Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: paulq on May 20, 2009, 03:50:24 PM

Title: how fast?
Post by: paulq on May 20, 2009, 03:50:24 PM
There's lots of talk about speed at sessions on the Forum, but having gone to my first ever session last night, I'd like to know, how fast IS fast? Take Morpeth Rant for instance (which a fiddler did last night, so fast I didn't recognize it until the second time round). What's a good speed for that in a session? These guys were taking it at over 100 bpm / minim. Any thoughts?
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: xgx on May 20, 2009, 04:08:02 PM
It's OK for them... they don't have to listen :P :|||:

some folks grow out of the 'boy racer'  bit, others grow into it ::)

much prefer 'steady' and enjoy the listening bit (even when I'm playing :D)
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 20, 2009, 04:36:08 PM
There is no standard speed for any tune: some people play them fast and some play them slowly. Personally, I prefer most tunes on the slow side so that you can get more expression into them and there is more room for ornamentation. When people play tunes too fast in sessions they usually lose the feel of the tune. If you start a tune at a given speed, others (if they are polite) should join in at that speed and follow your lead. However, some try to speed things up. When that happens, I just bellow "Steady" as loud as I can then follow it up with a dazzling smile to soften the effect a little.  :D
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Lester on May 20, 2009, 04:52:31 PM
There is no standard speed for any tune: some people play them fast and some play them slowly. Personally, I prefer most tunes on the slow side so that you can get more expression into them and there is more room for ornamentation. When people play tunes too fast in sessions they usually lose the feel of the tune. If you start a tune at a given speed, others (if they are polite) should join in at that speed and follow your lead. However, some try to speed things up. When that happens, I just bellow "Steady" as loud as I can then follow it up with a dazzling smile to soften the effect a little.  :D

Wish I had written this, in fact I would have done if Bob had not beaten me to it!
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Owen Woods on May 20, 2009, 05:02:55 PM
Morpeth Rant needs to go at a decent lick, 100 bpm is probably about right imo.

Different tunes need to go at different speeds. A lot of the scottish and irish tunes that we play sound best speeded up. A lot of the English tunes sound best at a much more sedate pace. People get a little uncomfortable when I play tunes slow though :(
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Sandy on May 20, 2009, 06:00:07 PM
I like to sip my wine, not down it in one!!! Trouble is, I think the adrenalin kicks in sometimes and people start tunes faster than they intend. It's one of the things that puts me off. I don't like the thought of competing with musicians and am not confident enough to go and blast something out.

cheers

Sandy (:)
p.s. slight cross-thread here, but I sometimes play a very slow 'Jump at the Sun' with a few jazz chords and i think manage to make the tune sound quite sleazy!!! (Apologies to John Kirkpatrick!).
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: TomB-R on May 20, 2009, 06:09:46 PM
It's a big issue with sound comments made already.

One thing that does bug me a little tiny bit  ::) is when people say they "prefer" to play stuff slowly or steadily, when the truth is, they can't play it faster (or play it well any faster.)
"Prefer" implies a real choice!

PLaying fast can be great fun, playing steady can be fantastic. Diffrent strokes...

BUT the person who starts the tune gets to choose!!!!!! It is extremely bad manners and poor musicianship to speed up someone else's set.
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: paulq on May 20, 2009, 06:51:00 PM
I think (as a drummer as well as a melodeon player) I'm looking for some way of putting a figure on what sort of speed to aim for in practicing a tune, once you've got the basic thing. In sessions it's not really connected with the speed people would dance, is it? Knowing that 100 bpm for Morpeth rant is a "resonable lick" is actually quite helpful, at least you know what to get your fingers round. I got the Nick Barber books with the cd and the speed things are recorded at there sound lovely but bear noooooo relation to how fast people play them in sessions.
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: xgx on May 20, 2009, 06:55:01 PM
It's a big issue with sound comments made already.

Big Issue.... is that an advert :P ;D

One thing that does bug me a little tiny bit  ::) is when people say they "prefer" to play stuff slowly or steadily, when the truth is, they can't play it faster (or play it well any faster.)
"Prefer" implies a real choice!

One tiny thing that has been known to bug me ... folks who purport to 'know' and under the influence of that delusion, indulge themselves in an unjustifiable, sweeping generalisation ....

I just hope Dentists don't make the same mistake ;D ;D ;D


 
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Owen Woods on May 20, 2009, 08:17:08 PM
I like to sip my wine, not down it in one!!! Trouble is, I think the adrenalin kicks in sometimes and people start tunes faster than they intend. It's one of the things that puts me off. I don't like the thought of competing with musicians and am not confident enough to go and blast something out.

cheers

Sandy (:)
p.s. slight cross-thread here, but I sometimes play a very slow 'Jump at the Sun' with a few jazz chords and i think manage to make the tune sound quite sleazy!!! (Apologies to John Kirkpatrick!).


Oh God, yes. Last term I started a set of reels significantly faster than I could physically play it  :-\ I was shattered by the end of it. I also tend to speed up if I'm nervous, which is NEVER good.
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: HallelujahAl on May 20, 2009, 08:48:46 PM
Yes, speed can be quite an issue in sessions. Personally I never take it and I find I play much more sedately as a result. I have been known to mess up my keys completely, however, I just call it jazz then.
 ;D
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: rees on May 20, 2009, 08:57:53 PM
I like to sip my wine, not down it in one!!! Trouble is, I think the adrenalin kicks in sometimes and people start tunes faster than they intend. It's one of the things that puts me off. I don't like the thought of competing with musicians and am not confident enough to go and blast something out.
Oh God, yes. Last term I started a set of reels significantly faster than I could physically play it  :-\ I was shattered by the end of it. I also tend to speed up if I'm nervous, which is NEVER good.



Aye, adrenalin - best drug known to humankind and others, but it has been the death of many a good tune, to be sure, to be sure.

You know that moment in a session when you are just about to kick off a tune? Stop, take a breath (chill out grandad, as I'm often being told) and set a steady tempo going in your head. Then ease out the clutch on the old melodeon and off you go - works every time, but it only works if you remember to do it.

Chances are that while you are taking a breath, some other speed merchant will hurtle in and destroy Walter Bulwer's No.2.
Be patient. You may have to sit through half a dozen of these insensitive manglings of our heritage but eventually someone will leave a big enough gap for you to make your stately entrance.

Chances are that while you waited it out through this musical desert you will have forgotten what you were going to play.
Be patient. Drink more beer and eventually none of it will matter until the next morning.

Be patient - hangovers are not just for Christmas, y'know.  ;)

Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Theo on May 20, 2009, 10:45:32 PM
There's lots of talk about speed at sessions on the Forum, but having gone to my first ever session last night, I'd like to know, how fast IS fast? Take Morpeth Rant for instance (which a fiddler did last night, so fast I didn't recognize it until the second time round). What's a good speed for that in a session? These guys were taking it at over 100 bpm / minim. Any thoughts?

Clearly that speed was too fast for that fiddler to play that tune.  A really good player can play fast and keep the tune recognisable, and have a good swing.  Of course a really good player may choose not to play so fast.

Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: theSmoiler on May 20, 2009, 10:58:54 PM

One thing that does bug me a little tiny bit  ::) is when people say they "prefer" to play stuff slowly or steadily, when the truth is, they can't play it faster (or play it well any faster.)


He hummm!! isn't it true that it is actually MORE DIFFICULT to play a tune more slowly/ steadily? IMO, too-fast playing can be the mark of the inexperienced/ less experienced player...often because nerves at starting a tune almost invariably mean you start it faster than you meant too (and then get 'hoisted by your own petard' when the quicker or more difficult bits come along), and, because playing fast allows you to skip loads of the notes out of the tune (cf how it would be written down to be played) and to mask the execution of difficult sections - such as 'runs' which tend to speed up, triplets, etc., - in the general noise produced. Just listen to a lot of the fast - but not very proficient - players of Irish reels, for instance, to see what I mean. Often, nobody cares in that instance - it's just perceived, by the pub audience, as background, drinking music. So, the more noise and speed the better, without discernment.

Whereas playing at a more reasonable tempo means you can't skip notes, or be 'muddy' with your phrasing and timing. And, because so many of the tunes we play (particularly from the English repertoire) are still essentially DANCE tunes (composed as such) then, whether in a session or at a dance, playing them without a semblance of the intended tempo, without the phrasing and timing which gives them their quintessential rhythm and 'bounce', and without the 'spaces' at the end of phrases, which help to sustain that rhythm and timing, is not the mark of someone who can play well!

Give me 'The Steamboat', 'Gloucester HP' or 'Jack Robinson's' played at the delicious speed of someone like the Old Swan Band - when you can inject real 'swing' into the tunes, and really make them rock! - anyday, than people charging through such tunes without a hint of feeling or passion for what they are playing...! (IMO)

Diane (who prefers to play tunes at a steady, danceable pace - out of CHOICE).  
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Sandy on May 20, 2009, 11:28:07 PM



[/quote]

Then ease out the clutch on the old melodeon and off you go - works every time, but it only works if you remember to do it.

[/quote]

I've often thought that the air button on the melodeon is like a clutch on the motorbike.....it's control of smoothness and acceleration as required!!

cheers
Sandy (:)
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 20, 2009, 11:38:20 PM
Morepeth Rant needs to be played fast enough to be interesting and just slow enough not to break the dancers' ankles when doing the rant step!  >:E
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: TomB-R on May 20, 2009, 11:43:38 PM
It's a big issue with sound comments made already.

Big Issue.... is that an advert :P ;D

One thing that does bug me a little tiny bit  ::) is when people say they "prefer" to play stuff slowly or steadily, when the truth is, they can't play it faster (or play it well any faster.)
"Prefer" implies a real choice!

One tiny thing that has been known to bug me ... folks who purport to 'know' and under the influence of that delusion, indulge themselves in an unjustifiable, sweeping generalisation ....

I just hope Dentists don't make the same mistake ;D ;D ;D


I think you've got me wrong there oldsoke.  No generalisation was intended and I'm sorry if my post wasn't clear. I'm talking about specific instances in my own experience where people have said they "prefer" to play slowly when I know they didn't actually have a choice.  I'm happy to know and play with plenty of players who can go at a hell of a lick when the mood takes them, or the dance requires it, but who genuinely enjoy playing at a steadier tempo of their own choice.

Diane - Yes I totally agree with what you say, no problem.

Tom



Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: xgx on May 21, 2009, 12:06:12 AM
Rees
Brilliant comments and pespective.... more beer and wider roads ;)

Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Owen Woods on May 21, 2009, 12:31:57 AM
I would concur that playing slowly is often more difficult than playing fast. That was one of the shocks of playing Morris. You can get away with such a lot if you play fast, but if you play slow every inaccuracy, every slip and every hesitation seems to be magnified a hundredfold :-/
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: ganderbox on May 21, 2009, 10:57:08 AM
There's probably no real set speed for most tunes, and it can be quite interesting experimenting with playing them fast or slow, or changing the rhythm slightly eg slowing a reel down and adding swing to turn it into a hornpipe.
The main thing is to be mindful of what you are playing it for. If its for a dance, it needs to be the right speed for the dance eg we play Balquider Lasses quite slow for our morris side, but much faster when we play it with the ceilidh band (and even then, the best ceilidh speed varies with the audience)
If you are playing it at a session and there are inexperienced players there, it is only polite to play the tunes they might know at a slow enough speed for them to join in. You can always speed it up the last couple of times through and hopefully keep everyone happy. On the other hand, if it is one of those sessions where all the players (and the audience) like fast, driving tunes, it's best to keep the pace up.
It's all a case of what seems right at the time.
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Scallyanglo on May 21, 2009, 11:00:25 AM
Rees
Brilliant comments and perspective.... more beer and wider roads ;)

I agree on all counts! Also wondering whether it's such a good idea to bike to Bampton on Monday  ::)

This is a really interesting & useful thread for English session newbies. Swing & timing. When practising, I visualise my own personal morris side dancing in the back garden  ;D Better than a metronome - can get a bit distracting though . . . .
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: george garside on May 21, 2009, 03:07:24 PM
for those who prefer sessions to be at a reasonable pace   I will be doing 2 lead sessions at Whitby Folk Week in august¨¨Well known tunes at a steady pace giving eveybody a chance to join in¨ probably in middle earth pub but not absolutely sure of venue at this stage

george
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: rees on May 21, 2009, 07:26:11 PM
............................ but not absolutely sure of venue at this stage

george

or do you mean "not absolutely sure of stage at this venue" - some of them can be a bit wobbly.
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 21, 2009, 09:44:04 PM
Hope to see you there George - I'll try not to stab folks in the eye with my fiddle-bow this year. I'm not sure whether my box playing is even up to "gentle" standard yet.
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: IanD on May 24, 2009, 01:30:36 PM
Morepeth Rant needs to be played fast enough to be interesting and just slow enough not to break the dancers' ankles when doing the rant step!  >:E

According to Gordon (Potts) it depends whether you're playing for Northern-style (faster) or Southern-style (slower) ranting at a dance -- we've never been able to agree which way to play it, which is one reason we don't.

Or you can slow it down to around 80bpm and play it as a skanky back-beat dotted hop-step, add a "chang-a" rhythm guitar, get some New Orleans funeral procession horn riffs into it...

I'd say there's no one correct speed to play any tune, it all depends what you want to do with it :-)

Ian
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: baz parkes on May 24, 2009, 05:59:10 PM
[it depends whether you're playing for Northern-style (faster) or Southern-style (slower) ranting at a dance -- we've never been able to agree which way to play it, which is one reason we don't.

Ian

Same here...tho it is a lovely tuhe....

Baz
with his ABU hat on
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Hello on May 25, 2009, 04:46:41 PM
Absolutely as fast as possible. But make sure you leave enough tempo to be able to accelerate though the tune.
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: IanD on May 25, 2009, 04:49:24 PM
Rees
Brilliant comments and perspective.... more beer and wider roads ;)

I agree on all counts! Also wondering whether it's such a good idea to bike to Bampton on Monday  ::)

This is a really interesting & useful thread for English session newbies. Swing & timing. When practising, I visualise my own personal morris side dancing in the back garden  ;D Better than a metronome - can get a bit distracting though . . . .

Surely that depends on the sex of the imaginary morris side? And what (if anything) they're wearing?

Gives terms like "swing" and "bounce" a whole new meaning...

Ian
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 03, 2009, 11:56:36 AM
Strange...

When I play for North West Morris, I always play the intro a little on the slow side - the band and dancers always come in faster than whatever I play!  For Border, the band step to keep to a good steady lope.

In sessions, I've always been accused of playing too loud and too fast.  When transcribing a tune and playing back on midi, I've found that most tunes sound best at dance speed which , curiously, is around the speed of your heartbeat.  That probably explains why the adrenalinde rush makes us start off too fast.  Certainly when a nervous newcomer starts a tune in sessions, it can help to join in as smoothly and steadily as possible, maybe even pulling the tempo down a bit.  The clue is the slightly unrythmic start.

Rob.
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Lester on June 03, 2009, 12:59:48 PM
In sessions, I've always been accused of playing too loud and too fast. 

Rob

You play too loud and too fast in sessions!    ;D
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 07, 2009, 11:32:14 AM
Thanks, Lester.  I knew you wouldn't let me down!

Rob.
Title: Re: how fast?
Post by: Malcolm Austen on June 08, 2009, 08:47:56 AM
How Fast?
I have to go with Lester there, no offence Rob but Rob you could equally say that it should be faster than me.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal