Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: deltasalmon on March 28, 2015, 04:58:15 PM
-
I recently purchased a G/C Sandpiper and am looking for a good tutor book for learning how to play it. I have been using the diato.org website for its tabs which I think are great but I don't know which tunes are easier to learn than others and would prefer a book that would have tunes in order from easier to learn to more difficult. I can read sheet music but I'm interested in taking advantage of the cross-row playing so I would prefer something with tabs. Also I can't read French that well.
The Pignol + Milleret has gotten really good reviews but its pretty expensive and I wanted to make sure it had what I was looking for. Could anyone tell me if it has tabs and teaches cross-row playing? Also my sandpiper is a two-row with low notes so I don't have any accidentals. Would I need accidentals to follow along with the P+M books?
-
Looks to me that the books are for 2 row 8 basses - I've seen some G#s but I presume you don't have that on the lower button. It wouldn't cut out many of the exercises. The examples on the websites I've seen are for cross row playing, and have tabs. I've also seen text in English on those examples.
I keep meaning to buy at least the first two. But again the price puts me off - especially as I don't need the CDs.
Does anyone have copies they'd be willing to sell?
-
Some background reading...
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=10057.0
-
Pm books are very usefull. I bought 3 of them (not the last one). You don't really need G#, it's not a problem. Go for it!
-
I'm a great fan of the Pignol-Milleret books: they're designed for the standard 2 row, 8 bass G/C layout, whether with accidentals or low notes, and the first one will take you a long way. They use a form of the usual French tabs (which are explained at the start), and are aimed at giving you a solid grounding in technique, rather than just learning a few tunes. They're quite dear - though better with the stronger pound than they used to be - but just volume one will last you a long time! And the service from Mustarded is usually excellent.
Good luck with your journey! (:)
Roger
-
Roger is completely correct: v.1 will last a long time!. I optimistically obtained the 3 vols from a melnet member when I retired, figuring to work through them….
Well, after 2 years, off and on, still on v. 1.
Worth it though, they kind of force one to develop some good techniques, especially with scales, albeit at the expense at learning as many tunes as some other methods may provide...