Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on May 05, 2009, 08:17:47 AM

Title: what makes a good box player???
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on May 05, 2009, 08:17:47 AM
i would be realy interested in what you fine folk think makes a great melodeon player????? :||:
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: HallelujahAl on May 05, 2009, 09:48:23 AM
Hi, this is far too dangerous a subject to get into ;)
I've written a great long and thoughtful response and decided to delete it. Basically, I think practice helps to make a good box player.
AL
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on May 05, 2009, 10:02:23 AM
i was thinking along the lines of clarity of notes, good seperation between bass and treble etc, any other ideas???
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Clive Williams on May 05, 2009, 11:12:19 AM
i was thinking along the lines of clarity of notes, good seperation between bass and treble etc, any other ideas???

Musicality and interpretation, I think. There are a *lot* of technically good players out there, but the special ones for me are the ones where I stop thinking 'My, that's clever, I wonder how he does it', and get lost in the music itself. John Kirkpatrick and Andy Cutting spring to mind for me, with wildly different techniques, and from France, people like Bernard Loffet, Stephane Delicq, Marc Perrone who can (and do) play *solo* for a dance and lose you in their music for hours at a time. How they do that with a single instrument, and in Stephane Delicq's case, a single 2 row, 8 bass instrument with no tricks, I've no idea... because every time I try to analyze it... I just drift off into the music...  ;D

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: george garside on May 05, 2009, 12:36:33 PM
no one single thing (and anyway there is no universal definition of 'a good' box player).  Having said that my thoughts aare  (amongst other things)

 - listening   constantly to what you are playing as you play it & making minor adjustments on the hoof to get it to sound right.

-  developing considerable manual dexterity so you don't have to think about fingering/bellows movement etc

-  treating phrasing & dynamics very seriously

-  enjoying playing the box  at every opportunity. i.e. not making hard work of it.

no doubt there will be many more views on this subject


george
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Owen Woods on May 05, 2009, 02:19:23 PM
The obvious answer is someone who plays musically and that is the most important answer. Other than that, someone who appears not to be conscious of the instrument in front of them, someone who just *plays*
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Quebecois on May 05, 2009, 03:19:59 PM
A great player is one who knows the difference between "playing an instrument" and "doing music"  :||:
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: TomB-R on May 05, 2009, 06:01:50 PM
"Musicality"





(The difference between music and "one note after another."  Helpful, eh?)
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Nick Hudis on May 06, 2009, 08:14:34 PM
Get an earful of Tony Hall, Stephane Delicq, Markku Lepisto, Riccardo Tesi, Andy Cutting,... and maybe many others I've yet to discover and hope that something of their wonderful muscianship rubs off on you.
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: GbH on May 06, 2009, 08:37:45 PM
Someone that can play really loud and really fast?   >:E
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: HallelujahAl on May 06, 2009, 08:42:51 PM
Quote
Someone that can play really loud and really fast?   

I'm ok then!
 ;)
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Quebecois on May 06, 2009, 09:04:38 PM
Someone people like to listen to her/his music!
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: george garside on May 06, 2009, 09:21:18 PM
Get an earful of Tony Hall, Stephane Delicq, Markku Lepisto, Riccardo Tesi, Andy Cutting,... and maybe many others I've yet to discover and hope that something of their wonderful muscianship rubs off on you.

there are 2 clips of tony hall on utube  - ships in the night & morris dance

george
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Andy Next Tune on May 06, 2009, 10:38:17 PM
Musicality, phrasing, dynamics.......

In its simplest form, its the same quality that also makes a good comedian - timing.

Andy
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: HallelujahAl on May 07, 2009, 06:26:08 AM
On a practical note I've noticed that all the really good box players that I admire (with one or two notable exceptions) hardly ever spend their time posting on Mel.net Coincidence? Or are they all too busy actually 'playing'? Like I said earlier, I think that what makes a good player is practice.
AL ;D
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Graeme on May 07, 2009, 12:50:40 PM
Oh boy! Endless definitions of a good box player available, quite rightly so! I think I'm good because I can manage a few tunes (some with both hands too using the BCC# & stradella). My daughter and family think I'm good. Fergie MacDonald thinks differently and perhaps sees some potential room for significant improvements. But, if you know why you're playing a box and your managing to achieve that then I would argue you are good. If you have aspirations beyond current ability, setting out a definition of where you want to be, to define your notion of success, could sensibly be followed up by a plan to achieve that success. Setting goals along the journey towards success which are attainable could still mean that you are good! Is there such a thing as a bad box player.  ???

Graeme
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: ganderbox on May 07, 2009, 05:15:58 PM
Is there such a thing as a bad box player.  ???

Graeme

Yes...but they often think they are good!
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Graeme on May 07, 2009, 09:04:15 PM
Is there such a thing as a bad box player.  ???

Graeme

Yes...but they often think they are good!

Or you think they're bad? And they think you are......and so on!  ;D
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Quebecois on May 08, 2009, 03:35:46 PM
One who knows how to get out of the mechanical and get into the musical aspect of playing!
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: squeezebox63 on May 13, 2009, 01:58:07 PM
How about rhythm. every real good player I've heard seems to have real good rhythm to their music.
You can play as methodicaly as possible but still not have that jump or chemistry to make the music come alive. You almost have to have the gift in your blood and bones.
I have yet to obtain that gift. Most of my music sounds , shall we say , clinical.
If you can play along with cd's or a group it helps.
Cliff.
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Hello on May 13, 2009, 07:44:52 PM
I would define a good player as:
Someone who has a combination of technical mastery and musicality which allows them to think outside the box and perform a tune and variations thereof in such a way as to make it interesting for themselves and to engage the audience at all times.
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 13, 2009, 11:16:44 PM
Ought we not to think inside the box, so we have some idea of what it's going to do next?  ;)
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Theo on May 13, 2009, 11:21:26 PM
Ought we not to think inside the box, so we have some idea of what it's going to do next?  ;)

Only when the box is in the workshop!

Then the technician must do all the thinking  ??? about the inside of the box so the player doesn't have to  :D
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: melod-ian on May 14, 2009, 09:11:11 PM
are we talking about playing solo or playing in a group..you can be the best box player around.. BUT in a band situation you need to be more complimentary to the other musicians
i consider myself as the rhythm section in my band NOT the lead.. that's the job of the Fiddle or recorder.

Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Stiamh on May 14, 2009, 09:54:17 PM
BUT in a band situation you need to be more complimentary to the other musicians
i consider myself as the rhythm section in my band NOT the lead.. that's the job of the Fiddle or recorder.

Reading your post I was thinking hear, hear, to myself and then I read the last word and nearly choked.  ;)

There was a long discussion on here not so long ago on the subject of whether the box a second-class instrument - and my view is that yes it is, because in the music I play it's at its best as a sympathetic foil to a good fiddle. But recorder... strewth. That's a third-class instrument!
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: melod-ian on May 14, 2009, 10:14:15 PM
Quote
But recorder... strewth. That's a third-class instrument!

its not a question of class, really .. my point is rhythm. and the recorder is not a rhythm instrument.. it will only be a lead.
the melodeon of course is both.. is'nt it more complimentary to play rhythm underneath a recorder playing the lead line?
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Stiamh on May 14, 2009, 10:27:12 PM
I was just taking the michael, Ian. I like recorders well enough - as long as they aren't playing trad. music.
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 14, 2009, 10:34:12 PM
...But recorder... strewth. That's a third-class instrument!
I get sick and bloody tired of this sort of attitude. If it is a third-class instrument, would you care to explain why Bach, Telemann and Handel, not to mention many Renaissance composers, wrote exquisitely for recorder, both as a solo and an ensemble instrument?

Third class instruments in action:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tcp164LBWfQ
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: melod-ian on May 14, 2009, 10:40:10 PM
I was just taking the michael, Ian. I like recorders well enough - as long as they aren't playing trad. music.

i know steve ;D... but they have as much right to be on the stage as me
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Stiamh on May 14, 2009, 10:51:50 PM
...But recorder... strewth. That's a third-class instrument!
I get sick and bloody tired of this sort of attitude. If it is a third-class instrument, would you care to explain why Bach, Telemann and Handel, not to mention many Renaissance composers, wrote exquisitely for recorder, both as a solo and an ensemble instrument?

Because the accordion hadn't yet been invented, perhaps?
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 14, 2009, 10:58:46 PM
I was just taking the michael, Ian. I like recorders well enough - as long as they aren't playing trad. music.
Don't forget that a great deal of the music we play which we think of as 'traditional' has its origins in baroque, renaissance and medieval music. Think of those jigs and hornpipes in the Playford collections, for example. These tunes would have been played by fiddles, lutes and various wind instruments including - yes - recorders. The recorder has a lot more claim to authenticity in our traditional music than this recent upstart, the melodeon.
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: joe on May 15, 2009, 10:15:21 AM
The recorder has a lot more claim to authenticity in our traditional music than this recent upstart, the melodeon.

But Melodeon sounds better!
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Owen Woods on May 15, 2009, 11:31:03 AM
We have a number of recorders in our group. Some of them are trying to learn the whistle (and complaining about it) but it works reasonably well as a folk instrument when played properly.

I agree with your analysis, but it's incredibly easy to be lazy. For instance, in our group for a typical lineup we would have a bodran, guitar, 3 fiddles, recorder and a few "misc", which might include melodeon (me), windsynth, cello, trombone, accordion, Charango (also me) etc. We have a different lineup each time.

I am classed as a melody line instrument and I think that my melody helps drown out complement the fiddle/recorder melody. However, evven with a guitarist it is incredible what effect a decent bass has, which is what I've been working on for the past few months.
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: melod-ian on May 15, 2009, 12:42:33 PM
Obviously its different between bands.. different dynamics etc.
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Falseknight on May 15, 2009, 05:51:04 PM
Depending on the music (even within a traditional context) I'd far sooner have a good recorder player (preferably with a good recorder) than an average whistle player.  At least the recorder is reasonably equally tempered and chromatic.
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 16, 2009, 11:42:40 AM
As long as the player is equally so?  (:)
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Mike Higgins on May 16, 2009, 11:46:35 AM
On Thursday night Brass Monkey played in our village hall, and I now understand what a good box player is. 
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Martin J on May 16, 2009, 11:59:15 AM
...But recorder... strewth. That's a third-class instrument!
I get sick and bloody tired of this sort of attitude. If it is a third-class instrument, would you care to explain why Bach, Telemann and Handel, not to mention many Renaissance composers, wrote exquisitely for recorder, both as a solo and an ensemble instrument?

Third class instruments in action:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tcp164LBWfQ

This is the worst ceilidh band I've ever heard  >:E
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: GbH on May 16, 2009, 12:16:48 PM
...But recorder... strewth. That's a third-class instrument!
I get sick and bloody tired of this sort of attitude. If it is a third-class instrument, would you care to explain why Bach, Telemann and Handel, not to mention many Renaissance composers, wrote exquisitely for recorder, both as a solo and an ensemble instrument?

Third class instruments in action:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tcp164LBWfQ


And another - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V8wL1AR7iqo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V8wL1AR7iqo)
Title: Re: what makes a good box player???
Post by: Falseknight on May 16, 2009, 12:37:30 PM
The U Tube comments are quite interesting on both pieces as well.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal