Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: squeezy on July 07, 2015, 10:20:19 PM
-
Hi there,
This is not a question, more of a musing about things with the hope of having a bit of a discussion that might lead us to understand how and why the current related keyboards of melodeons, bandoneons, anglo concertinas, harmonicas etc. exist in their current forms today.
This thought was prompted by listening to Stephen Fry's documentary on the history and evolution of the QWERTY keyboard which you can listen to here (http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00t9t6r) - I found the history fascinating!
The original instrument / design must have been very influential. A diatonic scale played push-pull-push-pull-push-pull-pull-push (or suck blow) with all the notes of the major chord of the key the instrument is in on the push and all the other notes on the pull. Does anyone know what the first recorded instrument to do this was? For playing outside the main octave - this design has a fundamental flaw - the fingering changes between octaves - but it was obviously very influential as most instruments that have the push-pull pattern conserve this approach to this day.
After this single-row / harmonica approach, we get the divergence of instruments with concertinas splitting the scale between the hands, melodeons adding basses, harmonicas developing in to the chromatic version with a slide. They get more and more complicated as the years go by, and yet only the club melodeon/dutch reversal system messes with the core of the scales by one note. What is it about this pattern of notes that made it so robust that it was almost always conserved?
In the meantime, many other systems of playing have been devised with more logical chromatic solutions to buttons that play free reeds. Continental chromatics, piano accordions and English Concertina are the most widespread alternative solutions that all play the same note on push and pull. And of course there are many other 'experimental' or 'minority' systems that end up being played like the duet systems of concertina, hayden system, hohner chromonica and atzarin keyboards. But despite their increased logic and chromaticism, there are still a massive proportion of free-reed instruments in the world based upon a 7 note diatonic scale that tries to reconcile an odd number of notes upon an even number of note permutations!! What is it about the diatonic push-pull/suck-blow scale that justifies this conservation?
Of course there are positives we talk about all the time on melodeon.net such as the snap and bounce created when playing a melody when the bellows are constantly changing direction which the diatonic scale forces us in to doing. The instruments are generally smaller because there are two notes per button too. But my gut feeling is that there must be something more to it than that - otherwise the benefits of something like swapping to an 8 note scale (e.g. G,A,B,C,D,E,F,F#) to fit the even number needed to give the same fingering between octaves would have been invented and adopted. My problem is I just can't put my finger on what that is.
My proposal is that someone invented an ancestor instrument back in the late 1700s or early 1800s that all these descendant instruments come from which had this 7 note scale and there's something brilliant about the concept. Even though we constantly strive to find extra notes, rows, reversals ... we stick to it very rigidly over time ... which in terms of evolutionary thinking suggests that it offers massive selective advantages.
-
While I have nothing to add currently, I really look forward to following this thread (and watching the QWERTY documentary)!
Thanks
Baron
-
I have Phillipe Krumm's l' Accordéon, Quelle histoire in fromt of me, planning a re-read. It explores these issues to some extent in a non technical manner, but uses a few words they don't teach in French A level ::)! Will come back …
I think the short answer is optimisation on the diatonic scale, and dare I say modes, and the fact that occidental music's liking for 1,3,5…7 etc "alternate notes of the mode" harmony structures throws simple triad chords, and bigger ones on 2+ rows into nice push or pull groups. All the club system does is to cleverly extend those possibilities.
I think it's conserved … because actually our music is culturally conserved, and they fit so well together. Alternative structures eg CBA can be made to work, but have intrinsic istability. 2 row kit is pretty damn stable in appropriate keys?
Robust alternatives? Theo will (I hope) soon convert a cadaveric box to a TT½.TT½.TT½.… forever intervals layout. Unstable for occidental folk tunes as the intervals in upper octave (above 7th) come flat … but all the right hand chords are still there and isn't b9, #9 and b14 what "da blues" is all about. It is a true experiment for me but "should" be stable in blues musical style. Again … will report back.
Standard kit is tuned TT½TTT½ (tone/semitones) incidentally. Yes, the (essentially major bebop) tuning you describe would also have interesting possibilities, and again note directions woud reverse in upper octave. Fancy building one?
-
Are there any musical instruments, out of the free reed family, where a single operation of a key plus another unrelated action gives two consecutive notes of a scale ? If not then it seems unlikely that that the principle developed elsewhere.
A major aspect of the gob iron is that to the untrained or uncouth gob overlapping adjacent notes are not too hard on the trained ear, the bisonoric bellow powered instrument has the same intrinsic benefit (hence 'melodeon' I guess) and even when mishandled is relatively harmonious while having roughly half the operating mechanism for mostly the same flexibility as a unisonoric diatonic and hugely less than a chromatic instrument makes its evolution a no brainer for manufacturers looking at the cheaper end of the market.
It is arguably a much simpler instrument to play than a Chromatic / PA, (although not at the level that many here attain!) and from the early models seen was initially probably quite expensive. At some point its popularity as a folk instrument spawned the cheap and cheerful models (we just cant resist on ebay) and voices, tunings, bass arrangements etc, developed to feed the different musical requirements of various market areas. Thereafter bells, whistles and other value adding until the Club layout which the contents of my cranium are still trying to come to terms with but fundamentally its still only 1/2 a button adrift from where Squeezy started......
Concertinas strike me as a blind alley where the original design was about right tonally and managing a pair of single reeds per button worked well - from thereon she was a creature of known habits and experimentation was largely the arrangement of the keys to get the right sounds out. Hallelujah Al can probably give chapter & verse.
Bandoneon seems to have developed as as portable (?) harmonium for a more classical role in Europe, never tried one so the key layout is a mystery but appears concertina like.
My money is on the layout developing as the fewest keys for the most notes (in a given diatonic scale) with the least chance of a discord from adjacent buttons pressed, while maximising appropriate chords.
Likewise looking forward to seeing this one expand as we must all at some time or other wondered "why the hell did they do it like that"
-
Is this of any interest? http://www.inorg.chem.ethz.ch/tango/band/band_node8.html (http://www.inorg.chem.ethz.ch/tango/band/band_node8.html)
Steve
-
Thanks for the link Steve, that possibly suggests that the first instrument to use the scale was the first mouth organ in 1821 - followed very quickly by the first primitive melodeon in 1822.
Thanks to everyone else for their contributions too.
-
No research to back any of this up, but here are my thoughts on it:
- as countless melodeon and harmonica players have found, it's very intuitive to play. Quite why this should be so I'm not sure, but it seems to be true. The suck-blow sequence seems to be instinctive - give a child a mouth-organ or toy accordion and that's what they'll immediately do
- it creates chords very easily, simply by pressing adjacent buttons
- left-hand chords can be matched (in terms of bellows direction) with the appropriate right-hand notes, so it's impossible to play the wrong chord
- the entire octave fits under the hand without stretching and is contained within only 4 or 5 buttons
- it is cheap and efficient to make, and exploits the natural reversal of airflow (unlike other wind instruments where the flow is always in one direction). Bisonoric instruments need twice as many reeds simply to overcome this, and then need twice as many sets of buttons, levers, valves etc for the same number of notes, which makes then more difficult and more expensive to build/li]
- it was suited to the popular music of the time, which was largely diatonic in nature.
As a concertina player I would naturally disagree with Broadland Boy's claim that these were a blind alley. However it should be noted that the most popular version by was far the push-pull anglo-german system, because it was cheap to make and easy to play. The other systems were usually more expensive and were preferred by the middle and upper classes who wanted to play more sophisticated music.
It was the change in musical fashions, when in the 20th century popular music became more chromatic, that caused these diatonic instruments to fall out of favour. However the chromatic accordion, in both button and piano versions, remained popular until another shift in fashion saw the guitar take over.
-
I've always wondered as to whether there was a social/educational reason for the way the separate strands of early squeezeboxes developed.
The English Concertina, via Charles Wheatstone, was designed to ape the violin in range but with improved playability and more equal distribution of work between the hands and fingers. In effect it was a middle class instrument amongst whom reading music would be one of the more usual attainments. The way a corpus of printed music for the EC develops may support this.
If you take the anglo (and the earliest bandoneons) you have a much more intuitive instrument which comes at the expense of flexibility across the keys. In it's home keys however almost anyone can knock out a tune fairly quickly by ear and make quite complicated arrangements without musical knowledge. Arguably that appealed to it's target audience and the lack of a specific printed musical canon may support this.
The melodeon follows on from this branch of the tradition whilst the duet concertina and maybe the piano accordion follows on from the more formal branch.
The bandoneon is in interesting diversion in that it develops it's own notation system. If you look at the sides of a bandoneon you'll see that each note is numbered. The main sequence relates to the original design when it was almost an anglo, the other notes and thus numbers were added over the years. Interestingly (but perversely) no attempt was made to amend the original sequence of buttons to make the new additions more logical in position. However the numbers were used to develop a specific bandoneon notation (I suppose today we'd call it a Tab) called "Waschleinensystem'' (clothes line system) which is thought to have been aimed at those without formal musical training. Essentially a string of numbers with some guidance on timing etc.
I included the piano accordion in this overview because, whilst we tend to see it as a folk instrument, in reality for most of it's life (and even today) it wasn't/isn't and again has quite an extensive canon of printed music.
Enough rambling (:)
Steve
-
A very interesting thread, squeezy.
Sebastian recently very kindly let me try out his amazing Atzarin layout for a few months. (Without going into the details here, I thought it was very clever, and potentially the way forward for serious accordion players starting out and wanting an instrument). However one thing it made me do was to rethink and re-appreciate the diato layout, with regard to 'quint' boxes.
It seems to me that the obvious advantage of the diato layout is to be found in its simplicity, which allows novices and previous non-musicians to get started. It is perhaps less obvious that it is also an efficient way of providing the notes you most need very close to each other, with others around the periphery of your playing position. This makes for efficient and easy playing, and great speed. The Atzarin layout is theoretically much more flexible, and efficiently provides all the notes you will need close to your home position. It will therefore allow the player virtually unlimited opportunities to play any tune in any key and mode. However I began to realise that in a sense, 'the best can be the enemy of the good' - what is actually most advantageous for playing most tunes is to have the most-needed notes within easy reach. The extra stretches you need to develop to become an Atzarin player are not great, but even a small additional stretch can significantly reduce playing speed. I feel this is also a potential problem with piano keyboards - if one looks at good players, you notice their hands flashing around all over the place, whereas a good button accordion player typically uses more economical hand movements, and often small finger movements alone.
The other thing I found about the Atzarin layout when compared with the diato concept is that the diato allows the player a 'home major triad' concept, from which other intervals can be built up mentally as the player gains experience - whereas with the Atazarin, I felt slightly lost, and didn't know how to begin. (I'm sure this develops with skill, but it is initially quite daunting to have to remember where each semitone interval lies.) A piano keyboard of course is best in terms of visualising notes and intervals, but the diato major chord triad is also something you can relate to easily.
There are of course loads of disadvantages and contradictions with the diato when trying to extend the concept to include non-diatonic notes or reversals, which is no doubt why there are so many different keyboard layout designs about, but still you have the advantages of allowing steady incremental learning, which I think was perhaps the main reason for the diato's original popular success.
-
I think there is a lot of truth in the idea being put forward that the push-pull diatonic scale pattern is an efficient intuitive system for playing simple tunes in the western major scale. In the early to mid 1800s that kind of music dominated in central Europe where the squeezeboxes undoubtedly originated - and it continues to be a very important tonality in a lot of folk traditions. Whether that became the case due to the rising influence of the squeezeboxes and harmonicas being played by people is something that would need debating.
The fact that the system is very forgiving when someone accidentally plays an adjacent button, giving simple harmony rather than a discordant note, probably adds to the case that the diatonic system is very folk-friendly compared to other possibilities in that it is the kind of instrument that you can learn to play without knowing any music theory, or indeed without knowing what any of the notes you are playing are called. That very much depends on what definition you use for the promiscuous term "folk" of course! But if it is music that people were able to make for themselves for their own entertainment then I would say that the melodeon scale is very much suited to that!
Yes ... part of this story is very much about the divergence of later systems based on the diatonic layout too. Within the melodeon family itself there is a massive divergence of seemingly identical instruments to look at when you think about fifth-apart systems compared to semitone systems for boxes of more than one row (and in the case of the Italian organetto - the reversal system too) ... which system is used tends to have a massive effect on how the instrument is played, the way it sounds and especially the ornamentation used on it.
There are cases where music that was developed using an instrument based on a diatonic scale has been almost completely superseded by a more logical system. The earliest French musette music was played on large 3 row G/C/B instruments with a Stradella bass system - this use probably came from people learning on more simple diatonic systems, and if you listen to anything recorded by Émile Vacher then you can be left in no doubt that he's already taken a 5th apart diatonic system to dizzying heights of chromaticism way back in the 1920s. However - because the music became more and more complicated and chromatic, players began to learn it on the continental chromatic accordions and that became the norm very soon afterwards. There is a more recent move among bandoneon players for tango music to use instruments with a unisonoric system based on continental chromatic accordions while keeping the shape and sound of the bandoneon.
-
As a concertina player I would naturally disagree with Broadland Boy's claim that these were a blind alley.
Good, you're sparing me objecting here.. ;D
However it should be noted that the most popular version by was far the push-pull anglo-german system, because it was cheap to make and easy to play. The other systems were usually more expensive and were preferred by the middle and upper classes who wanted to play more sophisticated music.
It was the change in musical fashions, when in the 20th century popular music became more chromatic, that caused these diatonic instruments to fall out of favour. However the chromatic accordion, in both button and piano versions, remained popular until another shift in fashion saw the guitar take over.
I don't want to bore the congregated melodeon community with talking about one of these "more sophisticated" systems, the English concertina, indeed introduced as sort of a parlour instrument for the Victorian lady back in those days... but can't abstain from chiming in here (hope you don't mind me), however trying to focus on the topical aspects:
IMO classifying this system under "chromatic" (which is very much common among concertinists) as opposed so "diatonic" is an oversimplification. The English system is based upon four (vertical) rows of buttons, with the center rows representing the "white keys" of a piano keyboard, whereas the outer rows left and right have the "black" accidentals. I consider this as much diatonic as the piano (and piano accordion) keyboard in its core, so to speak. You have diatonic scales, modes, intervals at hand, and the (full) chromatic abilities are just an extension, similar to the "helper rows" of a Club melodeon or an Anglo concertina, albeit "more" logical as for me (and of course with a unisonoric instrument and thus easily having space for all the 12 tones of the octave, furthernore allocating the flats and sharps aside the "natural" keys and thus retaining the pattern of a given scale as possible).
About the melodeon I'm really liking the bisonoric push/pull bounce, but also the diatonic foundation (shared with both piano and English concertina), as opposed to truly chromatic (maybe isomorphic) instruments such as the CBA and the Hayden Duet concertina. Mind you this is not idle or pointless talking from my side, as I'm very much relying on the diatonic structure in my playing the English concertina, starting with open fifths as basic accompaniment pattern - and that's what's leading me on my way back to the melodeon (using bass chords of course, but also double stop right hand "chords" asf.).
It has sort of become fashionable to look down at a diatonic approach to music in general, against what I'm going up; for me it's about, well, bisonoricity (as to the melodeon), off course about helpful limitations anyways, but furthermore about a tonal system which has been crucial for western traditional music and still can be explored to great results - with our diatonic free reed instruments being truly great tools on the journey....
Best wishes - Wolf
-
Bisonoric instruments need twice as many reeds simply to overcome this...
You mean "Unisonoric", don't you?
-
I often thought of building a diatonic harmonium that works with pedals sucking and blowing. As both hands would play the shift in opposite suck and blow in the octaves would make a bit of sense with the left mirroring the right. The right hand being the melody side. A simple instrument but small and relatively portable and I expect a jaunty sort of playing style. I wonder if one was made years ago and quickly evolved to using bellows.
-
You mean "Unisonoric", don't you?
Doh, of course. Always get those confused.
-
I often thought of building a diatonic harmonium that works with pedals sucking and blowing. As both hands would play the shift in opposite suck and blow in the octaves would make a bit of sense with the left mirroring the right. The right hand being the melody side. A simple instrument but small and relatively portable and I expect a jaunty sort of playing style.
Would love to give it a try...!
-
There is a more recent move among bandoneon players for tango music to use instruments with a unisonoric system based on continental chromatic accordions while keeping the shape and sound of the bandoneon.
There are also bandoneon players who argue that these don't sound bandoneons because they lose the bounciness/punch that the push/pull system can impart, particularly when chording. Does this sound familiar?
Steve
-
My comment on the concertina was not to raise ire amongst its devotees, I started out with one meself.
Poorly expressed but the intent was that the concertina seems to have arrived early on at a currently recognisable form which other than the aspects noted seems to have remained much the same, something the 'Oblong Box' took longer to arrive at.
Of course, none of the pioneers were hampered with cross point screws to spoil their works of art with............. >:E
-
Poorly expressed but the intent was that the concertina seems to have arrived early on at a currently recognisable form
Quite the opposite I would have thought, if we're talking about keyboards. You have the English and the Anglo-German and then several permutations of duet. The most recent layout, the Hayden, was only introduced relatively recently, although it turns out that the inventor had arrived independently at an earlier design.
The basic diato keyboard on the other hand seems to have remained fairly unchanged, and developments are based on adding additional rows in different key configurations, and tinkering with the odd button to provide accidentals, gleichtons and reversals to suit particular needs.
-
There have been a number of references in this thread to a view that the production of diatonic boxes is/was cheap. This is something that does not seem to be borne out by the current market and I have often wondered how the melodeon became a popular instrument with them being quite so expensive. Does anyone have a view on whether historically they were cheaper to produce and buy than today? Are the economics of production likely to have had an impact on their evolution - I suspect so, but don't have any evidence or knowledge.
-
nigelr:
I think it is all relative.
A melodeon, even the more expensive makes, are *realtively* cheap. This has cropped up on other threads where people have compared a top melodeon to a top quality cello and other similar orchestra instruments, making the point that even the best melodeon is relatively cheap.
As for concertinas, Colin Dipper is to my mind the only maker still going following in the footsteps of the classic makers such as Wheatstone or Lachenal. His anglo's aren't cheap as everything is hand made and so priced to reflect this.
Q
-
Does anyone have a view on whether historically they were cheaper to produce and buy than today?
Similar questions and discussion regarding the concertina use to occur frequently. In the heyday of the concertina there has been sort of an (semi?) industrial mass-production. Today's building such an instrument is so much more expensive because the demand is still ridiculously small compared with those times (regarding the concertina the issues is even bigger due to the fact that there's abolutely no mass production of - concertina - reeds).
-
Colin Dipper is to my mind the only maker still going following in the footsteps of the classic makers such as Wheatstone or Lachenal.
I'd say there are some more makers of that calibre in the market... (which might not be of further interest here as to the details).
-
Dipper makes everything as far as I'm aware..... are there others that make to this degree?
Q
-
Dipper makes everything as far as I'm aware..... are there others that make to this degree?
Q
Oh, I see what you mean - I'll have to inquire then but should think so...
-
My point being, he even tools the screws that hold the end plates to the bodies, and as far as I know buys in very little ready made, if anything. Total construction like this has to have a big bearing on the final costs.
From threads on here, I understand all melodeon makers buy in reed sets, many buy in ready made bellows, and some 'makers' simply re-badge boxes made for them, not by them!
Variations such as this means costs from maker to maker will vary considerably. Makers who make more of their melodeons often are higher up the price range as opposed to those that buy in part or all of their boxes ready made as an economy exercise.
Apologies Squeezy, I seem to be thread drifting here.....
Q
-
Here's the first maker that came to my mind, based in Germany:
Jürgen Suttner (http://www.suttnerconcertinas.com/)
He's making his own reeds, and as to further parts you may gauge what he's doing yourself...
(no making of tools, possibly)
I'm pretty sure there are more, as I believe there's hardly a market for "real" concertina reeds (apart from used ones screwed on theirs "shoes") at all...
-
Ive been out of the concertina world for a while so not heard of Suttner.
Looks nice stuff, and good to know other 'proper' makers out there!
Thanks
Q
-
He's selling quite a bit in Ireland, and there's a waiting list, current waiting time 18 months I seem to recall...
As to the reed-making, it's even being done by repair-persons or players/owners themselves at times, using used clock springs a.s.f.
P.S.: ... not including myself as yet... (:)
-
Well I think I expected some thread drift given how vague the original post was! Concertinas are an important part of the story of the place of instruments based on a diatonic push-pull scale - and if having a bisonoric layout helped some instruments to be more affordable then that would have a bearing on how popular the system became I suppose.
But yes - the finer details of how certain makes of concertinas are made are not really very helpful to this conversation >:E
It would be lovely to know whether the first mouth harmonica in 1821 had that scale designed specifically so that the advantages we all seem to be talking about existed or whether it was hastily put together as a gimmicky toy and the success of the system was a happy coincidence.
I know that the Kora in West African music has a scale very similar to the 'diatonic' middle rows of the English concertina - a major scale is played alternating strings left-right-left-right etc. - I don't know much more about the kora or whether it predates free-reed instruments in this format, whether it was an inspiration or a convergent evolution of a good idea. But the similarities are all there.
-
The first harmonicas in Europe (1820, Christian Frederick Buschmann) were blow only. The blow/suck is first done by Richter five years later and he used the tuning we now use, can't quite get my head round the chronology with diatonics, need to do a timeline.
In the same vein, Hohner introduces the chromatic in 1910, anyone got an old catalogue to check when the semitone box comes into being?
Steve
-
My trio is me on diato, a mountain dulcimer player, and a clarinet player.
We frequently comment on how the clarinet player has a chromatic temperament (pun intended!), while Barb and I have diatonic temperament. I know that I, particularly, have been drawn to diatonic instruments -- diatos, anglos, keyless flutes, tin whistles. When I play guitar, I typically have it in open tuning (Chris Wood's "C Tuning" is to die for). Technically, the guitar is still chromatic, but if you play it that way, you're going against the strengths of that tuning. If nothing else, sympathetic vibrations are a wonder.
My dulcimer player plays an old style instrument that only has the diatonic scales fretted. Apparently, extra frets have become all the rage for the dulcimer community, but she refuses -- feeling she would be sacrificing ... something ... by moving away from the original instrument. I can see where she's coming from. Two row/eight bass is my absolute favorite diato configuration (I am loving my new Erica!), and even though I know that the extra half row on my Pastourelle III (which I also LOVE) does nothing to interfere with the core diatonicity of the instrument, the 2R/8B set up just always feels more "right" to me.
It may be that we are uncomfortable with expanding options. Chaos is an over abundance of choice. If we have all those chromatic flobbies on our boxes, we're tempted to use them. Certainly, it's true that if you have chromatics available, you are more likely to make music that sounds chromatic than if you don't have those things. The instrument you use influences the music you make. As Duke Ellington said, "The trouble with writing for a big band is that everything you write sounds like big band music."
So, this doesn't address the question of why suck/blow started, but I think it does look at why it persists.
Great conversation,
Gary
-
I think that may be at the heart of why we all enjoy the music Gary - if not a complete answer as to why the system has been fairly ubiquitously conserved for almost 200 years.
As someone who is in the weird position of having progressed through more and more chromatic permutations of a quint system box until I'm now playing a 3 row D/G/accidentals system with fully chromatic Stradella 48 bass left hand (the B/C/C# for diehard quint system devotees!) I think I'm probably in a good place to comment on how the temptation of increased chromaticism can lead to a less distinctive sound. In short ... yes it does! But it doesn't have to. I'm currently learning tunes in F, Ab, C#m, Fm and B (more as an exercise than because of the need to do so and because I'm really bloody minded) - and you know what? If I stick to simple basses then they sound just as 'diatonic' and bouncy as tunes in the home keys of D, G and Em. It's the push-pull thing that gives that feel. However - if I let my imagination run wild and use the box in a completely chromatic way it has a tendency to take on an almost cheesy/overdone sound which I associate with unisonoric systems like PA and CC boxes. It also becomes a far harder thing (needing much more accuracy) to fill out chords and flourishes in these more outlandish keys.
This isn't really pertinent to my original musing - and it's very personal. But the fact that I can retreat back to those two rows of melodeon-ey comfort after completing the mental gymnastics needed to go far outside that is probably key to me sticking with the cornelia long enough to get on top of it.
The QWERTY analogy is good here - even if amazing claims were made about what you could do with it - who would seriously re-learn a whole new system of typing when given an alternative of a QWERTY keyboard with a few additions around it?
-
I think several have tried and failed to replace the QWERTY keyboard with more logical or less physically stressful layouts based on the characters frequency of use but the inertia of all the folk currently familiar resists the change.
Accidentals arrived with the teletype and early electrics which needed a line feed (previously a 'bellows' function) the advent of the PC brought another load - helper row ?? and the most recent and least needed being the 'Windows' (TM) key, whatever that was for, still it allows 'digital Theos' to retune for a useful purpose :D
My mother, now in her late 80's learned to type at Underwoods, there is a Youtube of the sort of class somewhere, massed monstrous mechanical machines being pounded in unison and in time to music by rows of girls just out of school, all being conditioned to touch type. - There are some pretty elderly folk in this 'parish' but was anyone actually taught to type ? Schoolkids don't appear to be taught (to type that is) just exposed to the kit and get on with it. The odd spello's which appear here generally look as if they are related to predictive text or the tiny screens / buttons of a phone.
If people can learn to type reasonably accurately on a not overly logical key layout and largely without thinking much about it, why the heck can it be so difficult to master relatively simple sequences on the logical diatonic keyboard ??? Must be the bellows reversals ;)
I think the typewriter analogy probably stands as a better parallel than most musical instruments.
As an afterthought, the small instruments which look like a cut down harmonium with a hand operated bellows at the back sometimes used in Indian music, what are they called and are they unisonoric ??
-
They are called harmoniums and they are unisonoric, the clever thing about them is a well of air at the back which releases independently of the bellows pumping so you fill up the well with the hand pumped bellows from time to time and it releases gradually. This is great for drones and long phrases but would rule out bisonoric use. It was a European design but (so I've read) it was in Asia that they found a use for it. if anyone can tell me why they have loose keys in the keyboard I would be very interested but that's thread drift.
-
Not sure what you're exactely referring to BB, as there are even smaller boxes providing only drones, with sufficient air for two of them, mostly a quint it quart apart, operated with switches instead of buttons. These are called Shruti boxes...
-
Very interesting drift, there, squeezy!
You are probably in the position of knowing more about the practical uses of variations in the diato quint concept than anyone else, so I hope you won't mind if I ask you this:
It would seem to me that 2-row quint plus long accidental/reversal row is a sort of optimised compromise for playing in the restricted 'home' keys, and I note that you are getting into playing them in other keys. Electronic boxes such as the FR18 have the potential to sweep away those restrictions, and open the door to easy key change mid-tune (though unfortunately with the current design it requires two button pushes to do so, and you need to be watching what you're doing.) If FR18's could be developed so that they sound a bit less like dogs' breakfasts (and we know from past melnet threads that they certainly can), and this key change became easier on the fly (which I would have thought would be a doddle to redesign), would you be using them?
-
Very interesting drift, there, squeezy!
Electronic boxes such as the FR18 have the potential to sweep away those restrictions, and open the door to easy key change mid-tune (though unfortunately with the current design it requires two button pushes to do so, and you need to be watching what you're doing.)
It has been a while since I owned one Chris - but can you not setup adjacent registers to have the same voicing but in a different key - that way you should be able to change key with a single button press of one of the main register buttons.
-
I've been down that route Chris :D I used a significantly better and more playable transposable MIDI system than the awful design of the Roland for a good 12 months on stage with Bellowhead back in 2008-2009. My system used the far more playable Streb 3 row 12 bass working through a wireless MIDI system to a low latency expander that was loaded with sample banks which I recorded myself from my own instruments! I put a lot of effort in to making it work. At the end of the period I assessed how it sounded via recordings and how it felt to play vs the convenience of being able to change tunings and sounds by way of a single button push. The verdict was sadly that the sound and accuracy of the amazing Streb was not a match for an acoustic box and I figured that if I was playing music professionally then I should be aiming for the best possible playing and sound to the audience so I went back to the acoustic boxes.
With the particular 3 row layout I'm using on the Hohner Cornelia, at first glance it looks like it's set up for playing in D and G with a lot of flexibility - and of course it is very good at that. However, by taking on other keys as a kind of challenge and brain experiment I'm surprised how well I get on in many of the outlandish keys. Of course the limiting factor of most boxes like this is the left hand and getting chords in the correct direction for the notes - by having a chromatic unisonoric bass system this really no longer applies and the keys become far more available.
(http://www.johnspiers.co.uk/pictures/cornelialayout.jpg)
I feel far more comfortable having a core 2 rows that are essentially the same as the 2 row pokerwork I started playing on than I ever have trying out a semitone system B/C/C# even though I know how much more logical the system is. I realise that's a very personal thing which doesn't necessarily apply to everyone ... but I think that this could be as much a reason for the conservation of the diatonic core of squeezebox instruments as anything ... familiarity!
-
(off topic PS)
The Streb is still a tool I use for all sorts of things as a MIDI input device, basically replacing any kind of use most musicians and composers would use a MIDI piano keyboard ... it's excellent at that even though it lost the battle for live performance.
-
(Interesting thought, summerstars - I think that means feeding in every note in advance, but I'll check!)
-
I used a significantly better and more playable transposable MIDI system than the awful design of the Roland
That's really interesting, thanks.
It's very much a side issue I know, but I wrote to Roland and tried to get them to listen to the wonderful improvements others have actually achieved using the midi input, but it seems they weren't prepared to put more money into development. That is such a shame, because it's so close to being a great instrument IMO, particularly the incredibly light and fast keyboard - would you support me in giving them another go?
-
I know that the Kora in West African music has a scale very similar to the 'diatonic' middle rows of the English concertina - a major scale is played alternating strings left-right-left-right etc. - I don't know much more about the kora or whether it predates free-reed instruments in this format, whether it was an inspiration or a convergent evolution of a good idea. But the similarities are all there.
This is indeed very interesting information which I will'll surely be following up...
-
I think I'm probably in a good place to comment on how the temptation of increased chromaticism can lead to a less distinctive sound. In short ... yes it does! But it doesn't have to. I'm currently learning tunes in F, Ab, C#m, Fm and B (more as an exercise than because of the need to do so and because I'm really bloody minded) - and you know what? If I stick to simple basses then they sound just as 'diatonic' and bouncy as tunes in the home keys of D, G and Em. It's the push-pull thing that gives that feel.
John and I have disagreed on this sort of thing before … but there is another way. My setup is C#DG and in D/G related keys I play a mix of on-row and cross-row … defo more of the latter than some here, but it is a true mix
Like you, I'm exploring flat keys, and in my case that takes me onto my C# row (better now cseen as Db?). As said before, it has notes changed on pull: C#>D and F#>F; making it a better accidental source (I have those notes pull on the other 2 rows).
So the difference it that my C, F, and Bb scales are 100% pull, Eb and Cm need and Ab but that's a rock on my "magic" Ab/Bb button (recall it started as a Db row)
I am presently working on nothing but songs and this style of play really suits it. As a baritone the keys are comfortable, there are loads of twiddles, chunks of pentatonic whatever there for decorative play, and I control rhythm and nuance separately using the bellows. My left hand also contributes any bass runs
Drawback is that this style lacks natural bellows balance - I either use air valve or a push F chord when available to collapse them. But "for song" constant push-pull truly wrecks my voice control and I find this way well twice as easy. Basically I'm using my light non-stradella ;) left end for percussion. The fluency of the scales in use essentially still derives from the diatonic basis of that Db row.
Well, it works for me :|glug
-
... but I think that this could be as much a reason for the conservation of the diatonic core of squeezebox instruments as anything ... familiarity!
Back on topic for me - yes, my overriding impression as a result of trying Atzarin was to go back to just that thought. The familiarity and popularity I reckon arises from the speedy learning curve in the early stages with diatos. The other important factor here is I feel the very useable relationship of a 2-row quint to the diato concept - but on the other hand, (and perhaps controversially?), it seems to me that no one's ever really been able to work out how to extend that underlying musical design philosophy from two to more rows, except by just tacking on other notes nearby, hence the great range of different third row and bass designs.
-
Well, it works for me
And similarly for me too, I think, though perhaps in a slightly different way, because I'm looking principally to extend playability in the home keys, and swap boxes or electronic keys for others. It seems to me that in principle both 'bouncy' and 'legato' are highly desirable effects to have at one's disposal, and I support the idea therefore of alternate directions being available for most if not all of the notes on the RHS of a D/G/Acc or equivalent. This tends to mean you run out of places to put the extra buttons, and I've begun to feel there may be a merit in a fourth inner row with occasional buttons. Gawd knows what the design would be, but the box would still have that diato/quint core!
-
(Interesting thought, summerstars - I think that means feeding in every note in advance, but I'll check!)
It shouldn't Chris; You should be able to set two of the registers to exactly the same settings, then change the default key on one of them and save that register. Then you will have two registers with the same voicing but different preset home keys
-
Drawback is that this style lacks natural bellows balance - I either use air valve or a push F chord when available to collapse them. But "for song" constant push-pull truly wrecks my voice control and I find this way well twice as easy. Basically I'm using my light non-stradella ;) left end for percussion. The fluency of the scales in use essentially still derives from the diatonic basis of that Db row.
I think I suffer less from reduced bellows balance in most keys on my system (which I've edited my previous entry on this discussion to include) - primarily because of the useful spread of reversals across the cycle of fifths I have. I've got G,D,A,B,F#,Eb and F in both directions which allows some push notes in most scales. I have deliberately learnt the scales to include the best balance and it works for the majority ... I have most trouble with balancing the bellows directions in E major - but it is possible to work around for most tunes.
As for constant push pull wrecking the voice control ... it has nothing to do with this thread ... but I absolutely agree - I don't think it's got much to do with the mechanical side of the voice being inhibited by the motion of the bellows though ... for me it's very much another one of those brain itches like patting your head and rubbing your tummy but a million times worse!
-
That's really interesting, thanks.
It's very much a side issue I know, but I wrote to Roland and tried to get them to listen to the wonderful improvements others have actually achieved using the midi input, but it seems they weren't prepared to put more money into development. That is such a shame, because it's so close to being a great instrument IMO, particularly the incredibly light and fast keyboard - would you support me in giving them another go?
I would certainly encourage anyone to lobby for better technology for melodeon players!
However the few dealings with Roland I've have shown to me that they are not really interested in what we want. Two very major issues need to be addressed before the instrument will be remotely playable in the manner of a real melodeon. Firstly, they have to reduce the size of the bodywork. There is no way that it needs to be the dimensions of a continental chromatic box apart from the fact that they want to use the same machines to make both models! The components inside the roland could easily fit in to a far smaller instrument with a weight and bellows dimensions that would be familiar to a diatonic player.
Secondly ... they need to address the problem they have with the bellows detecting the minute differences between push and pull (and have a device that allows for changing atmospheric pressure). Every Roland I've ever tried has had such a bad setup that I was able to sound push notes on the pull or vice versa. All the Roland reps I've talked to about it have denied that it was a problem and said that there was no way to calibrate the sensor in the software.
Until they can sort out those issues (both of which Streb instruments can cope with) then they will never have a chance of being a match for an acoustic box in their playability.
-
As for constant push pull wrecking the voice control ... it has nothing to do with this thread ... but I absolutely agree - I don't think it's got much to do with the mechanical side of the voice being inhibited by the motion of the bellows though ... for me it's very much another one of those brain itches like patting your head and rubbing your tummy but a million times worse!
I agree, similar thing when playing melody alongside the voice (I know, it's against common advice, but that's what I'm mainly doing with my EC accompaniment, and it works for me): hit a wrong button and find your singing following the mistake... ::)
Playing the melodeon I'm not expecting the push/pull issue affecting my singing that much as I'm taking much advantage of the two-row and "Club" layout (including the all-important reversal for "re" of the home row; largely sticking with the home keys and their relatives for the moment) and therefore using the push/pull mainly for bouncy phrasing, very similar to my style with the EC...
Best wishes - Wolf
-
Earlier in this interesting thread, it was stated, I think, that diatonic instruments began in the 1820s with the first mouth organ and were followed a year later by the first melodeon. Another post pointed out that the first mouth organs were unisonoric. Assuming that the first melodeons were bisonoric, does that mean that the melodeon was the first bisonoric diatonic free-reed instrument or perhaps even the first bisonoric diatonic instrument of any kind?
-
I feel far more comfortable having a core 2 rows that are essentially the same as the 2 row pokerwork I started playing on than I ever have trying out a semitone system B/C/C# even though I know how much more logical the system is. I realise that's a very personal thing which doesn't necessarily apply to everyone ... but I think that this could be as much a reason for the conservation of the diatonic core of squeezebox instruments as anything ... familiarity!
I feel like objecting here (as to "just familiarity", I mean). Albeit I just seem to get what the semitone boxes are about from reading a lot here during the last weeks (and they're still to some extent diatonic) I believe that the three row quint boxes with their zig-zag runs both on the push and on the pull providing an approach alternative to the single row push/pull (mouth) harmonica style are allowing for a natural, so to speak, wandering through the scales and modes, including two- or three-part right hand harmony.
Any shift in the direction of chromaticism (of course including the installation of a "helper" row instead of a third quint row) will expand the musical abilities but at the expense of losing bits of the diatonic foundations of folk music. A prolifient player may be able to overcome this, as do the French musette players on CBA, but wouldn't he be sort of faking then?
We could put it this way, couldn't we? The two-row (and of course "international" three-row) quint box and the CBA are the extremes, one fully diatonic, one fully chromatic, whereas the PA, the "Club" melodeon, the semitone-boxes are sort of trade-offs to a smaller or wider extent?
Best wishes - Wolf
-
Another post pointed out that the first mouth organs were unisonoric.
Didn't it say they where either? having just tones/reeds on the blow...
-
I certainly haven't seen enough evidence (indeed I don't know if it even exists) to convince me which instrument was the first diatonic instrument (push-pull/suck-blow). It would be a very interesting thing to know - but having used rudimentary googling skills and come up with very little I don't know where you'd actually go to get hold of that kind of history.
-
I certainly haven't seen enough evidence (indeed I don't know if it even exists) to convince me which instrument was the first diatonic instrument (push-pull/suck-blow). It would be a very interesting thing to know - but having used rudimentary googling skills and come up with very little I don't know where you'd actually go to get hold of that kind of history.
Possibly this one https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrill_Demian (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrill_Demian). Can't find anything earlier and as the patent was granted it should have been unique. Vienna at the time was really the capital of much of central Europe which is why the patent office was there. From there I suppose you go flutina then melodeon on one strand, EC, anglo bandoneon on another strand.
Steve
-
Until they can sort out those issues (both of which Streb instruments can cope with) then they will never have a chance of being a match for an acoustic box in their playability.
Would be up for talking about this if I start a new thread on this topic in the FR18 user group section, squeezy?
-
OK - I'll try to remember to check it ... I've been avoiding those threads like the plague!
And of course I'm not really allowed to post in that one ... as a non user!
-
Possibly this one https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrill_Demian (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrill_Demian). Can't find anything earlier and as the patent was granted it should have been unique. Vienna at the time was really the capital of much of central Europe which is why the patent office was there. From there I suppose you go flutina then melodeon on one strand, EC, anglo bandoneon on another strand.
Steve
By attempting to read that very badly translated account of the first instruments it would seem that Demian's accordion was not designed to play a melody, but that all the buttons (claves?) sound chords not notes. However - it does suggest that the system plays a different note on the push and pull. This would certainly make the name it was given (accord - ion = chord-ion) appropriate.
-
Possibly this one https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrill_Demian (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrill_Demian). Can't find anything earlier and as the patent was granted it should have been unique. Vienna at the time was really the capital of much of central Europe which is why the patent office was there. From there I suppose you go flutina then melodeon on one strand, EC, anglo bandoneon on another strand.
By attempting to read that very badly translated account of the first instruments it would seem that Demian's accordion was not designed to play a melody, but that all the buttons (claves?) sound chords not notes. However - it does suggest that the system plays a different note on the push and pull. This would certainly make the name it was given (accord - ion = chord-ion) appropriate.
I try to give a more accurate translation of how Demian's "Accordion" has been described in the book "Systematische Darstellung der neuesten Fortschritte in den Gewerben und Manufacturen und des gegenwärtigen Zustandes derselben asf." by Ritter von Kess, 1830 (p. 795):
"Steel-Harmonica: Organ- and piano-maker Cyrill Demian and his sons ... were granted a patent on the invention of a new instument, called Accordion, which has the shape of a small box with springs on steel plates including a bellows mounted in it and can comfortably be pouched. On this instrument marches and arias can be played even by ignorants in terms of music after short rehearsal, and the sweetest 3-, 4- or 5-note chords according to the setup of [could be read "after having adapted" as well, but I don't consider this a probable meaning] the instrument."
"Springs on steel plates" is odd, however my understanding of this explanation is that the instrument at least hadn't been restricted to chord playing...
Best wishes - Wolf
edited to add: "after instruction" is thus a clear misreading / mistranslation of "nach der Einrichtung" - "feathers" is of course to be replaced with "springs"..., I didn't consider the Wikipedia translation in any way, just reading it through again now - this is really weird, maybe simply Google? :-[
-
[edited] Found something useful in Philippe Krümm's book - which is pretty well researched. He cites Christian Friedrich Ludwig BUSCHMANN (1805-1864) as developing a number of free reed instruments, notably the first mouth harmonica. There is a. old advert in which these primitives look to be one reed per hole, set out either in chords or as "æolians - the name used in marketing. Continues …
It was again in Germany that the father of the modern diatonic harmonica, a certain "Richter" decided to put 2 reeds per hole, in order to get 2 notes per (?)socket/alvéole, one suck one blow. It's now called the Richter system.
goes on about the celebrated Matthias Hohner (1833-1902) and his Trossingen factory, and taylored assembly lines. But it's mainly about factory organisation. He exported to USA from 1862 and called everything "harmonica" seeding present name confusions I guess. Apparantly it was Sousa's best instument, though he played many! There is en passant reference to "a box of diatonics" but no
date with that. I think it refers to mouth instruments
chapter 2 refers to Vienna's Cyrill Demain (1772-1847) demonstating a small box with bellows, 5 buttons, 5 reeds in May 1829, and cites the asiatic mouth organ is inspiration. It got to Paris the following year. Krümm doesn't know who made the first one there.
There is then a plan of a 5 button bellows instrument
Buttons labelled G/A B/C D/E F#/G C#/D (suck/blow not specified)
This isn't quite diatonic but could be read as a mode of D. Nor modern layout - G changes direction and there is a C
below that some weird layout that I dont understand as chords - or as alternative scales, but there are again 5 groups
ADCF#D. CF#DAF#. ECGCG. GDHCH. DADAF#
v
HDHDG. DDGGH. GHGHD ADACF#. EACGC#
The text references accordéon lessons by M. Reisner in 1834. There is a front page article in music journal "Ménestrel" same year … too small to read I'm afraid.
The next page is all about rivalry between manufacturers. Same year.
-
Those are indeed some strange chords!
It seems at first glance that although these two were inventing away at the same sort of time - the name was coined by Demian but is the name we now use for instruments derived from Richter's system which was the system that Hohner went on to use for both mouth-organs and melodeon type instruments.
-
Pay dirt on page 27 Following her father, accordéoniste Louise Reisner published methods, and sheet music for accordéon, and contributed to the evolution instrument, and perfection ;) of the right end keyboard
There is a shot of a page from her méthode with a (modern) row layout in C (attached)
I find it difficult to tie the scale to the button layout, and the solfage doesn't match the ABs, but it does look diatonic. Louise is said to have dropped accordéon for concertina in 1839, so I guess the books might have been mid 1830s?
[ed] second image is her accordéon … you can see it's been dropped! ;D
-
We could put it this way, couldn't we? The two-row (and of course "international" three-row) quint box and the CBA are the extremes, one fully diatonic, one fully chromatic, whereas the PA, the "Club" melodeon, the semitone-boxes are sort of trade-offs to a smaller or wider extent?
Sorry, I am just catching up on this thread. Intrigued that you see the PA as a trade-off, not fully chromatic equivalent to the CBA. Can you expand on that?
-
Interesting. It seems that bisonoric layouts appeared on melodeons and harmonicas at around the same time (c.1830), although the fact that melodeons were sometimes called harmonicas at that time rather confuses the issue.
-
Sorry, I am just catching up on this thread. Intrigued that you see the PA as a trade-off, not fully chromatic equivalent to the CBA. Can you expand on that?
Not quite - I see the PA as totally "equivalent" to CBA - believe inside they are the same? One set of reeds per voice, one lever and one pallet per chromatic note, per octave? both have stradella at the blunt end?
They differ in what is attached to the lever (PA makers please correct me). In one case a simple button, or same with extend button to facilitate "any key" fingering on a 4 or 5 row
PA "isn't" a piano, but has the sze and to a limited extent extra weight of a mock piano keyboard attached. And instead of one fingering per key you learn 12? Makes no sense to me, but as I said above it might make a lot of sense to a trained pianist.
But all the CBA and 11/12ths of a PA are off topic - not diatonic ;)
-
We could put it this way, couldn't we? The two-row (and of course "international" three-row) quint box and the CBA are the extremes, one fully diatonic, one fully chromatic, whereas the PA, the "Club" melodeon, the semitone-boxes are sort of trade-offs to a smaller or wider extent?
Sorry, I am just catching up on this thread. Intrigued that you see the PA as a trade-off, not fully chromatic equivalent to the CBA. Can you expand on that?
Well, not exactly a trade-off as the PA is preceding the CBA by far to my knowledge. Moreover the PA is of course fully chromatic in terms of completeness (but not accesibility). OTOH the PA is more diatonic than the CBA, requiring instead of one fingering for all the keys (as Chris has correctly been remarking) increasing efforts for playing in flatter or sharper keys, but providing all relatives (modes) of its home key (Cmaj; whereas the CBA has no home key) just on the white keys (with a semitone step following each sequence of - strictly alternating - two or three whole-tone steps).
This doesn't result just in the difference of easy and difficult keys (as opposed to the CBA, which has only medium-hard keys so to speak) but furthermore in the PA reflecting the diatonic roots of melody and harmony in scales, intervals and chords (three major 3rd triads, three minor 3d chords built of white keys, or including one "black" accidental for the keys of Gmaj/Emin resp. Fmaj/Dmin asf.). This includes an intuitive approach to playing music, shared with the melodeon and other "really" diatonic (but however mostly limited then) instruments...
As mentioned in a previous post of mine this is very true and relevant for my playing the (English) concertina, but likewise playing the piano or piano accordion. I've been playing the piano and PA for decades before taking up a melodeon for the first time, and apart from the push/pull thing I was finding the instrument pretty familiar because I was familiar with diatonicly rooted music from my playing the piano keyboard. I can of course understand the attraction of isomorphic layouts as of the CBA or the Hayden duet concertina, but I would most likely be missing something myself when playing such an instrument.
The PA is perfectly diatonic in its home key (Cmaj, Amin asf.), allocating the accidentals just like in our common staff system, adding flats or sharps with every "turn" within the circle of fifths. Maybe the perfect diatonic instrument would be a 20-row quint box (doublications to the same extent as in a 120- resp. 140- button stradella bass system) then, which would of cause be unplayable (for the mouth harmonica the sixfold "Kreuzwender" has treaded that path to some further extent) because of weight and size, even when equipped with a super-clever coupling mechanism...
Personal "practical" conclusion: I would thus prefer the PA to a CBA but a melodeon to a PA, and then choose a two row or three row ("International" or in my more recent case rather "Club") quint layout over a semitone box, thus having just as much diatonic logic as possible as complete (in terms of chromaticism, or full circle of fiths) as possible, but very much preferable in a smaller and lightwheigt box (for partly private reasons) - in short: my newly found Preciosa! (:)
Best wishes - Wolf
-
It seems to me that no one's ever really been able to work out how to extend that underlying musical design philosophy from two to more rows, except by just tacking on other notes nearby, hence the great range of different third row and bass designs.
I think it depends on the style of music. I would say that Tex-Mex, Mexican, and similar musics are as "at home" on their three-rows as we are on two rows. By this, I don't mean just that they are more fluid and amazing on the three-row (though they are) ... I mean that the three row quint is foundational to their music in the way that the two row is to what we talk about. Nobody in conjunto circles is experimenting with an accidental row.
-
It always depends on what style you play, and here we have a nice example of a music style being brought into being be the organology of its instument (as frankly so many are)?
Elsewhere within melodeonism I'd also offer various 1-row traditions, in particular E Anglia, Québecoise, and 'Cajun. All very difficult to achieve on more complex instruments.
Don't get me onto bandonèon and tango … :|glug
-
But ... 11/12ths of a PA are off topic - not diatonic ;)
Shouldn't we rather say 5/12ths? (:)
Would anybody at all even consider to call a PA providing just the other 7/12ths "chromatic"?
-
.
5/12ths when you count piano keys ::)
11/12ths when you count musical keys (:)
-
To me, it doesn't matter much whether an instrument is described as diatonic or chromatic. Is a D/G instrument with a row of accidentals (or even with a few accidentals at the chin end) diatonic or chromatic? Who cares?
It is the bisonoricity of the melodeon that gives it that distinctive exciting sound that makes you want to dance, not whether it is diatonic or chromatic. It is also its bisonoricity (a lovely word!) that, for me, is the key distinguishing feature that sets the melodeon apart from the piano accordion and the CBA.
-
.
5/12ths when you count piano keys ::)
11/12ths when you count musical keys (:)
Touché! :|glug
-
It is the bisonoricity of the melodeon that gives it that distinctive exciting sound that makes you want to dance, not whether it is diatonic or chromatic. It is also its bisonoricity (a lovely word!) that, for me, is the key distinguishing feature that sets the melodeon apart from the piano accordion and the CBA.
Agreed, and I'm loving this word, concept and sound as well. That's partly what has lead me back the melodeon, and my point was rather the features shared by both PA and melodeon apart from bisonoricity.
However, this wide-spreading thread is about diatonicity and how appropriate keyboards had emerged. In this respect it's important to come up against the common equivovation of or at least linkage between bisonoricity and diatonicity in order to at least inquire and elaborate the pros (or cons) of both aspects.
-
Coining a couple more words, the thing that has always struck me as slightly odd about this sort of discussion is that the danceability effect is not related to bisonoricity so much as 'bellocity' - you could achieve just the same effect with a unisonoric instrument if it were also designed to be light and flexible enough to be wobbled about. And conversely, with enough reversal buttons, you can choose whether to wobble or not on a diato at different parts of a tune, a very useful effect. So, why don't unisonoric (non-diato) players try to wobble too, sometimes? (Or perhaps they do? - I've heard this done on a small PA to great effect.)
-
I don't think the kora is particularly relevant, since it has effectively different scales/modes for the two hands - if that parallels anything, it's the semitone box layout.
On the other hand, the hammered dulcimer is a lot more similar, and was popular in the same area as where the bisonoric box originated. The scale splits left/right paralleling the push/pull of the melodeon. Gusikov's "strohfidel" used a similar layout, a diatonic scale split into two columns up the middle with chromatics outlying on the left and right sides:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josef_Gusikov
That dates from the same decade as the first Western free-reeds.
-
Coining a couple more words, the thing that has always struck me as slightly odd about this sort of discussion is that the danceability effect is not related to bisonoricity so much as 'bellocity'
"Bellicousity" in the case of certain parishioners, Chris ;) As for bounce - well, horses for courses I think.
English Country Cancing is unusually bouncy, and frankly our music style suits that. Dutch is quite similar. The other traditions I'm familiar with - Belgian/French bal and a lot of Breton involve more horizontality than here and suits cross finger or CBA play quite well. Even their polka is less rumbustuous (see the videos I did 2 years back (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12880.0.html)). Rondos or mazurkas …'lilt' rather than bounce? Exceptions are perhaps the heartbeat rhythm of bourrée and the Breton Plinn - the latter particularly bouncy ;) - both work well on Accordeon
I did a lot of Eastern European as a lad, and that seems to work really well on CBA - almost what it was made for - lots of harmomonic minor modes. Csárdás is classically really strongly phrased, but like polskas is actually fiddle music.
Sweeping generalisations there I know, but I do feel that 'bounce' is one of the characteristic features of the English style :|glug
-
So, why don't unisonoric (non-diato) players try to wobble too, sometimes? (Or perhaps they do? - I've heard this done on a small PA to great effect.)
Drift drift drift drift ....
One of my favorite Breton players is Patrick Lefevbre, who I wrote about way back in 2011 (time for an undate!)
http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2011/03/tribute-accordeon-gavotte.html
His first disc, Accordeon Gavotte, absolutely floored me. It was so strong, so rhythmic, that it didn't even occur to me that most of the tracks were played on CBA. And some of the instruments had the wettest damn tunings between reeds that I've ever heard ... ssoooooooo delicious.
-
I don't think the kora is particularly relevant, since it has effectively different scales/modes for the two hands - if that parallels anything, it's the semitone box layout.
Well when a group of Ivorian musicians came over to a music venue I was working in about 15 years ago the Kora player was eager to explain his instrument to us and his Kora played a simple major diatonic scale (although not in equal temperament) and the scale ran from hand to hand in just the same way that the two middle rows of buttons on an English concertina play the scale of C. That was the point I was making when I mentioned it earlier in the thread.
I'm not denying that koras might come in a variety of different local tunings and fingerings ... but this one from the Ivory Coast definitely was tuned in that way.
-
On the other hand, the hammered dulcimer is a lot more similar, and was popular in the same area as where the bisonoric box originated. The scale splits left/right paralleling the push/pull of the melodeon. Gusikov's "strohfidel" used a similar layout, a diatonic scale split into two columns up the middle with chromatics outlying on the left and right sides:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josef_Gusikov
That dates from the same decade as the first Western free-reeds.
But this is very useful information to add to the conversation which I'm grateful for. Thanks Jack!
-
The last posts are suggesting another interesting choice: splitting a given diatonic scale into
1. just two equal parts of ascending thirds, major or minor as required, resulting in every new octave starting on a different row (English concertina, and apparently the Kora as well),
2. one part with just the major triad, with the other part having the remaining four notes, sticking with all the octaves to the same row (mouth organ, melodeon, apparently the hammered dulcimer as well).
The difference can thus be located at steps 7 and 8: either continued switching and thus mirroring the octaves, or reversing 7 + 8 by having 7 on the same row as 6 and thus ending with 8 on the row where 1 started the octave, no mirroring.
Small difference, very noticable results...
-
There are bits of useful/interesting information in this article even though it mainly pertains to concertinas http://www.concertina.com/chambers/michaelstein/index.htm (http://www.concertina.com/chambers/michaelstein/index.htm)
Steve
-
As far as I can find (I've time on my hands as I'm sat/laid here with my foot elevated) prior to 1822 everything is very fuzzy. There is basically one set of information of which the following is typical that has been rehashed in slightly different forms but with no supporting evidence -
"The Melodeon was developed from the Harmonica and other primitive free reed instruments early in the 19th century, in the border area between Saxony and Bohemia. The Abbe Georg Josef Vogler had a role in introducing the concept of the free reed principle to Europe and by his death in 1814 many prototype instruments were being made with a variety of names and shapes. The earliest instrument is said to be the Aeolidicon made by Eisenach in Hamburg in 1800. The Harmonica itself is said to have been perfected by Buschmann in 1821."
I cannot find any contemporary documentation or a referenced piece of research to take it any further backwards with any degree of confidence.
Steve
-
.
got an attributable source for that quotation?
-
To me, it doesn't matter much whether an instrument is described as diatonic or chromatic. Is a D/G instrument with a row of accidentals (or even with a few accidentals at the chin end) diatonic or chromatic? Who cares?
It is the bisonoricity of the melodeon that gives it that distinctive exciting sound that makes you want to dance, not whether it is diatonic or chromatic. It is also its bisonoricity (a lovely word!) that, for me, is the key distinguishing feature that sets the melodeon apart from the piano accordion and the CBA
oooh - careful there Bob. There are 2 very similar words in there, which had confused me in the past.
"bisonoric" = the reed makes a different note on push and pull
those might be Bb and F# if you wanted!
"diatonic" = mappable to white notes of a piano, or any other major scale preferred
the "bounce" of a diatonic melodeon certainly gains a lot from bisonoric buttons, but the reason that works so well as music, and especially dance music is that the rows respect the diatonic scale.
And a D/G/accs remains fundamentally diatonic (twice over) and therein much of its strength. I guess you wouldn't be very happy with a D/E harmonic minor/accs box, as is common in the Isère valley?
-
.
got an attributable source for that quotation?
That one's from FARNE, an almost identical quote is on Hobgoblin's intro to squeezeboxes, ditto Rattlejag Morris. This is a more comprehensive version but still low on detailed info http://www.hmtrad.com/sbx-info/sbx-name.html (http://www.hmtrad.com/sbx-info/sbx-name.html)
Steve
-
D/E harmonic minor/accs box, as is common in the Isère valley?
I would love more info on this trend (and a layout diagram if you've got one)!
Perhaps thread drift though (except for the evolution bit)...
Thanks,
Baron
-
I agree with you, Chris, and I was using the terms bisonoric and diatonic exactly as you have described them.
My point was that I believe it to be the bisonoricity of the melodeon rather than its diatonicity that gives the instrument its distinctive bounce. On your C#/D/G boxes and my D/G/acc. boxes, we can both play a complete scale in D and G either in the typical melodeon push-pull manner by playing the scale along the row or or we can the rows to play all the notes in the same direction. When we play along the row, we get a bouncier scale (or tune) than when we play the notes in the same direction by crossing the rows. While I have little experience with concertinas, chromatic button accordions, piano accordions and what-have-you, I believe it to be true that those free-reed instruments that are bisonoric tend to impart 'bounce' into a tune more easily than those that are unisonoric, although I am willing to be corrected by those with wider experience of unisonoric instruments.
I recognise that the degree of 'bounce' imparted is controlled by the bellows and that a good musician can make a unisonoric instrument sound as bouncy as one that is bisonoric, but I would contend that it is easier to impart 'bounce' into a tune on a bisonoric than on a unisonoric instrument and that it is this characteristic, to a greater extent than its diatonicity, that contributes most to the distinctive sound that melodeons make.
-
[Off topic]
Grenoble layout in G/Amharm/accs … transposable toD/Em/accs (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9529.msg118307.html?PHPSESSID=lnjpn3gkosoga8ktgt37es0m81#msg118307), and surprisingly popular in France and Low Countries. Only its G row is diatonic
[/Off topic]
-
Anybody tried a D misheberach/G harmonic minor layout for klezmer?
-
No, but it looks very promissing
-
My point was that I believe it to be the bisonoricity of the melodeon rather than its diatonicity that gives the instrument its distinctive bounce.
I would partially disagree. It is also the layout of the right hand on a single or two row box, with the major chord and triads in the same direction, that makes it bounce. B/C/C# boxes, bandoneons are equally bisonoric but rarely bounce. Part of this is the type of music we play on our boxes. Much of the traditional canon makes use of a simple 3 chord progression which the notes and chords easily fit. When you play music like, say, Andy Cutting's then you lose this bounce, you're playing across the box to make the chords fit, it no longer holds together. Doesn't make it any less valid but it doesn't have the same bounce as a morris jig because the bellows aren't bouncing.
Steve
-
Andy Cutting himself switches to a one-row when he really wants the music to bounce!
-
I think it's a combination of the box and the way we learn. With a bisonoric box you are forced from the start to think about the bellows changing direction from the very first moment you learn to play and you have to keep thinking about the bellows a the time as you progress. So bellows movement are integral to how you learn. In contrast when learning a unisonoric box it is quite possible to play a correct sequence of notes without having to think of the bellows except when you run out of air. As a consequence it is quite possible for the unisonoric player to get well into the learning process without ever having to think about the effect of bellows movement on musical phrasing or rhythmic emphasis. Good unisonoric players do learn to use the bellows musically, but the instrument does not force the player to think about the bellows.
-
I haven't seen anyone mention Gorka Hermosa's book on the organology of free reed instruments, The Accordion in the 19th Century. If I missed it, I apologize.
I write about it here
http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2013/03/accordion-in-19th-century-free-download.html
And the PDF is freely available here
http://gorkahermosa.com/web/img/publicaciones/Hermosa%20-%20The%20accordion%20in%20the%2019th.%20century.pdf
-
It always depends on what style you play, and here we have a nice example of a music style being brought into being be the organology of its instument (as frankly so many are)? Elsewhere within melodeonism I'd also offer various 1-row traditions, in particular E Anglia, Québecoise, and 'Cajun. All very difficult to achieve on more complex instruments.
Came across this nice example (https://youtu.be/ZSCuw4gO19Y) of 'non bounce' play while browsing youtube … yes it is a diatonic machine, albeit played in harmonic minor! (Ruchenitsa rhythm)?
-
It occurred to me that my suggestion for a bisonoric 2-row klezmer layout could be improved a bit.
One row: D misheberach but with a sharpened seventh (in practice this degree is usually mutable between sharp and natural, the original form of misheberach has it natural but that is not very common now). So: D/E, F/G#, A/B, D/C#.
The other row: D freygish, by far the commonest scale in klezmer. D/Eb, F#/G, A/Bb, D/C.
This puts all 12 chromatic degrees into 2 rows, gets the commonest scale on one row and one of the next commonest almost there. And the D and A are replicated, which is probably handy given that the commonest klezmer keys are based on D.
Makes playing in G major (also common) a bit of an adventure, though.
Comments?
-
Posted my kniri Blues box idea before but seems apposite to repeat it here
[tone tone semitone] forever so not 'diatonic' either …
ºG/ºA♠¹Bâ™/¹C ¹C♯/¹E♠¹F/¹F♯ ¹Aâ™/²B♠²B/²C♯ ²Eâ™/E ²F♯/²A♠³A/³B ³C♯/³D
ºEâ™/ºF♯ ºG/¹A ¹B/¹C ¹D/¹E ¹F/¹G ²A/²B♠²C/²D ²Eâ™/²F ²G/²A♠³Bâ™/³C ³Dâ™/³Eâ™
Emphasise - still untested - hope to get it next month some time :|glug
-
Wow, you're going to need a flexible brain for that one, Chris - Good luck with it!
-
Au contraire, old son. I'll be taking it to Adderbury when we meet in October
You are gonna need a flexible brain >:E