Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: folkiesophie on May 02, 2009, 01:25:04 PM
-
I would massively appreciate some (OK, make that any) advice on buying my first melodeon. I don't know any melodeon players to ask these things of - or to borrow a box from - so I'm hoping you can help.
Quick background: I want to pick up a 'folk' instrument after a youth spent playing classical cello, and a bit of piano and other instruments. I settled on the melodeon particularly after listening to an old Luke Daniels / Broderick record I picked up years ago, among others.
So, after lurking here for a while and doing some research, given is the kind of sound / playing that's inspired me:
http://www.stumbleaudio.com/share/lukedaniels/1
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CMZZgEtoBbQ
I _think_ I'm after a B/C "irish" style box (though I've just seen that that last clip is a D/G?) with dry-ish (or is that 'swing'?) tuning. But to be honest I remain fairly confused about what to look for in terms of basses, wet/dry/swing tunings and 1/2/3 voice. I'm worried I could easily end up with the 'wrong' box by making a load of wrong assumptions about the kind of sound I'm after.
I'm at the stage of preparing to go and try a few boxes. My shortlist so far has me seriously considering the Hohner Morgane - which my budget will just about stretch to. But I see conflicting reports about whether it's wet/dry, and mentions that the stepped keyboard isn't suitable for irish-style playing. Obviously there's also the Double-Ray, plus I've seen mention of a Delicia Popular and that the stephanelli(?) beginner boxes are pretty good.
Trying any box is going to involve some travelling, as I'm based in Cheltenham and other than Hobgoblin in Bristol there doesn't seem to be anywhere nearby. So any advice which may avoid me driving 100s of miles to try a box that a bit more knowledge would have told me was obviously not what I'm after would be much appreciated. Plus tips on what to look for when I _do_ try one, as a total beginner who has no idea how to actually play!
Thanks in advance.
Sophie
-
I've got a DG Morgane which I'm pleased with. It has good build quality, and the standard tuning is swing, which is between wet and dry. It's a 2-voice (treble side) box. In my view, the keyboard isn't really stepped - more like a slight wrinkle. The only thing I have against it is the keyboard edge which is a bit "user-unfriendly" when compared to the other and older Hohner designs. It may have been changed for the newer Morganes.
I suggest that you contact Rees Wesson if you need more info on the Morgane, at http://www.melodeons.com/
When you're starting out, I think it's pretty important to try out melodeons to see which suits you and what you want to do with it. I know people who've bought "unseen" after working it all out to a formula - and then been bitterly disappointed that a perfectly good instrument wasn't right for them in some way. It's always handy to get to know players in your area, try out boxes and generally get a feel for the things. With the summer now a'coming in, there are also the music festivals and so forth to go to-though whether there's a lot of Irish music played at the West Country ones I couldn't hazard.
If they would be any help, I could probably post some Morgane (and other DG box) sound clips somewhere. Let me know. Can't help with B/C, though.
-
Hi Sophie and welcome to the forum - it's a great place to start especially if you're a long way from being able to physically try a whole load of boxes out. The last clip you refer to is of course the marvellously talented multi-instrumentalist Tim Edey who can make a bag of chips sound like a la carte! But you're right, he is playing a D/G box. Now for a lot of the kind of music you appear to want to play I think a B/C box is probably a much better bet - although as a great many people have pointed out before many times, there is absolutely no 'reason' why one cannot play Trad Irish music on a D/G (Dave Mallinson is another fine example of someone who does just that). Obviously your budget will pretty much determine the ranges of instrument you could consider. Emilio Allodi down in London has a few B/C boxes you might like to look have a look at http://www.accordions.co.uk/Button.htm (http://www.accordions.co.uk/Button.htm) including one or two that the more 'Folk' orientated music shops don't appear to stock. Hohner, Weltmeister & Delicia are all able to provide a range of decent machines for a beginner/intermediate players to get going on. But also it might be worth having a chat with our very own Theo Gibb http://theboxplace.co.uk/ (http://theboxplace.co.uk/) and of course Rees Wesson as mentioned in a previous post. BTW I also play a Primo which I got from the Musicroom http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_485/products_id/4221?mrSid=d924cd89a584b3bafa5bb8a2d7bf13c8 (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_485/products_id/4221?mrSid=d924cd89a584b3bafa5bb8a2d7bf13c8) and it was difficult to get it played in (stiff bellows) but once done so it is a fine instrument. The B/C model that they're offering also has a thirds stop which basically is a wee little tool enabling you to change the way the bass chords sound - giving more options musically speaking. That little feature is a thing unheard of on an instrument that retails at under £300. In fact you have to pay many hundreds more to get that as standard on most other brands. So just maybe worth looking at and thinking about. Bear in mind it's a beginners instrument and if you took to it then you'd soon want to trade up I guess. Given your previous musical experience I don't think you'll have any trouble at all on going to a B/C system which is very chromatic. It is perhaps a little less intuitive an instrument than the D/G system... but that's only my perception. So don't just take my word for it.
Anyway - a little food for thought and I hope it helps!
AL (:)
-
...a B/C system which is very chromatic. It is perhaps a little less intuitive an instrument than the D/G system... but that's only my perception.
Very chromatic - as opposed to not very? (:) Actually halfstep boxes are not quite as chromatic as you might assume. Yes you have all the notes. Yes you can play in any key - theoretically. But in practice nobody does.
However with a B/C you can handle practically the entire Irish trad. repertoire easily enough. You can't with a D/G.
You also can with a C#/D, btw, which (coming from playing fiddle and whistle in Irish music for decades) I found a lot more intuitive than the B/C system.
Sophie, before you spend any serious money, I recommend you follow Prestidigitator's advice. Try to borrow a melodeon/diatonic accordion and experiment with it for a few days. If you are a cellist, you want to be sure you think you can live with the eccentricities and limitations of these instruments before you burn a hole in your budget! Maybe there are some players in or near Cheltenham who could help you out.
-
It really depends on what music you wish to play. If you are keen on playing English music for Morris or in sessions, a D/G would be the appropriate choice. Irish music specifically however is apparently best suited to the semitone boxes. I know that a lot of it is in funny keys, like A, which is also a problem with Scottish music. I wouldn't worry about dry/wet and so on at the moment until you know what you want.
In terms of models, I learned on a Delicia and still hold that there isn't a better value beginner's box. You can pick one up second hand for around £300 or less (I got mine for £180, but that was 6 years ago or so. Sold it on for £50, wish I didn't). I considered the Morgane when moving up from the Delicia and thought it a very fine box.
I would reiterate the advice given by everyone else in that it would be a very good idea to try and borrow a box to play around with, especially if you are trying to decide between key systems.
-
Very chromatic - as opposed to not very? Actually halfstep boxes are not quite as chromatic as you might assume. Yes you have all the notes. Yes you can play in any key - theoretically. But in practice nobody does.
Thanks for picking me up on that Steve - I suppose what I was trying to say was that for someone with a piano/instrumental background a B/C box would be a bit more logical - a bit more like a piano keyboard with white notes on one row and black notes on the other. Having said that I agree with you that although it's possible to play in almost any key - I disagree that 'nobody does' - I play in a very wide range of keys. The halfstep box should not be limited simply to trad & diddly-diddly stuff, it's a complete instrument (though not as complete, I feel, as a BCC# which is what I'm moving onto). It's people who limit what instruments can do I guess.
AL (:)
-
I too play in a wide range of keys.
Sometimes nasty jealous people tell me that the predominant one is "OFF". With their tin ears, what do they know, I ask?
-
Very chromatic - as opposed to not very? Actually halfstep boxes are not quite as chromatic as you might assume. Yes you have all the notes. Yes you can play in any key - theoretically. But in practice nobody does.
Thanks for picking me up on that Steve - I suppose what I was trying to say was that for someone with a piano/instrumental background a B/C box would be a bit more logical - a bit more like a piano keyboard with white notes on one row and black notes on the other. Having said that I agree with you that although it's possible to play in almost any key - I disagree that 'nobody does' - I play in a very wide range of keys. The halfstep box should not be limited simply to trad & diddly-diddly stuff, it's a complete instrument (though not as complete, I feel, as a BCC# which is what I'm moving onto). It's people who limit what instruments can do I guess.
AL (:)
Hmm, I don't know. I've played piano for 15 years but I wouldn't say that the semitone boxes are any more logical than the quint ones.
-
Well fellas, I endeavour to play in a wide range of keys also, but in my book a "wide range" is a long way from "almost any" - and even farther from "any". There are after all 24 possible major and minor keys - how many of them can you say you are proficient in?
I don't buy the analogy between the B/C keyboard and the piano as bieng very helpful, either.
Nor am I sure - with my fiddler's ears (wooden fiddle, not Donegal tin fiddle) that I would dismiss the complaints of anybody well versed in trad music who said that the tuning on an accordion was off. It's equal temperament after all and we've discussed the shortcomings of this system for trad music a few times.
-
I would massively appreciate some (OK, make that any) advice on buying my first melodeon. I don't know any melodeon players to ask these things of - or to borrow a box from - so I'm hoping you can help.
Hi Sophie, this isn't actually 'advice' but just my story, which started out similar to yours (I didn't know anything about playing a melodeon and don't know anyone with one - also I live in a place where there are no 'sessions' that I know of), although I was given a one row Hohner in the key of C.
All I really knew about it was that the instrument played one note on the push and another on the pull and I bought a simple 'How to' book. I had no idea of the sort of music I wanted to play but definitely wanted to play by ear so just started trying to pick out tunes once I got to about page 4 of the book. On a bit of whim, after a couple of months I got my husband to buy me a 2 row that was for sale on ebay here in Australia (G/C with extra accidentals), so now I am learning on that. It is all mostly experimenting and having a go. I am enjoying it enormously.
I realise that there is a much more scientific way of going about these things but am happy enough, for now, with just getting into it, as it were.
Good luck (:)
-
There are after all 24 possible major and minor keys - how many of them can you say you are proficient in?
Most - the music's the thing, not the key it's in. Some music is more difficult for me to play than other pieces. But I don't allow myself to be guided by the key.
I don't buy the analogy between the B/C keyboard and the piano as bieng very helpful, either.
Shame that, I found it useful - still do in fact. But then as a pianist I suppose that's a natural thing to do. Just thought that Sophie might find the analogy useful as she too was a pianist. Variety of opinion is the spice of this forum I guess.
AL
-
I don't know quite how much help this will be, but when reading through the original post, I started to get a vague sense of deja vu...
I grew up in Hampshire, having fairly conventional classical training at school and also playing in a low-achieving village brass band. Although I encountered a few folk tunes along the way, I never really figured that that's what they were, or, indeed, that I might possibly ever actually enjoy folk music of some kind. I can't say I remember ever actually seeing anything folk-related that wasn't either morris or 'country dance' demonstrations at fetes - neither of which held any interest for me.
Anyhow, at some point after leaving school, I heard the Pogues on Radio 1 and, as a consequence, a whole new world of music suddenly became interesting to me. At some point, I started experimenting with a piano box (well, James Fearnley played one...), which, having previously had piano lesssons, seemed a obvious thing to try. This led to finding out a little more about other squeezeboxes, with the Hobgoblin catalogue proving partcularly enlightening to someone who otherwise knew nothing. At some point too, I obtained recordings of people like Máirtin O'Connor and, indeed, Luke Daniels which then seemed to cement the impression that I'd got from the catalogue - that B/C was a good, logical system and that D/G (or other quint boxes), er, wasn't. At some point I think I must have mulled over the idea of getting a B/C box, but in the end, never followed it through, probably because I had no real idea about how to go about learning it (this was obviously pre-internet). So, for a while, I carried on with the piano box until gradually losing interest.
At some point, though, something unexpected happened. Whilst in France, I went on a somewhat speculative shopping spree and bought an album that I thought was going to be standard accordion music. However, when I got home and listened, it wasn't what I expected at all - it sounded much simpler and, on first listen, a bit 'amateur'. Yet, for some reason, although I had no clue what was going on, I really liked it and started playing it a lot. It was quite some time before I discovered that the words 'accordéon diatonique' actually meant 'melodeon', that the music was Breton in origin and that the instruments weren't tuned in B/C, but in the 'bad' quint way. And so, by just hearing one album, my perception of what quint-tuned melodeons were capable of changed dramatically. Even then, I didn't actually go out and get an instrument, as, again, I had no real idea of how to go about learning one. But I think it did, in the end, make me realise that there was more to these instruments that I'd previously bargained for.
And so, as you may be aware by now, I did eventually end up with a D/G instrument and, although I still like to hear semitone boxes played well, have never once found myself wishing I'd gone with the other system. As I mostly play on my own, I really appreciate having an instrument that can deliver a complete accompaniment on the bass side - something that seems to be a struggle for many players of semitone boxes.
So, what I'm trying to get at is don't settle on choosing a B/C instrument just because it seems, at first sight, to be more consistent with what you're used to.
-
Thanks for all the info so far. I hadn't come across Emilio or Rees's sites/shops before and will have a look. I think you're all confirming the problem that there is no "right" answer to what melodeon I should buy! That it isn't as simple as English/Morris = D/G or Irish/Scottish = Chromatic. There's a lot that's just personal preference and playing style, which as a total beginner you just can't know.
I remain inclined to a chromatic for the greater potential range of keys available, as I do want to play with others, mainly my partner who plays fiddle and guitar. Can I ask what keys tend to fall easiest - realising "easy" here is all relative - on a B/C (or C#D) chromatic? (Assuming C#D is the same layout as BC but a tone higher?)
For most folk I'm assuming (and here the fact I don't have much practical experience playing folk music is coming out) that the keys of D, G and A maj (plus rel mins) are most important, plus the same keys played in common 'folky' modal scales which after much wikipediaing looks like basically wanting the notes of C maj (for D dorian) and F maj (for G dorian) in addition to the above.
Or am I overcomplicating this and should concentrate on finding a good quality beginner box to start on (a 2nd hand delicia maybe?) and work out all this stuff later?
-
Hi Sophie,
Yes C#/D is the same as B/C but a tone higher.
My rule of thumb is that on C#/D, any key with between 1 and 2 sharps is dead easy. Extending to 4 or even 5 sharps isn't terribly difficult either. On a B/C this translates into any key ranging from 1 flat to and no accidentals for the "dead easy part" and extending to 3 sharps easily enough.
Going beyond these ranges in either direction takes a bit more practice but is doable. The territory feels less familiar in these keys: there may be lots of unrelenting pushing and pulling or conversely very long strings of notes in one direction only. Plus some new finger-twisting button sequences to get used to.
I should add that there are a few exotic keys that you can easily get by using the outer row as your home row - for example C# major, F# major and D# minor on C#/D (B major, E major and c# minor on B/C). Others such as Eb major (Db major on B/C) are also based mainly on the outer row but are a little trickier.
I'd say that if you want to play Irish music, it's a pretty straight toss up, the result depending on the style of playing you aspire to. If you want to to do other stuff, choose on the basis of the keys that you need most. Or go for a continental chromatic button accordion!
Good luck!
There are after all 24 possible major and minor keys - how many of them can you say you are proficient in?
Most - the music's the thing, not the key it's in. Some music is more difficult for me to play than other pieces. But I don't allow myself to be guided by the key.
Al, when I say things like "practically nobody" and "proficient" I am thinking of the B/C purely in terms of Irish trad music (and maybe Scottish as well) - which is after all what the vast majority of B/Cs on the planet are used for. I wouldn't regard myself as "proficient" in a key until I could play a demanding reel in it at normal speed. There are quite a few keys in which I can play song airs (or scales ;) ) without trouble but in which the prospect of reels is a distant mountaintop that will (or maybe I should say would) take me long hours of trudging practice to arrive at. Sorry if I appeared to me casting doubts on your own proficiency.
Cheers
Steve
-
Thanks Steve. That's very helpful.
-
Another thing to keep in mind is that the nature of these instruments is that they are all limited in some way. That is their special magic. You just have to work out which limitations you can live with.
Edited to add that one of our members has a nice Delicia B/C for sale here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1450.msg14920.html#new). It would make a good starter box.
-
Also, there's just no substitute for learning by doing. Many members of this forum will have moved through several different systems and setups, driven by the experience, understanding and preference that you can gain really only through playing. So while it's great to have got all of the above useful advice, which you should certainly take into account, you shouldn't be afraid of buying something that you're going to discover, maybe quite quickly, is not quite or even at all your ideal instrument. And from that point of view, whatever system you initially go for, it's probably a good idea to get a reputable starting box with a reliable resale value.
-
Also, there's just no substitute for learning by doing. Many members of this forum will have moved through several different systems and setups, driven by the experience, understanding and preference that you can gain really only through playing.
How very true jb. Excellent advice. ;D
Tom
-
whatever system you initially go for, it's probably a good idea to get a reputable starting box with a reliable resale value.
Again I totally agree with JB
AL
-
I had started to think that after all going for something at the lower end of my budget / very cheap, just to get started on (as I don't have the option of borrowing a box) might after all be the better option. Normally I'd say to buy the best you can afford when buying instruments, but as you say it's not just about 'quality' here, but also style.
So, would the delicia popular fit the description of "a reputable starting box with a reliable resale value"? I've searched on here and seen some very different opinions of the Popular.
In the "very cheap" category I spotted this 2nd hand on ebay. A B/C two row, made in German Democratic Republic
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&item=330326104148
Normally I'd be leary of buying off ebay, but as this looks like it may go for under £100 I thought it might be worth a punt to get some kind of box to get started with.
-
Hve you looked at the Delicia that is on offer in the forum here - looks like a better instrument to me than the one on eBay. I just get a bit nervous when the pictures on eBay are all upside down like the seller doesn't really know which way up the instrument is supposed to be standing etc. But that's probably me just being a little too cautious! have a look at Bill Young's http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1450.msg14920.html#new (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1450.msg14920.html#new)
- he really knows about this system and if its not too late you may be able to catch it before it goes. The plus side is that if you find you don't get on with it you''l always be able to pass it on again and recoup most if not all your money ;)
AL
-
The Delicia should hold its value better than the one on ebay, and be easier to sell if it comes to that.
-
I learned on a Delicia. They are cheap, reasonably good and apparently have a decent resale. For someone who is unwilling to pay the money for a Morgane or similar they are ideal.
-
...a B/C system which is very chromatic. It is perhaps a little less intuitive an instrument than the D/G system CORRECT
However with a B/C you can handle practically the entire Irish trad. repertoire easily enough. You can't with a D/G. WRONG
Sophie, before you spend any serious money, I recommend you follow Prestidigitator's advice. Try to borrow a melodeon/diatonic accordion and experiment with it for a few days. GOOD ADVICE
I'm late coming to this thread and I'm not getting at Steve J, it's just that his post contains three things I think are very important. Two I agree with and one I would strongly contest. Al is absolutely correct in saying chromatic systems are not intuitive so I don't understand why he then encourages you to buy one later in the thread. Nor can you generally find the correct chords on a chromatic once you move away from the home key, thus reducing your instrument to a melody only machine. Certainly try/experiment/borrow before you buy, the best advice you can get. If you like quint boxes, ie. D/G then look for extra buttons (four or five is good) so that you can play in all keys if you want to and for the most popular keys play a full accompaniment as well.
All the best with your choice.
-
There's not much I can say here that hasn't already been covered in this thread but I feel I should say something.
There's pros & cons to all systems. Personal choice always seems to over-rule when it comes to melodeons.
In my opinion b/c is the best system as you can play all of the notes you want with doubled notes for alternative bellow direction. Yes the bass end is limited but thats why you can get boxes with the stradella bass system, which is a lot more useful than the diatonic bass system.
But for a beginner, I think the melody is more important to learn first, and if you can do that on a box and be able to play in any key you wish...then you should look at the bass end.
Go for B/C, didn't do Jimmy Shand, Will Starr, Jimmy Blue or me any harm
-
Al is absolutely correct in saying chromatic systems are not intuitive so I don't understand why he then encourages you to buy one later in the thread.
Just seemed to me that B/C was already the system of choice. I think that I said that the halfstep boxes were less intuitive that their diatonic cousin.
Go for B/C, didn't do Jimmy Shand, Will Starr, Jimmy Blue or me any harm
Too right! Back to my BCC# hohner trichord now for some scales and arpeggio practice :o
And yes, Sophie - get your hands on an instrument and give it a go, preferably before you part with any money (:)
AL
-
There's pros & cons to all systems. Personal choice always seems to over-rule when it comes to melodeons.
Nicely put Graeme!
However with a B/C you can handle practically the entire Irish trad. repertoire easily enough. You can't with a D/G. WRONG
If you like quint boxes, ie. D/G then look for extra buttons (four or five is good) so that you can play in all keys if you want to and for the most popular keys play a full accompaniment as well.
Thanks for putting me straight so gently (:) OK, wrong if we are talking about a 2½-row D/G perhaps. I wasn't, and it seems to me that you are setting the bar a little high for someone looking for an entry-level box. Unless you get a converted Club relatively inexpensively, seems to me you are looking at Saltarelle Connemara as a starting point - not cheap!
Also, not any old 2½-row D/G would do the job. I have looked at the 2½-row layouts on the main website and (apart from Steve Freereader's as far as I can see) every one of them seems to have one or more important notes missing. Several have no low C natural, and several no low G - notes I consider essential for Irish trad. Others have no low Bb, which some tunes I know use, and which I wouldn't want to be without.
But, as Graeme said, get a C#/D! Didn't do Joe Cooley, Jackie Daly, Tony McMahon and Mairtin O Connor any harm >:E
-
c#/d would do the job well too. Fully chromatic which is very good.
But when we have someone who already plays piano, then having all the "white notes" on one row (C)& "black notes" (B) on the other, it would sureley be easier to make the transitiion from piano to box.
-
But when we have someone who already plays piano, then having all the "white notes" on one row (C)& "black notes" (B) on the other, it would sureley be easier to make the transitiion from piano to box.
Amen!
AL 8)
-
I am confused about the use of the terms 'diatonic' and 'chromatic' here. I thought that diatonic referred to the 'push for one note' 'pull for another one' aspect of the melodeon. Does that mean that semitone boxes only play one note on the push and the pull, like a piano accordion? Or am I wrong about the terms in the first place ???
-
But when we have someone who already plays piano, then having all the "white notes" on one row (C)& "black notes" (B) on the other, it would sureley be easier to make the transitiion from piano to box.
Granted, Graeme. For me, having played trad. on fiddle and whistle for many years, having the D scale as my home row was much more intuitive.
An advantage of semitone box layouts (among all their disadvantages) is that your accidental is always close to your fingers - next to the "unaccidented" note. Logical, easy to remember, and no need to go send a finger shooting out to some remote button...
This allows five-note "rolls", still an important part of Irish technique, even if going out of fashion somewhat these days. It also allows you to get a very satisfying attack on a key note on the inner row by first sounding the note a semitone below for a nanosecond. Akin to an upward slide on a fiddle - adds a lot of woomph.
Juker - no, diatonic merely means without accidentals. So a diatonic one-row box can play only the notes of one major scale. Chromatic means you can play all 12 notes of the Western scale - all the black and white notes on a piano.
Various terms are used to designate the push-pull action: melodeon is "bisonoric" or "single-action", piano accordion is "unisonoric" or "double-action."
-
I am confused about the use of the terms 'diatonic' and 'chromatic' here. I thought that diatonic referred to the 'push for one note' 'pull for another one' aspect of the melodeon. Does that mean that semitone boxes only play one note on the push and the pull, like a piano accordion? Or am I wrong about the terms in the first place
No, you're right the whole terminology thing is pretty crazy because yes, the B/C is diatonic in the rows but because the rows are tuned a semitone apart it is possible to play it 'chromatically' - in other words get all the semitones. It's why I chose to go with BCC# rather than a CBA - I still have that Diatonic feel and approach (i.e push, pull for different notes) but also have the benefit of mucking around with whatever musical combination I like and not having to worry about whether I can play or not. For example I'm playing with a brass band shortly. No probs ??? BTW excuse my ignorance but I'd love to know more about five note rolls - sounds like something from Earl Scruggs!
AL
-
c#/d would do the job well too. Fully chromatic which is very good.
But when we have someone who already plays piano, then having all the "white notes" on one row (C)& "black notes" (B) on the other, it would sureley be easier to make the transitiion from piano to box.
I still don't think that analogy would help me in the slightest :P I don't think of the black notes as a seperate entity, they are just, er, notes. It sounds to me like the argument that reading music on an english concertina is easy because the gaps are on one hand and the lines on the other. That kind of reasoning makes my brain hurt.
Diatonic means that each row is in a particular key, i.e. 8 notes in a scale as opposed to 12. A Chromatic box means that you can play the chromatic scale across the rows, but is strictly speaking still diatonic... or something like that.
-
I agree my analogy won't help everyone. I am merely saying that titch has experience on the piano. My first instrument was the piano and it helped me learn by the fact that the "whites & Blacks" were in different places. I then learned where the doubled nots were.
Doesn't matter to me what instrument I pick up, I always think of naturals as white and flats & sharps as black. It's what was drummed into my head at piano lessons.
I'll go back and say that it is all personal choice. But Titch has asked for our advice on what to try. I am basing my advice on the experience that Titch has on other instruments.
-
Five-note rolls, Al? A quick clip is worth a thousand words and this one is full of rolls: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FgVYHvTwLWo
In the first part of this tune there are repeated rolls on a dotted crotchet E, thus E{G}E{Eb}E, the notes in brackets being the graces.
They are an attempt to duplicate the rhythmic devices called rolls used by pipers, fiddlers and fluter players. Mostly unsuccessful on the accordion in my estimation - most players get a slurry smeary sort of sound with a wincingly out-of-key lower grace note. In the 1950s so delighted were B/C box players to be able to emulate these devices (using the outer row for the lower grace) that they failed to notice that the results sounded pretty disgusting, esp. on a musette-tuned four-voice Paolo, and really not very much like a roll on fiddle or pipes. ;D Fortunately 50 years down the road most of the younger generation of players have cottoned on and use them much more sparingly if at all.
None of this is meant as a slur (hehe) on the playing of Martin Mulhaire, a great box player and composer, a venerated figure in Irish music.
-
It sounds to me like the argument that reading music on an english concertina is easy because the gaps are on one hand and the lines on the other. That kind of reasoning makes my brain hurt.
Er...that's exactly the way I initially learnt to play the EC, in fact I can't really think of any other way to learnt to play the dots on an English - lines LH & space RH...diddly dum! My brain recovered.
Five-note rolls, Al? A quick clip is worth a thousand words and this one is full of rolls: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FgVYHvTwLWo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FgVYHvTwLWo)
Thanks Steve - very informative.
AL
-
It sounds to me like the argument that reading music on an english concertina is easy because the gaps are on one hand and the lines on the other. That kind of reasoning makes my brain hurt.
Er...that's exactly the way I initially learnt to play the EC, in fact I can't really think of any other way to learnt to play the dots on an English - lines LH & space RH...diddly dum! My brain recovered.
Five-note rolls, Al? A quick clip is worth a thousand words and this one is full of rolls: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FgVYHvTwLWo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FgVYHvTwLWo)
Thanks Steve - very informative.
AL
See I can't think like that. A note is a note, an E an E, whether it is on the RHS or the LHS. I think that if I tried to apply that system I would just get very confused.
-
Sophie, Did you get the eBay item you were looking at?
Went for £107 I see - so your estimate was pretty accurate.
AL
-
This is certainly a high speed thread, I'm only just replying to Steve J two pages ago. You're quite right Steve, I sort of lost sight of the beginner theme and my own prejudices came out. :-[
My own box had all the notes moved up one to accommodate full low octaves on both the D and the G row and a full low C scale on the draw. It was so long ago that I now take it for granted. My layout is very similar to Steve Freereeder's and even after eighteen years I still get great delight from playing it and never being without the notes needed for any tune, usually with full accompaniment. That's not to say it's easy or that I am always skilled enough to play it, but at least the box isn't the limiting factor. Like a few others in this thread, I have always had trouble getting my head round half step boxes and I have no great skill on my continental C system either. From this background I have no hesitation in recommending a quint box but of course I am unable to compare and contrast properly with half steps having no skill in this area.
So back to Titch / Sophie - opinions are plentiful and we champion our favorites but there is one thing we are all agreed on - try before you buy.
-
Thanks for all the continuing advice everyone.
Sophie, Did you get the eBay item you were looking at?
Went for £107 I see - so your estimate was pretty accurate.
AL
I got wrapped up in work and missed the end of the auction. Doh! Looks like I might have been able to pick up something very cheap to at least get started on in the absence of knowing anyone to borrow a box from.
I have emailed Bill Young about his Delicia Popular.
I am considering trying to get hold of any kind of box cheaply - regardless of whether it's B/C, C#/D or D/G - just to try playing one. Then once I have a better feel for the instrument quite quickly moving to buy a good quality, sub-£1,000 model in a whatever configuration turns out to suit me best.
On the piano discussion. I can see that for someone with a strong piano background the black note/white note analogy would be helpful. However my primary instrument was always cello. Plus I read music in a slightly "odd" way - simply learning which dot means what fingering/sound, with little regard for what the note actually is. This has actually stood me in good stead, as it makes any kind of sight reading where you need to transpose much easier (I played saxophone for a while). You just need to 'learn' a different notation to intrument system. So in my case I don't think the B/C : keyboard analogy will help me much. However I'm hopeful I won't find translating tunes to any kind of box too hard once I get the basic hang of where all the notes are.
Famous last words?
-
However my primary instrument was always cello.
Sadly very little melodeon music has been written in the bass clef :D
Good luck with your search for the right instrument.
AL
-
On the piano discussion. I can see that for someone with a strong piano background the black note/white note analogy would be helpful. However my primary instrument was always cello. Plus I read music in a slightly "odd" way - simply learning which dot means what fingering/sound, with little regard for what the note actually is. This has actually stood me in good stead, as it makes any kind of sight reading where you need to transpose much easier (I played saxophone for a while). You just need to 'learn' a different notation to intrument system. So in my case I don't think the B/C : keyboard analogy will help me much. However I'm hopeful I won't find translating tunes to any kind of box too hard once I get the basic hang of where all the notes are.
I've been keeping out of the D/G vs B/C discussions because I'm completely a fifths box player -- but having read this I think you might well want to go with a D/G (or other fifths box such as a G/C), because they really reward an intuitive playing style. It's amazingly easy to play tunes in the main keys of the box. The downside is, of course, that when someone starts a tune in a 'difficult' key, it's very hard to join in, and some keys are completely impossible.
-
thefact that you a bugered with a plain 2 row DG if you need to play in most other keys is why I play both DG & BC(C#). I tend to use the Dg for ceilidh band work as its volume and built in bounce is totally disproportunate to its size & weight & more importantly I can play it for lengthy periods despite having angina. I also tend to use Dg for sessions where I know most stuff will be in D or G.. For sessions that are likely to range accross a wide range of keys I use a chromatic box & also find it more or less essential for accompanying singrs. The two systems are quite compatible having far more similaarities than differences.
As for the 'black & white key ' way of looking at BC(C#) I find it very useful for anybody starting on the instrument as most people have at some time or other buggered about with a piano or electic keyboard & so have at least a vague grasp of the black & white notes.
george
-
My two penneth on this subject: having played D/G for a number of years for morris and sessions, which are mostly D/G tunes ,and related minors, I decided to trade my D/G for a B/C. I WISH I HAD DONE IT YEARS AGO. I will not play a D/G while I am learning to play the new machine so as not to confuse things. Key of G is coming along nicely, D is a bit more challenging. I am surprised how many minor things and oddities seem fairly straight forward. I think for a novice starting from scratch it might be easier than re-learning one's whole repertoir on a new system, thus un-learning what you have already learnt. The D/G is limited and can become frustrating, but can sound amazing in the right hands. That said ther are some tunes you just can't manage. Good luck in choosing a box.
-
Thanks to everyone for their suggestions and advice.
The short version is that I ended up completely blowing my budget and buying Prestidigitator's beautiful B/C Castagnari Lilly which he'd advertised on here.
The long version is that I went down to Hobgoblin in Bristol and tried out every B/C box they had. Both the Popular and Double Ray were too wet/tremolo for my taste, which of the beginner/budget boxes left me with the Scarlatti (they don't stock the Morgane). I'm sure this would make an OK beginner box, but I was concerned (after checking comments on here) that it was probably a very short-term option which might have little re-sale value. That a few months down the road I'd find I'd basically "thrown away" £300.
I of course also made the 'mistake' to trying the much more expensive boxes on offer. I was (pleasantly) surprised to find I could hear and feel the difference between the cheap Scarlatti and more expensive Serenellis/Castagnaris/Beltunas. This got both me and by partner thinking that maybe a second-hand, high-quality box which would at least hold it's value if I gave up and decided to sell it, might be a better idea.
By lucky coincidence Prestidigitator had listed his B/C Lilly for sale the day before. As that had been far and away my favourite in the shop, and being in the fortunate position of being able to afford it, I went ahead a bought it.
I got the box last Thursday and it's fantastic. I'm picking my way through a few tunes and really enjoying playing it. I already have a few "how to play" beginner questions which I may post up soon. Thanks again to everyone - and obviously particularly Peter for the box!
-
Good to hear you've found what suits you... (:)
don't know whether there's any places left on the course....
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1525.0.html
...might be a little far if you're in the Bristol area ;)
-
There's also the workshop in September - still places left
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1595.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1595.0.html)
Glad you got your box. Good choice of tuning too ;D
Enjoy it!
-
Great choice of box. I am sure you won't regret it.
AL
-
Hi,
Re you buying over origional budget and getting better box,we've always found with instruments that this is the best policy,we've got two,now grown up daughters,both musicians and have always sacrificed other things to buy the best second hand insrument we could because we learned early on that when you see kids trying to play fiddle say with cheap school instruments even ones with a bit of talent realy struggle because they get frustrated .
This has now paid off because they have their own band, Fiddlers Wreck and our youngest daughter also plays fiddle for another band,Foolish Virgins. Both have web sites.
Also when instrument changed haven't actualy lost much money,in fact sometimes gained so possibly best policy if you can