Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Myrrh Music on July 24, 2015, 11:11:11 AM

Title: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Myrrh Music on July 24, 2015, 11:11:11 AM
I have the exact same melodeon as Anahata - but there the similarity ends! I've been meaning to find out this for some time, and as this rain seems set for the day, can any kind person find a minute to please tell me how I know by looking at the sheet of music whether things would sound better with the thirds button up or down?

Thanks very much

Mary
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: george garside on July 24, 2015, 11:31:19 AM
If a tune is in a minor key then 'thirds out' is the order of the day. Other than that sheet music will not provide an answer  and the choice of thirds in or out is entirely down to what you think sounds best/right for a particular tune so its just a question of experimentation.

george
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Myrrh Music on July 24, 2015, 11:37:30 AM
mmm, Thanks,and, running for cover....how do I know if it's in a minor key? :|bl
Mary
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: stevejay on July 24, 2015, 11:58:54 AM
Em is the relative minor of G Major
Am is the relative minor of C Major

I usually count 3 steps back to determine the relative minor of a key.

Although they share the same notes, Am starts on the A of white keys of piano, and C obviously the C

Look for the first and last chord of a tune, it usually tells you the key.

This is a very basic answer, but looking at the first and last chord might be ok for now. This is best explained on a piano keyboard as most theory is.

And if a song sounds sad, it's probably minor.

Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Myrrh Music on July 24, 2015, 12:11:51 PM
Thanks Steve. Well it might be a basic answer to you....! I think it'll have be what sounds best :|glug
Mary
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 24, 2015, 12:17:50 PM
I'm not sure I wholly agree with the thirds out for minor argument.  It certainly avoids having to cross chords in A min, but the D/G box is set up to play in E min if it has the B maj chord rather than B min.  It seems to be a modern concept that minor keys are "sad", an older description was "melancholy" which encompasses a wide range of strong emotions!  Just think of all the Border tunes in minor keys, which are robust rather than sad and benefit from having full triads rather than the rather thin sound with thirds out.  Yes it is largely down to trial and error.

Rob.
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: blue eyed sailor on July 24, 2015, 12:22:57 PM
mmm, Thanks,and, running for cover....how do I know if it's in a minor key? :|bl
Mary

Look first at the last note of the tune, for that is most likely indicating the root note of its key.

Let's say you find an A. So the tune is in the key of A"xy".

Then look at the accidentals (flats or sharps).

If there aren't any, you'll know that you have a tune in a key relative to C maj.

Combining these two pieces of information you have to determine the "distance" between the notes C and A (as Steve is saying: 3 semitones downwards, IOW: 2 steps of the diatonic scale downwards - or 9 semitones / 5 steps upwards: which is the relative minor).

Your tune is in the key of Amin then.

The same applies for other combinations of root notes and accidentals (albeit not always resulting in major or minor, as  there are more "modes" such as dorian and mixolydian - but you can ignore this part for now).

Feel free to ask again!
Best wishes - Wolf
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Myrrh Music on July 24, 2015, 12:28:46 PM
"but you can ignore this part for now".........I certainly will!!

Thanks very much. I shall go and put my thinking cap on and digest everyone's input
 :|||:
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 24, 2015, 12:52:55 PM
Don't competely ignore it, Mary. Major/minorness indeed can be a complicated issue, but is so fundamental to a human being's perception of music that you'd lose something in that.

once you've got this tunes solved, I'd suggest playing up and down a few scales -say G on the inner row. If you can access a piano you can check your note. Play it up and down, feel  its positivity … Then simply play the same scale up and down starting on the next note of pull A … quite different feel?

First big step made.  (:)
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Lester on July 24, 2015, 12:57:16 PM
Play the tune with the thirds in, play the tune with the thirds out, decide which you like, play that one.
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Theo on July 24, 2015, 01:10:02 PM
What Lester  said, but also try playing without any chords, just basses. That will give your music a different feel again, and one which you can switch in and out of whether chords are set to play with thirds or without.
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Myrrh Music on July 24, 2015, 01:15:54 PM
(:)Thanks Chris. I should think experimenting, and playing around generally must yield some interesting stuff, even when one knows their modal from their elbow!

Thank you too, Lester - succinctly put!

Good idea, Theo. If I'm not sure what sounds best I can just play the basses.

Thanks all

Mary
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 24, 2015, 01:24:33 PM
I totally agree with what Lester and Theo have said.

Experiment: try thirds in, no thirds, just basses, no chords/basses at all, etc.  If, on any particular tune, one of those sounds OK to you, then go with it. If something clashes or otherwise sounds 'not quite right', then try switching the thirds stop in or out, and see if you like it better. Despite all the theory of harmony, you are allowed to ignore it: ultimately there are no rules. Do what sounds OK to you.
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: george garside on July 24, 2015, 01:35:12 PM
ear-ear!

g
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: arty on July 24, 2015, 02:18:51 PM
So much about music is about trusting yourself, trusting your ears and having the confidence to be yourself and to play the way you want to play. But sometimes, that is hard.

Theory is about the brain - it's about mathematics, logic, academics - stuff like that.

Music is about the heart and you actually don't need much theory to play beautiful music.

So....follow your heart [and your ears] Mary. That's what I think, for what it's worth.
One player I listen to often on You Tube, is Massimo Craveri. I listen to him because he plays a lot of Stephane Delicq's music and indeed they were friends and played together sometimes, until Stephane died. In a comment under one of his videos, Massimo admits that he can't read music, doesn't know the names of the notes and doesn't even know what notes each button on his accordion plays. But, my goodness, he knows how to play from his heart.
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 24, 2015, 02:22:42 PM
I'd say theory tells you rather more about what doesn't work (perhaps why, if you want to explore that far) than what works. And some of the "what works" can amaze you. eg much Blues

a useful and  "in context" not worker is to play a major 3rd (C# on Amin) over a minor chord with those thirds in. It is diabolical. Whereas, and bizarrely playing a minor 3rd note (C over Amaj) over the major chord "with thirds in" … works!
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Myrrh Music on July 24, 2015, 02:25:42 PM
 (:) Encouraging, Arty. Must have a look at some of his stuff, I must admit I've never heard of him.


Mary

Oh wow, the man's a genius. Such fluidity of tone. 8)
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: arty on July 24, 2015, 02:53:25 PM
This is Massimo's channel page on You Tube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCv3u7rT8YyQSfFoEIXnSZJw

He's not a virtuoso, he's not even brilliant compared with some, but he has a way of communicating [with me], which is in itself quite beautiful. He is like a poet. He is also a romantic, I suspect. And his accordion has become just an extension of him. You can actually feel his love for the music. Enjoy.
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Mike Hirst on July 24, 2015, 02:58:02 PM
Dm is the saddest of all keys "it makes people weep instantly" as is evidenced in this 1984 Nigel Tufnel film clip:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NgViOqGJEvM

Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: arty on July 24, 2015, 03:06:23 PM
And I don't like Eminor - - it gives me the E B G B's  :-[ sorry
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Graham Spencer on July 24, 2015, 04:09:51 PM
And I don't like Eminor - - it gives me the E B G B's  :-[ sorry

Good key for "Too Depressed To Commit Suicide", then..........
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: george garside on July 24, 2015, 04:40:47 PM
Whilst non
t over keen on minor keys I am reasonably happy with tunes that were originally written in a monor key.  I can't say the same for the  transposing of 'major' tunes  in 'minor keys.

Many years ago I attended a workshop, by a then prominent player,   in which we were supposed to develop the ability to play Davy Nick Nack in E minor - it sounded bloody awful!

george
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Pat. on July 24, 2015, 06:36:08 PM
Well said Steve Freereeder,I completely agree ,I am so glad I have absolutely no knowledge of musical theory,what sounds right IS right this is a folk instrument  with limitations that is what is so great abut the melodeon .
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: stevejay on July 24, 2015, 07:03:49 PM
Well said Steve Freereeder,I completely agree ,I am so glad I have absolutely no knowledge of musical theory,what sounds right IS right this is a folk instrument  with limitations that is what is so great abut the melodeon .

Having some theory is very useful. If you're with a guitar player who knows some, all you have to say is

i.e. "iim7 V I"  in key of G - and done, they play it instantly. No it's not an end in itself, but never discount its usefulness. It certainly doesn't hurt to know some theory, but yes the ear is the final judge.
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: GBbox on July 24, 2015, 07:19:24 PM
A musical ear is a gift some lucky people are born with.

The good new for those who aren't is that, with a constant practice, they will be able to build such harmonic ear for themselves.. To use the words a musician with some formal would choose: the ear can be trained.

There are two bad news, though. The first is that it might take some time, eventually years. The second is that, when asking for advice to those who were gifted by an harmonic ear, they will be told to follow that ear you can't trust yet!

If you can afford the cost, try finding a serious teacher. Someone that can not just teach you to read and write music, but will guarantee to teach you the basic rules of harmony as well. The two row melodeon is a simple instrument, and to find a way round to its limitations some music theory knowledge is worth learning.

If you can't, next best, as stevejay suggested, try finding a guitar player to strum along - he'll definitely should be able to show you the difference between a correct and interesting chord progression and the use of the basses as pitched percussions that most melodeon players seems to be satisfied with.


Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: george garside on July 24, 2015, 07:51:43 PM
but how does one define  the so called 'correct' and does it carry the inference that anybody doing it in another way is 'incorrect' even though what they are doing may sound absolutely fine or does that  then by definition become 'correct'

The 'if it sounds right it is right'  brigade  are usually on the right lines but, particularly in the early stages, it can be useful to  seek a second opinion!

george
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: tom f on July 24, 2015, 08:17:25 PM
This is Massimo's channel page on You Tube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCv3u7rT8YyQSfFoEIXnSZJw

He's not a virtuoso, he's not even brilliant compared with some, but he has a way of communicating [with me], which is in itself quite beautiful. He is like a poet. He is also a romantic, I suspect. And his accordion has become just an extension of him. You can actually feel his love for the music. Enjoy.
I think he's a stunning player but I've only just noticed that he plays with a Castagnari duster taped over the treble grill.  Presumably this is to mute the melody side?
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: GBbox on July 24, 2015, 10:03:10 PM
but how does one define  the so called 'correct' and does it carry the inference that anybody doing it in another way is 'incorrect' even though what they are doing may sound absolutely fine or does that  then by definition become 'correct'

The 'if it sounds right it is right'  brigade  are usually on the right lines but, particularly in the early stages, it can be useful to  seek a second opinion!

george

There are usually a number of different chord progressions that you can use with a tune, and that are all correct. In general the choice is a matter of taste, yet on the melodeon some chord progressions simply aren't playable – for instance, on the D/G box you can't play a G chord, that's push only,  when in the melody appears an E note, that's pull only.

Then, there are chord progression that aren't correct – for instance when in an accented position you play a note that is dissonant with the chord, with the obvious exceptions of anticipations and retards, or when a chords doesn't resolve the tension, like ending a major tonal tune on the dominant rather than on the tonic because the melody ends on the fifth of the scale, and so on.

What makes the chord progressions correct or incorrect is the fact that they respect the the rules of harmony or they don't. Telling that the ear should judge isn't wrong in itself, but it assume that one has  a trained ear, and that in fact simply means that he's able to understand when such rules are respected and when they aren't, even if it's not consciously aware of what they dictate.

Now, if I use a past tense when I should use a future tense, probably even someone that can't read nor write could eventually tell me that what I wrote makes no sense. Having learned a bit of grammar helps to understand that the mistakeis  in in the use of a wrong tense, and to tell which is the wrong tense, and which should have been the right one.

What seems good about the melodeon is that when you play a major tonal tune, as far as you keep you left hand on the tonic/dominant bass buttons and play the melody press and draw on one row, you have six chances out of seven not to play a melody note that sounds dissonant with the chords. Than, it's easy to spot when it happens and move to the sub dominant – the C major chord playing in G – or eventually the mediant – the E minor chord playing in D -. 

The problem is that this way the chances you have to play the tonic as a chord  on the fifth degree of the scale in the melody – i.e. to play a G chord on a D note playing in the key of G, or the D major chord on A note in the Key of D -, when in fct you should play the dominant chord, are about the 50%. That way, and there are thousands of examples of it in the YouTube videos, you end up with what a guitar player or a piano player would call an incorrect chords progression. Or, like I prefer to say, you end up using the basses and chords like pitched percussion.

Why this happens? I suppose because those who play that way aren't hearing the dissonance and trust they ear, but unfortunately their ears aren't trained to perceive the development of the progressions, but only the eventual dissonances. 

When I was actively teaching, I used to tell my students – well, those of them who weren't already playing another instrument – they they had chosen probably the worst instrument to train they ears.  Probably they were fed up with it, but they ended up taking care of the harmonic dimension of the music they were playing, not just of the melodic of rhythmic ones.



Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: blue eyed sailor on July 25, 2015, 05:31:56 AM
I widely agree with what GBbox is saying / and as to the matter of thirds it's helpful if one has some understanding, be it implicitly or explicitly, of the nature of the conflict between major and minor, of the concept of "leading tones" with harmonic minor asf. ...

Best wishes - Wolf
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 25, 2015, 09:23:45 AM
Well said Steve Freereeder,I completely agree ,I am so glad I have absolutely no knowledge of musical theory,what sounds right IS right this is a folk instrument  with limitations that is what is so great abut the melodeon .
Thank you for your words of support, Pat.

It's true that one can go a very long way on any instrument (not just the melodeon) without knowing anything about the theory of music, and there are fine players around to demonstrate just that.

BUT - and it's a huge 'but' - in my opinion we have to be very careful about making ignorance of music theory into a virtue. Someone who knows nothing about it is not automatically a better musician than someone who has a degree in music, and vice versa. And even a little theoretical knowledge can bring greater understanding of their music and performance to a 'traditional' musician.

Music comes from the heart. It doesn't matter whether you are a traditional or a classically-trained musician, or what genre of music you are attempting to play, be it an East Anglian schottische or the Bach Goldberg Variations, the music must come from the heart, otherwise it isn't music.
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: arty on July 25, 2015, 09:55:25 AM
Absolutely right Steve.
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: george garside on July 25, 2015, 10:07:27 AM
   
 , the music must come from the heart, otherwise it isn't music.



Steve. that   hits the nail precisely on the head!

george (:)
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on July 25, 2015, 10:59:56 AM
Ditto  ;D
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Ellisteph on July 25, 2015, 12:08:33 PM
Well said Steve Freereeder,I completely agree ,I am so glad I have absolutely no knowledge of musical theory,what sounds right IS right this is a folk instrument  with limitations that is what is so great abut the melodeon .
Thank you for your words of support, Pat.

It's true that one can go a very long way on any instrument (not just the melodeon) without knowing anything about the theory of music, and there are fine players around to demonstrate just that.

BUT - and it's a huge 'but' - in my opinion we have to be very careful about making ignorance of music theory into a virtue. Someone who knows nothing about it is not automatically a better musician than someone who has a degree in music, and vice versa. And even a little theoretical knowledge can bring greater understanding of their music and performance to a 'traditional' musician.

Music comes from the heart. It doesn't matter whether you are a traditional or a classically-trained musician, or what genre of music you are attempting to play, be it an East Anglian schottische or the Bach Goldberg Variations, the music must come from the heart, otherwise it isn't music.
Absolute agreement.Most of us who can learn tunes by ear will get the odd bit wrong now & again - this is point at which looking at the music can put us back on track. Similarly, playing  from the dots is a very worthwhile skill,but not so impressive if you can't play without the music in front of you - only when you have learnt it can you start to include your own subtle interpretation. Doing a bit of both is the answer!
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: george garside on July 25, 2015, 12:17:02 PM
At what point does ''getting the odd bit wrong''  become a new ''arrangement''?. 


george  ;D
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: GBbox on July 25, 2015, 12:20:22 PM
Well said Steve Freereeder,I completely agree ,I am so glad I have absolutely no knowledge of musical theory,what sounds right IS right this is a folk instrument  with limitations that is what is so great abut the melodeon .
Thank you for your words of support, Pat.

It's true that one can go a very long way on any instrument (not just the melodeon) without knowing anything about the theory of music, and there are fine players around to demonstrate just that.

BUT - and it's a huge 'but' - in my opinion we have to be very careful about making ignorance of music theory into a virtue. Someone who knows nothing about it is not automatically a better musician than someone who has a degree in music, and vice versa. And even a little theoretical knowledge can bring greater understanding of their music and performance to a 'traditional' musician.

Music comes from the heart. It doesn't matter whether you are a traditional or a classically-trained musician, or what genre of music you are attempting to play, be it an East Anglian schottische or the Bach Goldberg Variations, the music must come from the heart, otherwise it isn't music.

At a glance, I thought we were saying the same things in a different way. Yet, reading it carefully, I'm not sure about it.

The music theory doesn't necessarily come before the music, although of course it influences the writers and the performers. It's just a way to record what sounds good and what not. And obviously, for those who haven't been gifted with a natural musical ear, it offers the tools to build it.

Yet, there's more about it. The musical contest we live in influences us all beyond our perception, and that's plain to see especially when we try to escape from it.

Let's take, for instance, the idea the the dominant chord resolves on the tonic chord because its third, the so called sensible, in the scale is a half tone below the tonic. For the western classical music theory that's an undisputed truth, and if you say that it's just bullshit (a splendid English word that I adopted a number of years ago after an interview with Paul James) any musician with a formal tuition will call you an erethic (anarchist, communist, no global... love the Logical Song!).

Yet, anybody who has played a bit of modal music, and in particular the minor sounding modes where the seventh degrees of the scales aren't sharpened to make them sensible as the classically trained musicians do with the thirds of the dominant chords in the minor tonal scales (eventually finding the need to sharpen the third in the sub dominant chord as well), can actually state that there is no scientific evidence of the pretended attraction of the sensible toward the tonic.

What actually happens is that almost all the music we hear since we're born – if not, according to a number of recent serious studies, since we are in our mother's womb – is based on the dominant vs tonic attraction convention. The so called natural music ear is just the fruit of this osmothical and unconscious process of assimilation, and cannot bring anything else than its the imprinting.

The problems start when someone without a natural musical ear nor any kind of formal tuition teaches himself to play a musical instrument. In this case the melodeon, given its limitation, is the worst choice. At least, with a piano accordeon, you can try any chord progression you like...

Of course I agree the we can have a competent, or even a virtuoso player, that sound sterile because  his music dosen't come, to use your own words, “from the hearth”. Yet at the same time I can't help remembering that, at least in the classical western orchestral music, where the real interpreter is reputed to be the conductor, this is seen as a as virtue even for the soloist. The music theory awarness and the emotional approach are both crucial in a musical performance, but to me they really seem totally unrelated.
 
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: george garside on July 25, 2015, 12:38:55 PM
 one definition of an orchestra is ' a bloody great musical instrument played by a conductor'!

george >:E

Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on July 25, 2015, 04:15:13 PM
As an example. Faure's Requiem. Two different conductors, two completely different adaptations, two totally different sounding music. Q.E.D.  >:E
Title: Re: Showing my ignorance again....
Post by: playandteach on July 25, 2015, 11:16:43 PM
As an example. Faure's Requiem. Two different conductors, two completely different adaptations, two totally different sounding music. Q.E.D.  >:E
Can't help but put in a vote for the orchestra. Most conductors in truth add little. There are notable exceptions of course. but the combined experience and skill of the players (also the collective experience of working with great conductors and amalgamating their contributions) can form a better interpretation.
Stand up in front of the Philharmonia with a Brahms symphony on the stands, and say go. Sit back and enjoy.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal