not affect us. They do their best.
Oooh! I hadn't realised it was that bad for you and Corrie.
In that case, I think it is worth putting in some feedback to the organisers for this particular cock-up, if only to help stop it happening again, either to you or someone else.
-
Actually it wasn't too bad for Corrie, just one or two folks who'd brought their fiddles to Whitby for her advice, some of which could be given at her stall. But I came pretty close to being beaten-up, as anyone who was there at the start on Wednesday would testify. As you mentioned, though, the landlord was probably much the worse for his own merchandise, and I suspect this was a combination of circumstances unlikely to be repeated.
-
As Frank and others have said, the Middle Earth is not the ideal venue. Knowing this, I went down there on the first Saturday morning to ask the management if we could have my three Well Known Tunes at a Steady Pace sessions upstairs, which I hoped would be quieter than downstairs. I was told that this could not happen because they were not going to open the upstairs bar and they did not want people carrying drinks up and down the stairs. So what happened? During two of my three sessions they allowed impromptu sessions to take place upstairs! Since there is no door between the two to shut out the sound, those people at the back of my sessions had to contend with tunes from upstairs clashing with the tunes we were playing downstairs. No doubt the same was true for programmed sessions in the Middle Earth.
The only concession I was able to persuade them to grant was a rearrangement of the furniture at the end of the room nearest the fireplace into an open square rather than the serried ranks of 'church pews' that were there when I went in on Saturday.
Having discussed the problem with Sue Houston, one of the festival directors, she suggested that they should have stewards at the Middle Earth next year, whose duties would include preventing impromptu sessions upstairs. Let's hope this happens.
-
l
The only concession I was able to persuade them to grant was a rearrangement of the furniture at the end of the room nearest the fireplace into an open square rather than the serried ranks of 'church pews' that were there when I went in on Saturday.
Having discussed the problem with Sue Houston, one of the festival directors, she suggested that they should have stewards at the Middle Earth next year, whose duties would include preventing impromptu sessions upstairs. Let's hope this happens.
You did a good job with the furniture Bob, certainly it was a lot better than last year. I'd guess the only day you might persuade him to let you have the upstairs room would be the Wednesday, when Egton Show drains most of his regulars. He expressed the intention to run his upstairs 'Sloop John B'
sessions whenever possible otherwise, and these are very popular and no doubt bring-in a lot of revenue for him. I hope any stewards trying to dissuade him from continuing with this catch him on one of his better days - or they'd better take Basher with them! My Tuneswap on Thursday continued in (relative) peace after the upstairs crowd had gone for dinner, but last year it was almost impossible to cope with the noise filtering down the spiral stairwell, and from their stamping on the floor.
-
I should have emphasised that the 'impromptu' sessions upstairs are not, in fact, impromptu, but encouraged by the landlord, he calls them 'My Free-for-All Sessions'. As they left on Thursday there were people carrying what looked like either PA gear or percussion instruments in large black soft cases - nothing much 'impromptu' about that! Another source of noise at The Middle Earth is the sessions in the front yard, and I've often had to close the windows to reduce it, but my guess would be, if it happens to be wet, the outside crowd would join the ranks of the upstairs lot, in which case heaven help anyone downstairs!
-
Scary place that ole Whitby..
-
The Middle Earth certainly isn't the place it used to be. Last year I turned up (as did about 15 others) for a programmed session that the staff, as well as we, were expecting but which never happened as no-one ever arrived to run it or to say whether it was on or off. There was, however, a session going on upstairs and another out front. I left. The "steady pace" session, ably fronted by Steve in George's absence, was much better, but the seating was still not ideal. It used to be such a good place for a session when there were seats round the walls and, as far as I (not reliably!) remember, no upstairs bar.
-
Why does the festival need to use the Middle Earth next year? Mike got be time to find another venue. Can't believe the poor quality of people's experience and that it is still used.
M
-
Last year I turned up (as did about 15 others) for a programmed session that the staff, as well as we, were expecting but which never happened as no-one ever arrived to run it or to say whether it was on or off.
Some of the other problems mentioned here might be the Middle Earth's fault but that one surely wasn't. (I went to a session there last year where the leaders on the programme never turned up - the rest of us just got on with it).
There are lots of pubs in Whitby that aren't used as WFW venues and I doubt it's because they're all hostile to the idea.
-
I used the middle earth for several years for both sessions and workshops and found the landlady and bar staff most helpful and cooperative. I have missed the last 2 Whitby's due to various ailments and from youtube vids the new layout is far from ideal although the old set up was far from perfect due to the long narrow nature of the venue. I never had any problem with the outside lot playing.
I would endorse the idea of changing venue, but then no venues are perfect for big sessions
Has the pub changed hands?
george
-
We have to remember that Frank's session and those that used to be led by George (last year by Steve and this year by me) are programmed sessions and, while we might prefer a different venue, I got the impression that 't'management' of Folk Week are not contemplating a change of venue.
Sue Houston told me that they had come to an agreement with the Middle Earth that there would not be any competing sessions in the upstairs bar this year and she expressed surprise that they had happened. Her suggestion of placing stewards in the pub next year to ensure that what had been agreed actually occurs seems to me to be a step in the right direction. Once planning begins for next year (probably very soon), I will discuss this further with Sue, emphasising that the problem affected not just my sessions, but those of Frank, Pete Coe and probably others.
-
Given my hip I'm glad I didn't walk that far... :|glug
-
What appears to be emerging is that The Middle Earth is a rather 'Jekyll and Hyde' venue.
When it's good, I quite like it; it has a nice atmosphere and the landlady Jill and her staff are always friendly and helpful, especially for the early morning workshops and sessions, where they have everything nice and tidy and welcoming with nice coffee on the go for those that need it.
Bob - I didn't know it was your influence which persuaded them to rearrange the benches at the end. Thanks! It was a good move and very amenable to my teaching workshops. (:)
I also like the upstairs room at the ME; light and airy with great views and good for a nice session; there is less conflict for space with people trying to get to the bar and having a natter.
The main problem in my opinion, and as already been alluded to, is the unpredictable nature of the landlord when he has got a few drinks inside him. He can be irrational and aggressive. We've already learned of Frank's unfortunate experience. Last year the landlord (in his cups) actually knocked one of my workshop participants off his bar stool by storming through the entrance door. Fortunately, no injuries or damage occurred. Jill took him in hand and for the rest of the week he was OK and rather sheepish. But it seems he is back to his usual tricks this year. I don't know how Jill puts up with him. But if he is deliberately running his own conflicting 'local session for local people' simultaneously with programmed WFW events that's not really acceptable.
It's unfortunate that the non-folkie punters seem to think it is all part of the organised WFW things and they love joining in with such as 'The Wild Rover' and stamping their feet enthusiastically. That's great in its own way and at the proper time and place, but there's definitely a conflict of interest at the moment. Perhaps greater pressure in advance from the WFW organisers and more robust stewarding would help?
-
Similar experience. At Frank's first tune swap I was well up the table and a friend arrived (rendezvous). I did the normal thing - go to greet. But the side of the table away fom window was congested with players, no easy way through.
So I nipped through the (empty) bar area, and bought her in through there. It is wide open both sides, essentially breakfast bar style and was an easy corridor. It's actually wider than it needs to be (:)
Er, no. A staff member just come up the stair challenged me - what was I doing in there (I wondered "what was she doing not in there"?) explained the innocence of the situation and went back to my seat.
Er, no. Next thing a large male comes up, being even more aggressive. Made the same excuse, and he seemed to cool off, but it wasn't something to attract me back into his hostelry. I had no idea what larceny he suspected I might be up to.
But it isn't just ME. Several Whitby bars, eg Station and even Wetherspoons now have shaven headed bouncers outside :- Might indicate that it is the town that is … losing it?
-
Wow, I'm delighted that I avoided ME this year. The behaviour of the landlord sounds as if its on the borderline of becoming a police matter. An intoxicated publican is a serious business, (could lead to loss of licence). Do the festival organisers know of this situation?
-
I suspect the best idea so far is to find another pub. I agree with Steve that the upstairs room is ideal, and the downstairs area with the Bob Ellis furniture arrangement is also conducive to playing together, but given that the landlord's job is to sell beer, he'll have to weigh-up compliance with the festival's wishes with running his own 'festival' in his pub. From what experience I have, once his upstairs 'free-for-alls' get going, they keep going, and they're a hard-singing, hard-drinking lot who simply enjoy a well-lubricated foot-stamping sing-song, which in turn oils the pub wheels very nicely.
-
Just to (again) note that the 'B' part of sessionoid 'Bear Dance' is rather different from what is is played in the original Belgian version (and elsewhere within continental Europe).
Brits (and Canadians ::)) repeat 'A' bars 9-16 … whereas the real tune does something different. I suspect this to be a 1970's mis-remembering. But 'flat out' the resultant 'average note' is the same :|glug
I learned the Belgian version as "The Dancing Bear" in a different key, and happily played it in the band for some years whilst also playing the "Bear Dance" in another set of tunes without realising that it was the same tune. I suspect that this says more about my ability to reognise what's going on than any intrinsic merits in the tunes though...
Cheers,
Guy
-
It may be going a bit far to suggest that the behaviour of Sandy (the landlord at the Middle Earth) is on the borderline of becoming a police matter. He is co-operative up to a point: it was he who agreed to reorganise the bar into a more workshop/session friendly configuration.
It would also be a shame if we had to move away from the Middle Earth, which has had such a long association with the festival. Perhaps the way forward would be for the festival directors to have a word with Jill and Sandy, explaining that if programmed events are to continue there, the licensees need to undertake not to have sessions going in another part of the pub at the same time as a programmed workshop, session or tune swap. Perhaps Sue Houston's suggestion that stewards could be stationed in the Middle Earth next year would be a good way of ensuring that the licensees comply with what they agree with the festival directors. I seem to remember that in previous years there were stewards at the Middle Earth, but I didn't see any this year.
-
It may be going a bit far to suggest that the behaviour of Sandy (the landlord at the Middle Earth) is on the borderline of becoming a police matter. He is co-operative up to a point: it was he who agreed to reorganise the bar into a more workshop/session friendly configuration.
If a publicans behaviour depends on how much alcohol he has consumed that would worry me! I wasn't there so I may be over reacting.
-
Re. Sandy, all that was missing on the Wednesday was the trident and horned head. The following day he was quite the opposite. Nevertheless he seemed very adamant that his upstairs sessions were very worthwhile and showed no sign of relinquishing the room to the festival. I used it on the Wednesday after a scene 'East Enders' would be pleased to have written into a script, but it was the day of Egton Show, and he realised it might be better to sell beer to a handful of musicians than to 'not sell beer to no-one(!)'. Policing the place with festival stewards might be a good idea, but I, for one, won't be volunteering as a steward next year!
-
Several Whitby bars, eg Station and even Wetherspoons now have shaven headed bouncers outside :- Might indicate that it is the town that is … losing it?
I spent the Friday night before WFW in Scarborough. Won't be doing that again. Every single pub in the centre had pulverizingly loud music. The place seems to think it's Magaluf-on-the-North-Sea. In Whitby, the Little Angel already has that attitude. Let's hope it isn't catching.
-
I only live 30 mins away from Whitby so visit at all times of year. I can remember when most shops literally boarded up their windows and closed down in October and did'nt reopen until April. In recent years the town has become a year round venue with Goth weekends, 60s music weekends etc etc as a result more jobs and cash for what was an unemployment black spot. A couple of Max and Paddy type bouncers seems a small price to pay! Whitby is after all a seaside resort, not a country village. If you really want to see somewhere spoilt by the hen/stag night culture try York on a saturday night >:E
-
Do I also understand it that 2016 is going to be another clash with the Regatta year? I hope that I've got it wrong, because that always leads to uncomfortable situations in the pubs as the Regatta is very much the local's knees-up and they generally don't want the folkies in there at the same time, which I can understand.
Bouncers on pubs at the seaside is, unfortunately, the norm these days. I grew up in Cleethorpes and it's just the same there. You just hope that these door staff have enough about them to realise who makes trouble and who is unlikeley to.
Mike
-
You're right about regatta Mike (according to the ice cream lady at the bandstand). It's only one weekend though isn't it?
-
Never in the history of melnet has there been so much grumping about Whitby week . Is it a s0rt of mutual winding it up session?
george :(
-
A problem of forums (fora?) I think George! Most of this is about one issue! I actually had a brilliant week, and yes, came back feeling fitter having carried two or three boxes a total of 35.6 miles! Haven't calculated total height climbed but that would be interesting!
-
The regatta definitely clashes with Folk Week next year. The Yacht Club management told the Euro sessioners this year that the regatta would make the Yacht Club unavailable on Sunday afternoon, so we are trying to put others plans in place for that day. The Yacht Club staff also said that the main day of the regatta would be Monday.
I agree that anybody reading this thread might get the wrong impression that Whitby was poor this year, but nothing could be further from the truth. There were some small glitches, mainly at the Middle Earth, but overall the festival was fantastic.
-
Apart from any incidents with the landlord( which I didn't experience) Middle Earth is one of the best sessions pubs. I don't think you can expect to restrict activities to single room in a public house because we want (free) music session. I certainly don't think that stewards should have the unenviable task of policing them. Presumably the workshops are scheduled in the morning because that is when the pubs are relatively quiet.
I was in Middle Earth from 9 hours (10-7) on Friday and had a great time because it was relatively quiet. The root cause is generally at Whitby for an ideal session there are too many people wanting to play with too few spaces. If people were playing by the staircase for Bob's sessions then even without noise leakage from other sessions they would have had a less than ideal experience. There have always been problems with multiple sessions in the pubs - anyone remember recent sessions in the Fleece ?
Also we need to be careful about criticising venues - there can't be a great deal of choice for the organisers - particularly with pub closures in recent years ( The Bottom House and Stokesby ()? being examples - . I'd like to congratulate the Festival organisers for managing to find the venues they do.
Re the comments on "hosts" not turning up for sessions. In my experience when this happens people are quite capable of running a decent session for themselves providing they've all turned up for the same type of music. There was an excellent session in the Fisherman's this year when the host didn't turned up - understandably because he'd been programmed to finish a workshop at the Spa and then host a session 10 minutes later . Again with 600+ events there are bound to be some programming glitches.
-
Apart from any incidents with the landlord( which I didn't experience) Middle Earth is one of the best sessions pubs. I don't think you can expect to restrict activities to single room in a public house because we want (free) music session.
At Whitby the programmed sessions are not "free" - or at least used not to be; true, you don't have to cough up if you already hold a season ticket, but a steward will normally pass among the gathered and collect a contribution from non-ticket holders. At least that used to be the case - and the "suggested" contribution wasn't particularly cheap, as I remember. If a session truly is free, then I think you have a point, but if you've paid for it - and if it's a programmed event and you're a ticket holder then you have - you have a right to expect reasonable playing conditions.
Graham
-
At Whitby the programmed sessions are not "free" - or at least used not to be; true, you don't have to cough up if you already hold a season ticket, but a steward will normally pass among the gathered and collect a contribution from non-ticket holders. At least that used to be the case - and the "suggested" contribution wasn't particularly cheap, as I remember. If a session truly is free, then I think you have a point, but if you've paid for it - and if it's a programmed event and you're a ticket holder then you have - you have a right to expect reasonable playing conditions.
I agree you have a right to expect reasonable playing conditions but I think that's unfeasible at a large festival - my "reasonable" playing conditions would not include sitting next to an insensitive squeezebox player.
-
I agree you have a right to expect reasonable playing conditions but I think that's unfeasible at a large festival - my "reasonable" playing conditions would not include sitting next to an insensitive squeezebox player.
my "reasonable" playing conditions would not include sitting next to an insensitive squeezebox player of any instrument. Triangles are terrible played in your ear! ;D ;D
-
. Triangles are terrible played in your ear!
Someone at Whitby recounted the tale of someone suffering an insensitive triangle player and responded "Sir, have you tried playing the middle - any damnfool can hit the sides
-
Having been particularly impressed by one Mr A Cutting's triangle playing last Saturday I'm hoping for a workshop led by himself soon... particularly emphasising left hand technique....triangles at Witney maybe ? ;D
-
Heck, can't WFW (or Witney) dig deep and bring over the real experts?
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=103090094
http://valcourrecords.com/releases/christine-balfa-plays-the-triangle
-
Having been particularly impressed by one Mr A Cutting's triangle playing last Saturday I'm hoping for a workshop led by himself soon... particularly emphasising left hand technique....triangles at Witney maybe ? ;D
He's been playing triangle for a while
-
Never in the history of melnet has there been so much grumping about Whitby week....
'Tis true. We enjoyed it, though we were with one of the booked morris teams, so our ability to get to the sessions was severely limited. On our Tuesday day off I accompanied my wife to Bob's Slow and Steady at the ME which did indeed have significant noise from the room above something akin to a boy racer car with a boot full of bass speakers - but I didn't realise what was happening. I took the approach of "relax, chill and enjoy yourself - it's a holiday" - and had a good time. The only other events we got to apart from one concert was Ken Watson's Wednesday session at The Dolphin, which we enjoyed, I missed a dance spot to attend the mel.net meet and one night played for a bit in the Board - and that was it. I too still feel a bit wrecked - not helped by spending BH Monday helping move a canal barge from Burnley to Barnoldswick(!) - but on reflection feel satisfied with the way Whitby went.
-
from Burnley to Barnoldswick(!)
Isn't that an Emmylou Harris song?
-
oh, sorry...that's THIS one...(warning...may not contain melodeon...but it should and could...)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=99LAL0Sjl3Y
:|glug
-
Just got home after a great Whitby. Weather was great, as was the music.
Re the Melnet Thursday session; nobody asked who I was, or introduced themselves. So I still don't know who TF was whom. The only one I know is Chris Ryall.
Enjoyed it though. Would it be better to play round the room, with players introducing themselves, and making their excuses before playing? ;)
Present format appears somewhat cliquey.
John
-
Just got home after a great Whitby. Weather was great, as was the music.
Re the Melnet Thursday session; nobody asked who I was, or introduced themselves. So I still don't know who TF was whom. The only one I know is Chris Ryall.
Enjoyed it though. Would it be better to play round the room, with players introducing themselves, and making their excuses before playing? ;)
Present format appears somewhat cliquey.
John
I find that surprising; when I went last year I was made most welcome, and I was meeting everyone there for the first time.
Graham
-
Would it be better to play round the room, with players introducing themselves, and making their excuses before playing?
That looks like an excellent idea for starting the meeting. And maybe not in a crowded pub, but in one of those "set-aside" workshop spaces of which there seemed to be several this time? Especially if any of those spaces also had drinks for sale.
One we'd gone round the room once, then it could relax into general chatter and session playing, but at least then we'd know who everyone was...
-
Just got home after a great Whitby. Weather was great, as was the music.
Re the Melnet Thursday session; nobody asked who I was, or introduced themselves. So I still don't know who TF was whom. The only one I know is Chris Ryall.
Enjoyed it though. Would it be better to play round the room, with players introducing themselves, and making their excuses before playing? ;)
Present format appears somewhat cliquey.
It was nice to meet you at my Intermediate Melodeon Workshop, John. I'm glad you introduced yourself. Not sure if any other melnet members were there, other than Bob Ellis whom I knew, of course.
-
Sorry, forgot Bob, I also knew him, having introduced myself, at the Rugby Club, camp site.
I still have all the sheet music, BTW :(
John
-
Just got home after a great Whitby. Weather was great, as was the music.
Re the Melnet Thursday session; nobody asked who I was, or introduced themselves. So I still don't know who TF was whom. The only one I know is Chris Ryall.
Enjoyed it though. Would it be better to play round the room, with players introducing themselves, and making their excuses before playing? ;)
Present format appears somewhat cliquey.
It was nice to meet you at my Intermediate Melodeon Workshop, John. I'm glad you introduced yourself. Not sure if any other melnet members were there, other than Bob Ellis whom I knew, of course.
I was at both workshops at Whitby and really enjoyed them (having also enjoyed your minor key workshops at Witney last year). Sorry, should have made myself known. N
-
Would it be better to play round the room, with players introducing themselves, and making their excuses before playing?
That looks like an excellent idea for starting the meeting. And maybe not in a crowded pub, but in one of those "set-aside" workshop spaces of which there seemed to be several this time? Especially if any of those spaces also had drinks for sale.
One we'd gone round the room once, then it could relax into general chatter and session playing, but at least then we'd know who everyone was...
Echo that. Much better idea. I had to make a real effort to say hello to a few people, which wasn't easy in such a crowded space.
M
-
(:) had a great time :|||: :M :|glug so many friendly people, wonderful music ...... apologies for missing the Melnet session but the Eurosessions ran at the same time and were superb ;D It was a pleasure to hear Chris Ryall in the Station on Thursday, to have the talent to sing and play at the same time :D it gave a lift to the afternoon's session. I need a Tardis for next year ;D
-
Would it be better to play round the room, with players introducing themselves, and making their excuses before playing?
That looks like an excellent idea for starting the meeting.
Seconded. And that is what we did at the Bb/Eb. I'd say a couple of tunes first to relax us and allow folk from other events to swing by. So basically we need a volunteer to chair mElsinore next year. And I'd hope he/she would also welcome latecomers in the same way.
The success of a meeing like this should not be measured in the number of melodeons in the room, rather by the number of new friendships joined?
btw A "round the room, introduce oneself" has happened at every french get together I've attended :|glug
-
Indeed!
g
-
A sound practice. The session I run here isn't a folk session as there aren't enough of us on the island - at least not within easy reach of one another - for that. Instead it's an Acoustic Music session; folk, blues, pop, jazz, country, whatever - any instrument, any voice. The only rule in NO electronic aids. We operate a "round the circle" system, rather like the old singaround format, you don't HAVE to play or sing each time it comes round to your turn, but most people do. The rule is that everyone present is free to join in unless the performer stipulates it's a solo (no-on ever does!). Newcomers are always welcomed first and asked to reveal as much or as little as they wish beyond name, rank & number, and many of them have become regulars. Most of us know each other now, but there was a time when we didn't, and the "I'm XXXX and I'm going to play YYYY in the key of whatever" approach has been an important part of that - and of exposing many of us to types of music we might not otherwise have taken an interest in.
Graham
-
I just wish more sessions were like that. I'm going to make sure I announce tunes, and keys of course every time I start a set from now on ( and give my name/if necessary. Maybe it'll catch on !
-
You wouldn't even have to play if you're too shy, or unsure of your abilities. Just make yourself known, when your turn comes round.
I realised that people don't know me by my given name, as I chose to use the handle Cugiok (See you Jock) Not easy to pronounce if you have no Italian, and at best confusing. So the more astute amongst us will note, that I have changed my Melnet name, to correspond with my everyday one.
John
-
Brill! I've been after that C-Ugi-OK one for ages. ;D
-
I always thought it was "see you Jimmy" John. But what do I know being a mere Sassenack. Sp.? 8)
-
Good point on the lack of intros. I was as guilty as anybody. To help with recognition in the future, I've changed my avatar to one with me on it. Hope this doesn't frighten anybody....
Mike
-
AAAAAAAARGH! ;D
-
How could one not be frightened in the presence of The Lord himself? >:E
(a little German should help to understand what I'm saying...)
-
Gott in himmel ?
-
(https://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&site=imghp&tbm=isch&source=hp&biw=1051&bih=501&q=boy+in+lederhosen&oq=boy+in+lederhosen&gs_l=img.3...21817.32940.0.34770.17.17.0.0.0.0.228.2319.3j13j1.17.0.ccynfh...0...1.1.64.img..8.9.1390.0Kurezmb4jU#imgrc=owYr0is7Nh-U8M%3A)
Stereotypical Brit response... >:E
-
How could one not be frightened in the presence of The Lord himself? >:E
(a little German should help to understand what I'm saying...)
It's always a problem in Germany, usually at the airport, somebody always says "you have a very holy name" or something like that. I undestand that it's of viking origin, some who'd settled in northern France - "Norman/Norseman" - and came here on a day trip in 1066 and stayed, but I've not done the full family roots bit. An ancestor, Benjamin Gott, built one of the first big woolen mills, Armley Mills in Leeds, now the home of Leeds Industrial Museum. I've a photo of myself stood in front of it in "one of these days, lad, all this'll be yours" pose. It's suprising how many people think it must be of German origin, but no...you don't have a "Mr God". Actually, my dad was a Seafire pilot...........
Mike
-
I have met a Peter Gott, who is the proprietor of Sillfield Farm fine food. Great bacon and sausages!
John
-
Never in the history of melnet has there been so much grumping about Whitby week . Is it a s0rt of mutual winding it up session?
george :(
Grumble. Grumble . Grumble.
Whitby is what you make it. I had a great two days catching up with old friends, making new ones, playing old tunes and hearing ones new to me.
Please let's not turn into a Grumbling and Griping forum.
End of gentle rant (or was it a hornpipe ? ) ;)
-
Would it be better to play round the room, with players introducing themselves, and making their excuses before playing?
That looks like an excellent idea for starting the meeting. And maybe not in a crowded pub, but in one of those "set-aside" workshop spaces of which there seemed to be several this time? Especially if any of those spaces also had drinks for sale.
One we'd gone round the room once, then it could relax into general chatter and session playing, but at least then we'd know who everyone was...
Good idea, Bob - lets talk before next year and arrange it, Yacht Club sounds like a good bet, before the Euro session. I'm sure that we could chair it between us.
Also a good excuse to come to see you beforehand .......
;)
-
...
...
Good idea, Bob
I'm not Bob, I'm Spartacus!
-
;)
No, Nick is Spartacus......
-
I think Pikey was referring to me, Anahata, because I suggested the Yacht Club, although it was, of course, you who suggested the format of going round the room introducing oneself and then starting a tune, which I think is a great idea. I shall use that for the Sidmouth melnet meeting(s) next year, which I am also thinking of moving to a quieter venue, possibly the 1922 Club opposite the church.
With regard to Whitby, I shall sound out Katie about using the Sailing Club and then talk it over with Pikey. You are welcome to come and see me any time, Pikey. You might like to consider coming up to t'Dales on the first Thursday of the month so that you can spend the evening with us in our session at the Old Hill Inn.
-
I'm confused - I know Whitby has lots of goths but was Spartacus a goth ? And what kind of box did he play - presumably given the romans had water organs maybe they had portable versions ? Perhaps we are getting too far from the subject (and reality....!) ::)
-
Spartacus was greek (Spartan?) - whereas Goths lived in Spain, and … somewhere in Yorkshire, I believe
While I do favour 'chairing' of the next Whitby get together, that does mean 'chairing' … viz leading it, and offering some of the structure that was lacking in the recent two. So not a trivial job, please. An 'agenda' would take it a bit too far ::) but more "I'm ______" I'd like to play "______" from the various melodeonistas seems a really idea.
A good 'chair' should also take responsibility for encouraging our shyer members to have a go, maybe 'coming back to them' once the meeting had settled?
-
There were a lot of blank workshop slots in the programme this year - if I remember right, there was one at the Brunswick Centre early Thursday afternoon. The Brunswick is a church with corresponding acoustic, might sound good.
-
Having been particularly impressed by one Mr A Cutting's triangle playing last Saturday I'm hoping for a workshop led by himself soon... particularly emphasising left hand technique....triangles at Witney maybe ? ;D
He's been playing triangle for a while
That's one of my pet hates :neigh:...give the triangle to the most musically inept member of the side.... :|glug
-
.......I'm hoping for a workshop led by himself soon... particularly emphasising left hand technique....triangles at Witney maybe ?
Maybe even an Eb/Bb triangle seminar.
Mike
-
Just got home after a great Whitby. Weather was great, as was the music.
Re the Melnet Thursday session; nobody asked who I was, or introduced themselves. So I still don't know who TF was whom. The only one I know is Chris Ryall.
Enjoyed it though. Would it be better to play round the room, with players introducing themselves, and making their excuses before playing? ;)
Present format appears somewhat cliquey.
John
"I think Pikey was referring to me, Anahata, because I suggested the Yacht Club, although it was, of course, you who suggested the format of going round the room introducing oneself and then starting a tune, which I think is a great idea."
Ahem!
John
-
I am Spartacus, and I'd like to play the Triangle ???
Let's not make it too formal, but the concensus seems to be more of a 'tune around' led session ?
I'd still go to the Elsinore Thursday pm for a general session, so we could do both ? 'Meet melnetters' in somewhere like the yacht club, and a general do what you want session 3 to 5 Thursday ?
Btw it's perfectly acceptable to introduce yourself to others rather than wait for someone to ask you. That's how I got myself known.
-
Btw it's perfectly acceptable to introduce yourself to others rather than wait for someone to ask you. That's how I got myself known.
Who are you? ???
-
I was only able to attend the first Sidmouth meeting on the friday.
Bob immediately asked everyone to introduce themselves, using both melnet 'handle' and real name, then off we went.
It was very enjoyable, very amenable and friendly and Bob, MartinW and I ended up chatting for so long afterwards I nearly missd my Volunteer's Briefing.
Great, perfect way to run a very laid back session amongst friends old and new.
Dunno what happened at Whitby but vibes are a tad conflicting.......
Q
-
Awkward shaped room with lots of tables in the way , lots of people , filled up very quickly , lots came later . Apart from that I thought it was a good session . I will post the recording sometime so you can listen (:)
-
Sorry, i totally disagree. There is nothing wrong with the room, its been the top session site for decades. The issue was lack of a focus (leadership if you prefer) and … of conversation.
You could bang through tune after tune in any pub in the town. The Melnet gettogether should have been more than that.
-
Could I make a suggestion,why not book a room specifically for this event and make it a social get together for Mel Net only.you would then have space,be able to chat and play tune etc as you wish,as Chris says,you can bash out tunes in other pubs.
I think this could become a welcome break in the calender for the week and a chance to meet other members rather than sit in a room wondering who,s who.
I know some venues have been suggested however these are venues that are already in use by the festival and will be hard to split off from that.
Pete
-
I agree, Pete, which is why I suggested the Yacht Club. The only problem is that we couldn't have the 3.00 - 5.00 slot because it is already taken by the Euro-sessions. 5.00 - 7.00 wouldn't work because of people's evening meal arrangements. 1.00 - 3.00 might be possible but it is a popular time for workshops and programmed sessions, which may involve several of us.
Another way forward might be to wait until next year's Events Listings are published and then book a vacant workshop slot and publish the details in the Wailer. The problem with that is that the only venue with vacant workshop slots between 3.00 and 5.00 this year was the Mission Hall, which I don't think has a bar.
-
Could I make a suggestion,why not book a room specifically for this event and make it a social get together for Mel Net only.
The chance of yer average Whitby season ticket holder trying to get in to a meeting of 23 melodeons is rather limited ::)
-
My regular stewarding venue, the Conservative Club, usually has nothing happening, between 3PM and 8PM. Cheap beer, and there are usually sandwiches available.
John
-
Good suggestion, John. I've just checked the 2015 Events Listings and there was nothing on all week in the Conservative Club between 3.00 and 5.00 pm. If they would be amenable, that sounds like an excellent suggestion.
As for "average Whitby season ticket holders trying to get into a meeting of 23 melodeons", it seems to happen most years that one or two people playing other instruments who are not partners of melodeon.net members gatecrash the meeting. Nothing wrong with that provided that (a) they realise that it is a melnet meeting and (b) they don't try to dominate the session. This year there was a piano accordionist who jumped in at every opportunity, starting far more than his fair share of tunes. His argument might well have been that the Elsinore is a session pub and he had a perfect right to be there. Moving to somewhere that is not normally used for sessions would reduce the risk of this happening.
-
Last year (surely you haven't forgotten!) the melnet event was dominated by Dartmoorish Gypsy tap dancers ::) Interesting … absolutely, but not entirely melodeonic ;) It did make for rather less end to end medleyed tunes though, and as such much more "craik". Think I even got a nice chat with you?
Yes, Tory Club is about right, though the festival would likely charge any fringe melnetters. It does reopen the bar to members at some times though. Don't assume it will be available. :|glug
-
Last year (surely you haven't forgotten!) the melnet event was dominated by Dartmoorish Gypsy tap dancers ::)
A bit disparaging of the fine true Dartmoor musicians and step dancers :(
Interesting … absolutely, but not entirely melodeonic ;) It did make for rather less end to end medleyed tunes though, and as such much more "craik". Think I even got a nice chat with you?
It's spelled 'craic' or better still since it started in Norther England 'crack'.
Yes, Tory Club is about right, though the festival would likely charge any fringe melnetters. It does reopen the bar to members at some times though. Don't assume it will be available. :|glug
The Conservative Club is open to its members all the time
-
Not at all, Lester. I really enjoyed them and frankly would have paid to see these guys But even with my nose firmly in my dictionary I'd have noticed that the bar had a split (I daren't risk 'schism' without spellchecker ;)) between its melodeon end, and our dancers, which wasn't quite as intended? Neither joined in with the other.
But as I say above, the unintended consequence was a lot more conversation and repartie amongst the corps melodeonista. So no bad thing there either?
Suggest the next Sidmouth melnet gettogether be scheduled for the appropriate pub on Dartmoor ;)
[ed] btw, up here in Wirral we spell Northern with two 'n's ::)
-
There's room in Princetown.
John
-
"Last year (surely you haven't forgotten!) the melnet event was dominated by Dartmoorish Gypsy tap dancers"
Please note that some of the Orchard family are members of melnet and so had as much right to be involved as anyone! I for one jumped at the chance to be involved in their tradition and made the trek south, partly, to meet up again at the Dartmoor festival this year, where I was made very welcome in their sessions.
The issue seems to be that there has been no agreed idea of what the melnet session is for. Is it a session, a chance to meet and discuss or what? As a recently retired teacher can I suggest the formation of a task and finish group, to establish the perameters for a working party tasked to clarify our aims and return with recommendations for: aims, objectives and success criteria by the end of the year ...... oh did I say why I got out of teaching? >:E
-
This is all very well but do we want this to be a melodeon session for Melnet members or a social get together to chat etc a few drinks and maybe a few tunes but mainly a get together to meet one another get bit of advice and have a look at instruments which you would see from the other side of a room played by someone you do not know.
You may also have the chance with permission to have a go on that instrument
What ever is decided sadly I wont be there,booked our stall already however I know which I would find more enjoyable and the Conservative club bar would be ideal for that.
The event could be split with a meet and greet for an hour the an hour for tunes that way it could be flexible.
Pete
-
As a recently retired teacher can I suggest the formation of a task and finish group, to establish the perameters for a working party tasked to clarify our aims and return with recommendations for: aims, objectives and success criteria by the end of the year >:E
As long as we've completed an icebreaker, shared our thoughts with the group, and then completed a risk assessment..and with you 100% on Dartmoor style and traditions. I've made several comments here which I've deleted..but suely one of the best combinations in the world is melodeon+dancer...no matter what persuasion...
-
As a recently retired teacher can I suggest the formation of a task and finish group, to establish the perameters for a working party tasked to clarify our aims and return with recommendations for: aims, objectives and success criteria by the end of the year
I'm SO glad I got out of teaching when I did.......
(What the ****** is a task and finish group?)
Graham
-
How will we know when we've succeeded if we don't know what success looks like?
It ain't just teaching.
Personally, for a melnet meet, I would prefer more chat and introductions. Otherwise it's just another session with a bunch of people you don't really speak to.
-
I doubt that the old Essex boys at the Peterboat, Leigh on Sea 70 years ago would have agreed that step dancing and melodeons didn't go together. I seldom saw one without the other....
-
So next year it's Con Club or Yacht Club , with a leader, introductions , chat, and a few tunes ?
Name badges ?
Maybe play the previous few months tune of the month ?
-
Next years melnet get together seems to be getting more complicated by the minute!
Why not just bill it clearly and succinctly as ''melnet play and natter'' and hope that common sense prevails!
george ;)
-
Next years melnet get together seems to be getting more complicated by the minute!
Why not just bill it clearly and succinctly as ''melnet play and natter'' and hope that common sense prevails!
george ;)
We are melodeon players George, without a set of rules such as number of straps, which button start, up and down or across, we are but lost souls who need a nanny to look after our well being. ;)
-
So next year it's Con Club or Yacht Club , with a leader, introductions , chat, and a few tunes ?
I don't think I could bring myself to enter the conservative club. I feel myself getting agitated just walking past the outside of it.
-
So next year it's Con Club or Yacht Club , with a leader, introductions , chat, and a few tunes ?
I don't think I could bring myself to enter the conservative club. I feel myself getting agitated just walking past the outside of it.
Most of the yachts are owned by money grabbing, bankers who are Conservatives as well you know, all Labour supports invest any spare cash in flat caps and whippets.
-
What kind of a Melodeon is a Whippet? I've already got my flat 'at - they're issued to Yorkshiremen at birth, along with the epnonimous terrier.
-
Most of the yachts are owned by money grabbing, bankers who are Conservatives as well you know,
I suspect you're right, but at least the yacht club is one step removed.
I did have a part-share in a racing dinghy in my younger days...
-
I doubt that the old Essex boys at the Peterboat, Leigh on Sea 70 years ago would have agreed that step dancing and melodeons didn't go together. I seldom saw one without the other....
I'm sure you're right, but it's a matter of context. I was at last year's melnet session, and although it was enjoyable in its own way and I did get to meet a number of melnetters in person it was, frankly, a bit chaotic. Clearly the two quite different simultaneous sessions in the same room (presumably by prior agreement with the management - what could they have been thinking?) had quite different objectives, and though eventually some common ground was found and the session ended in a slightly uneasy truce, it couldn't have been entirely satisfactory for either end of the room. If you're expecting step-dancing (or belly-dancing, fire-eating, Chinese plate-spinning or trapeze artists, for that matter) to go with melodeons, that's fine; but if you're expecting a session specifically intended for group members to meet and get to know each other that's a completely different kettle of Whitby kippers.
Graham
-
"I don't think I could bring myself to enter the conservative club. I feel myself getting agitated just walking past the outside of it".
I was in a session in the Cons Club at Saltburn Festival a few weeks ago, we took great pleasure in playing some Irish rebel stuff with a portrait of Churchill looking down and I swear he looked increasingly glum as time went by ;D
-
What kind of a Melodeon is a Whippet? I've already got my flat 'at - they're issued to Yorkshiremen at birth, along with the epnonimous terrier.
I suspect it's small and prone to being played too fast -good for rapper but only over short distances.
Personally I like the sound of a floor spot of stepping but what are the chances of massed boxes keeping time ? ::) Belly dancing could work but we'd definitely need to agree a suitable tune beforehand ! (Suggestions?)
Seriously maybe the best format for gettogether is simply to divide time between sharing tunes ( with personal introductions) and the social bit afterwards. Is that sensible enough ? Task and finish group could meet at the same time in a different location to enjoy appropriate gripes, grumbles and beers....mebbe with Churchill looking on from on high ( did he play an instrument ?)
-
There probably is a picture of Churchill there, but the first Tory whose picture you encounter going up the stairs is... Leon Brittan.
Hmm.
-
I must admit that I've been quite shocked to come across the recent anti Conservative Party statements on an otherwise friendly forum topic dedicated to melodeon antics at Whitby! Does this mean that melodeon aficionados who are anything but card-carrying Labour or Communist Party members are not welcome here? Seriously? Or are these comments just "friendly banter"?
-
Guess not. And I guess we should exclude the Greens and Scots Nats too? I foolishly sent a sub to the Lib Dems last month, but the local mob have so ignored requests not to pester me that I'm resigning - would that be OK with you Tufty?
I have stayed away from the excellent Frodsham FC since it moved into the towns Con Club. But that was "about" their members insisting on their "right" to sit in the function room and talk loudly through otherwise a cappella singing. I'm amazed the FC stuck it.
"Brit Leon" as we always called him was MP for Whitby for some time but left for safer Richmond (AFAiR) when his constituency was merged with … shall we say several villages full of card carrying squirrels Seems it may have been a shrewd move :|glug
-
I must admit that I've been quite shocked to come across the recent anti Conservative Party statements on an otherwise friendly forum topic dedicated to melodeon antics at Whitby! Does this mean that melodeon aficionados who are anything but card-carrying Labour or Communist Party members are not welcome here? Seriously? Or are these comments just "friendly banter"?
+1
-
for what its worth Churchill was a card carrying member of the amalgamated union of bricklayers and was a dab hand as a bricky!
However lets keep politics well away from this forum and again for what its worth I ran sessions and workshops in the con club for several years and was happy so to do 'cos of the good cheap real ale anad very reasonably priced butties - oh and the wonderful view from the windows.
I would also have been just as happy if it was under the labour, lib dem or monster raving loonies banner! In other words I couldn't give a shite about politics during Whitby week as there are much more important matters to attend to!
george :D
-
I have stayed away from the excellent Frodsham FC since it moved into the towns Con Club. But that was "about" their members insisting on their "right" to sit in the function room and talk loudly through otherwise a cappella singing. I'm amazed the FC stuck it.
I was once at a workshop in the Whitby Con Club (at the end on the left as you go in) where there were two guys propping up the bar (i.e. quite a long way off) nattering about nothing in particular VERY LOUDLY and being pretty disruptive. I didn't understand what they were doing there at that time in the morning but if they were members that would explain it. Doesn't seem to happen very often though.
-
I must admit that I've been quite shocked to come across the recent anti Conservative Party statements on an otherwise friendly forum topic dedicated to melodeon antics at Whitby! Does this mean that melodeon aficionados who are anything but card-carrying Labour or Communist Party members are not welcome here? Seriously? Or are these comments just "friendly banter"?
Sorry to offend but if it helps I have a fair measure of contempt for all parties, apart from those with cake!
-
"However lets keep politics well away from this forum..................I couldn't give a shite about politics during Whitby week"
You've gone some way to restoring my confidence in the usually friendly nature of melodeon.net, thank you.
And thank you too, Tufty, as long as it's not carrot cake, eh?
-
Well Tufty, your Irish rebel songs, need to be played more widely. Both the Normans, and Cromwell, oppressed that poor country too.
FWIW, the upstairs function room, is one of the best for playing, or singing in, at Whitby; Fred Jordan said so.
The beer is also the cheapest in town.
John
-
Well Tufty, your Irish rebel songs, need to be played more widely. Both the Normans, and Cromwell, oppressed that poor country too.
Slight thread drift, but...way back in the early days of ABU we had a wedding gig at a pub in Yorkshire somewhere. The landlord had, shall we say, somewhat singular political views, and I was a condition of hiring the function room (and displayed above the stage...) that any performance should end with the playing of the National Anthem. We finished, circassianed, and the late lamented Paul Havell launched into "The Soldier's Song", and grinning at the rest of us announced "Well, he didn't say WHICH national anthem did he..." >:E :|glug
-
Time to end the thread?
-
Time to start the 2016 one! >:E
-
Time to end the thread?
:||: :M :|glug :|glug :|glug
-
I agree that politics has no place here. I've attended a number of sessions in the Conservative Club: it is a good venue with friendly staff and decent beer - and that is all that matters.
I would have thought that anyone who is not prepared to attend a session there for political reasons is probably cutting off their nose to spite their face.
-
Even I've been in there !
-
I learnt long ago that just because people share interests it doesn't mean we share views,attitudes or of course politics. We just need to remember that some might prefer not to support a particular political party - if only by buying a drink in the club whatever the colour - or even entering the premises. We can always vote with our feet or abstain from drink as a political statement I suppose !
-
Whatever our political views we all have a responsibility not to alienate the managers of the venues which would prevent them being used as venues for the festival in future.
-
Time to end the thread?
Please..
-
The last word? My Uncle Bernard, a deputy at Moorgreen Colliery, DH Lawrence Country, was an NUM man AND a member of the Eastwood Conservative Club. His family even held his wake in an establishment where he had spent many happy hours. Why? Because it had the best snooker tables for miles around and he wasn't interested in football,whippets etc!
-
[[[ ADMIN: Nice final thought to end on I think. Thread locked... ]]]