Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Sebastian on May 20, 2009, 07:38:22 AM
-
Hi.
Some months ago I got a two-row melodeon, but never really started to play. That is, I don't have a book for learning nor did I venture to look for melodeon players in my region nor did I do much of anything with the box, because normally I prefer a conc***** to it. Now, some days ago, I saw a piece on Youtube, Flatworld, which made me think: Wow, you would do be able to play this on a melodeon.
Well, so I did this video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EqLDAzaksPw). But, never having seen any melodeon player in reality (well, at least not since I left childhood) I would appreciate comments/critique about:
- how to hold the box,
- should the right hand be more flat to the grove on the side,
- sholud the left hand strap be less tight,
- should the basses be played more lightly,
- and other things I should improve on.
Danke! (:)
-
Really excellent! I would suggest that you keep on playing just as you are. There are no hard and fast rules - its what works that matters and the way you play really works so well done. Maybe slightly heavy on the bass buttons but hey, you want to see the way I play them! ;D
AL
-
you want to see the way I play them!
I do want to, indeed. :P
It didn't escape me that most players use shoulder straps even for the small two-row boxes. I tried them and for bigger boxes they may be helpful, but I don't like to be harnessed. Are there any videos from players who use the thumb strap instead, so that I can see how they hold and handle the instrument?
-
It didn't escape me that most players use shoulder straps even for the small two-row boxes. I tried them and for bigger boxes they may be helpful, but I don't like to be harnessed. Are there any videos from players who use the thumb strap instead, so that I can see how they hold and handle the instrument?
Nobody that I know uses a thumb strap, probably because it can restrict the movement of the fingers up and down the keyboard. Those, like me, who don't like to be harnessed tend to use a single strap on the right shoulder, which provides control without the feeling of being in a straight jacket.
-
I agree a thumb strap would be very limiting. I use a single strap, and allows me enough control, and to play sitting and standing. Without it I think you would struggle with bellow control.
I dont like the idea of the two straps, but the more I get into it the more I think it would allow me even greater freedom with the right hand, so I may try that in the near future.
-
I used to use a thumb strap, but cured myself of it over an extended period of time. It severely restricts agility.
I think that two straps is not particularly cumbersome and it does increase your ability to move your hand up the treble end and gives a lot more support overall.
-
I use the thumbstrap on my 2 row quint boxes - but the move to BCC# is changing all that. I'm starting to go strapless a lot more often!
;)
-
It was much more common in the old days, however many Irish one-row players use the thumb strap. e.g Bobby Gardiner.
East Anglian musician Oscar Woods used a thumb strap.
Older Cajun musicians used it and so do many modern players.
-
I use the thumbstrap on my 2 row quint boxes - but the move to BCC# is changing all that. I'm starting to go strapless a lot more often!
;)
Yes, I have a Club accordion with shoulderstraps which I tried to play a few times. But even though the Club system is really interesting and I should like it more, playing the little Viennese is more fun. I suppose I didn't yet reach the point where the music would force such complicated moves of the right hand, that the thumbstrap would be a hinderance.
:D
many Irish one-row players use the thumb strap. e.g Bobby Gardiner.
East Anglian musician Oscar Woods used a thumb strap.
Older Cajun musicians used it and so do many modern players.
Thank you, I will search for them on Youtube.
(:)
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHOVnFLOV4 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHOVnFLOV4)
and
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CoeG2-ZKLBQ (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CoeG2-ZKLBQ)
Links to Bobby Gardiner.
-
Idi Amin (see elsewhere) used a thumbstrap, so that has just put me off .... ..
-
Idi Amin (see elsewhere) used a thumbstrap, so that has just put me off .... ..
Did he play melodeon? Gosh, I should return to my irenic little 'tina. ;)
-
Idi Amin (see elsewhere) used a thumbstrap, so that has just put me off .... ..
Did he play melodeon? Gosh, I should return to my irenic little 'tina. ;)
He did, you can hear it here (http://www.klezmusic.com/sbx-info/sbx-fame.html#amin)
-
Idi Amin (see elsewhere) used a thumbstrap, so that has just put me off .... ..
Did he play melodeon? Gosh, I should return to my irenic little 'tina.
He did, you can hear it here
Let's face it - he was pants - thumbstrap or no thumbstrap!
AL
-
he was pants - thumbstrap or no thumbstrap!
AL
Would you have told him tho, Al....
Baz
-
Given the man's tendency towards murder and mayhem the answer is probably no, not to his face - I might have sent him an email though ;D
AL
-
Maybe everyone told him his playing was pants and he took slight umbridge.
-
no excuse - my folk are always telling me what a rubbish player I am, but I don't let that affect me...much >:E