Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Grape Ape on April 06, 2015, 04:50:45 AM
-
Dry, Swing, or Demi- Swing?
(Not talking about Vouvray here)
Also like Bruno Le Tron, the music of Francois Heim, Aurelian Clarenbaux, and Naragonia....
All play Castagnari's, except Mr Clarenbaux, I think, and all sound fairly similar to my ear, but what is the tuning?
-
I am not very experienced when it comes to these technical things but, all the musicians you name here, make a very pure sound. I would take that to be a light swing, or demi swing. It reminds me of a clarinet.
I'm quite possibly wrong but, in my view, a wetter sound just wouldn't suit the type of music they play, turning it to a kind of mush.
-
Dry, Swing, or Demi- Swing?
Before you go any further you should define the tuning in a less ambiguous manner. Dry is ok no ambiguity there, but "swing" is a much abused term that seems to vary between 1Hz swing which is typical of Castagnari factory tuning and 2Hz swing which is typical of Saltarelle. Both are called swing by their respective makers and retailers, but one has twice as much pitch difference as the other. There are some useful sound samples on Marc Serafini's web site but it is down for maintenance at present.
You will also get a different sound depending on the maker of the box, and on the make of reeds.
-
I don't think there should be anything overly ambiguous about it. If we just focus on Marc Perrone's box, that is just one box made by Castagnari. Is there anyone who has enough experience with Castagnaris to define the tuning he uses? I can hear that it is a dryer style tuning, but most Castagnaris are tuned somewhat dry. Castagnari uses the terms Dry or Swing to define their tuning and I am wondering where a box like Marc Perrone's falls on their scale.