Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Adam-T on November 26, 2015, 08:15:32 AM
-
I know parts of this have been talked about many times before but there must be a way of gauging the age of a German / Swiss Erica by the various design changes over the years .. some will say "who cares, its how the box sounds that matters" - true but if that was all we stuck to, this would be a boring forum and box history is interesting ..
Some Variances in German Ericas over the years - there must be more
1:- Flush or ridged grille
2:- lettering - Gold outline filled in with silver, gold outline filled in with red, gold outline not filled in at all, black overpainted inner with silver .. I think solid block gold was Chinese onwards
3:- Bass plate with either circular arranged or in-line holes - I don`t remember seeing an Erica with the small holes early pokerworks got
4:- Celluloid underneath either "split" (black line through it) or seamless
5:- Wooden or plastic keyboard
6:- either solid or "wobbly" strap lugs (seen both on early and late)
7:- black or gold bellows tape
8:- wood or plastic bellows ends ridges
There must be combinations of these things which give an idea of date of a box - also the cardboard box itself (though I bet few are left) I`ve seen two types, one looks older with a pic of a mouthie on it and later with solid blocks of print . internals of Ericas don`t seem to have changed , the Swiss one I had looked identical to a German one too - only the setup and finishing seemed to differ from a german one, it was made from the same bits .
-
Red or Black?
-
Or grey, or purple, or glittery-flecked black? Or blue?
(I'd love to get my hands on a blue one!!! I've seen two, only one of which was for sale, but the price went through the roof on German eBay.)
At least 3 varieties of gold bellows tape.
Two different shapes of the wooden keyboard.
T or H reedplate markings.
With or without reedplate pins.
Hook or screw plate reed block clamps.
Reedblock gaskets attached to the reed block or the fondo.
Enough! I'm sure I've missed some....
-
Here's a great example of my favorite model of German-made Erica, an early model in blue-grey, with original box (on left in photo). Happy to answer questions about its details in case any of its features are useful in terms of the questions Adam posed. This one is in GC and all-original except that I added strap brackets.
I like the Swiss-made ones also! Do not have one here at present but I think they used a different wood in the reedblocks and the bellows also handle differently.
PG
-
Interesting addons there Malcolm - I didn`t realise that the two wooden fingerboard shapes and reedblock clamp types affected Ericas thought they`d sorted those before the model was released like the bass plate hole size - learn something every day :D .... I thought about reed pins but re-waxing often removes them from the equasion , the T/H reedplate business will always be a Hohner conundrum with no logical conclusion , some weird mixes of both in earlier boxes , even mixes of Zinc and ally reedplates - I thought all this was gone by the 50s when the Erica came out ..
only seen Red, black and grey ones, the latter being rather rare (always wanted one as it kinda laughs at the hi-ticket vintage Paolos) , never seen a blue or glittery flecked black one (I had a Trichord that colour though)
-
That Blue Erica is lovely Paul - the nicest I`ve seen colour wise ......
you`re also showing the two cardboard box designs I mentioned, the Erica being on the same type as the one I have coming (the older style carton ?)
The swiss Erica I had used the same wood as the german reedblocks I swapped in , the quality diff seemed to be on the outside (finish) and the setup as well as attention to detail regarding cleanliness and roughness inside
-
Interesting blue/grey, Paul. Not quite the blue I had in mind though. The colour of the ones I referred to was a much brighter blue.
Attached photo of a green/grey I bought from NZ a while back. Wish I had kept it, but after some desperate pleading from a customer, I let it go :(
-
Attached photo of an Erica with original (though repainted) "winged" keyboard.
-
A purple Erica, though faded to almost brown on exposed areas.
-
Interesting addons there Malcolm - I didn`t realise that the two wooden fingerboard shapes and reedblock clamp types affected Ericas thought they`d sorted those before the model was released like the bass plate hole size - learn something every day :D .... I thought about reed pins but re-waxing often removes them from the equasion , the T/H reedplate business will always be a Hohner conundrum with no logical conclusion , some weird mixes of both in earlier boxes , even mixes of Zinc and ally reedplates - I thought all this was gone by the 50s when the Erica came out ..
Can't recall ever seeing original-looking zinc reedplates on an Erica, but definitely some had aluminium H reeds.
Later German Ericas definitely came from the factory without reedplate pins, as did all the Chinese ones afaik.
-
that "purple" Erica looks almost preciosa coloured
-
Mine has turned up from Germany - it has got a plastic keyboard (with made in Germany printed underneath) - Ridged grille, gold outline lettering with no filling, gold bellows tape (Duller not bright like the new bogpaper) circular pattern bass plate, split style celluloid underneath, "wobbly" type strap brackets, wooden bellows ends, the bellows pins are the smaller head ones though without the washers as you`d expect, Cardboard carton is the older style ..
this box has that bright raucous sound Hohners are famous for with attitude ....... I`m guessing it is 1970s from the above, if it is, it`s in amazing condition , slightly faded on the bass end top (across the whole top thankfully not just a patch) but apart from some minor playing rash, as mint as you could possibly expect this side of an unplayed wardrobe find ..
For the record, the swiss one I had was better finished cosmetically but sounded duller and wan`t as fast to play (stiffer pallet springs ? )