Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Boxhead on April 11, 2015, 10:42:32 AM

Title: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Boxhead on April 11, 2015, 10:42:32 AM
Hello everyone,

Just wanted to share this picture of the new grille Mrs Boxhead has designed and made for her 21 button b/c Sandpiper. She used a laser cutter. This is her first attempt at making a grille. It was one of the older models with the Oakwood styling.  She would be far too modest to post this but I think it deserves a share.

regards

Boxhead
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on April 11, 2015, 11:07:22 AM
V nice. When you say, laser cutter, do you mean she designed it, and got someone with a laser cutter to cut it out. Or do you possess such a wonderful item?

John
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Boxhead on April 11, 2015, 11:13:44 AM
Hi Cugiok, Yes she designed it and made it. She has a background in art and design and has access to a laser cutter, actually two laser cutters!
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Roger Howard on April 11, 2015, 11:40:48 AM
Congratulate her on a lovely design. What a great way to personalise the instrument!  (:)

Roger

Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Theo on April 11, 2015, 01:09:42 PM
Nice work, there could be a market there for personal grills!
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: NickF on April 11, 2015, 01:22:25 PM
Fascinating - and very, very nice :) Hats off to your friend.

I possibly can get access to a laser cutter.... I know it had previously been used to make commemorative remembrance crosses - the smoke (creosote) can be an issue.
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Mike Carney on April 11, 2015, 01:29:59 PM
Beautifully done. Some very light grille cloth under it would enhance it I think, as well as keep dust out.
M  (:)
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Boxhead on April 11, 2015, 01:34:03 PM
Indeed, I am going to sacrifice the replacement grille cloth that Theo sent me a while back when I bought my Sandpiper from him. I think this is a worthy cause!

Can anybody tell me the best way for her to attach the cloth to the grille ?

will post another pic when completed
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: invadm on April 13, 2015, 04:39:43 PM
Nice work, there could be a market there for personal grills!
I have 2 boxes with out the grill and keep thinking what/how to do...if your friend starts taking orders please add me on the list for two  :D
very nice job  indeed..
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: brazilian.BOX on April 13, 2015, 05:02:08 PM
It got really beautiful. Congratulations. Charming and different. You told about laser cutting. Looking at a first I would talk about he use that same technique that they use in jewelry.

Like here, another photo of Castagnari: (the 2 initial photos here)

This saw device he is using in the photo is the same same used in jewelry. According I saw in little movies and documentaries it seem these grills are made this way also (same technique here at the 2 initial photos, is used to do this grills in these both photos here (the last 2 photos).


Are you sure about he used this laser? Cause it's not necessary exactly complex techniques to produce such effect.

Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: rees on April 13, 2015, 06:05:59 PM
Sorry bra-box but Castagnari have been using laser cutters for 10 years now. They only use the fretsaw for special jobs.
The bottom two photos that you posted show laser cut grilles.
They also laser cut the bass panels.
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 13, 2015, 06:15:34 PM
Thought everyone used laser? Even vanderAa (1/month) and Bergflodt (about the same?) do.

     Might even include the renouned "one-row" Wesson Bra-Clip?  >:E
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: AirTime on April 13, 2015, 06:38:01 PM
Does this mean that older Castas have saw-cut grills? My Handry has the older style logo, which definitely has a hand-cut look to it. I can't imagine cutting the newer "signature" logo with a saw! It's hard to see much difference between the older Casta grills & newer ones though.

What about the older Hohner grills? Would they have been hand-cut, or was there some other, pre-laser, process for mass-producing the grills?
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: brazilian.BOX on April 13, 2015, 06:43:03 PM
Sorry bra-box but Castagnari have been using laser cutters for 10 years now. They only use the fretsaw for special jobs.
The bottom two photos that you posted show laser cut grilles.

Ahh ok. No problem. If you sure about it so, ok. I was talking cause I imagined actually that was this way, with the FRETSAW (so that's the name  :D)
Ive seem sometimes this work with wood, and I am sure about it still exists in jewelry industry... in the work with metals.

But if they are cutting the wood now with laser ok. This Castagnari grill really seem veeeery well finished, and these roles and details in forms in the grill. Very professional work.
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: brazilian.BOX on April 13, 2015, 06:46:31 PM
Does this mean that older Castas have saw-cut grills? My Handry has the older style logo, which definitely has a hand-cut look to it. I can't imagine cutting the newer "signature" logo with a saw! It's hard to see much difference between the older Casta grills & newer ones though.

What about the older Hohner grills? Would they have been hand-cut, or was there some other, pre-laser, process for mass-producing the grills?

Yeah, I believe the olders always will be cutter this way in the hand ... cause just the name LASER isolated already make you think about it wouldnt be available for us in the times of the Hohners of the 30's   (:)
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 13, 2015, 06:51:09 PM
and I am sure about it still exists in jewelry industry... in the work with metals.

My lad makes mediaeval armour, and several other bespoke metalwear things in up to 3mm steel. 
He wouldn't dream of using a fretsaw.  Plasma cutter is much quicker and more accurate :|glug



[ed] apologies to Boxhead and his lovely wife Goldiloxhead in this
  We are all way off topic. That's nicely made, especially if a first go  (:)
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Boxhead on April 13, 2015, 07:32:26 PM
Hi everyone, Mrs Boxhead is delighted with all the lovely comments..!

Here's the finished item with Theo's grille cloth

I think there may be some more designs in the pipeline...!

Fascinating to see the use of the fret saw in the pictures above, thanks for that.

@invadm we have been thinking about ways to possibly go about this in the future, you are top of the list should Mrs B decide to take it any further. It's a difficult thing to do by distance, requires design skills and extremely precise measurements etc.Will let you know.

Regards

Boxhead ( Mr)
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: brazilian.BOX on April 13, 2015, 08:27:57 PM
My lad makes mediaeval armour, and several other bespoke metalwear things in up to 3mm steel. 
He wouldn't dream of using a fretsaw.  Plasma cutter is much quicker and more accurate :|glug
[ed] apologies to Boxhead and his lovely wife Goldiloxhead in this
  We are all way off topic. That's nicely made, especially if a first go  (:)


Hello Ryall, how are you?

This video here please: www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ZK5bKC_qAM

The video is interesting and with a soundtrack very pleasant and relaxing. If you don't have time or patience to watch the entire video, so please just check the time 1:40 til 2:20 in this video. This is the technique I was telling came basically from the jewelry and in the photos above I showed Castagnari using the same device the fretsaw to to some parts in the wood, some pieces. I believe in the preview times, this technique was very used to make the detailed parts of the melodeons as the grills and other little logos... It is still used in jewelry as we can see in the video in this time I indicated the guy is cutting with the fretsaw, some little hearts in gold.
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: rees on April 13, 2015, 11:25:48 PM
Before Castagnari got their laser machine, the guy with the fretsaw worked the longest hours of all the employees arriving at 5am - very labour intensive but man, he was good.
Now they just press a button and ping, there's another grille (and some smoke).
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: brazilian.BOX on April 14, 2015, 12:02:43 AM
Yeah Rees,

A great comparison always between the handicraft and the machinery ...
These new grills as these photos Ive put here above, they seem really detailed and a very precise work undoubtedly... we can also compare with the girl our friend post here AirTime posted his Handry 18bass. Look this grill that is seems was really hand cut, and look the girl of my 4th photo there above. So, we can see that ... it seems they went much far about the complexity of the designs and the wealth of details in the grills.

It seem before when hand cut, there was a "limit" there was apparently a limit to how far they could dare. Can you realize that the older grill are much more simple. As the new designs have so varied forms in a same grill, different textures and sizes of the holes, and flowers and triangle and crowns... and...  ::)
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: savantuk on April 22, 2015, 10:57:12 AM
Hi,

I think your wife did a wonderful job, and now it's been lined, it looks even better.

May I make a suggestion??

I don't wish to appear rude, but the screws fixing the grille look very 'out of place', and I think, stop the whole job looking perfect, because they aren't sitting flush with the surface of the wood.  It looks as though you have used screws designed for counter sinking, which stand proud of the grille.

It would be easy, and a job of a few minutes to countersink the holes in the grille, and then the screw heads would sit flush with the surface, or, alternatively, swap the countersink screws for dome headed screws, so that the screwhead, at least, sit's flush on the wooden surface.  This would make it look as if the screws were meant to be there, rather than as an afterthought.

Personally, I'd use slotted screws rather than Phillips.  I always think they look more traditional, and less 'industrial.

Doug



Hi everyone, Mrs Boxhead is delighted with all the lovely comments..!

Here's the finished item with Theo's grille cloth

I think there may be some more designs in the pipeline...!

Fascinating to see the use of the fret saw in the pictures above, thanks for that.

@invadm we have been thinking about ways to possibly go about this in the future, you are top of the list should Mrs B decide to take it any further. It's a difficult thing to do by distance, requires design skills and extremely precise measurements etc.Will let you know.

Regards

Boxhead ( Mr)
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Gromit on April 22, 2015, 05:48:23 PM
As there are cross heads or phillips on the keyboard it may be better to stick with those screws and use screw cups or change them all to slotted screws (in which case line the heads up ie slots in same direction)
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Boxhead on April 23, 2015, 03:26:29 PM
Yes Doug you are right, have just checked the original grille and the holes are indeed countersunk. I will draw her attention to this later.

How do you make the countersunk holes, is there a special tool?

Regards

Boxhead
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 23, 2015, 03:47:11 PM
A countersink drill bit is a short stumpy bit with a very flared end to it to give the countersinking effect.
I use it if countersinking  some wood to loose the screw head though I'm normally using size 10 screws.
I assume there's a smaller version available for such delicate work?
Q
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Roger Howard on April 23, 2015, 04:18:56 PM
Yup ...just take a sample screw along to your local DIY place. The grille looks great already, but that will make it just perfect. Congratulations! :D

Roger
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Owen Woods on April 23, 2015, 08:27:44 PM
Laser cutters are awesome. Do you have it through work or is this a hackspace like me?
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Theo on April 23, 2015, 10:03:39 PM
One further suggestion - your grill seems to be sitting below the edge of the case.  It would look neater if you place some packing to bring the top of the grill up to be flush with the top edges of the case.  Strips of card would be suitable as packing.
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Boxhead on April 24, 2015, 10:16:39 AM
Thanks Thrup and Roger, Mrs B said she did actually try and program the cutter to get the countersink by using engrave mode but it didn't quite do it.

A very busy person is Mrs B, she doesn't seem to be losing sleep over the countersink but I am sure she will do it eventually

 Ukebert, Hi, the laser cutters she uses are part of a community resource for artists and makers here in Liverpool. Once you have done the training you can book the laser cutter and use it.

Theo, thanks, I notice again the original grille has thin strips as you describe along the edge of the frame. I am sure this will be sorted soon.

I didn't notice these details as I was just so totally impressed with the new grille, but I can see the issues now. We both appreciate people's input.

We are going to The Music Room this weekend to get some TLC for that box, one of the buttons is crunching a bit and it feels like its going to go. She replaced the felt underneath as the button was occasionally getting trapped under the fingerboard, this cured the trapping but it still feels crunchy.

It's a long way to go for repairs but AFAIK there is nobody in Liverpool who does this kind of thing. Anyone know anybody?

Hope this can be fixed in situe as I am going to borrow this box as my emergency spare. Got gigs coming up very soon, weddings etc and am terrified of some disaster happening onstage and ruining someone's big day because I didn't have a spare box with me.

Regards

Boxhead
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Theo on April 24, 2015, 11:13:42 AM
Roy Whitely in Cheshire would be much closer http://www.accordionmagic.com/ (http://www.accordionmagic.com/)
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Boxhead on April 24, 2015, 11:34:39 AM
Cheers Theo, we've just phoned him.
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on April 24, 2015, 12:51:42 PM
As there are cross heads or phillips on the keyboard it may be better to stick with those screws and use screw cups or change them all to slotted screws (in which case line the heads up ie slots in same direction)

Do you know, that was the one thing I was disappointed with in building the Pariselle, the use of cruciform screws. I hate the things. I never seem to have the right bit for the screw. They look ugly and how many types are there? Buy a box of cruciform screw bits and it weighs probably half a Kilo.
   The only thing these horrible screws were designed for ( by Philips) was so a machine could screw them in, which is difficult with a slotted screw.  Can you imagine a piece of Chipendale furniture put together with Philips screws.  :o
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Theo on April 24, 2015, 12:54:50 PM
Can you imagine a piece of Chipendale furniture put together with Philips screws.  :o

I can't imagine a piece of Chippendale furniture with any screw heads showing, and probably not used at all!
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Gromit on April 24, 2015, 01:22:37 PM
Phillips and pozidrive are the main two types in use, seperate bits or screwdrivers required for each type - as you say designed for power tools. I only use slotted's for cabinet work and invariably brass (only brass if oak).

Chippendale furniture - seems like handmade nails used occasionally
 
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on April 24, 2015, 01:58:16 PM
Ah yes!  Steel dowels ;D
Title: Re: Alternative grille for Sandpiper
Post by: Owen Woods on April 30, 2015, 10:14:17 PM
Ukebert, Hi, the laser cutters she uses are part of a community resource for artists and makers here in Liverpool. Once you have done the training you can book the laser cutter and use it.

yup, a hackspace, like makespace in Cambridge where I built mine. Long may they prosper!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal