Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: PDarcy on May 28, 2009, 10:21:26 PM
-
A friend of mine recently found this photo of her grandmother holding a single row melodeon. The photo was taken around 1920 in Battle Ground, Indiana. Any help identifying the box would be great.
(http://www.patdarcy.com/photos/frances_lynch_cook_1920_battle_ground_indiana.jpg)
The full size photo can be seen at http://www.patdarcy.com/photos/frances_lynch_cook_1920_battle_ground_indiana.jpg (http://www.patdarcy.com/photos/frances_lynch_cook_1920_battle_ground_indiana.jpg)
Thanks,
Pat.
-
Hi Pat,
Its hard to see that melodeon even in the larger photo so cant help you there sorry. BTW hows the Paolo going?
-
Yes, it is hard to make out. I am hoping that someone will be very familiar with this model and be able to let us know.
The Paolo is going great. It's a lovely box. What are you using now in place of it?
Pat.
-
I'm glad to hear it Pat. The keyboard on that one you have is as good as I've ever played. I'm playing a 1940s grey three voice C#/D Paolo at the moment. It's louder than loud!
-
What a wonderful photograph! I printed it out to put in my scrapbook. It looks similar to the boxes that the Cajuns currently use.
It does not appear that there is a grille over the mechanism on the treble side. It looks like there are at least three stops on top of the treble side of the box.
It seems to be one of the typical German accordions that were for sale in the early 20th century in the Sears & Roebuck catalogue.
I am sure that your original photograph is much clearer that wat I see on my Web-TV.
-
This is my Grandmother Frances pictured here...
I showed this picture to a 73 year old man who lives in the US who emigrated from Clare in 1958. He said that it was a Hohner, they played them all the time back home..Another man in his late 70s from Connemara said his sisters used to play that type of box back home and seeing the picture made him sad and miss home...
Does it look like an older model Hohner?
We figure this picture was taken in the early 1920s in Indiana. I am very curious about this instrument. I knew she played the piano, but had no idea about the melodeon!!
-
It looks like there are at least three stops on top of the treble side of the box.
I see only two stops.
To me it looks as if there is one frame in the middle of the bellow?
In an old thread you can find some pictures of an old one-row Hohner pokerwork with two stops. It looks different:
http://melodeon.aimoo.com/categroy/Hohner-2-stop-and-Hohner-Help--1-441852.html
-
It looks like there are at least three stops on top of the treble side of the box.
I see only two stops.
To me it looks as if there is one frame in the middle of the bellow?
In an old thread you can find some pictures of an old one-row Hohner pokerwork with two stops. It looks different:
http://melodeon.aimoo.com/categroy/Hohner-2-stop-and-Hohner-Help--1-441852.html
That two-stop Hohner is a much more recent model.
The one in PDaryc's post is most probably not a Hohner, but one of the cheap mass-produced one-rows that came from one of the factories in Saxony in the late 19th and early 20 century. They filled the same part of the market as the Chinese do today.
-
Great photo - but yes, I think Theo is right, it could be one of quite a number of makes originating from Saxony. I've seen melodeons from this era that are totally anonymous - it could be anything, really.
Mike
-
It looks like there are at least three stops on top of the treble side of the box.
I see only two stops.
To me it looks as if there is one frame in the middle of the bellow?
In an old thread you can find some pictures of an old one-row Hohner pokerwork with two stops. It looks different:
http://melodeon.aimoo.com/categroy/Hohner-2-stop-and-Hohner-Help--1-441852.html
That two-stop Hohner is a much more recent model.
The one in PDaryc's post is most probably not a Hohner, but one of the cheap mass-produced one-rows that came from one of the factories in Saxony in the late 19th and early 20 century. They filled the same part of the market as the Chinese do today.
Thanks for this information. I wonder why the Irish guys looked at it and thought it was a Hohner like their sisters played in Ireland? Or it could be a Saxony box as well. She was a great character, I never knew she played it, so I was trying to identify it!
-
Great photo - but yes, I think Theo is right, it could be one of quite a number of makes originating from Saxony. I've seen melodeons from this era that are totally anonymous - it could be anything, really. Mike
I've mentioned before that a general rule is that if it says "Made in Saxony", the labeling indicates that it was built before the end of WW1. International treaties starting in the late 1800's require the country of origin to be indicated on an item in commerce; usually, an item made after the end of WW1 will be labeled "Made in Germany" (the individual States were joined together to make the country of Germany after WW1). But there were so many variations and such a likelihood of small manufacturers carrying on an outdated practice, that I wouldn't depend on this.
Also, as to the "anonymous" melodeons, it's not uncommon to find a "Saxony" melodeon labeled something like "Made for Fred Smith's Music Emporium, Edinburgh". Or, as Mike notes, just anonymous.
-
(the individual States were joined together to make the country of Germany after WW1)
No.
The individual states do exist till today, called länder. Every land is e. g. represented at the European Union. All german states, except the Netherlands, Luxemburg, Switzerland, Liechtenstein and Austria formed the German Reich in 1871. The Reich did exist at least till 1945. (It is debated whether the Reich ceased to exist in 1945.)