Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Pierre B on August 20, 2015, 10:13:07 PM

Title: Learning curve
Post by: Pierre B on August 20, 2015, 10:13:07 PM
Hi to all,
I started 2 row accordion a few years ago. I have a B/C for Irish and A/D for the rest. I'm wondering how long it takes to play Irish with an Irish feel, since I didn't grow up in that culture. I think it's easier to me to play French waltz or Breton tunes. But Irish tunes are... almost some kind of arcane music. I know I have to listen to Irish musicians, what I do. But when, for instance, I listen to Sharon Shannon or Anette Owens, I will die before I get to that level.

Thank you and happy boxing
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: gettabettabox on August 20, 2015, 11:00:19 PM
the B/C box is a great instrument, but can prove difficult for some to master. well worth it if you persevere, but time can be a consideration!
the C+/D system might be less of a struggle, complementing your existing skills on the A/D.
i'm guessing that you've already tried some irish tunes on your D row? if not, give it a go.
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: deltasalmon on August 20, 2015, 11:21:50 PM
I second the C#/D suggestion as a lot of tunes will carry over between the A/D and C#/D. I guess technically you could say the same about a B/C and G/C but playing Irish music in D on a B/C not many at all will carry over to the G/C.

I have a C#/D for Irish and a G/C for other types of music but I would happily trade that if I could find an A/D available.
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: Pierre B on August 21, 2015, 02:07:06 AM
Thanks for you suggestions, but first I don't feel for changing to another system; second, I don't have the money for a third box. Moreover, the B/C allow me to play any chromatic tunes (B row and C row = respectively black keys and white keys on the piano). I even have the blue note  ;).

deltasalmon,
I'm sure you know The Button Box. That's where I traded for my B/C. They may have an A/D.
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: Stiamh on August 21, 2015, 03:01:49 AM
My take on it, Pierre, is that you can't learn either Irish music or the B/C system part-time. Especially as an adult beginner. Both are complex systems.

To get to what I would consider an acceptable level with Irish music - on any instrument - you have to devote yourself to it seriously. As an adult beginner I would say you have to devote yourself to it pretty well exclusively (by which I mean play only Irish music), and for quite a number of years.

Exactly the same could be said about the B/C accordion.

You are asking about getting proficient at two complex systems. It's a tough assignment. I don't think one can do it and dabble in other musics, other systems, and other instruments at the same time.  :|glug

Edited to add: When I took up the C#/D (which by the way is just as "chromatic" as the B/C) at about the same age as you, I knew Irish music very well already. I had played it on fiddle and whistle to a pretty decent standard for over 25 years. So I knew the repertoire, I knew the language, I knew what it was supposed to sound like. It took me several years of hard work - practising many hours a week - to get to anything approaching an acceptable level on the box. Now after 11 years I'm still just OK at it.

You did ask.  (:)
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: Vector on August 21, 2015, 05:16:40 AM
I really have enjoyed taking up the B/C - I stumbled upon it because it was the first Irish box I was able to find - I'm glad I went B/C because many of my musical heros are B/C players and it helps to watch and emulate their playing.

To me, the Irish sound is kind of like a dialect - if you did not grow up immersed in it, you are never going to be able to fully emulate it - I kind of sound Irish in my playing, but I know that I'll never be fully authentic, and I'm OK with that - I admire and respect the sound and try my best - but it's like how we each speak English with a dialect - it would be silly to try to affect a dialect - I just try to be me.

I am influenced by the music and players I listen to but I know no one is ever going to confuse me for one of my heros -

I have found the B/C system to be very easy to learn if you don't over think it - to me it's just muscle memory. When I was getting started I worked scales a lot and that helped. I also don't try to play too many different tunes - probably less than 100 - the tunes I play I practice really really hard to build up the muscle memory.

Someday I hope to have the opportunity to study the C#/D system. I think it would be fun to find the benefits of each system and use them to the best results - I like the B/C system because I have the opportunity to play in the same direction so much - my mentor lectures me against "chucking the box" he frequently points out phrases that I am playing that are not as smooth because I'm not taking advantage of the B or E in the same direction of the other notes in the phrase. I would imagine the C#/D system has something similar -

In my experience I did not have a very long learning curve because I mainly learn tunes from the dots. I start slow with a tune and build it up to speed. It's tempting to want to work on tons of tunes but I just stick to learning a half dozen or so at a time and really getting them engrained into muscle memory so I can play the tune well. Once I have it down I'll look a another tune to add to the repertoire but not before -

Listen to great box players for inspiration but don't hold yourself to their level - work on your own tune to get it to a level that you are happy with and then try to find opportunities to play with others.
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: 911377brian on August 21, 2015, 08:11:10 AM
Vector, you say you can play around 100 tunes. Respect! I've been playing for over two years and am just about competent with around 20 :-[ ...on a good day and a following wind..
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: gettabettabox on August 21, 2015, 08:23:56 AM
stick at it and welcome to the quest.   (:)

the music doesn't give itself up easily, particularly the ''pulse'' that you hear good players generate.
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: Vector on August 21, 2015, 05:16:05 PM
Vector, you say you can play around 100 tunes. Respect! I've been playing for over two years and am just about competent with around 20 :-[ ...on a good day and a following wind..

ha ha! considering I've been playing since 2007 isn't that impressive - :)
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: Pierre B on August 21, 2015, 06:39:40 PM
I know this is a difficult music. That I need to devote hours and hours to it. I don't aim to be professional, but to have a decent play. I'm working on "Apples in winter" for many months now (Damien Connolly B/C method) and I start to be comfortable with it.

I prefer playing well just 2 or 3 tunes than 10 badly. Since I also love French music, can't put it down. So, I decided to learn both system.
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: Stiamh on August 21, 2015, 08:39:35 PM
Well once you have set the parameters (in your case two systems, at least two kinds of music) I suppose it's a matter of expectations, of setting your goals according to what seems possible (given your aptitude and the time you have available). You may need to adjust your goals as you go along in the cold light of progress - I think few of us ever get to where we would really like to be.

If you are enjoying the journey, then your original question (how long...) is irrelevant, isn't it? In any case each person's answer will depend on what they would consider an "Irish feel" so it's an unanswerable question. Maybe it's like that old saying, "if you have to ask the price, you can't afford it." If you have to ask "how long", you will not like the answer...

So, as others have said, keep at it.  :|glug

@Vector - "re. studying the C#/D system" I see B/C and C#/D as the same instrument, each played with certain scales more frequently than others. You certainly don't need to get a box tuned to the other system to experiment, unless maybe you are cursed with perfect pitch.

At some point, in my view anyway, every C#/D player needs to learn to play fluently in E major and F# minor (D maj and E minor fingering for you fellas) and every B/C player would benefit from learning to play in F major (G major for us girls) - and even D minor and C major (our E minor and D major). I took a B/C class once and the tutor introduced a simple waltz tune in C major and I was amazed to realize that most of the students - supposedly intermediate - were lost looking for the tune on the row.

Our "magic notes" on C#/D are F# and C# and are extremely useful. I can understand your mentor's noticing that you aren't using yours to the full!
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: boxer on August 21, 2015, 09:56:14 PM
You can only play Irish tunes well when you've overcome the irregular and uneven dynamics of the B/C system, to the extent that you can stress or not stress any note or notes you choose, anywhere in any bar of the tune, and create phrases, without having to think about how you're going to do it.

I suppose the same principle applies to other instruments and other traditions too, but few realistic combinations present as many challenges as playing Irish tunes on B/C box.  However, few offer as many rewards, so you might as well make a start straight away.

Good luck 

 

Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: butimba on August 21, 2015, 10:37:52 PM
I prefer playing well just 2 or 3 tunes than 10 badly.

I just wanted to say a small hooray for this  (:)
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: george garside on August 22, 2015, 08:33:36 AM
  , to the extent that you can stress or not stress any note or notes you choose, anywhere in any bar of the tune, and create phrases, without having to think about how you're going to do it.

I

Surely that is an essential skill or a vital' learning aim' for the playing  of any type of box and any musical genre

george
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: blue eyed sailor on August 22, 2015, 08:59:16 AM
  , to the extent that you can stress or not stress any note or notes you choose, anywhere in any bar of the tune, and create phrases, without having to think about how you're going to do it.

Surely that is an essential skill or a vital' learning aim' for the playing  of any type of box and any musical genre

george

I seemed to understand that boxer was stressing "the irregular and uneven dynamics of the B/C system" too, as opposed both to a C#/D for playing Irish and a fourth-apart box in its favourite keys... with no playing on the rows at all and reversals required for notes which you wouldn't want to accent... And hence the huge reward in overcoming that...

Best wishes - Wolf
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: george garside on August 22, 2015, 11:55:41 AM
playing on the row on a Dg  or whatever results in a lot more reversals of notes you don't want to accent than on a BC using both rows.  Indeed reversals are an integral part of any ''diatonic'' box  and developing fine bellows control is the answer to aavoiding  irregular and uneven dynamics.

The sensible answer for those who find smoothing reversals a problem is to go over to a continental B or C system  -- but then it wouldn't be half as much fun!

george ;)
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: gettabettabox on August 22, 2015, 12:55:02 PM
'tis true there are reversals when playing ''on the row''....but if playing in the home key of that row, then emphasis is more intuitive as the tune's dominant notes usually fall on the push. i guess this is why the single row ''gift'' melodeons were so popular. ie. easier to play and not forgetting cheap of course.  (:)
(''gift'' as in a present, or school prize.)
Title: Re: Learning curve
Post by: boxer on August 22, 2015, 05:10:17 PM
Thank you Wolf for your acute observation.

I think that the particular demands of Irish tunes and the limited bass arrangement of the B/C box means that the player has to be more resourceful in creating stresses at points within the "smooth" parts of the scales of the fiddle keys as they fall on B/C treble keyboard, than would need to be the case when playing tunes from other genres on a fifth-tuned box with a useful bass array.

That good bellows control is a prerequisite of a decent performance on any box obviously goes without saying. 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal