Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: drjack on May 13, 2009, 05:32:15 PM
-
Does anyone have any thoughts or opinions about this box? eBay #260406642398
Any info appreciated
Jack
-
Well, it's a very typical 2-row Italian organetto...
It'll have 2 middle reeds and a low one controlled by a stop, and it's got an open, stepped keyboard. Beyond that?
-
What distinguishes an accordion from an organetto?
How would this differ from a Hohner Erica or Pokerworks in the same A/D tuning?
Thanks
J
-
What distinguishes an accordion from an organetto?
How would this differ from a Hohner Erica or Pokerworks in the same A/D tuning?
Thanks
J
My thoughts too. I've always understood Organetto to be single key with reversals on the second row and basses limited to the home key. Once it has two keys and 8 basses I consider it to be a melodeon/accordeon diatonic/knopfakkordeon etc. If the true definition is different, like Dr Jack I too would be interested.
-
What distinguishes an accordion from an organetto?
Language. The Italians describe all diatonic accordions as organetti (and especially their own traditional style ones - which is how I was meaning the term), and then sub-group them according to how many basses they have.
My thoughts too. I've always understood Organetto to be single key with reversals on the second row and basses limited to the home key.
They're one type of organetto, which the Italians sometimes describe as "due botti", since they have two basses.
Once it has two keys and 8 basses I consider it to be a melodeon/accordeon diatonic/knopfakkordeon etc.
Take a look at (for example) the Giustozzi Catalogue (http://www.giustozzi.it/Catalogo/vetrina/catalogo_ita.asp?IdC=C0035&PCat=;0;C0035;) in Italian if you don't believe me, whilst "knopfakkordeon" means a continental chromatic accordion, not a melodeon in Germany. (I deal with accordion factories in both Germany and Italy, so I need to understand what these names imply to their makers... )
How would this differ from a Hohner Erica or Pokerworks in the same A/D tuning?
I think I've already answered that in my last reply, or is there something that I haven't understood in your question?
-
whatever misunderstandings there are are on my part. i just have lots to learn
jack
-
whatever misunderstandings there are are on my part. i just have lots to learn
jack
And Ebay is not the place to start learning, unless you want to risk some expensive mistakes!
-
"Organetto" is simply an Italian word for diatonic accordion, the equivalent of the English "Melodeon". Here's a website showing the construction of a 2-row 8-bass organetto - looks like a Castagnari. http://www.organetto.it/pages/struttura.html (http://www.organetto.it/pages/struttura.html) The rest of the site shows various other types of organetti.
-
whatever misunderstandings there are are on my part. i just have lots to learn
Jack,
Ok, maybe I'm assuming that you know some very basic stuff, when maybe you don't yet?
A Hohner Erica, or Pokerwork, has only two sets of reeds - which are both in the same (middle) octave. It also has an enclosed action and a flat keyboard.
This Paolo Soprani similarly has 2 middle reeds, plus another set one octave lower that are controlled by a stop on top of the instrument (so they can be switched on or off). It has an open keyboard action, which is stepped (so that the inside row buttons are physically higher than the outside ones).
Does that help?
-
whilst "knopfakkordeon" means a continental chromatic accordion, not a melodeon in Germany.
Maybe someone should tell German Ebay then as their customers use it for melodeons, Steirish for Alpine types with helikon base and C griff or B griff for the chromatics.
-
Nope I don't know the basics. that's why i subscribe to this forum and check eBay. I would never buy one on line buy it's a good way to check out boxes and to see what sells and for how much
Is there a good site to learn the basics about melodeon types etc?
Jack
-
Is there a good site to learn the basics about melodeon types etc?
Jack,
You're on it! You just need to dig around a bit on this site, to find threads that will tell you about basic stuff.
Otherwise, spell it out and ask specifically about what you don't understand, or want to find out about - there's a wealth of knowledge here...
-
whilst "knopfakkordeon" means a continental chromatic accordion, not a melodeon in Germany.
Maybe someone should tell German Ebay then as their customers use it for melodeons ...
Well I wouldn't worry too much about the way anything is described on eBay... ::)
But plenty of German users do use Knopfakkordeon (http://www.akkordeon-klingenthal.de/index.php?option=content&task=view&id=72) correctly, whilst the usual German term (for melodeon) is Handharmonika (or Diatonische-Harmonika (http://www.akkordeon-klingenthal.de/index.php?option=content&task=view&id=85)), which can then be subdivided into the specific types Club-Harmonikas (Club Accordions), Wiener-Harmonikas (Vienna Accordions), Deutsche-Harmonikas (German Accordions) or Steirische-Harmonikas (Styrian Accordions).
-
Is there a good site to learn the basics about melodeon types etc?
Jack
Jack, go to our parent website www.melodeon.net (http://www.melodeon.net) - click on "Website Home", above. It's all there.
-
Is there a good site to learn the basics about melodeon types etc?
Jack
Triskel is right, you're on it. I've just learnt a great deal about which types of diatonics are called what in Germany. Many thanks Triskel. (:)