Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Dazbo on May 29, 2009, 01:24:15 PM
-
I know than unETtunings have a number of fans here and, as I've not been able to find what I want elsewhere perhaps these people can help.
I can work out the note frequencies for ET (440*2^(1/12) = A# in excel speak) and Pythagorean (440*3/2 for the E) but what equations does you tuning use (I think Theo mentions 1/4comma(?)) or do you just adjust the odd note (thirds, fifths). If you do the whole scale how do you cope with the comma at the end (ie the octave above A is not twice the frequency of the lower A)
Or do you just set your tuner to the type of tuning you want and it works it all out for you?
-
I've just had an email from Dirk of "Dirk's Accordion Tuner" who says that a new version with scads of temperaments will soon be available. So yes, that will work it all out for you.
As for doing it yourself I'd keep all the octave as true octaves and put the comma in a fifth between two notes that are rare accidentals in whichever key(s) your box is in e.g. for a D/G box between B-flat and F perhaps.
-
In most cases there is not a simple formula, because the size of all 12 semitones may be different in any given temperament. Where you 'hide' the comma varies too. in 1/4 comma meantone its all stuffed into one interval as Waltham describes, so in playing you have to avoid that interval, which is pretty easy for most melodeon playing. Temperaments like that are described as 'open' because you can't play continuously round the circle of fifths without getting a nasty surprise in one interval. There are many other temperaments where the comma is distributed equally or unequally between intervals so that you can play all round the circle of fifths. These are called closed temperaments. Examples of these on my chromatic tuner (Korg OT-12) include Werckmeister III, Young etc.
-
I know than unETtunings have a number of fans here and, as I've not been able to find what I want elsewhere perhaps these people can help.
I can work out the note frequencies for ET (440*2^(1/12) = A# in excel speak) and Pythagorean (440*3/2 for the E) but what equations does you tuning use (I think Theo mentions 1/4comma(?)) or do you just adjust the odd note (thirds, fifths). If you do the whole scale how do you cope with the comma at the end (ie the octave above A is not twice the frequency of the lower A)
Or do you just set your tuner to the type of tuning you want and it works it all out for you?
Goto here
http://pages.globetrotter.net/roule/js/acc.htm (http://pages.globetrotter.net/roule/js/acc.htm)
and it will do it all for you -- and you can hear what all the temperaments sound like.
The you'll realise just how nasty equal temperament really sounds...
Ian
-
Goto here
http://pages.globetrotter.net/roule/js/acc.htm (http://pages.globetrotter.net/roule/js/acc.htm)
and it will do it all for you -- and you can hear what all the temperaments sound like.
The you'll realise just how nasty equal temperament really sounds...
Good site, thanks for the steer. I guess that anyone interested in this topic may have already come across this recent book (http://www.amazon.co.uk/How-Equal-Temperament-Ruined-Harmony/dp/0393334201/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1244073704&sr=8-1), which I found to be very clear and interesting.
-
People who play instruments such as violin and trumpet know how "bad" equal temperament sounds compared to the "natural" note progression of scales!
-
Thanks, Dazbo for starting this thread, and also IanD for your link. This is a bit of a foggy world for me, and I'm feeling compelled to study up a bit myself... here's some other data that I have found useful, with lots of links:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_temperament
-
This is a bit of a foggy world for me, and I'm feeling compelled to study up a bit myself...
It is a huge subject so be prepared for the 'bit' to lead on to a bit more, and more...
For example try google searches for 'just intonation' and 'historic temperaments' which between them will get going on for a million links.
-
It is a huge subject so be prepared for the 'bit' to lead on to a bit more, and more...
For example try google searches for 'just intonation' and 'historic temperaments' which between them will get going on for a million links.
Yes, sounds as if, after all of these centuries, the questions have not yet quite been resolved. But then look at the questions. It's akin to "What color would look best on the living room walls, dear....? ;D
-
I guess that anyone interested in this topic may have already come across this recent book (http://www.amazon.co.uk/How-Equal-Temperament-Ruined-Harmony/dp/0393334201/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1244073704&sr=8-1), which I found to be very clear and interesting.
Yes, I picked up a copy in Seattle, when I was there for the Moisture Festival last year - it's a fascinating introduction to the subject.
It is a huge subject ...
Indeed so, one of my books on the subject (Tuning, by Owen H. Jorgenson) is about as big as many's the Family Bible, with instructions for more than 200 methods of tuning. :o
-
Oh, and I meant to mention - if you're thinking of tuning a semitone-tuned box to an unequal temperament, you could finish up with a bit of a surprise! At least, a certain Irish tuner did, maybe 20 years ago, when he was asked to tune a Hohner B/C to the same meantone tuning I'd done on a Jeffries Anglo for a friend - and found that, though the keys of D, G, A and C (in which it would be played) sounded wonderful, playing along the straight B row (which would not normally be done) sounded absolutely horrible! :o
-
Oh, and I meant to mention - if you're thinking of tuning a semitone-tuned box to an unequal temperament, you could finish up with a bit of a surprise! At least, a certain Irish tuner did, maybe 20 years ago, when he was asked to tune a Hohner B/C to the same meantone tuning I'd done on a Jeffries Anglo for a friend - and found that, though the keys of D, G, A and C (in which it would be played) sounded wonderful, playing along the straight B row (which would not normally be done) sounded absolutely horrible! :o
I was musing about this a couple of years ago with regard to a C#/D and consulted Paul Groff about it. What he said came down to the same thing - that you would have to optimize for two or three keys and be prepared for the rest to sound strange. So I gave up on the idea as a complete can of worms.
I've mentioned this before, but this man seems to developed a system - or rediscovered the system used by Bach (http://www.larips.com/) - that allows you to play in all the major and minor keys and still have different colours and nice-sounding chords. Would love to have the means to get a box tuned this way!
-
Oh, and I meant to mention - if you're thinking of tuning a semitone-tuned box to an unequal temperament, you could finish up with a bit of a surprise! At least, a certain Irish tuner did, maybe 20 years ago, when he was asked to tune a Hohner B/C to the same meantone tuning I'd done on a Jeffries Anglo for a friend - and found that, though the keys of D, G, A and C (in which it would be played) sounded wonderful, playing along the straight B row (which would not normally be done) sounded absolutely horrible! :o
I was musing about this a couple of years ago with regard to a C#/D and consulted Paul Groff about it. What he said came down to the same thing - that you would have to optimize for two or three keys and be prepared for the rest to sound strange. So I gave up on the idea as a complete can of worms.
I've mentioned this before, but this man seems to developed a system - or rediscovered the system used by Bach (http://www.larips.com/) - that allows you to play in all the major and minor keys and still have different colours and nice-sounding chords. Would love to have the means to get a box tuned this way!
And there are other "well temperaments" that are usable in every key that might be suitable for a semitone box that was to be played in a wide range of keys. For example I tuned a piano accordion to Werkmeister III, which is a tuning that is still used for some pipe organs. The owner of the accordion was also an organist, and he wanted to be able to play the accordion in concert with an organ. In this temperament all the keys are usable, but different keys have different colours, as in the rediscovered Bach tuning.
-
And there are other "well temperaments" that are usable in every key that might be suitable for a semitone box that was to be played in a wide range of keys. For example I tuned a piano accordion to Werkmeister III ...
Indeed so, which is why I was careful in how I used the terms "unequal temperament" and "meantone" in my post, but (as you'd know Theo) English concertinas weren't tuned to a normal organ scale, they have duplicated keys for Ab/G# and Eb/D# which were originally (in the mid-19th century) tuned differently like (famously) the Temple organ in London, to avoid the "wolf" in meantone, and you'd come across similar duplication of semitones in Jeffries Anglos, though the actual tuning of the latter was originally even more complicated... (Paul Groff is the man for that subject!)
Anyway, like I said, the Jeffries was tuned to meantone, then (later) the box to match, and they sound very well together on the (Fisherstreet) band's second album, which the job was done for (only you'll find, if you listen to it, they were both actually in Eb - I've been trying to simplify things by talking as if they were "concert pitch", as would be common here in Ireland).
-
[Mention of Berlioz coming in three, two, one,...]
-
[Mention of Berlioz coming in three, two, one,...]
Wot, and get marched to the scaffold... ???
Fantastique! :P
-
All this is itching the scratch for me... a raft of questions:
I tuned a piano accordion to Werkmeister III, which is a tuning that is still used for some pipe organs.
Theo, I read in another post of yours that you have this temperament on your electronic tuner, which must have made the task easier for you! How did you handle the gap for other voices in the same octave, if there were any? In the usual way?
BTW Steve, looking at this here tuner: http://www.americanmusical.com/Item--i-KOR-OT120 it offers two meantone settings, one Eb and one D#. Do you know what this means, and did Korg include them for concertina tuners? ;)
I gather from a bit of googling that some electronic keyboards allow you to select a variety temperaments at the touch of a button. Has anyone experimented with different temperaments on such an instrument to see if any of them are more satisfying for trad?
Thinking about the electronic tuner makes me wonder: does anybody know whether any electronic tuners allow you to calibrate odd temperaments yourself, e.g. via a computer link? For example, if one could get hold of the values for the Bradley Lehman "Bach" tuning I linked to earlier...
-
All this is itching the scratch for me... a raft of questions:
I tuned a piano accordion to Werkmeister III, which is a tuning that is still used for some pipe organs.
Theo, I read in another post of yours that you have this temperament on your electronic tuner, which must have made the task easier for you! How did you handle the gap for other voices in the same octave, if there were any? In the usual way?
Yes, exactly the same way with the tuner set to the temperament in question, then I shift the reference pitch for A up to the offset I want. Of course that raises the question of how the offset changes up the scale, but that is a separate question.
BTW I use the Korg OT 120 tuner which you linked to below (though the link didn't work for me)
BTW Steve, looking at this here tuner: http://www.americanmusical.com/Item--i-KOR-OT120 it offers two meantone settings, one Eb and one D#. Do you know what this means, and did Korg include them for concertina tuners? ;)
It means do you want the note between D and E to be D# or Eb. In effect you are choosing where to put the wolf interval, either above or below that note.
I gather from a bit of googling that some electronic keyboards allow you to select a variety temperaments at the touch of a button. Has anyone experimented with different temperaments on such an instrument to see if any of them are more satisfying for trad?
Thinking about the electronic tuner makes me wonder: does anybody know whether any electronic tuners allow you to calibrate odd temperaments yourself, e.g. via a computer link? For example, if one could get hold of the values for the Bradley Lehman "Bach" tuning I linked to earlier...
Petersen strobe tuners (http://www.petersontuners.com/) let you set up your own scales, and so does Dirks Accordion Tuner (http://www.dirksprojects.nl/)
-
Continuing on this subject, it follows that the simpler instruments, i.e. one and two row melodeons (excluding the Irish chromatic, or improved one row systems, ) would not really benefit from ET tuning. The cajun boxes already demonstrate this by either approaching or achieving Just tuning. My question is this: why are Quebecois or Irish one row (or two row standard layout) boxes tuned in ET? Why not in a temperament more favorable to the keys capable by the box? If wolf fifth can be hidden in a corner never accessed by these instruments, why not use a temperament that will accomplish that? ????............jwf
-
Continuing on this subject, it follows that the simpler instruments, i.e. one and two row melodeons (excluding the Irish chromatic, or improved one row systems, ) would not really benefit from ET tuning.
Oh but they do, as long as you don't have to play them with ET tuned instruments...
The cajun boxes already demonstrate this by either approaching or achieving Just tuning.
They don't even approach it, let alone achieve it. They only arbitrarily flatten the thirds by 15 cents.
My question is this: why are Quebecois or Irish one row (or two row standard layout) boxes tuned in ET?
Because other fixed pitch instruments are tuned in ET - pianos, accordions, concertinas (though not all harmonicas) and they'd clash.
-
My question is this: why are Quebecois or Irish one row (or two row standard layout) boxes tuned in ET?
Because other fixed pitch instruments are tuned in ET - pianos, accordions, concertinas (though not all harmonicas) and they'd clash.
This means that if other instruments are involved,tuned in ET, that a non-ET tuned instrument will clash. So it then follows that a non-ET tuned instrument will sound more in tune, but only when played solo? I don't mean to be intentionally obtuse, at least no more than is naturally possible............ ;D
-
So it then follows that a non-ET tuned instrument will sound more in tune, but only when played solo?
Or when played with other fixed-pitch instruments in the same non-ET intonation, or with instruments having more flexible intonation - like violins or flutes...
It depends on which particular unequal temperament(s) you're using, but some notes could finish up being a third (or more) of a semitone different - and even half that is very noticeable.
-
So it then follows that a non-ET tuned instrument will sound more in tune, but only when played solo? I don't mean to be intentionally obtuse, at least no more than is naturally possible............ ;D
"In tune" is relative in several ways, including not only relative to other instruments you are playing with but also, and perhaps more subjectively, relative to the key and mode you are playing in.
If everyone played all the time in mainly the same key then it would sound sweet (to most ears) for every instrument to be tuned to a just intonation (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just_intonation) based on that key. But this is relative to that specific key.
Most modern instruments, like piano accordions, are designed and tuned to be playable in a wide variety of keys and modulations. This requires some form of compromise with just intonation, standardly ET. So for example a one-row melodeon sweetly tuned to play in say C major will have some notes (notably E) that audibly clash with the corresponding notes on an ET-tuned instrument. But neither of the two is (more) "in tune" in any absolute sense.
-
Thanks for the replies, they are quite illuminating. What I am driving at is this: if one is playing music in a genre, say Irish, for instance, and the large majority of tunes is in a small handful of keys, say D, G, A, and relative minors, and was accompanied by flutes, whistles, fiddle, other fretted instruments, would it be imprudent to have your concertina or melodeon tuned in a non-ET temperament? This, of course would exclude pianoforte, or PA, horns, and possibly other woodwinds. I am interested in an alternative tuning for my 30b anglo, as I play mostly solo and use lots of chords. I would not like to sacrifice the ability to play reasonably in tune with other instruments, though, although I'm sure I am not likely to play along with flueglehorns or harpsichords, but the occasional guitar, mandolin, fiddle, flute, etc. I have noticed many systems of non-ET tuning, and have toyed with them on the Java Tuner site. It is hard for me to judge which might be the least radical in terms of deviation from ET, but the Lehman system looks interesting. Any thoughts out there?........................ :||:
-
You could be quite popular with fiddle players. I've only been fiddling a couple of years but the major thirds seem all wrong when when I play together with my wife on PA.
-
You married a piano accordionist!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
All things being equal, it's just a matter of temperament. Having said that, is there a bad temperament tuning? AL ;D