Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: melodeon on November 18, 2015, 03:46:28 PM

Title: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 18, 2015, 03:46:28 PM
For those of you who play, or have some knowledge, what third row system is currently being used by Euro/French players.

I am aware that there is a Heim System, which I believe is the Castganari "default" system, but yet there are three known Heim systems.

I have searched on Mel Net for historical postings on this subject and also this

http://www.geocities.ws/kozulich/3rowGC.html#fh

Is there a preferred system for Trad French and  also "modern" playing style?

Would it help if I were to name some players who use the G/C/Acc ?

Thanks

PS..
Almost makes you want to get a few 2 rows in various keys!
Or get a couple Morys.. G/C and A/D....

Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: James R on November 18, 2015, 06:07:17 PM
There are of course a variety of different systems as you seem to have already found. I'm not entirely sure on what most players play - a lot seem to have their own systems! I do happen to have a copy of Pascale Rubens' (half of Naragonia) layout on my computer, this seems to be designed to allow all notes in the keys of G and C in both directions whilst offering a range of accidentals on the push and pull. If you've ever seen Naragonia's tunebooks, you'll realise that this box layout seems to cope with almost any key thrown at it!

You can find the layout here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6IuFYCgS2IRM1NQZGlPeGxUMDQ/view?usp=sharing (https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6IuFYCgS2IRM1NQZGlPeGxUMDQ/view?usp=sharing)
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 18, 2015, 06:46:28 PM
Thanks, I had no familiarity with Pascale Reubens.
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 18, 2015, 09:01:05 PM
Large numbers in Rhône Alpes (southeast), and fewer elsewhere in France, and a surprising number in Belgium use Milleret/Pignol (G, A harmonic minor, accs). You can even order it from Castagnari

All systems are compromises and if you want reversed outer row tonic/9th you cannot have full chromaticity. The Naragonia one above "Dutch inverts" that plate on inner row - a very logical and efficient decision, but a pig to "unlearn" all your known tunes practiced previously on standard diatonic. I lasted about 7 months … but inversion plus lots of accs is probably optimal :|glug
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 19, 2015, 01:00:21 AM
Chris,

What system do you favor and is the MAS Bas system bas(s)akwards ?  not to mention the switch to go free reed ....

What dio you think fo the MAS.

I am considering a G/C Acc   either Handry 12/ Handry 18  or the MAS..
but having spent more time than I would like researching and analyzing the 3 row systems I am about to commit to my third Mory.

Any comments abot the MAS, presuming bandoneon treble side in GC Acc.

Also, any comments about the Van Der Aa  boxes ?
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 19, 2015, 01:34:38 AM
I am considering a G/C Acc   either Hascy 12/ Hascy 18  or the MAS..
but having spent more time than I would like researching and analyzing the 3 row systems I am about to commit to my third Mory.

Jeff, as you will doubtless have realised, there are various G/C/acc layouts around, each with their proponents, strengths and weaknesses. With a Handry layout having a full-length third row, there is a lot of potential usable flexibility simply because there are so many buttons available. However, with a Mory, having only 5 buttons on the inner row, I believe the choice of layout/tuning is more critical because it needs to maximise the usefulness to the individual player, depending on what their style of music is.

A year ago, I also committed to my third Mory. My half-row layout has a Dutch reversal on the middle button and logical accidentals for a D/G box on either side. It is a modification of the old Castagnari factory layout and I find it works well for me on a D/G box. See attached layout plan. It ought to be good transposed for a G/C instrument too, although it is probably slightly biased to playing more at the chin end (like a D/G) rather than at the floor end (like a G/C). 
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 19, 2015, 03:13:51 AM
Thanks Steve.

I have owned two Morys  both GC  both stove stock with whatever Castagnari supplied.

I sold both ( in a fit of poverty)  not allowing enough time to explore their keyboards.

I am wanting some chromaticism and wanting to play a variety of styles.

For the last few weeks I have considered a half step box,  but GC Acc still keeps coming back to me .

With the confusion of too many GC  Acc systems, particularly in three row..
I once again began thinking Mory.. simpler and lots of great music has been made on these ie Markku Lepisto.

Then my mind has wandered again back to half step mostly because I do not want to make a mistake and commit a considerable amount of money to a GC Acc system which may prove to be not to my liking or ability.


Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Chris Brimley on November 19, 2015, 10:18:29 AM
I think we may all be having some difficulty responding on this one because there aren't all that many 3-rowers around, and because for those that do have them, I think we generally find that we use some of the buttons only rarely, and therefore it's not in practice all that easy to compare alternatives - there's a lot of uncharted territory in this.  I'm not familiar with any of the Heim, Castagnari, or Milleret/Pignol layouts - mine was a logical extension of the Cutting Salterelle 14-bass DGAcc Tramontane layout, to an 18-bass FR18.  It's the inner row on the basses that's particularly uncharted territory, and is wide open to disagreements based on playing style.

I entirely agree with those who say if you're going to have a third Acc row it might as well be a full one - it doesn't add anything to the LHS weight per se.  This can be seen in terms of simple note availability, but after experience you will find how really useful it is to have reversals of certain notes to improve playing style, feel, and bellows direction issues.  This is a huge and often under-recognised benefit of having big boxes.  To illustrate this in practice, I have recently recently been relearning Atholl Highlanders (an Ama tune) on my DGAcc layout boxes.  I needed to incorporate some sections of push, because there was too much pull for even playing.  To do this, I had to search the tune for convenient sections where I could play push passages on both RH and LH sides.  The result was much more satisfying to play.  It might even be useful to have another (fourth) row of accidentals and reversals to make this process even easier, but I digress.

It's also necessary to consider LH and RH layouts together - it's only of limited use to have lots of chords that don't match the RHS 'accidental' note direction availability.  You will find that 'the best is the enemy of the good' here - if you have a box designed to be able to play anything in any key, it will not be easy or versatile to play in the home keys, I'm afraid.  IMO it's best to consider a box that allows smooth, sensitive and nicely harmonised playing in the home keys - so it should be possible to throw in some major or flat seventh RHS chords, for example, in those keys.  If you want to play in very different keys, you need another box.

Maybe now's the time to throw in a plug for the FR18?  Many people rightly criticise it's sound, but if you had one, you can change layouts to your heart's content, and change key mid-playing to whatever you want.  And at around £800 for a second-hand one, what's not to like about that?  I'd even go so far as to say that if you're looking to buy a proper expensive box, buying a FR18 to experiment on first would be a good option.  What I do is to use the acoustic boxes for most tunes in mainly home keys, but swap to the FR18 for occasional tunes in weird keys, putting up with the rubbish sound and calling it 'variety'.

Here's my FR18 layout in DGAcc for what it's worth, which obviously you'll need to transpose to GCAcc:


                    Ama/Ema   A/E      Dma/Ama    D/A         Gma/Dma      G/D   
Basses:
                 Bbma/Fma  Bb/F      Bma/Emi      B/E         Cma/Cma      C/C   

                   Fma/Ebma  F/Eb    F#mi/C#ma F#/C#    Ebma/Abma   Eb/Ab





The three rows:

   Bb/Ab  C/Bb   E/D     Eb/F     Bb/Ab   C/Bb     E/D       Eb/F   Bb/Ab    C/Bb   E/D    Eb/F

D/A   G/C      B/E      D/F#   G/A       B/C      D/E       G/F#      B/A     D/C     G/E     B/F#    D/A

   D/G     F#/B    A/C#     D/E      F#/G     A/B     D/C#      F#/E    A/G      D/B    F#/C#   A/E

I hope this is of some help.
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 19, 2015, 10:46:46 AM
re Melodeon's questions. I played a Casta Mas about 6 years back and it is essentially Grenoble system with different voicing. So that row based on A harmonic minor means you no longer play "in C" along the row. You have to borrow a G from outer row and avoid the G#

But no one in Grenoble plays on the row! A GCaccs Mas would be played on the pull in A - be that Am, dorian, major, myxolydian, blues, or exotics like Am-dorian#4; with various melodic minor modes for impro. Stéph/Norbert actually play CFaccs - it comes out in D and most of their tunes are in that key

Their 18 bass, first realised by Gaillard is quite glorious. We argue here about pros and cons of various 12 chord systems, but they aren't that! A couple of chords are both ways (now 9-10?) and the rest play only in one direction. Grenoble/Mas bass only tries for 12 real chords, the rest are extra/reversed basses

Now the bass sets the "mode" of a line of music (real "perception" this time) and this means that you can play in the mode you want whether the rt end line is on push or pull 8). As ever, in the melodeonic mix, audience then perceive chords that aren't actually there.

van der Aa stuff is great, and subject to continuous inprovement, but Gaillards obsessive nature makes his kit "prefect. Frans did put that 18 bass in for me, think it was his first. Also the Gaillard "gulps like a whale" air hole. Another big issue if you play mostly on the pull. The Aire&Geste DVD is about that.

Not sure this appies to a Mory. I had one and it is essentially a 2 rows with lots of accs and reversed notes. Full three row play is very different as you can play in any key (Ab is a pig on mine) It becomes a matter of practicing them  ::)
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Roger Howard on November 19, 2015, 11:05:42 AM
For what it's worth (if only for ease of reference for you), I've attached a pdf of the Milleret-Pignol layout that I have on my Serafini:

I agree with Chris Brimley that some of the notes on the third row are not used all that often (though I'm getting to use more of them), and this is the only three row I've played, so I can't make any comparisons. I do have a Loffet 2.6 row, though, and I find I'm playing it less and less since I got the Serafini (nearly a year ago). It's a three voice instrument, and I like the different sounds it offers, but the Serafini's flexibility seems to win most of the time. Also, as a two voice box, it's lighter and smaller than the Loffet - I'm a big fan of it now, and haven't found it too difficult to switch between the standard G/C layout and the M-P. Mind you, I don't have the repertoire (or skill) of the others who've commented.

Best wishes for your choice

Roger

Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Chris Brimley on November 19, 2015, 12:34:13 PM
Chris R and I have different approaches to our playing, I think.  Chris, is it right to characterise your and the 'French' concept as playing largely on the pull, and using your knowledge of music to allow improvisation in different modes?  Mine is essentially an extension of the original two row quint box concept, and I suppose I'm thinking in chords and therefore intervals, which may be on push or pull.  Also, I'm always conscious of bellows direction and dynamics in my playing - trying to mix up or add to the different legato and 'bouncy' feels that are inherent in the feel of airs versus dance music, as and when I feel it necessary.  This is important in the context of keyboard design because it is related to the use of reversed notes, which I find I do more and more.

To me there are various issues, which, knowing what I do now, I could have recognised when I started on my particular 3-row musical path.  It seems to me that the original quint box concept is useful for folk music, because it is a fundamental basis to which a player can return while playing,  and so my idea was to extend that.  The most important first directions to go in are undoubtedly to add the notes you don't have as accidentals, and to allow 'proper' playing of many home key tunes that you might like to be playable on a two-row 8-bass, but actually aren't.  I used to feel really embarrassed because I simply couldn't play my pokerwork (even with end-row accidentals) with other instruments without leaving out the accompaniment - the notes and chords just weren't there, so how could I consider myself the player of a proper musical instrument?  Perhaps the next stage is to add playability - allowing the dynamics of the instrument to work better, and then the next one after that is to add the subtler chords.  The layout I have shown certainly gives me most of those abilities, and there isn't much I'd want to change about it, for my styles of playing.

However, if you want to go down the path of improvisation directly, perhaps considering LH accompaniment later, as I think many French players do, you would perhaps want a totally different set of RH accidentals and LH chords. I would be interested to hear Chris R's views on this, as I know he is considering quite radical redesigns of the quint layout.  I could add that I've experimented with the Atzarin layout, which is a three-row layout that effectively allows any note push or pull on RH.  I think it is very clever and offers amazing opportunities, but I had to give it up because I might as well have started again - the 'home' concept is so fundamentally different.
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 19, 2015, 04:50:32 PM
Am I correct that Pascale Rubens plays GCF..
That being the case.. what's up with her "new" MAZ

I like the idea of the MAZ.. I am not thrilled about the Millert/Pignol set up. (nor wenge.. this is known as fish-hook wood.. get a sliver and you'll know what I mean... stringy, porous NPA)
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Steve C. on November 19, 2015, 05:17:05 PM
Jeff, all:
I have been pretty happy with this "Heim" iteration.  I am not especially musically literate, but it plays "normal" GC with acc pretty well and also does a good job with "balkan sounding" tunes (harmonic minor, I think).
Though I haven't spent as much time playing on it as I had hoped, having found a lot of happiness with the low end of "anahata-style" DG...
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Steve C. on November 19, 2015, 05:25:47 PM
oops, wrong file, fetching right one...
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Steve C. on November 19, 2015, 05:38:18 PM
This is the one.  Regrets for haste..not sure what that first one was for..
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 19, 2015, 05:56:40 PM
http://www.lamaisondelaccordeon.com/pdf/plans_clavier.pdf

Two Heim Systems
Leray
Corgeron and the
Milleret/Pignol....
I am trying to understand the logic and advantage of each.

Milleret /Pignol baffles me , particularly the Bass.

The Heim system ( not #1) seems to be the most logical for extending diatoni play and I believe is Castagnari's default system.
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 19, 2015, 07:59:15 PM
No Chris, I don't think French music is "played all on the pull". Their trad stuff is frankly quite like English, played on row, with an admitted and famous tendency to go for A minor ;) 

There are many regional styles, eg a lot of Auvergne (including Embraud & co) is in D (major or minor, bagpipe led).  Again, melodeonistas have suitable kit. Breton rondos can be quite exotic Eb, Bb, C minor. My best friend Pierre in Brittany ports Bb and Bb/Eb Martins, and plays those keys with his local bagpipes and bombardes.

There is also a "chanson" tradition, and neo jazz. In theory this is "any mode, any key";  the Grenoble course used to add "any instrument"! Nowadays they recommend 2½ rows at least for accordion. I'd say this is a minority of the French folks scene, but nevertheless there are a lot of them, well aided and abetted by the Flemish Boombal phenomenon.

But in practice ….well, like us they have their favourite keys. Improvisers (far more numerous than here) play mostly on the pull because that offers more modes, more blue notes. But the theme is still likely to be a diatonic or harmonic minor played mostly on row.

François Heim is a bit of a one off, specialising in Balkan and harmonic minor. His system is in my view optimised for that. People like Naragonia and Duo Absynthe are far more mainstream in the Bal Folk scene. And they still do bals traditionels, where you might hear no tune from more than 100km away. The Breton fest noz dances perhaps the purest example (=10km ;))!
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: george garside on November 19, 2015, 08:40:32 PM


Here's my FR18 layout in DGAcc for what it's worth, which obviously you'll need to transpose to GCAcc:


                    Ama/Ema   A/E      Dma/Ama    D/A         Gma/Dma      G/D   
Basses:
                 Bbma/Fma  Bb/F      Bma/Emi      B/E         Cma/Cma      C/C   

                   Fma/Ebma  F/Eb    F#mi/C#ma F#/C#    Ebma/Abma   Eb/Ab





The three rows:

   Bb/Ab  C/Bb   E/D     Eb/F     Bb/Ab   C/Bb     E/D       Eb/F   Bb/Ab    C/Bb   E/D    Eb/F

D/A   G/C      B/E      D/F#   G/A       B/C      D/E       G/F#      B/A     D/C     G/E     B/F#    D/A

   D/G     F#/B    A/C#     D/E      F#/G     A/B     D/C#      F#/E    A/G      D/B    F#/C#   A/E

I hope this is of some help.

looks hellishly complicated and totaly illogical to a  simple BCCsharpist!


george ;)
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 19, 2015, 10:03:02 PM
Makes sense to me ….other than C# major!

Are you using it as a Db?
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: george garside on November 19, 2015, 10:20:39 PM
on a BCC#  C# major is the same as G or Ab!

george ;)
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Chris Brimley on November 19, 2015, 11:10:47 PM
(My quote button seems to have stopped working), but: Re:  No Chris, I don't think French music is "played all on the pull".

Sorry, Chris, I obviously didn't mean that to be taken as literally as that - I was just trying to characterise the approach of improvising using a succession of pull notes, as you describe.

Re:  C# Major

Good point, Chris, as the relative minor to E major, C# minor might indeed be better.  I think my thought at the time was to emulate semitone-displaced sliding chords, C# to C, or C# to D, as I have sometimes used Eb to D in playing certain pieces.  However, since I almost always play with thirds removed, (and in practice can't remember ever needing to use that chord button anyway), the issue has not yet arisen for me!

However I now think melodeon's original query was much more specific to the pros and cons of particular alternative systems, so my adding a further option probably didn't help him much.  As I don't have experience of those systems (and translating from solfa to note names and then transposing is a somewhat time-consuming process), I wasn't really intending to add any further to this thread.





Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 21, 2015, 03:24:21 PM
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=11079.0
From years past.
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 21, 2015, 03:45:30 PM
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,14061.msg173332.html#msg173332

In reference toNaragonia accordeons.
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: benammiswift on November 22, 2015, 05:57:50 PM
My Advice would be to design your own layout from the ground up. I did that and it was the best decision. Everything is exactly how I want in designed just for my style.

The Heim ( or other "standard" systems make absolutely no sense to me at all ) because they are designed by somebody else for how they play.


Benammi
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 22, 2015, 07:12:15 PM
I did that excercise years ago and realized I had reached my limits of  theoretical comprension as applies to practical use.

More experienced and skilled players and builders have been at this for years.  I would defer to them.

Where it gets muddy is trying to play too many styles with one box system.

I envy the 1/2 step players who have managed to limit their choices to mainly  2 rows and  4-6 basic choices.

This is why I delved into single rows a few years back, having offed several 2 , 2 1/2 and three rows.

I have 4  one rows and an 1880 Austrian/Bohemian made.   2 1/2 row  6 bass buuton model   in D/G
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 22, 2015, 07:30:18 PM
My Advice would be to design your own layout from the ground up. I did that and it was the best decision. Everything is exactly how I want in designed just for my style.

The Heim ( or other "standard" systems make absolutely no sense to me at all ) because they are designed by somebody else for how they play. Benammi

Hi Ben - totally agree. "it all depends on what you play" as ever, and I've already offered that Francois Heim's kit favours his obsession with harmonic minor and its modes. The Grenoble system ditto with full chromaticity on the pull. A Dutch reversal … and accs is probably optimal as one wastes no buttons on reversed notes. But it's a bugger to learn if you have spent a decade playing 'standard'. 

I have done well on an accs/D/G based on a C#/D/G - modified to make more use that system's duplication of C# and F# pull - which I filed to D and F respectively - thus destroying any C#/D playability - but it felt right  8) -  Also I like the trivial 'flattening' of any note on the outer row.

I'd offer (agan) that any accs/reversal row might sensibly start with a diatonic row ½ tone away from one of the standard rows. Or 3 tones away from outer row, which is the same thing. I think that is a really sound and general basis, providing "a structure". Structure is good in layout? 

Beyond that - all is subject to personal whim
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Baron Collins-Hill on November 22, 2015, 08:14:12 PM
I tend to think of it as a process of elimination (D/G speak). Here are some questions I asked myself (in rough order of importance):

1) Can you deal with a dutch reversal?

2) Why do you want a third row of accidentals? (choose all that apply, though a sense of priority is helpful):

to smooth out bellows?
to access other modes?
to access other keys?
to sound like a particular player?
to play with a particular instrument?
to play a particular style?

3) Is there a particular instrument model you are looking at?
4) 30 button right hand or 33?
5) Do you want a low third bank of reeds on the melody side?

6) 12 or 18 bass (has the potential to affect the dexterity of the instrument)?
7) Do you want to be able to take thirds in an out on the chords on the bass side, or leave all thirds out of the box entirely?
8) Would you consider chords and basses playing the same notes in both directions on one button on the left hand?

In my opinion it doesn't make that much sense to try and decide on a layout until at least some these questions have been answered, and every question answered will bring you closer to an ideal layout for you.

Hope this helps,
Baron
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 22, 2015, 08:56:40 PM
To answer the questions.

1. I would have to know what and why about Dutch reversals.. at this moment I cannot answer.
But, I will do some research.

2.  Yes

3. A few
4. 30 ok   33 ...not necessary
5. Depending on the box. Bandoneon could be possible on a 3 row.
6. 12 would be good, depending on the box and the right hand system.. 18 could be ok.. not a detriment or deterrent to purchase
7. Prefer to be able to pull the 3rds out
Smiley Shades.. not relevent at this point... Not playing Trikitixia

Other questions might be

1. Does size matter
2. Does weight matter
3. Does quality matter
4. Does button spacing matter
5. Do you have a tone/makers identifiable tone in mind
6. Do you favor a particular maker
7. Do you have a budget
8. Are you known to "flip" boxes

Thanks for the questions.

After owning 50 plus acordeons ( including a dozen Castaganaris and 18 Hohners ) , and dissecting half of them.. still clueless.
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Steve C. on November 23, 2015, 01:58:54 AM
Ben--I agree, except: don't plan to ever sell it, without huge discount!
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 23, 2015, 02:42:12 PM
Steve,

Which of the Heim systems and was it a default system when you bought it or did you specifiy that specific system.

What is your opinion of the system ?
What is your opinion of the Benny.

Are the treble buttons far enough apart ( wider than Lilly) that you can manouver ?
Is the bass and chords adequate for you ?
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Steve C. on November 24, 2015, 08:39:28 PM
Jeff, all...
(please jump in if my musical theory is off…)
I like the Heim.  If I could have 4 or five 1 or 2-row boxes with layouts from Lee Oskar, all in harmonic minor, that would be great fun, but, not very practical.
Did consider getting a "Cm" harmonic minor box, 1 or 2 row, but wasnt' sure how to lay it out.  Then tried to figure out a Cm/Am harmonic minor box, but I thinks it impossible.
So, the Heim.
The GCacc presents lots of A flats and E flats and associated bass and chords to play very easily is what I think is C harmonic minor, which to my liking is the lowest pitched, flatted out minor sound. 
Plays in the usual GC box keys, or at least have not yet hit a tune when I did not have the accidental somewhere.
And since the Benny has a stop to take out thirds, the chords are pretty flexible.
Bennys do not have thundering bass, but the newer ones are pretty good, reeds are quite big and resonate pretty well.  Sound is more full with the thirds in, though.
Spacing no problem.  Way more spacious than a Lilly, no comparison.  Since a Tommy is my usual player, don't find any issues at all.  Plenty of air.  Very portable, near same size as a Tommy.  I like to play standing, so don't like a full size box.  Can play it rumpy pumpy DG style.
Definitely would recommend.  The M-P layouts blew my mind (pea brain for music theory, admittedly).
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: melodeon on November 24, 2015, 11:54:03 PM
Steve,, I am sympathetic to the theory portion of all the various systems....

In the words of a former boss  ( from Yorkshire )  at a BMC  dealership (1968-72) when I asked a technical question and he gave a brilliant answer which I did not comprehend and asked for further clarification........." I don't understand all I know".

Aside form "rumpy pumpy" ( I have added that to my vocabulary ) what is your usual style of play.. ie (overused word)  genre ?

I like the idea of the Benny and even mor-eso the BIG.. (except for the aesthetics of the BIG, I refer the 12 Bass Benny, the 12BB )
However the MAS  rocks my boat ( except for the Wenge and the M-P default format)
The MAS because of the LM possibility and switches left and right  and the size and look of the box... but not enamoured of the M-P default system. ( though M-P  play C/F acc. )
I enjoy M-P for about 5 minutes, then I'm done. I admire the skill level but the music is boring.

By the way  Heim is now playing a MAS  ! instead of his usual Handry 12.  I wonder if his MAS  is Heim'd ?
Title: Re: G/C/Acc Layout
Post by: Cooper on November 27, 2015, 11:23:25 AM
I haven't the time to read all, but some quick things that were mentioned:

1) i play a MAS, and i don't use the MP-system (i can change beween Dutch and regular,...but not MP). I designed the layout myself, based on a) what i've seen around me, and trying to make sense of the choices the made and why, and b) what i want to play, and what i regularly miss. I am quite happy with the result, but i am also still canging stuff now and then.
2) I also ave a Gaillard 3r18B, but i play the Mas more at this time. Probably largely due to the choice that the chords are in the same octave as the basses...very low. It costs me versatility in sound.
3) Naragonia plays GC#, not GCF (in my humble opinion, a third quint row like that is a waste of buttons,...you lose so much, while you win so little)

But most importantly, for me, size and weight matter! a LOT! I havent been entirely happy with either Mas or Gaillard, even though they are the most lightweight 3rows i could find, because i couldnt quite controll the box and bellows as good as i wanted, and as i could on my 2rows.

I jut returned yesterday with a self-built bandoneon-voiced 2.6 row 14B from Pariselle. The size, weight and thereby control are MUCH more to my liking. I am playing the reeds in with joy at the moment, and we'll see how happy i am with it after a (half) year or so :-)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal