Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Stiamh on May 29, 2009, 01:24:30 PM

Title: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Stiamh on May 29, 2009, 01:24:30 PM
It seems that manic boy wonder Tim Edey has got himself a variant of the Shand system, a C#/D/D#, although without stradella bass. It will be interesting to see what he does with it after a while, although he's making a pretty splashy start: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pNHvx-D00PA

I actually had the idea of a C#/D/D# a few years ago when Theo had a Trichord for sale, but decided I was too old to go down that path.

Another 3-row halfstep variant I have seen was a 2-v D/C#/C box (yes, in that order) that André Bouchard had a couple of years ago. (He's now gone over to a 3-v D/C#)
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Owen Woods on May 29, 2009, 01:43:35 PM
I cannot stress how happy that video has made me :P Fantastic stuff.

I am very keen to try the BCC# and the C#D (if I were to get a three row it would be either the BCC# or the C#DG) but actually the C#DD# would make a lot of sense.

So many fingering systems, so little money with which to try them :(
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Dazbo on May 29, 2009, 02:37:50 PM
variant of the Shand system, a C#/D/D

 ;DSurely that should be DbDD# ;D
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Theo on May 29, 2009, 02:51:40 PM
Julian Sutton has been using a C#/D/D# system for some years.  He uses it almost exclusively for Irish style music.
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Stiamh on May 29, 2009, 03:08:05 PM
So when is somebody going whack a D row onto a Shand system: B/C/C#/D ?

No wait a minute, why not a B/C/C#/D/D# ? 
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Andy Simpson on May 29, 2009, 03:31:02 PM
When's someone going to tell all these people seeking the ability to play chromatically and with better bass accompaniment by adding ever more rows and stradella bass about the continental button accordion?. ;D
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: triskel on May 29, 2009, 04:23:12 PM
So when is somebody going whack a D row onto a Shand system: B/C/C#/D ?

That's just what I think the Scottish "melodeon great" James Brown (http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?s=&showtopic=2347&view=findpost&p=22950) probably did, 90-odd years ago (and long before Jimmy Shand took up the B/C/C#):

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/JamesBrown1879-1919edit.jpg)
James Brown with 4-row
 Paolo Soprani and trophies,
 c.1918.

It would have enabled him to play in "the Scottish keys" of A and E, using G and D fingering, just as Shand sometimes did on a C#/D.

Quote
No wait a minute, why not a B/C/C#/D/D# ?  

OMG! :o
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: TomB-R on May 29, 2009, 08:11:34 PM
As a D/D# player, (the only one here last time I looked at the systems poll  ;D ) I looked at C#/D/D#, on paper at least, and came to the conclusion that it didn't add enough to D/D# to be worth pursuing for the sort of playing I do. (But then, I'm no Tim Edey!) I wasn't thinking too much about chordal playing on the right hand end.
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Lars on May 29, 2009, 09:51:01 PM
As a D/D# player, (the only one here last time I looked at the systems poll  ;D )

I do play D/D# - though for E-flat session use, and at home since I prefer the higher pitched sound:)

Tim is an amazing player, and a very funny guy indeed! (so far the only participant of the local session ever to get out of his seat and drag the entire session out into the streets to much amusement of passing cars who suddently found themselves surrounded by banjos, flutes, and dancing people holding pintglasses!) He used to have a danish girlfriend, so a couple of years ago he was hanging around copenhagen numerous times a year. Back then he was playing either his D/G saltarelle or his B/C Castagnari Dinn II.

I remember one night a couple of years ago when he told me about these plans. He was thinking about a 3-row castagnari, but I disagreed (due to a friend getting a not-so-great custom made C#/D/G made by costalotti) leading to a long discussion about boxes and rows. I thought it was just another one of his crazy plans and that he would never go down that route, but I must agree that it turned out rather well! Well done, Tim!

But am I the only one who thinks the D# row sounds muted? I know the inside row often has less volume than the other(s), but still - the sound difference is quite significant.
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Owen Woods on May 29, 2009, 10:17:41 PM
As a D/D# player, (the only one here last time I looked at the systems poll  ;D )

I do play D/D# - though for E-flat session use, and at home since I prefer the higher pitched sound:)

Tim is an amazing player, and a very funny guy indeed! (so far the only participant of the local session ever to get out of his seat and drag the entire session out into the streets to much amusement of passing cars who suddently found themselves surrounded by banjos, flutes, and dancing people holding pintglasses!) He used to have a danish girlfriend, so a couple of years ago he was hanging around copenhagen numerous times a year. Back then he was playing either his D/G saltarelle or his B/C Castagnari Dinn II.

I remember one night a couple of years ago when he told me about these plans. He was thinking about a 3-row castagnari, but I disagreed (due to a friend getting a not-so-great custom made C#/D/G made by costalotti) leading to a long discussion about boxes and rows. I thought it was just another one of his crazy plans and that he would never go down that route, but I must agree that it turned out rather well! Well done, Tim!

But am I the only one who thinks the D# row sounds muted? I know the inside row often has less volume than the other(s), but still - the sound difference is quite significant.

I know what you mean, I can hear it on the recording. I coudln't say whether it would be a problem or not.

Now if it were me I'd ask Saltarelle to marry it with a Stradella bass end... if only I had the cash :P
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: TomB-R on May 30, 2009, 12:24:47 PM
Enjoyed the video. Reminded me strongly of Mairtin O'Connor, (not surprisingly) who, apart from being amazing, is a noted player of D/D# !!!!!
Tom
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Owen Woods on May 30, 2009, 12:47:48 PM
Enjoyed the video. Reminded me strongly of Mairtin O'Connor, (not surprisingly) who, apart from being amazing, is a noted player of D/D# !!!!!
Tom

Oh is he? I didn't realise that was his system. I recently borrowed one of his albums off a friend, a fine player. Meaning so far ahead of me that he's over the horizon.
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Stiamh on June 01, 2009, 01:08:12 PM
Well he plays a D/D# box but he's an "inside-out" player. He plays it like a C#/D, so for practical purposes it's an "Eb" box.
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: TomB-R on June 01, 2009, 01:30:08 PM
Well he plays a D/D# box but he's an "inside-out" player. He plays it like a C#/D, so for practical purposes it's an "Eb" box.

True enough!  ;D
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Owen Woods on June 01, 2009, 07:18:39 PM
Well he plays a D/D# box but he's an "inside-out" player. He plays it like a C#/D, so for practical purposes it's an "Eb" box.

Ah I see. That would make sense, and explain why all his stuff are in insane keys as well.
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Red Diesel on June 08, 2009, 07:54:18 PM
Hi all...
I play a D D# Saltarelle (still not sold!!) which you can hear at www.myspace.com/ciarankelly01
or see on youtube if you google "Saltarelle Super Nuage" (4 clips) or "tcz60"

My late uncle, who taught me how to play 45 years ago, gave me his old Hohner D D# to get me started. When he died he was playing a C# D D# Paolo Soprani- a monster of a box. The size and weight put me off straight away, and I have had no inclinations to get a three row of my own since. It sounds nice in theory, but in practice..
well... just my opinion, don't take it too seriously!
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: Bocsa on June 10, 2009, 06:12:38 PM
Quote
But am I the only one who thinks the D# row sounds muted? I know the inside row often has less volume than the other(s), but still - the sound difference is quite significant.

It does sound very weak :-\
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: melodeon on June 10, 2009, 08:12:57 PM
FWIW

I read an interview with Jimmy Shand from many years back

He said that if he had to do it all over again  he would play the CBA  Chromatic button accordion.
He said the reason he did not switch is that he had so many years behind him with the B/C/C# ;   in spite of the far superior CBA versatilty and ease of play. His words.
Title: Re: C#/D/D# !
Post by: melodeon on June 10, 2009, 08:20:06 PM
Tim Eady's usual brilliant playing

inner row seemed a bit muted

I will bet dollars to crullers  that Saltarelle put decent reeds in this box  rather than their usual mediocre reeds considering it was for Tim Eady.

BTW  the Gagne brothers  in Quebec claim they designed the Laurentide for Saltarelle
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal