Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: HallelujahAl on May 20, 2009, 08:00:48 AM
-
Hi - does anyone have a preferred rh fingering method for BCC#. At the moment my fingers are just playing whatever notes come to hand (pun not intended). Is there a preferred fingering method for scales etc? Since I don't have a tutor book (come on George!) I'm just making it up as I go along - I need someone to bring some order into my BCC' life ;D
If anyone has any suggestions I'd really appreciate it. Dots or diagrams would also be really helpful.
AL
-
eagerly watching this one..... ;)
-
eagerly watching this one.....
Wouldn't hold your breath ;)
AL
-
I don't have a preferred fingering for the BCC# system. It really depends on what you find easiest for a given tune and what effect you hope to achieve as a result of more or less bellows waggling.
Unlike the melodeon, where what chords you want in the bass dictate which row a particular note is played on, a BCC# with stradella bass doesn't have this characteristic. As a result you can do what you want on either end without if affecting the other.
The best bet would be to probably take something, eg a scale and work out all the different ways you can play it. Then have a go at them all and see which ones feels most comfortable. You can see the layout from John Kirkpatrick's website. I think it's somewhere under the "writings" section.
-
Well you've already taken a step in the right direction by signing up for my workshop ;D :||: ???
There is no written rules with how the fingers should be used. But Shand had the right idea by keeping everyone guessing. B/C/C# boxes can be played with minimumuminimumum (too late at night to spell) effort with maximum impact. Having a huge range of notes in such a small area, all being in the right place! As long as the fingers know where those places are.
Try playing kate dalrymple in G on the middle row. You probably know already you can play whole tune without moving any fingers. Then start to use the doubles. You will find your own personal path choice. If your fingers are in a twist use the bellows & vicey versai!
If George is listening...Need a hand with that book?
Cheers
Graeme
-
>>Try playing kate dalrymple in G on the middle row. You probably know already you can play whole tune without moving any fingers. Then start to use the doubles. You will find your own personal path choice. If your fingers are in a twist use the bellows & vicey versai!>>
Ah, tried playing Kate Dalrymple last night in A - fingers got into a total mess - never the same way twice! Will try it in G later today.
btw any news on that Gaelic?
Thanks AL :)
-
Well you've already taken a step in the right direction by signing up for my workshop ;D :||: ???
There is no written rules with how the fingers should be used. But Shand had the right idea by keeping everyone guessing. B/C/C# boxes can be played with minimumuminimumum (too late at night to spell) effort with maximum impact. Having a huge range of notes in such a small area, all being in the right place! As long as the fingers know
If George is listening...Need a hand with that book?
Cheers
Graeme
cheers graeme willbe in touch
george
-
Surely the best fingering for a B/C/C# is typing
FOR SALE
into Ebay ;D
-
Surely the best fingering for a B/C/C# is typing
FOR SALE
into Ebay
LOL ... walked straight into that one! :D
AL
-
Perhaps a better question may be concerning scale patterns? Any suggestions for preferred routes on the BCC# - just for starters - obviously the doubles will come in later on?
Another thing I've noticed from watching carefully on YouTube both Graeme Mackay and Graham Irvine is that only the first three fingers of the right hand seem to be used - very rarely does the little finger seem to come into play - is this so? Obviously whether one uses the little finger or not would affect how you progress up and down the fingerboard?
AL
-
the simple answer to this is that many tunes can be played with 3 fingers & some players use this technique most of the time, however the little finger is not to be ignored & can be very useful for certain bits of certain tunes! Probably not a very helpful answer but thats the way it goes i.e. use whatever technique enables you to play 'that particular bit' with least effort be it 2, 3 or 4 fingers.
george
-
the simple answer to this is that many tunes can be played with 3 fingers & some players use this technique most of the time, however the little finger is not to be ignored & can be very useful for certain bits of certain tunes! Probably not a very helpful answer but thats the way it goes i.e. use whatever technique enables you to play 'that particular bit' with least effort be it 2, 3 or 4 fingers.
george
So, let me get this right then...there's no answer, just make it up as you go along working out what best for you? No system, no preferred technique, not even a preferred way of playing scales and arpeggios? Now I know why there's no book for the instrument - cos you'd certainly save the rainforest with that manual.
Ok I'll carry on regardless!
AL (:)
-
So, let me get this right then...there's no answer, just make it up as you go along working out what best for you? No system, no preferred technique, not even a preferred way of playing scales and arpeggios? Now I know why there's no book for the instrument - cos you'd certainly save the rainforest with that manual.
Ok I'll carry on regardless!
AL (:)
Oh, I love this forum! Informative friendly advice, that even though it may sound bizarre, is actually SO Right! :D :D :D
Skipy
-
I'll tell you at the workshop ;)
-
I'll tell you at the workshop
Looking forward to it. I find that I'm using my little finger a lot on the right hand - and concerned that I may be storing up problems for the future?
AL (:)
-
It never caused me any problems but you might find deliberately restricting yourself to three fingers useful as a practice technique to make you think harder about where you're going to find that next note and how you're going to finger it. Then try two, then just one. Then when you go back to four fingers try playing a RH chord with every note of the tune etc.
-
It's good that you are using your little finger! It's hard enough only having 4 to work with.
Don't worry about the future. Live for today man!!!
-
I would have thought that the key would be to have versatility in the amount of fingers that you use. So using four is good, but not if you can't get by with three if needs be. If you want to do complex harmony and chords then you will need your fingers working as efficiently as possible. I am a great believer in using the 5th finger on my box, just because it means that the range is a lot better and that your second finger can double stop a lot more easily.
/uninformed claptrap
-
I can't see how making a conscious effort to use only 3 fingers would be of any benefit. It's like learning to walk using only one leg.
You may as well use what you have in away that you find easiest.
-
I agree. Use all the fingers available to make efficient use of your keyboard and bellows. Always cross over your fingers rather than use the same one twice. It all depends on which tune you are playing in the end of the day. What is easy for your fingers creates work for your bellows and vice versa. Find a happy medium and stick to it.
-
Always cross over your fingers rather than use the same one twice.
That's very helpful Graeme, thanks.
AL
-
Got it!! ...........finger knitting :o
-
Finger knitting??? Maybe I should attach wool to my fingers and sell jumpers at the end of my gigs.
-
I think you are searching in the wrong place. It's not the fingering that's a problem, it's in the brain.
B/C/C# - tain't natural I say ???
-
Ah, tried playing Kate Dalrymple last night in A - fingers got into a total mess - never the same way twice! Will try it in G later today.
Thanks AL :)
How about singing it ?? (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lKmPxLkSqv8)
-
I think you are searching in the wrong place. It's not the fingering that's a problem, it's in the brain.
B/C/C# - tain't natural I say ???
But its much more logical than say a DG plus row of odds & sods or diving all over the place on an ADG in the hpe of finding enough half notes , accidentals, black notes or whatevr you want to call them to enable you to play in 12 major keys. 5 scales will do the trick. Also you have a logical and sensibly placed range of altrnative notes enabling you to come or go at will!
Its also has the benefit of a standard keybourd layout which means once you can play one you can play any BCC# box. The really diabolical contraptions are the 2.5 or 3 row DG etc boxes with the accidentals and low notes arranged to suite one individuals preference making it very difficult for any othr buggr to get the best out of it.
george ;)
-
B/C/C#-best keyboard layout in the world. everything you need, where and when you need it.
-
Both George and Graeme are obviously affectionardo's of the B/C/C# system. I've just visited an old post (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,176.0.html) and note that you, George, recommend starting with B/C. I still thinks it'aint natural but I'm not close minded about anything. I do have a five row C griff box which seemed on paper to be very sensible, but I do struggle with it. I would be interested in you compare and contrast opinions between the two systems. Not only do I find the logic weird but I find the playing to have less bounce than a quint box. I hope you can convince me enough to give it a serious try, and if I do how strong is the argument for beginning on B/C rather than having an additional C# row?
If I'm persuaded, does anyone have a set of B/C reed blocks for an Erica?
-
B/C/C#-best keyboard layout in the world. everything you need, where and when you need it.
I totally agree - 'cept my fingers are still learning their way round :D
-
If I'm persuaded, does anyone have a set of B/C reed blocks for an Erica?
No, but I've just taken a B/C Double Ray in part-ex. As new condition, red pearl finish: £295.
-
Well B/C gives you the chromtatic keyboard, as does C/C#.
By putting them together there is much more possibilities to explore ie harmonies, chords and akward keys that can be accessed easily simply by changing rows.
example: bagpipe music is all written in A. So we learn the tunes in A which is sensible (flattening the G where relevant). Bagpipes play in the key of Bb (providing they are in tune). Now it takes a good musician to transpose on any instrument, but we can cheat. Simply by using the same fingering as A, on the inside row, we can use the same techniques without having to use our brains. Before anyone gives bagpipes the boot, this can be the same for playing with brass or for singers and with ANY type of music. I use mine along with a wedding band, playing from soul, to rock & roll with a bit of ceilidh in the middle even giving the odd instumental blues solo.
You don't have to lose the dynamics that you get from a quint box. if you wanted to go in and out on every note you can. But you have the option to make things efficient and smooth when you need to. Giving more control on volume and air quantities.
I find B/C/C# very natural indeed. Once you find your path round the keys, anything is possible.
-
I do have a five row C griff box
5 row C griff box? Is that a strange name for a chromatic accordion?
-
5 row C griff box? Is that a strange name for a chromatic accordion?
Yes. I've heard them called all sorts of things, CBA, Continental C system, Continental B system, B griff etc.
-
Both George and Graeme are obviously affectionardo's of the B/C/C# system. I've just visited an old post (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,176.0.html) and note that you, George, recommend starting with B/C. I still thinks it'aint natural but I'm not close minded about anything. I do have a five row C griff box which seemed on paper to be very sensible, but I do struggle with it. I would be interested in you compare and contrast opinions between the two systems. Not only do I find the logic weird but I find the playing to have less bounce than a quint box. I hope you can convince me enough to give it a serious try, and if I do how strong is the argument for beginning on B/C rather than having an additional C# row?
If I'm persuaded, does anyone have a set of B/C reed blocks for an Erica?
not so much starting with a BC box unless you already have one or can pick one up cheaply as starting by learning to play the BCC# using initially only the B&C rows. The reason for this is because, as greme has outlined, you can then nip over onto the CC# rows for those strange flat keys. Once the 2 row playing, be it on a 2 or 3 row box,is mastered you have the chromatic range available . At around this point you can start learning the various aadvaantages of the wide choice of note directions with regard to bellows control , phrasing & dynamics the key to this being to thoroughly learn where & in which direction each note is situated.
On the other hand if you learn the BCC# from the start on 3 rows you are likely to have more difficulty playing on just 2 rows and hence playing in the less used keys. You may also tend to go too much for long runs in 1 direction which can result in difficulty with bellows control. I am of course only talking about the initial learning period ( which is about as long as a pice of string!) after which you should be able to sort out a system that suits you & the music you want to play.
The 5 ( or 3 or 4) row continental chromatic is a different beast altogether with one note per button , To my way of thinking they are far more sensible than a piano keybord as an octave is much more compact & therefore right hand chords are much easier to play. IN effect they have all the black & white notes of a piano accordion but rearranged into circular(ish) patterns. The 3 outside rows are all you need the inside 2 ( on a 5 row) being repeats of the outside 2 rows. Very sensible machines but much closer to the piano box than to any of the push/pull jobs which all have a sort of random built in bounce.
Several people on this forum have suggested that the BC(C#) etc boxes lack the bounce of the 4th apart boxes. I find this a bit contradictory as many 4th aprt players then go to enormous lengths to cross rows in order to smooth things out! All push pull boxes have a random bounce whther played on the row or accross the rows. This is simply because , depending on the tune being played, some notes MUST be changed on the bellows, some on the button and some either way at the choice of the driver.
george
-
starting by learning to play the BCC# using initially only the B&C rows
George this sounds like good advice, but how the deuce do you play in A? I seem to be permanently challenged in the air department.
Mike
-
not so much starting with a BC box unless you already have one or can pick one up cheaply as starting by learning to play the BCC# using initially only the B&C rows. The reason for this is because, as greme has outlined, you can then nip over onto the CC# rows for those strange flat keys.
Good advice - I've just been playing a loda of tunes this evening in Ab Major. Four flats is dead easy using CC# rows! I can't do that on either of my quint boxes. In a way I wish I'd started on BC(C#) and not gone via the D/G route. But no major regrets!
AL
-
starting by learning to play the BCC# using initially only the B&C rows
George this sounds like good advice, but how the deuce do you play in A? I seem to be permanently challenged in the air department.
Mike
most problems playing in A arise from using too many pull notes resulting in the bellows going ever outwards and then being difficult to bring back. You have on the BC rows b & e in both directions - try using the push b & e as the notes of choice so to speak. You may even find that by doing this you have to use the air button to open the bellows a bit! There will be situations where the pull b or e make more sense but be very aware that you have both available on the push as using them more or less equalises the amount of push/pull (depending of course on the tune!) As an exercise in the use of the push b&e when playing in A tMy Home, cock of the north and harvest home in A using the push b & e. Even using full bass you should not need to open bellows more than 6 -8 inches with fairly minimal use of air button. Using just the B &C rows of course!
george
-
more or less equalises the amount of push/pull (depending of course on the tune!) As an exercise in the use of the push b&e when playing in A My Home
George
Just had a crack at MyHome in A, phew its a bit tricky. Am I missing something? It seemed easier to play it in E? I accidentally found that I was playing in E not deliberately. The more I fiddle about with this thing the more interesting it becomes. I wish that I had found it 40 years ago (or 50 years ago).
Mike
-
Forgive me if you only have a 2 row. But if it's 3 don't forget G# & C# have push notes on the inside row.
The more you play the B/C/C# the more your explore it. You really never finish learning new things. Thats one of the reasons I love it so much and have never really learned any other instrument on the same level.
In the end of the day you will find your own path round the keyboard. Keep at it.
-
Just had a crack at MyHome in A, phew its a bit tricky. Am I missing something? It seemed easier to play it in E? I accidentally found that I was playing in E not deliberately. The more I fiddle about with this thing the more interesting it becomes. I wish that I had found it 40 years ago (or 50 years ago).
Mike
I would echo your sentiment Mike - but its real fun isn't it? I'm just enjoying playing music in keys that I'd never thought possible before now. Even though my efforts are pretty poor I'm getting such pleasure from that fact alone at the moment. But yes, I do tend to find my fingers in a bit of a tangle when trying to play in A. As Graeme says, its remembering the alternative notes on the inside row. Wish you were coming to the workshop as I'm guessing that we're at about the same stage with things.
AL
-
see posting under events - whitby folk week with regard to BCC#
george
-
I've been playing Cara Mia on the BCC# today and it's really good for helping to learn the way around in G as it also modulates and couple of times and throws in a couple of eb's and some C minor chords. It is also a really nice song, if like me a little dated :D
If anyone wants a copy I have it on pdf. File is just too large to insert in here at about 330kb. So pm with email if you would like a copy.
AL