Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: up-fiddler on September 22, 2015, 06:14:23 PM
-
I have always been handy with tools. (I have a well-equipped 26x30 woodworking shop.) I would really like to get more involved with box repair and maintenance. The only problem is that all my melodeons are rather nice vintage boxes. As such, when I have needed work done on them I have mailed them out. (Kudos to Scott Bellinger, by the way.) I need a box or two to use as a means to begin learning. This leads me to a couple questions:
1. Can I get an old or new Erica case and buy bellows, mechanisms, and reed blocks and hope to make a great sounding/playing box?
2. To what model Hohner would the Supertone be comparable? I have one that was given to me a while back. (I am at camp so no pictures at the moment but I can get something posted this weekend.)
3. What common pitfalls should I be alert to avoid?
Thanks in advance for your responses.
Dave
-
Dave-
Erica, Pokerwork, Pressedwood and other Hohner derivatives are good to start on. Robust mechanics and available parts help. I would avoid longplate instruments and Hohner 3 or 4 stop single rows as the reed work is more difficult. I have 10 parts boxes and 40 or more instruments in the restoration queue so maybe I can help you out. Your Supertone may also be a good place to start depending on how late it was made.
If you are traveling east please stop by and we can put together a 'mettler's starter kit'. You are also welcome to steal shamelessly (ideas at least;) from my restoration/tuning shop.
Scott
BellingersButtonBoxes.com (http://BellingersButtonBoxes.com)
ps Thanks for the Kudos
-
Thanks for the offer, Scott. I think I will head east for the squeeze in this year. Perhaps I can add your shop to the list of places to drop in.
The kudos are earned. My Tommy, the little Corso, and the ancient Hohner club are the only boxes I play now. You restored all three of those instruments and they are a true joy to play and hear. My chemnitzer, the Corona II, the Morse anglo, and the newish Weltmeister sit sad on the shelf. :(
Thanks again,
Dave
-
1. Can I get an old or new Erica case and buy bellows, mechanisms, and reed blocks and hope to make a great sounding/playing box?
Just get an old Hohner two row, or perhaps a two voice club and take it to bits and repair it. You should not need to buy any major new parts unless you are unlucky. Bellows can be repaired, mechanisms usually need little more than cleaning and the occasional new spring, reed blocks sometimes need woodwork repairs, and reeds need cleaning, re-valving and re-waxing. With your experience and facilities you should be able to tackle all of that.
-
Thanks for the info and vote of confidence, Theo. I think I will give the Supertone a go. I know - from past failures - that the most important thing is generally to go slow and steady. I tend to research rather thoroughly before starting. I am not a "dive in and break it" kind of guy. Thanks again,
Dave
-
Yes, an old Hohner is good. I paid £100 for an oldish Erica and annoyingly it's the box I play more than my Pariselle and my Baffetti etc. It has a great sound.
-
Hi Dave, for what its worth, I have just finished a full refurb of a Hohner Pressed Wood Key CF, including removal / clean reeds, revalve and rewax, reface pallets, new reed valves, adjust action and restrict button movement (buttons disappearing down holes in keyboard) action now fast, repair and taping bellows, build tuning rig, retune all reeds to concert pitch - dedic demi swing or thereabouts. The most important thing - before starting - lots of reading and research to gather info how to do the work, all info on the internet, especially melnet (fantastic resource) and utube. Very enjoyable project and surprisingly successful, the box sounds and looks great. Previous experience - just a bit of melodeon tuning and building a number of classical guitars and lots of guitar maintenance refrets setups etc and reasonably good craft skills. Tip - instrument tuner apps available for android tablets, look for one that will measure pitch in cents ie 1/100th of a tone.
Have fun.
-
Android tuner apps... Which ones would you recommend?
-
Android tuner apps... Which ones would you recommend?
I use the Peterson iStroboSoft Tuner
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.istrobosoft.tuner&hl=en
-
Peterson strobosoft is the bee's knees. Well worth the cost.
-
Thanks Lester and Theo. If you two use the Peterson iStrobe then it comes with stellar recommendations. For $10 it is inexpensive also. I will install it on the ipad right away.
Thanks again,
Dave
-
Peterson strobosoft is the bee's knees. Well worth the cost.
I also have a set of finely tuned bee's knees for final tuning :)
-
Do they look like this?
-
Surely 33.333333% elbows ? ;)
Without that front pair we'd all have to have screwed/pinned on gasket reedplates :(
-
I guess the straight answer to the original question is that you can buy just abour every component for an Erica from stock and put them together - they will all fit. Guaranteed that will get you a better box than the Chinese assembly plant but at twice the price! There are still many improvements to be made to get a real great action and fine sounding box, but your experience and thorough methodical approach should stand you in good stead to achieve most of these. The first tuning attempt could have a few failures, requiring a new reed plate or two - overtuning can ruin the tone of the note produced as you're constantly thinning the reed and you may be tempted to get the final tuning done by someone with more expertise.
Most people go the route of renovating and refurbing where possible. It's cheaper and some of the components were better made in past years. So long as you're not hurried to have the finished box in your hands and can afford to stop to enquire and take advice you should get there.
Rob.
P.S. Going back over my mistypes, I wonder whether anyone knows how to improve the computer keyboard action?
-
Thanks, Rob.
Yes, the more I read and check the more that the advice from you, Theo, and others rings true. I have picked up a couple old Supertones to begin. I also have a full set of reeds from an unknown diatonic that was given to me. I think I will begin with them and then move on to the Supertones. That will get me going without fear of damaging a fine instrument. Thanks also for the offer of future advise. This forum is a Godsend for folks like me that live near the middle of nowhere.
Regards,
Dave