Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: mike delta on December 11, 2007, 09:01:52 PM
-
Hello,
Can anyone recommend a small punchy D/G currently in production? Or vintage possibly although I have considered the Hohner Lilyput.
Not including the Lily or Touptit as these are single voice instruments. These are a superb size though but I am thinking more in terms of a two voice. Weight is not an issue but physical dimensions are.
Anyone have any suggestions?
Many thanks
Mike Delta.
-
The Saltarelle Bouebe, or Castganari Studio should fit the bill. Not as small as the Lily, but still lighter than most.
-
The Saltarelle Bouebe, or Castganari Studio should fit the bill. Not as small as the Lily, but still lighter than most.
I play a Serenellini Selli which I bought to 'step up' from a Castagnari Studio. I don't think it's noticably larger than the Studio; it's still pretty small and light. According to the Serenellini website, the Selli is 29.5 x 26 x 15.5cm and weighs 3.1kg; and according to the Castagnari website, the Studio is 28 x 16.5 cm and weighs 3.4kg. (My Studio is a 19 button one; they now have 21 buttons). I am not sure it is as punchy as the Liliput though. Liliputs are amazingly punchy. And also tiny.
I've been meaning to write a review of my Selli for the melodeons page but haven't got round to it yet. Short version -- I bought it off Derek Shaw from a small ad in melodeon.net, quite by accident; I just had a go on it and that was that. He'd bought it new to replace a Pokerwork for morris but decided after a few months that he missed the Pokerwork. In the meantime he'd played the Selli in and had it tuned by Nils Nielson. So I ended up with a better-than-factory box and I love it to bits. But of course I completely failed to do that thing where you go and play twenty boxes and then choose one; I played one box, liked how it felt and sounded, and bought it.
-
Hello,
Can anyone recommend a small punchy D/G currently in production? Or vintage possibly although I have considered the Hohner Lilyput.
Not including the Lily or Touptit as these are single voice instruments. These are a superb size though but I am thinking more in terms of a two voice. Weight is not an issue but physical dimensions are.
Anyone have any suggestions?
Many thanks
Mike Delta.
Hohner Preciosa, smaller than a Liliput. I have one which Theo re-tuned to DG, brilliant little box and Theo has one for sale on his website.
-
Hello,
Can anyone recommend a small punchy D/G currently in production? Or vintage possibly although I have considered the Hohner Lilyput.
Not including the Lily or Touptit as these are single voice instruments. These are a superb size though but I am thinking more in terms of a two voice. Weight is not an issue but physical dimensions are.
Anyone have any suggestions?
Many thanks
Mike Delta.
How about a Castagnari Tommy (being biased) or Saltarelle L'Elfique?
Roy.
-
How about a Dino Baffetti black pearl II.
A small, tough box that can be played loud (it can be a very loud box) but with reeds good enough to be played very quietly.
Mine's been played a *lot* (morris, rapper, ceilidh bands, sessions, busking) and it has never let me down - there's a hostage to fortune if I ever saw one:-)
It's considerably cheaper than many other options and I have never regretted buying it for a moment. Personally, I prefer it to the more expensive boxes anyway.
I am assuming, of course, that 12 years or so on they are still being made to the same quality.
-
How about a Dino Baffetti black pearl II.
Ah yes, forgot that one. Great box and extremely good value.
Roy.
-
How about a Dino Baffetti black pearl II.
Ah yes, forgot that one. Great box and extremely good value.
Roy.
But like Marmite - you either love it or you hate it!
Love it for: compact size, light weight, loud, low cost
Hate it for: can be air hungry, restricted size of air valve on some examples, raucous sound, some examples have stiff bellows
-
Definitely Hohner Morgane in D/G!!!
Good price, superb look, punchy sound.
-
Theo, you wrote.
[/quote]
But like Marmite - you either love it or you hate it!
Love it for: compact size, light weight, loud, low cost
Hate it for: can be air hungry, restricted size of air valve on some examples, raucous sound, some examples have stiff bellows
[/quote]
The minus points you have stated; is this related to a particular production date or is it a matter of luck.
I have seen and heard these in the flesh but have not had time to try one personally. I was happy with the sound although obviously I was only hearing the projected sound and not what the player was hearing.
Thanx, Mike.
-
OLDCLUB11,
Thanx for your input but isn't the Morgane of similar size to the Pokerwork?
I have a Pokerwork (happy with it too) but I'm wanting a smaller box for portability based upon my own particular needs at certain times of the year or to be more precise for use at certain festivals and sessions.
Horses for courses as they say.
Mike.
-
From the Hohner web site:
Morgane:
Sizes in cm: 28,5 x 15,5 (the body excluding the keyboard and feet is 24cm in height)
Weight in kg: 3,3
It is not lightweight but the sound is amazing!
-
Hi,
I haven't heard the Morgane but I've seen one. Nice looking box. I had assumed that it would sound the same as a Pokerwork. How do they compare?
Mike.
-
Hi,
I haven't heard the Morgane but I've seen one. Nice looking box. I had assumed that it would sound the same as a Pokerwork. How do they compare?
Mike.
The only difference in the sound is that the Morgane is tuned almost dry. You could get the same sound from a pokerwork/Erica by changing the tuning.
The minus points you have stated; is this related to a particular production date or is it a matter of luck.
I have seen and heard these in the flesh but have not had time to try one personally. I was happy with the sound although obviously I was only hearing the projected sound and not what the player was hearing.
Thanx, Mike.
I don't know about production dates, you just need to try before you buy. Also the BP is 19 treble button and at about 2.8kg its not much different from the weight of a pokerwork. Smaller, but hardly a mini???
-
There is a nice clip where we can hear a Morgane here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiTpLfsPpC8
The sound is definitely NOT dry!
Perhaps the first series were (the buttons had a screw in the middle), mine says "Morgane II" on the factory label and it sounds just like the one in the clip.
-
Moved my comments concerning the Morgane to the Hohner Morgane (B/C) thread.
-
As I have stated elsewhere in the Forum pages, I have just purchased a Beltuna Sara II, From Hobgoblin. It is a simply stunning box, similar in size to the ubiquitous Black Pearl II. It has a single stop on the bass side - with the most gorgeous basses. It certainly fits the bill regarding size and voices. Possibly a bit pricey though.
-
Stormy Hyde makes a fabulous small light-weight box in any tuning or key combination you want. I think they beat Castagnari. Austin seems to be a hot-bed of Hyde accordions, I know of at least 6 in town. Only problem is that it could take 6 months or more to get one. See this link:
http://www.concertina.info/hydeaccordions/about.htm