Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: squeezebox63 on December 16, 2007, 01:58:18 PM

Title: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: squeezebox63 on December 16, 2007, 01:58:18 PM
I am a piano acc player that has also been playin C/G and A/D melodeons. Would like to know how difficult it is to chg to a semitone apart box.{C#/D or B/C} I do play some crossrow now, but always seem to end up single row. I am not an accomplished player, but get a lot of enjoyment from playing. Any Opinions.
Cliff.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on December 16, 2007, 09:37:38 PM
whereas the 4th apart boxes such as DG, cf etc only need one set of fingering and belows movements to enable a basic tune to be played i.e. saqme on either row the semitone boxes require a different mental approach which  involves knowing the keyboard well and  (in the case of BC) thinking of the C row as being the equivelent of the 'white' notes on a piano and the B row as containing the 'black notes' In effect each scale consists of a part of the C scale but pulling a sharp note from the B row. 1 for G 2 for D, 3 for A etc.  It is therefore important to practice scales for each key in just the same way as it is on most instruments. The scales can be played as outlined but there is also a bit of a bonus in that (on BC) there are two 'alternative' notes i.e. B & E both occur on push & pull of the bellows and can be used to advantage to control bellows movement once basic scales are mastered.

Because you only have one of everything ( if you ignore the 2 alternatives as above) it is easier to read from the dots onto a BC box compared to a Dg on which eg the G is in a defferent direction acording to which row & key you are playing in.

There is sufficient difference between the two systems  to enable both to be played without causing undue confusion any moree than playing a box and a fiddle.  I only run into difficulties when instantly changing from one system to the other eg for two immediately consequitive lessons. If  learning a tune from the dots I tend to use the semitone box first & then play the tune from memory on the DG. 

The only problem with most semitone boxes is that the bass is of limited use (which is shy many irish players ignore the bass) it is also one of the reasons why I play the 3 row BCC# with stradella bass.

in a nutshell it is best to view the 2 systems as complimentary rather than either /or

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Robin Harrison on December 17, 2007, 01:48:55 AM
My initial response is to ask "Why ?"
        What I have done is to paintakingly convert myself from a D/G up-and-down-the rows player to an ADG cross-row-player...........and this has been plenty difficult and has taken 2-3 years and it's still tough sleddin'.
        I imagine going from the C/G ,A/D to the semi-tone apart system would be even more difficult.Going to a three row is not a complete deconstruction of what you already do.
        I've enjoyed the change to the three row but again it's hard to do.
                  How committed are you to such a change ? I think the easiest  thing to do is to keep doing what you can already do but do it better.
           Not that I've ever taken this advice, of course.
        Regards Robin
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Theo on December 17, 2007, 08:54:19 AM
.... been playin C/G and A/D melodeons. Would like to know how difficult it is to chg to a semitone apart box.{C#/D or B/C} ....

I'm a D/G player, but I sometimes attempt to play a B/C when nobody is listening.

If you play up and down the  rows then you can do that on semitone systems too.  Not many admit to this, but I have a couple of customers who have had me modify basses on B/C boxes (expensive ones too) so that they can play in C major and B major!   Lots of East Anglian players play in C on any box with a C row and ignore the other row.  Same applies to C#/D though of course D tends to be a much more popular key.

To my mind the link between the two systems is to find a key where the fingering is (almost) the same.  For example the fingering you use to play in A on a D row would give you G on the C row of a B/C. Except for the G#, but the pattern of pushes and pulls is the.

So to get a feel for what it would be like try playing in D on your G/C box, or in E on your A/D.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on December 17, 2007, 01:30:01 PM
If you play up and down the  rows then you can do that on semitone systems too.  Not many admit to this, but I have a couple of customers who have had me modify basses on B/C boxes (expensive ones too) so that they can play in C major and B major!   Lots of East Anglian players play in C on any box with a C row and ignore the other row.  Same applies to C#/D though of course D tends to be a much more popular key.

It's very easy to get a C#/D and then play it as if it were a one-row melodeon. I know a couple of people who do this... interestingly both are former quint-box players. (Mind you one of them confessed to me that he plays his 3-row boxes up and down the row, too!!!)

George mentioned that you have two alternative notes on a B/C - in fact you have two such notes on any half-step box (as I almost replied to Kiwi in another post, this is because there are seven notes in the diatonic scale, which means a two-row box has fourteen different notes, and since there are only twelve semitones in the chromatic scale, you are bound to have two notes in common between the rows 8) ).

On a C#/D these notes are F# and C# - two notes doesn't sound like much in the way of cross-rowing options, but  just these two make a huge difference to the possibilities for phrasing and flow and not using them is, well, dumb.

If you get a B/C, you'll be forced to explore both rows. But if you get a C#/D, don't fall into the trap of not doing the same - otherwise, why bother changing?
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: risto on December 17, 2007, 05:07:51 PM
Quote
I am a piano acc player .
Cliff.

Isn't this a strange question for a piano player? ;) I've been playing the B/C for little more than 5 months now and really don't understand what is it what some consider to be so specially difficult in half a semitone boxes. It is just lots of work and practise like with any other instrument. If you work out where all the notes are it really shouldn't be that difficult, specially for a pianodude!  :)
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on December 17, 2007, 07:41:24 PM
the semitone boxes should in a sense be a airly esy move fro a piano player as apart from the slight difference of 2 notes per button it is much the same!!    To play a BC or CC# yu need to move away from thinking in terms of  playing  in the home key of each row and  think in terms of an integrated system  with 'white ' notes on C row & 'black' notes  on the other row.  Start off by learning the scale in C right up the length of the keyboard. All other keys then consist of a part of the C scale with the addition of eg F# from the other row for key of G and F# & C# for key of D etc etc.  Forget the idea of 'crossing the rows' as being a particular  (optional)technique as it is on 4th apart boxes  and look on it as just the normal  way you play the thing.  As others have said with C#D there is a tendencey to stick on the D row which prevents some people from developing the skill to paly chromatically.  This can apply even more with a 3 row C#DG box which is why to me the BCC# makes moe sense. ( I also play a bog standard DG, limiting row crossing to where it really makes a difference to the bass availability in slow tunes - waltzes & marches etc)

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: squeezebox63 on December 18, 2007, 12:17:08 PM
Very good explanation george. am I to take it that I also can play in any key with a B/C.
I also like to play the bass side, and very much would like to hav a stradella base. the one you have sounds very good but I assume quite hard to find.
I'm not a piano player but a piano accordion player, which is why the stradella bass sounds like it would be very comfortable to play on a diatonic.
Thanks for all your opinions, very interesting to hear from those that have been there. any more?.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on December 18, 2007, 01:28:48 PM
Very good explanation george. am I to take it that I also can play in any key with a B/C.

(Edited to add this caveat - the following is based on my experiments with exotic keys on a C#/D box, but transposed down a tone as it were. I might be missing something, if so I hope George or Bill can set me straight.)

Well you can, but... you probably wouldn't want to. On a B/C, any key sig between 1 flat and 3 sharps is comfortable (although B/C players don't go looking for opportunities to play in A major as far as I can see). Start adding more flats or sharps and things get progressively more awkward because bellows changes become problematic (too many or too few) and/or because notes on the keyboard get more out of synch than they are already (higher notes on lower buttons, etc.). Doable but it's a steepish learning curve.

A small selection of exotic keys are available to you on the B row but as far as I know hardly anybody bothers to explore those, probably because you have to grab extra notes from the inner row rather than the outer and it feels like playing a completely different system.

If you like the idea of a stradella bass and playing in a greater range of keys, you sound like a good candidate for a B/C/C#. (At which point some smart alecs might be tempted to say, why not stick with a piano accordion?  :P )
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on December 18, 2007, 02:39:24 PM
Steve
I quite agree re kes on 2 row semitone boxes eg on Bc FCGDAE are failry straitforward  (as for A  the BC box is very popular in certain parts of Scotland  and they certainly play plenty of tunes in A!)

Whilst all the other keys aare of course present (otherwise it wouldn't be a 'chromatic box'  some can be buggers to play.  The addition of the C sharp row  on the BCC#  takes the sweat out of playing in all keys provided you have learned  to play it as a 2 row BC box to begin with.  The 2 inside rows provide the flat keys with exactly the same fingering as the sharp keys on the 2 outside rows.  Other advantages are  better bellows control and  easier fingering and also a much greater range of right hand chords.

 As to stradella  its a matter of preference.  Some hohner trichords have 'melodeon' bass which I feel are about as 'useful' as the 8 bass on a BC.  MOst have 12 stradella & having only 12 to think about & bass buttons with wider spacing than on larger stradella systems makes it easier to learn the principle of stradella bass whcih can later , if required, be extended to a larger setup.  Stradella bass aent just the perogative of 3 row  semitone boxes as hohner did a dou;ble ray delux 2 row with stradella and I one haad a DG erica that had been converted to 12 stradella & which I thought was a distinct improvementon the normal 8 bass - but then I'm not a great fan of minor keys.

As to comparison with piano accordion  on paper the piano accordion (and indeed the continental chromatic) make far more sense.  However  the BCC# has a  some definate plus points -  It is 'quicker' to finger as less distance has to be travelled and the note changes are randomly shared between button changes and bellows direction changes.  It is part of the melodeon family in sharing the push/pull system so is a natural progression from any other push/pull box.   It provides a lifelong challenge and a sense of satisfaction on 'getting it right' that  make the piano or continental accordions seem somewhat bland & uninteresting.

thats my view anyway!

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: mikesamwild on February 13, 2008, 11:43:37 AM
Hi
Does anyone know a good tutor DVD or book for Csharp/D style?
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on February 13, 2008, 01:31:47 PM
Hi
Does anyone know a good tutor DVD or book for Csharp/D style?

don't know of a c#d tutor book, the only BC one available is the box  which has been around for a long time. There are a couple of videos available from hobgob & music room . My BC tutor "Button Accordion - starts with a crash course for beginners but goes much furthur" is now in final stages of setting layout so with luck may be availble april/may

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on February 13, 2008, 02:31:47 PM
There aren't any tutor books or videos for C#/D that I know of. We C#/D players walk alone and find the path to enlightenment unaided!

However Damien Connolly is putting a book together aimed mainly at B/C learners, but he says he will include some material for C#/D players too (after I badgered him to do so  8) ). He's aiming to get it out this year.

Damien is a very fine player - the son of Martin Connolly, the maker of Kincora accordions. He is known as a B/C player but likes to play C#/D too. He lives in Connecticut.

http://cdbaby.com/cd/damienc
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: mikesamwild on February 14, 2008, 02:19:25 PM
Cheers George and Steve
I have begun to get the hang and am playing up and down the D row (inside row) But using triangular diagrams to get onto Csharp row for notes that give me a continuous flow. It has been worth the move from D/G dependence after so many years with morris and ceilidh band work and song accompaniment. I am evolving a hybrid style which suits me as I still like melodeon and listen to Johnny Connolly etc.
I Got a Mairtin OConnor model Csharp/D Saltarelle from a French player on EBay.
I find playing along to The Box CD by D Hanrahan helps force the pace and though it is for B/C I have to go across for C natural as recommended by him and Peter Browne and John Williams on their excellent DVDs The tunes are in 'fiddle' type keys so playing by ear is quite simple. I'm leaving E flat etc for a while but F is nice for playing with Northumbrian pipers.
Incidentally all this whilst working on C/G Anglo to split my ageing brain still further! Am I seeking to delay'Oldtimer's disease'?

I look forward to the forthcoming publications you mention.
I also find that writing tunes out in ABC  with two marker pens for shading push and pull notes helps with flow and hints for chordal accompaniment. I'm leaving the oompah aside for a bit and listening to concertina players and pipers for the 'blarts' and 'scitheridooodles'. Although a lot of my old records have vamping piano or banjo which was common on Irish 78s. All grist to the mill eh?

Cheers Mike in Sheffield
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on February 14, 2008, 03:21:00 PM

I ) But using triangular diagrams to get onto Csharp row for notes that give me a continuous flow. 
 

Cheers Mike in Sheffield

I strongly recommend that on semitone boxes practicing scales is the easiest way of approaching things rather than thinking in terms of triaangles etc.  once you can play the scales of say GDA at  a reasonable speed and all the way up the keyboard  without thinking about it your fingers will automatically  go for the  accidentals appropriate to a particular key without  the need to think about having to  prod  notes on the outside row.  Scale practice is very much the norm on most instruments & has the incidental benefits of improving manual dexterity so you don't slow down on the tricky bits and in the case of button boxes of  developing fine bellows control. Scales can also be use as a awarm up exercise for those who think it necessary.
george

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on February 14, 2008, 06:01:27 PM
I strongly recommend that on semitone boxes practicing scales is the easiest way of approaching things rather than thinking in terms of triangles etc.

I think scales are a good idea too (unlike Andrew W!), but even when playing scales you still have to choose whether or not to do "triangles" when the opportunity is there. For example (on a C#/D), playing EF#G all on the pull rather than pull-push-pull. You can play those notes both ways in a scale of D or G just as easily as in a tune.

I used to assume that saving a bellows reversal automatically meant less effort, but these days I find it's sometimes easier to make that extra bellows move than to get your fingers lined up for crossing the rows. And of course, the extra bellows move sometimes sounds better too. So I don't have a recipe for when to use the "magic notes" - it's all about what sounds best in a particular place in a particular tune.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on February 14, 2008, 07:29:04 PM
 
I think scales are a good idea too (unlike Andrew W!), but even when playing scales you still have to choose whether or not to do "triangles" when the opportunity is there. For example (on a C#/D), playing EF#G all on the pull rather than pull-push-pull. You can play those notes both ways in a scale of D or G just as easily as in a tune.

I used to assume that saving a bellows reversal automatically meant less effort, but these days I find it's sometimes easier to make that extra bellows move than to get your fingers lined up for crossing the rows. And of course, the extra bellows move sometimes sounds better too. So I don't have a recipe for when to use the "magic notes" - it's all about what sounds best in a particular place in a particular tune.
[/quote]

Quite agree Steve . The experienced player has to make the choice of  alternative note according to the particular tune and as you have said sometimes taking into consideration the subtly different sound that can be had from a 'bellows change' or a 'button change'.    However I find new players cope better by ignoring the choice of alternatives and playing based on scales using  the inside row for everything  exept what it hasn't got!  With new players I teach  (on BC or BCC#)  keys of CGDA in that order and only introduce the alternatives once the key of A is mastered playing without them.ON the  rare occasion of a beginner on C#D I use exactly the same principle i.e.DAEG. With BCC# I use exactly the same principle, keeping entirely to two rows and again only using the B row when absolutely essential. This is followed by exactly the same as a BC i.e. introducing the B & E on the outside row.  Only when this is working reasonably do I bring in the C# row, introducing the  alternatives there just one at a time in the order of F#C# & G# etc.

Learning this way means ( with luck!) that the player  makes  best use of the 'alternative or 'majic' notes  rather than just potting them randomly because they are there. 

george
1 row in C with 2 rows of accidentals!
 

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 14, 2008, 09:19:53 PM
Scales are just very boring tunes   :P

(I was going to say "crap tunes", but it sounded a bit rude  :-*  )
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on February 14, 2008, 09:42:55 PM
Scales are just very boring tunes   :P

(I was going to say "crap tunes", but it sounded a bit rude  :-*  )

Sorry Andrew  whilst I agree scales can be boring  they provide a way of programming the brain and exercising the fingers etc  in a way that  playing non boring tunes or for that matter boring tunes ( whether or not aparticular   tune is boring is entirely up to the taste of the individual listener/e) will not do. Competence at playing scales in a veriety of keys enables the appropriate sharps & flats to be played without any thought i.e. on auto pilot, just by knowing the key the tune is in.  They also assist in developing good fingering styles & can greatly help when playing fast runs as these can be part of a scale. This is why  player of most instruments learn and practice scales in much .the same way as athletes do 'boring' exercises to get in trim &  develop & maintain the stamina needed for a sporting event. Not practicing scales the full length of the box is also the main reason why many players  have difficulty playing in the top octave or if they play all the time in the top octave have difficulty with the lower octave.

Scale playing is not of course compulsory & thankfully we are all free to 'do our own thing'  However it should not be dismissed as boring, crap or whatever  when the evidence is clear that a great many musicians benefit from learning & practicing scales.  Practicing scales cannot do anyone any harm and may well do a great deal of good.

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 14, 2008, 10:10:18 PM
Oh dear, I see my mistake now.

Scales ARE just crap tunes.  Yes, of course we often have to "keep at it" and be dedicated and all that.  There's no need to imply that I'm not aware of the necessity of practise.

All the same, there is not some moral imperative in suffering for music.  Just because it's boring doesn't mean it's doing any good.

I cannot see how in folk music constant practising of scales trumps learning/playing  tunes in any way.  I'm also aware that I'm not alone in this belief either. Playing tunes also (rather obviously) teaches you where the notes are and gives all of the scope you'll ever need to learn "tricks" and techniques.

Sharps, flats, runs and all the rest occur in tunes, in natural ways that you can learn.  When learning/playing tunes, you also, well, learn tunes, get better at playing them, get better at playing them on the Melodeon; whilst obsessively practising scales, you just end up with a load of scales which are, sadly, just crap tunes.

There you are.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: trombonetom on February 14, 2008, 10:47:14 PM
Scales ARE just crap tunes.

I hope I don't offend anybody by saying this, but scales are just crap. (especially C# melodic minor, not very relevant for melodeons, but still hard to play and pointless on any instrument)
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on February 15, 2008, 03:39:32 AM
Whatever floats your boat, gentlemen! You have a point but I'll choose to practise whatever I think helps me. If it helps me, it's not boring. But who said anything about "constant" or "obsessive" practice of scales?
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on February 15, 2008, 09:48:22 AM
[quote  . But who said anything about "constant" or "obsessive" practice of scales?
[/quote]

Quite! and I for one have absolutely no intention of practising/playing C# melodic minor or for that matter any other scales of keys I dont intend to play in.
george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Theo on February 15, 2008, 09:50:55 AM
Scales - love them or hate them?

I still have unpleasant memories of a piano teacher who I had the misfortune to take lessons with when I was aged about 8 or 9.  It was just scales, scales scales. 

He managed to completely remove from me any concept that music could be fun, entertaining, inspiring or any of those positives that thankfully I discovered again about 30 year later.  All he made me do was play scales, teach me the names of the notes on a stave, then expected me to be able to decode and play from notation.  Nothing at all about the most important aspect of learning music, namely using the ears, and nothing about how much fun and pleasure was available in music.

That is an extreme case, but sadly all too common.

I understand that practising scales can be useful, but only as a means to an end.  In the context of this discussion, if you are changing from D/G to C#/D and are struggling with some tunes, then practising the scales is may be very helpful. If you can play everything you want to then don't play scales, you don't need them, but if you want to develop your ability as a musician then scales may be helpful. So if you want to change from playing on one row to playing across the rows then playing scales can be a useful aid to the learning process.  So I'm sure George didn't mean that you should play exclusively scales for days, weeks, months or years but that you should use them as part of the learning process.

Ways to make scale less boring:

Try each in turn, as soon as you get bored move to the next


But only do it if its either fun or its letting you learn something you want to learn
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: mikesamwild on February 15, 2008, 11:15:09 AM
George, I find the diagrams useful to place the notes in my head and helpthe old muscle memory but now I'm finding I just go for them, even if I miss them sometimes. I do agree about the scales and arpeggios.
Another tip I got from this site or The Session was not to use the little finger on the right hand (although I keep it in reserve as John William's advises)
Thanks for your helpful comments
Mike
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Quebecois on February 15, 2008, 12:55:24 PM
Oh dear, I see my mistake now.

Scales ARE just crap tunes.  Yes, of course we often have to "keep at it" and be dedicated and all that.  There's no need to imply that I'm not aware of the necessity of practise.
<snip>

Many phrases in very many tunes ARE scales! I find that practicing them in the context of the tune I am learning can be very helpful.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on February 15, 2008, 02:22:22 PM
Musing about the subject some more, I think whether you think scales are useful or a complete waste of time is a matter of where you are coming from, musically, and what you are trying to achieve short or long-term.

Theo's early experience of music lessons is sadly shared by many and it may be responsible for scalophobia in the general populace. (Happily many of today's music teachers seem to have learned a lot about how to avoid that kind of depressing experience for the child. My 5-year old has been taking piano lessons for the past four months from a very fine teacher (incidentally one of the best trad. accompanists I've ever heard) who makes the whole process a lot of fun while subtly instilling good habits. I'm totally amazed at his progress and enthusiasm. No scales yet... hehe )

Most of us, I would imagine are teaching ourselves. It follows that none of us (unless we are totally misguided) are going to do what we don't enjoy doing. I'm certainly not anyway. I don't approach scales as a chore, but as a challenge, and a way of learning fingering and fluency. I certainly don't practise them obsessively - maybe once a week or a fortnight, or whenever the fancy takes me.

Now it's perfectly possible that in time, simply playing tunes and experimenting with the best way of playing them will achieve all that - and more in fact, because tunes pose many challenges that you don't get in scales. I recognise all that but I still don't understand what there is to get all hot under the collar about.

Is it an inverted snobbery thing? That folk musicians should do it all naturally? I get the impression from various comments I read here and elswhere that some players are quite content not to know even which button sounds which note. That's all very fine, and I'm sure they are good, intuitive players who make lovely music. I would never condemn them or accuse them of "obsessively ignoring the names of notes" for example.  ;)

But approaching the instrument that way is not for me. I came to the box after 40 years of playing other instruments, and I want to get the thing under control as quickly as I can, and that means knowing exactly where all the notes are, without thinking about it, and scales are most certainly a help with that. I have absolutely no doubt that this knowledge makes things a lot easier for me - learning tunes alone, sharing tunes with others, and even, more recently, teaching a small class of beginners and relative beginners. (Yes I give them a couple of scales and drills to practise - if they want to. Most of them don't, and I don't insist. Their loss, in my opinion.)

Or maybe it's a question of the style of box? On a half-step box you have more possibilities for keys and accidentals than on a quint box - and on a BCC# you have more still. I dunno. But even if I were learning on a quint box I'm sure I'd be looking at ways to use all the notes effectively.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Quebecois on February 15, 2008, 02:44:31 PM
Is it an inverted snobbery thing? That folk musicians should do it all naturally? I get the impression from various comments I read here and elswhere that some players are quite content not to know even which button sounds which note. That's all very fine, and I'm sure they are good, intuitive players who make lovely music. I would never condemn them or accuse them of "obsessively ignoring the names of notes" for example.  ;)

Incidentally, my father has played melodeon for 60+ years by ear, only knowing about button numbers and push-pull on the written notes he keeps about the 200+ tunes he plays! Amazing...
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: trombonetom on February 15, 2008, 03:00:25 PM
On a chromatic instrument (B/C or C#/D) i suppose you can get any scale out of it but on a quint box you can only get 6. What is the point of practicing just 6 different scales? If you can play the tunes you want/need to play, then what does it matter. In my opinion, time should be spent learning the tunes you want to learn, not practising things you would never actually play as a piece.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 15, 2008, 05:53:12 PM
On a chromatic instrument (B/C or C#/D) i suppose you can get any scale out of it but on a quint box you can only get 6. What is the point of practicing just 6 different scales? If you can play the tunes you want/need to play, then what does it matter. In my opinion, time should be spent learning the tunes you want to learn, not practising things you would never actually play as a piece.
But tunes are often made up of scales and portions of scales. Similarly with arpeggios. Think of them as useful tools. Practising scales and arpeggios which are used in the tunes that you want to learn will develop your dexterity so that you can play the tunes better.

Learning tunes is not just about playing them through. You need to look out for those awkward bits - you can bet your life that many of those bits will be based on a scale or arpeggio of some sort.  Work hard on those to get them even, steady and safe. I've never known anyone (whatever their instrument) who didn't improve by incorporating a short period of time devoted to scales and arpeggios as part of their practise routine. Then, next time you are learning a new tune that's got a tricky run in E minor, say, you will be able to learn it more efficiently and more dexterously because your fingers have developed a 'scale pattern memory'. You will be able to play it better than the next guy.

Stands to reason really, dunnit?.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on February 15, 2008, 06:57:44 PM
another way of looking at it is that there are two basic ingredients to becoming a half decent musician. - musical ability and manual dexterity.  Most people have sufficient musical ability i.e. if you can hum or whistle a tune or two that should be enough for starters.  Manual dexterity though is a very different matter, often   lacking , and has to be worked at as no amount of musical ability will make a tune sound good if the fingers cant manipulate the machine skilfully and at the correct speed (& not slowing down for the tricky bits or having to leave notes out here & there  )

When we sing, hum or whistle we don't send concious instructions to the gob - open wider, tongue up, purse lips, etc etc etc.  We 'think' the song & get on with it.  I think the ultimate aim, achieved by few and certainly not by me, is to get to the stage of 'thinking' a tune and being able to play it without sending any concious directions down the arm to the fingers. In other words developing  a sort of direct connection between brain & box!  NOw to even partialy achieve this  we need to train the fingers so that they will do the right thing in whatever key (given the limitations of the instrument) that we want to play the tune in, & this is where scales come in. 

Rather like once you have learned to drive you can go where you want - once you have learned the manual skills required to 'drive' your instrument you can play whatever tunes you want in whatever key you want and this applies eqally to dot readers and 'by ear' players.  Concentrating just on learning tunes is likely to mean that you can only play the tunes you have already learned which can limit your ability to busk along in a session, gradually picking out more of a tune as it is played through a few times.  I also feel that just 'tune learning' can lead to an over ridgid approach  i.e. such & such a tune  must be in such & such a key - and then some bugger starts it off in A but you can only play it in G so you sit there doing nothing.
I find it very useful once a new tune is learned to then play it in a few or several other keys, again depending only on the limitations of your box .

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: mikesamwild on February 16, 2008, 11:20:27 AM
Interesting comments so far in my quest for info on moving onto C sharp/D.

I spoke to Theo on the phone when I was trying to register on melodeon.net

He recommended listening to Conor Keane from Ennis Co.Clare, and I got his solo CD Oidhreacht from Living Tradition . He plays Csharp/D and D/Dsharp, having started on B/C. He was inspired by Joe Cooley, Tony MacMahon, Jackie Daly etc and I like his comment. 'The older style suits me better, although it was difficult to adapt to at first (he was born 1968).There also seemed to be a bit of a credibility problem in certain quarters but I think this is changing. While the B/C system seems certain to remain the dominant one amongst accordionists in Ireland today, more and more the 'push and draw' is seen to represent a more authentic side to the tradition.'

Anybody know any other exponents?
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Quebecois on February 16, 2008, 01:09:23 PM
Perhaps the question should be: what do YOU want to do as a musician?

I play on D/G and A/D/G boxes because 95% of the repertoire I play is written in those keys and it also makes it easy to play with fiddlers, for which most tunes are in A, D or G this side of the Big Pond.

Getting a B/C or C/C# box could work but it would not provide the "sound" I am looking for, which is, lots of push and draw, and the basses would not sound "authentic" either.

If you think a B/C or C#/D box is what you need for the music you want to play, then go for it. I guess there are no "good" or "bad" things to say about one tuning style or another.

Have fun, and that's what counts!
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on February 16, 2008, 01:21:56 PM
Perhaps the question should be: what do YOU want to do as a musician?

I play on D/G and A/D/G boxes because 95% of the repertoire I play is written in those keys and it also makes it easy to play with fiddlers, for which most tunes are in A, D or G this side of the Big Pond.

Getting a B/C or C/C# box could work but it would not provide the "sound" I am looking for, which is, lots of push and draw, and the basses would not sound "authentic" either.

If you think a B/C or C#/D box is what you need for the music you want to play, then go for it. I guess there are no "good" or "bad" things to say about one tuning style or another.

Have fun, and that's what counts!


perhaps thats why I like (& play) both DG & BC(C#)  although I havn't thought about  reasons particularly.  I just pick up whichever box suits the music & the mood so to speak but I don't have specific tunes restricted to one or the other playing most tunes on both (but not at the same time!)  I suppose to some degree  I tend to go for the DG if playing with DG players 'cos I know I will have the same keys as everybody else although having saiad that an irish band I occasionally play with plays everything expt one tune in D or G (the odd tune is in C). It is however nice to be able to fit in with other keys when necessary.

playing both systems is not contradictory as the similarities are greater than the differences  and playing in other than Dor G by cross rowing on a DG box or DG + row of odds & sods  is far less logical to learn than the semitone system. Thats my view on it for what its worth

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on February 18, 2008, 01:42:06 AM
Conor Keane ... was inspired by Joe Cooley, Tony MacMahon, Jackie Daly...  Anybody know any other exponents?

Apart Tony MacMahon and Jackie Daly, I would recommend listening to Andrew MacNamara, Seamus Begley, Charlie Piggott and Eoghan O Sullivan for starters. All very individual styles, all great IMO.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: EeeJay on February 18, 2008, 03:13:51 PM
Interesting comments so far in my quest for info on moving onto C sharp/D.

Anybody know any other exponents?

Don't forget Dermot Byrne. Cut his teeth on B/C, shifted on to C#/D... absolute class ;D

Someone recently stuck a lot of Dermot's playing on YouTube (possibly from the early/mid '90s at a guess) - here's a couple of rakes of reels...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r3P6q4nuFAA (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r3P6q4nuFAA)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1ayHYwMtJo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1ayHYwMtJo)

And for his party piece... 8)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lU7tt8BSe-c (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lU7tt8BSe-c)

Ed J

Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: risto on February 18, 2008, 11:32:18 PM
Quote

And for his party piece... 8)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lU7tt8BSe-c (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lU7tt8BSe-c)

Ed J


Definatively cool! Muchias grazias!!!  I play the 'Tico Tico No Fuba' on the mandolin, a version by Os Novos Boemios, just a little different than that version. Not long ago I started it with the B/C in the key of E, the original mandolin version is in F. That is what I have meant playing other folk music as well, there are lots of nice Choros out there suitable for 2-row chromatics...
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: mikesamwild on February 21, 2008, 01:16:49 PM
C sharp/D transfer from D/G box

Thanks to all for helpful comments plus leads to musicians playing C sharp/D
I found a Dermot Byrne record which was inspiring. I didn't know he played Csharp/D Up to now I only had him on a record by Terry Bingham a great Anglo Conc player. The YouTube clips were brilliant.

Incidentally George, after your comment on teaching scales I had a bash at A which I always felt 'scared of' becaue of the sharps. I was terrorized by a school music 'teacher' who was a bully and put off fiidle till recently.

On the Csharp/D it is quite straightforward and I got Atholl Highlanders after the second bash and I didn't end up witth my arms a fathom apart!
Any other good tunes in A to try?

Cheers
Mike  Sheffield
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on February 21, 2008, 01:33:23 PM
You need to try some that are really in A major - ones that have a few G#s - not A mixolydian, with G-nats, or "G-less" A like the Atholl Highlanders.

Try Miss McLeod's in A as a fairly easy starter, or transpose any tune you know in G up a tone.

On the subject of Dermot Byrne, this is the kind of thing I hesitate to say because it seems either churlish or the usual sour grapes of someone who can never dream of reaching his level, but... although his skill is absolutely mind-boggling, I find his playing of Irish music rather bland, lacking in personality somehow.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on February 21, 2008, 01:48:11 PM
Incidentally George, after your comment on teaching scales I had a bash at A which I always felt 'scared of' becaue of the sharps. I was terrorized by a school music 'teacher' who was a bully and put off fiidle till recently.

On the Csharp/D it is quite straightforward and I got Atholl Highlanders after the second bash and I didn't end up witth my arms a fathom apart!
Any other good tunes in A to try?

Cheers
Mike  Sheffield

Good stuff Mike!  Don't worry too much about playing tunes originally composed in A in A  just try tunes (that you may have played in D or G)  in A. The better you know the tune the easier it is for starters.  For what its worth a few of my personal faavourites to play in A include  - My Home, The Cradle Song (scott skinner).  Lamb Skinnet , Babes in the Wood, stool of repentance,  Hundred  Pipers, cock of the north;, Bonny Dundee, Rowan Tree, Rosin the bow, Westering Home.

Then have a go at prodding out a G scale    then you will have DGA available

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: rees on February 21, 2008, 02:25:48 PM
A good deal of Jackie Daly's tunes are in A on a C#/D. Also much of the Kerry Polka and Slide style.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: EeeJay on February 21, 2008, 09:30:13 PM
On the subject of Dermot Byrne, this is the kind of thing I hesitate to say because it seems either churlish or the usual sour grapes of someone who can never dream of reaching his level, but... although his skill is absolutely mind-boggling, I find his playing of Irish music rather bland, lacking in personality somehow.

Bland? ???

Oh, Steve, you churlish larrikin!

Dermot's style is just, well... Dermot 8) - top dog in my book!

His playing may be flash in parts, but seems to be rooted in the whole Donegal tradition - loads of fiddlers but not so many boxplayers. So if he sounds more like a fiddle player, well that's why.

Not as I'm implying fiddles are bland... good lord no! :o

Ed J
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on February 22, 2008, 01:04:01 AM
I'm sorry but I'm with Steve,for me Dermot's just typing the tune out.It's nice to listen his Tico-Tico to hear how it's played but there's no rythym or life to the music.Compared to Cooley or MacMahon he's very boring.

Chris
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Quebecois on February 22, 2008, 01:27:07 PM
MacMahon rules...

I love this old TV session:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=n06hpDSpsko

Look at his face while he plays: he IS the music!
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on February 22, 2008, 01:48:52 PM

Steve, you churlish larrikin!

Guilty as charged  :P

Well, in many respects he _is_ top dog, no question. There has probably never been a half-step box player with such a command of his instrument. I don't know how on earth he can play so smoothly. Can play simply anything with breathtaking ease, and in any key you like, sir, no bother. But... sorry, I can't help it. I felt this way when (in my fiddling days) I first heard his solo album, years before I ever imagined I would take up accordion.

BTW the Donegal fiddlers I like best (leaving the Altan crew and the Glackin bros. out of it) are more Stilton than yogurt. James Byrne, Vincent Campbell for example.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on February 22, 2008, 01:57:22 PM
MacMahon rules...

I love this old TV session: http://youtube.com/watch?v=n06hpDSpsko

I love that too, but this later one even better: http://youtube.com/watch?v=cdXRX9VEqaQ 

On the subject of Joe Cooley, the published recordings and video clips of him at the very end of his life only give a hint of why he was so revered. Here's a tantalizing morsel of real Stilton for you - Cooley in full flight (http://www.rogermillington.com/steam/cooleysdairymaid.mp3).



Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Malcolm Austen on February 22, 2008, 03:38:38 PM
"I love this old TV session: http://youtube.com/watch?v=n06hpDSpsko"

Is it my eyes or there no cover on the keyboard, it looks like you can see down to the levers?

malcolm
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on February 22, 2008, 05:30:48 PM
Here's a clip of the Fureys from the same 1963 show.You can see Tony's head throughout the performance.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=lFVmUU0B9dA

Thanks for the Joe Cooley recording Steeve,great tune.I wish there was more video from the "Wise Maid" session.I love the power and drive of his playing.

Chris
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: EeeJay on February 22, 2008, 07:57:03 PM
I'm sorry but I'm with Steve,for me Dermot's just typing the tune out.It's nice to listen his Tico-Tico to hear how it's played but there's no rythym or life to the music.Compared to Cooley or MacMahon he's very boring.

Chris

Boring? ???

Oh well, we're not wrong... just different.

IMHO Cooley and his protégé McMahon are totally different - It's like comparing chalk and cheese...

...speaking of "cheese scales"... stylistically, Dermot and Sharon Shannon are poles apart in my book. All that stuttery stuff every twist and turn...

Sharon sure likes to use that triplet. Again and again and again... ::)

Anyways, that's made me think of another great C#/D player on CD - Mary Staunton. Same box as Sharon (Casti Tommy), but far more laid back...

Ed J
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Quebecois on February 22, 2008, 10:33:01 PM
"I love this old TV session: http://youtube.com/watch?v=n06hpDSpsko"

Is it my eyes or there no cover on the keyboard, it looks like you can see down to the levers?

malcolm
Looks indeed like if there is no keyboard cover.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: mikesamwild on February 23, 2008, 12:15:10 PM
Hi all!
I love where a simple enquiry takes you. Love all the video clips.  Watching Tony MacMahon shows him up and down the inside row a lot Did Joe Cooley play like that? What keys were his boxes in?
 I am beginning to realise that a lot of tunes I heard in the 60s and 70s in E flat were probably not speeded up from D to confuse us all but were on D sharp boxes.  My mates and me were only aware of D/G boxes and played D whistles! to keep up with flute and fiddle players

Hindsight is a marvellous thing!
Mike
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: TomB-R on February 23, 2008, 06:51:04 PM
The wisdom of the internet seems to be that Joe Cooley played C#/D style on a D/D# box so transposing up a semitone.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: mikesamwild on February 25, 2008, 11:35:04 AM
So mainly up and down on the inside row like any old  melodeon or 'gob iron',  plus trips to the outside row for 'accidentals'? .  Looks like Tony Mac Mahon etc

Were these the boxes common in America/ Does anyone know who was making these 'D Accordions'?
Since I started using an E flat whistle I've been able to work out tunes from such records more readily.

However I pretend I'm in D then transfer to my box in D.  For example I was listening to Noel Hill in E flat and a mate said he does it on a 30 button C/G Concerina. He plays with MacMahon so maybe he has to go that way? Or is it the tendency to get brighter and brighter? What is it with Eflat or D sharp? Scott Skinner seemed to do it on fiddle.Any comments?
Mike in Sheffield



Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: george garside on February 25, 2008, 01:37:40 PM
Hi all!
I love where a simple enquiry takes you. Love all the video clips.  Watching Tony MacMahon shows him up and down the inside row a lot Did Joe Cooley play like that? What keys were his boxes in?
 I am beginning to realise that a lot of tunes I heard in the 60s and 70s in E flat were probably not speeded up from D to confuse us all but were on D sharp boxes.  My mates and me were only aware of D/G boxes and played D whistles! to keep up with flute and fiddle players

Hindsight is a marvellous thing!
Mike

60s/70s stuff in e flat is quite likely to have been played on CC# box  . some plaayers had both BC & CC# using the CC# for the 'flat' keys as the fingering & bellowing is the same as that fotr the 'sharp' keys on a BC. Thats why I like the BCC# as you can do both  without learning anything new, a bit like the same only different to the way a continental chromatic works!!!!

george
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: EeeJay on February 26, 2008, 11:14:15 PM
However I pretend I'm in D then transfer to my box in D.  For example I was listening to Noel Hill in E flat and a mate said he does it on a 30 button C/G Concerina. He plays with MacMahon so maybe he has to go that way?

As far as I know, Noel uses a flat tuned Concertina... a vintage machine... probably originally a non-concert pitch instrument, later adapted for use in a specifically semitone higher tuned context. Modern makers produce such instruments for this purpose, and many players tend to order new C#/G#s (for familiarity, as its a semitone above "standard"). However, there are lower pitched Bb/F and Ab/Eb instruments that may be used. Exactly what Noel uses, I'm not so certain... probably several different pitches, as he owns a fair few 'tinas...

Anyhow... E flat... The maestro, Máirtín O'Connor...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NxCTaoZ3Mjk (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NxCTaoZ3Mjk)

Love the way Cathal just tears into that reel after the Queen of Sheba... what is that tune anyway - anyone know? Here's another rake of reels...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q4DTrZH-qrM (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q4DTrZH-qrM)

And that technique... Máirtín seems to break a lot of the rules - his fingers seem to be flying around a heck of a lot, not staying within minimal travel like a lot of Irish players. AND using the fifth finger as far as I can tell. Yet the control is phenomenal. And the thumb behind the keyboard... it seems to enable Máirtín to drive the box both ways - all those powerchords on 'The Wise Maid' for instance.

Ed J
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on February 27, 2008, 01:02:15 AM
Ed - stop finding these clips, how is a body supposed to get some work done?

A closeup of Mairtin's unorthodox r/h technique at about 4:50 into this one: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sr7kXjHPxTI
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: EeeJay on March 01, 2008, 10:42:23 PM
Ed - stop finding these clips, how is a body supposed to get some work done?

Oooh, ain't I a stinker?  ;)

Here's Conor Keane, toting a splendid looking (and sounding) Maugein box...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWnTlUbk5Xo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aWnTlUbk5Xo)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IstQyuOVE8M (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IstQyuOVE8M)

Well, it's the weekend so learn some new tunes... ;D

Ed J
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on March 03, 2008, 01:54:11 PM
Oooh, ain't I a stinker?  ;)

Hmm, if you want to establish your pungency quotient, you'll have to post a clip of yourself  :D (this seems the most appropriate icon: "cheesy")

I read on another forum that Conor K is now some kind of agent for Maugein boxes and want to know more. He seems to be playing a 2-voice 12-bass, interesting. At least we now know he's not an advocate of the 3-finger style.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Lars on March 04, 2008, 04:10:08 AM
The Joe Cooley clip of The Wise Maid (found on youtube) came from a video interview of him (about his life if America) and Tony MacMahon (talking about Cooley). I have seen this on an old VHS-tape at a friends' house, I think it was about 10-15 minutes in all. He plays a few tunes, and show that he actually plays the box rather differently sometimes than on the Wise Maid-clip. Crossing his legs, holding the box somewhat slanted, but still with the strong powerful sound.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Bocsa on November 16, 2008, 09:46:06 PM
Steve Jones, i was just browsing the site here when i stumbled upon your post including a clip of Joe Cooley.....THANK YOU!! Where did you get that clip do you mind me asking? And do you have more? Such life! Thank you!
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on November 17, 2008, 01:53:35 PM
Steve Jones, i was just browsing the site here when i stumbled upon your post including a clip of Joe Cooley.....THANK YOU!! Where did you get that clip do you mind me asking? And do you have more? Such life! Thank you!

Liam, it's from an amateur recording that is being passed around privately among enthusiasts. I got in on CD from a friend but he knew nothing about when and where it was made. I'd say it was taped by one of Joe's students because (IIRC) most of it consists of him playing tunes once through quite slowly. There are only a couple of "in concert" tracks and the one I posted above is the best of those.

I'll gladly pass on a copy to you and anyone else interested but first I have to find the CD - which might take some time  ;)  Let me know by email if you'd like a copy or and we'll work something out. In the meantime here is the only other clip from it that I digitized before allowing the CD to become submerged in piles of books, papers and other CDs. It's 1.2 MB.

http://www.rogermillington.com/steam/cooleyscrowleys.mp3
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Bocsa on November 17, 2008, 04:52:14 PM
Thanks for the reply.These are very precious recordings!If you find the cd would you be able to digitize more tracks?If not Ill email you my address and you can send on the cd.Thanks very much :)
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Bocsa on November 17, 2008, 04:56:08 PM
Oh, and ive started a thread were people can post more recordings if they have them.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Bocsa on January 21, 2009, 09:34:00 PM
Stevejones, your email address isnt on your profile.I was hoping we could come to an arrangement on the Cooley recordings you have(If you have found the cd ;)).Please email me.Thanks
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on January 21, 2009, 10:25:34 PM
Hi Liam

My email address is in my profile actually... as far as I know, if you are logged in, you should be able to see it. I haven't found the CD, so I'll ask the man who gave it me if he can make another copy.

Steve
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Bocsa on January 22, 2009, 05:15:43 PM
Ive sent you an email through your website.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Bocsa on January 24, 2009, 04:58:06 PM
Steve, I got an email saying that an error occurred when i sent you an email :-\.Did you receive my email?Your email address on your profile is hidden.
Title: Re: Changing playing style from C/G, to B/C or C#/D
Post by: Stiamh on January 24, 2009, 08:28:31 PM
Steve, I got an email saying that an error occurred when i sent you an email :-\.Did you receive my email?Your email address on your profile is hidden.

I've sent you one! Meanwhile will try to "unhide" the email address in my profile.
Steve
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal