Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: ACE on July 20, 2015, 08:54:46 AM
-
I cannot fathom the search bit so could somebody point me to a thread. It is a single row box so it is expected that the occasional note will choke, but this one seem to be permanent, playing at a dusty venue at the weekend so a clean out probably.
-
No reeds should "occasionally choke" on any kind of box. Not if they are set up properly. Dirt is unlikely to be the cause. Dirt can get stuck in reeds but almost always the result is a reed that does not play at all, and is more common on high pitch reeds.
-
Sorry Theo, my A pull reed on the G row (ie 4 buttons in) has choked for some time, but only when I stress it for a loud note, to be fair.
It sounds Neeeooooww- GDUNK-[silence] which is not quite what I'm after, and not what its neighbours can achieve. This only happens in low voicing, suggesting that in LM the other reed stabilises things somehow. Was going to invite you to look at it at Whitby (though could swing by Sunniside when passing)?
-
Sorry Theo, my A pull reed on the G row (ie 4 buttons in) has choked for some time, but only when I stress it for a loud note, to be fair.
It sounds Neeeooooww- GDUNK-[silence] which is not quite what I'm after, and not what its neighbours can achieve. This only happens in low voicing, suggesting that in LM the other reed stabilises things somehow. Was going to invite you to look at it at Whitby (though could swing by Sunniside when passing)?
And as Theo said 'If it were properly set up' it would not happen.
-
There is a small element if compromise in reed setting, someone who usually plays hard and loud will need a slightly different setup from someone who wants the ultimate reed response when playing quietly.
-
There is a small element if compromise in reed setting, someone who usually plays hard and loud will need a slightly different setup from someone who wants the ultimate reed response when playing quietly.
That'll be Chris then... >:E
-
Ah. Perhaps as I give it some wellie some times I should get it 'personalised' . Thanks for the info
-
Choking at high volume is often caused by the gap at the reed tip being a bit too small. I often have to gap reeds a bit large for my tex-mex customers as they play really loud. This will affect the playing at low volumes as the reeds may be slow to sound.
-
There is a small element if compromise in reed setting, someone who usually plays hard and loud will need a slightly different setup from someone who wants the ultimate reed response when playing quietly.
That'll be Chris then... >:E
… Mea culpa :|bl
-
I cannot fathom the search bit so could somebody point me to a thread. It is a single row box so it is expected that the occasional note will choke, but this one seem to be permanent, playing at a dusty venue at the weekend so a clean out probably.
It certainly won't hurt to check it for dirt particles that have gotten lodged in a reed tongue. Sometimes on a PA, a small bit of dust can stop a reed from vibrating. This said, it's also possible that you have a broken reed tongue.