Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: malcolmbebb on December 16, 2015, 11:20:07 PM

Title: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 16, 2015, 11:20:07 PM
I have a couple of broken Hohner fingerboards, with the web missing between several keys. Common damage, it seems. One is a pressed wood, the other an Erica.

I was wondering about repairing rather than replacing them. Is this viable - do you need to be a dab hand with a router?

Suggestions?
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Theo on December 16, 2015, 11:46:29 PM
You could either:
Slice off the broken top, cut a replacement from ply, plastic or metal, cut button holes, drill and countersink screw holes
or
Carefully fit and glue patches into the broken areas, re-cut button holes, refinish the surface
or
Just buy some of the lovely replacement fingerboard from Acorn Instruments, they fit, it's easy to adjust button travel, (and I'm not on commission)
The old fingerboards make really good kindling for your wood stove:-)
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on December 17, 2015, 01:17:03 AM
Like!
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 17, 2015, 05:24:21 AM

or
Carefully fit and glue patches into the broken areas, re-cut button holes, refinish the surface


That's what I usually do; I generally use a piece of lime (linden in most of the rest of the world) as it's pale coloured, takes stain well and has very little discernible grain. Rather than try to glue in patches edge-to-edge, I first put in a backing piece of 1mm ply to provide plenty of gluing surface.

Graham
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Adam-T on December 17, 2015, 07:43:33 AM
Good idea Graham, 1mm underneath  isn`t going to foul the button ....... sadly Acorn Instruments don`t make Club-One , Too/Erika , pre-Corso sizes ones (or tops for those with removable tops as few have the tools to accurately drill a new top well) or standard ones with pressed graphics so repair ideas are valuable .

I`m thankfully getting a used one for my Club Too from Robotmay when he`s dug it out but I`m going to have a go at gluing the old one and trial gap repair techniques on it (which now don`t matter if they fail)
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: mr hohner on December 17, 2015, 08:55:44 AM
Or build your own, hard work but satisfying
 (:)
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Lars on December 17, 2015, 09:30:17 AM
I've previously repaired a few keyboards, but I always made a removable back plate too, for ease of padding and adjusting. Removing some of the back surface makes it a lot easier to insert patches, and put reinforcing struts on the back, as the rather crude inner surface benefits from some sanding to ensure a good, flat surface.

Version one:
With a small router base (on a dremel-type router), rout out a rectangle 1 mm deep, covering the back of all buttons. Then, rout all the way through, leaving 5 mm all the way around for the panel to rest on. Cut 1 mm alu to the right size, fit to the countersunk 'hole', countersink screw holes and install with appropiate screws to the back, resting on the 5 mm 'shelf'. Install felt (you might want to put the felt on a 4 mm wooden strip to avoid having to install too high felt padding).

Version two:
On a router table, rout out a channel all the way across the back of the fingerboard, leaving about 1 cm at the edges towards the thumb and 'box' sides. Rout about 5-6 mm deep, depending on the plywood avaiable. Cut a strip of stiff ply or hardwood to fit the channel in a tight, snug fit, install with screw at the ends. If possible, rout with a slight angle, so the strip/panel fits in a dovetail manner. It will need to be contoured at the ends to match the keyboard, and naturally painted or stained. Install felt, and voila, your own removable back panel on an old wooden keyboard.

None of these are however a match for Pete and Jilly's Acorn keyboards. No commision here either, just a great product.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: mr hohner on December 17, 2015, 10:16:51 AM
The hardest part of making key board I found was drilling the holes to the right size!!! To start of with I used a router ( I think that's what there called) to drill into solid oak. I then put a thin piece of wood between back and front and drilled the marked out holes (this requires real accuracy, I made lots of mistakes until I got it right)!!! I then used a dremnel mini sanding piece to make the holes the oval shape they need to be, this was time consuming but satisfying!!! If you have some spare time make your own keyboard, hard work but satisfying at the end!!!
Cheers
Mr hohner
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Broadland Boy on December 17, 2015, 02:06:22 PM
Have you discovered lip and spur drills Mr H ? much easier to start accurately from a centre pop and cuts a much smoother hole, also a little more forgiving if the hole needs to be a little off 90 degrees to the surface.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Theo on December 17, 2015, 02:10:44 PM
And another tip is that it is not actually necessary to make the holes oval.   Hohner is the only maker I can think of that does this, and then only on some models. Most club models for example have circular holes.   I suspect the reason for the oval holes is that it saves having to make any individual adjustments to centralise buttons to avoid making contact with the edge of the hole.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 17, 2015, 02:35:33 PM
On Hohner mechanisms you only have side to side adjustment (and height,of course), the length of the arms is fixed, so I have wondered why there is extra clearance in that direction. 

I should confess that I have a couple of Pete's fingerboards in waiting (and, unusually, know exactly where they are).
But I was thinking that, mainly for the presswood, it would be nice to keep the original if a repair was a sensible option.
If I do, the removable back seems a pretty good idea.

Not having a wood burner...

(Goes away to Google lip and spur drills - oh, those... wondered what they were called...)
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: boxcall on December 17, 2015, 02:50:25 PM
I went with the Insert method, I found the holes to be easy enough using a drill press with a fence that has center of drill marked on it. then layout holes on finger bd. and line up the marks when drilling.
I started at the top of the hole and drilled those then I put a small strip of wood between fence and finger bd. then drilled all holes again to elongate. cleanup holes with sand paper.
For the cut out in the finger board I use a router with flush cut bit( the ones with bearing on the top),
I cut a slot in a piece of quaility plywood (no voids) the size I wanted, then I lined up the finger bd. in the slot I just made in the plywood. I corraled the finger bd. with scraps of wood hot glued in place.
then clamped the lot down on to bench and cut out slot in fnger bd.
The strip with holes I cut out useing table saw and chop saw then I rounded corners by hand.
I also made a finger bd. out of cherry ( posted here somwhere) I sent it to another member.

seen here

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16508.0;attach=16052


Edit: no layout on finger bd. needed in insert method as I just put strip in the slot in finger bd. , filled in the space inside the finger bd. with a backer for drilling and used the tick marks at base of finger bd. for layout when driling.


Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: mr hohner on December 17, 2015, 05:14:53 PM
And another tip is that it is not actually necessary to make the holes oval.   Hohner is the only maker I can think of that does this, and then only on some models. Most club models for example have circular holes.   I suspect the reason for the oval holes is that it saves having to make any individual adjustments to centralise buttons to avoid making contact with the edge of the hole.

I've found that it gives the buttons some clearence to travel up and down at the slight angle there at, it seems to "run" smoother this way than when they were round.
Cheers
Mr hohner
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Theo on December 17, 2015, 05:37:52 PM
On Hohner mechanisms you only have side to side adjustment (and height,of course), the length of the arms is fixed,

It can be adjusted by putting a kink in the lever, same as in Italian boxes.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Adam-T on December 17, 2015, 05:56:38 PM
Yeah, I`ve seen plenty of Coronas and corsos with curvy levers straighten them and the buttons are off centre
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 17, 2015, 06:24:39 PM
On Hohner mechanisms you only have side to side adjustment (and height,of course), the length of the arms is fixed,

It can be adjusted by putting a kink in the lever, same as in Italian boxes.

Ah. Hadn't met that.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 17, 2015, 07:23:15 PM
And another tip is that it is not actually necessary to make the holes oval.   Hohner is the only maker I can think of that does this, and then only on some models. Most club models for example have circular holes.   I suspect the reason for the oval holes is that it saves having to make any individual adjustments to centralise buttons to avoid making contact with the edge of the hole.

Perfectly true; but if you're patching up an existing unit that already has elongated (they're actually not "oval" in the strict sense of the word) holes you really don't have a lot of choice other than to try and match them as closely as you can.

Graham
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: pete /acorn on December 17, 2015, 09:01:14 PM
Hi
For the pressed wood I supply them in the white [not painted]] to colour and polish yourselves.

Pete

www.acorninstruments.co.uk
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 17, 2015, 09:13:47 PM
Hi
For the pressed wood I supply them in the white [not painted]] to colour and polish yourselves.

Pete

www.acorninstruments.co.uk
I would describe the one I have as "natural" rather than "white"   (:)
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: pete /acorn on December 17, 2015, 09:31:20 PM
''In the white'' is a term used in the furniture manufacturing industry to describe products as in natural state un painted or polished
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 17, 2015, 09:46:49 PM
Amazing what you learn here!  ;D
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Theo on December 17, 2015, 09:53:43 PM
I'm old enough to remember white wood kitchen units.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: playandteach on December 17, 2015, 10:47:19 PM
In the white is also how violin makers refer to yet-to-be varnished (and loud) natural state instruments. Violin varnishes are often well kept secrets and some British makers import (often excellent) violins in various states from China and finish them off. Not a con, just another option for buyers of budget instruments.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Broadland Boy on December 17, 2015, 11:55:52 PM
I remember the delight when a new whitewood unit replaced one of mums 'War Utility' plywood kitchen cupboards (from the early prefab period) Wind forward 45 years, the 'new' one has sagged and bent under a nominal kitchen load whereas its predecessor, relocated to the garage and subjected to an obscene amount of tool and fixings storage, remains straight and true - I suspect some sort of conclusion could be drawn..........
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Adam-T on December 18, 2015, 11:01:03 AM
Yep - that Plywood is vastly underrated - Boxwise most Hohners have battled on with it for eons while costalottis with their solid wood have suffered cracks and warping . the wood used has no affect on the sound anyway so may as well use the most practical stuff out there - Plywood
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 18, 2015, 11:22:40 AM
Yep - that Plywood is vastly underrated - Boxwise most Hohners have battled on with it for eons while costalottis with their solid wood have suffered cracks and warping . the wood used has no affect on the sound anyway so may as well use the most practical stuff out there - Plywood

Another vote for plywood; it's stable, strong and relatively cheap. My ancient Saltarelle is made of veneered ply and despite years of hard use (and abuse!) is as solid and straight as the day it was bought new.

Graham
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Psuggmog Volbenz on December 23, 2015, 09:27:51 PM
I just finished repairing a damaged button board on a presswood Koch G/C after this thread had started. I photo documented the repair. I used hot hide glue to stabilize 9 cracks and install a missing segment. This type of glue only allows a about 90 seconds of working time before the glues cools down and is ineffective. I used this type of glue because it was used in the original construction, is superior to modern glues for certain applications, and is possible to remove without damage to the instrument if desired at a later date. I thought about why the button board structure failed. I concluded that failure was due to excess flexing of the wood during playing cycles.  Plywood retrofit substrate is a common repair strategy. I decided to try a different approach this time. I stiffened the assembly by adding three pine compression blocks in the routed out cavity at the outboard edge. I added one compression post at the central inner edge. Because the button board has to slide over the keys to install, there wasn't enough room for a block at the inner edge. The central outboard compression block provided the added benefit of internal support of the patch piece applied to the top of the button board between the keys. This was approach required the fabrication and fitting of the compression blocks and post, but negates the cutting of the 21 openings in the plywood substrate used in the more common repair strategy. The repaired button board is very stiff without noticeable weight added from repair materials.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Psuggmog Volbenz on December 23, 2015, 09:46:43 PM
Here are more photos of the repair process. Someone had attached a thump strap using a #14 sheet metal screw. The original strap was attached with two #4 screws with a metal plate between the screw heads and the strap. This instrument still had the original mounting holes. I made wooden inserts out of pine and plugged the inappropriate holes. The original metal plate was tin plated steel,  and was missing on this box. I made a new one and attached the strap with screws similar to the missing original ones. The shortest screws I could find were too long for this application, so I made a fixture to hold the screws while I shortened them using a hand cranked grinder.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Psuggmog Volbenz on December 23, 2015, 09:58:13 PM
This instrument had another problem. One of the pallets wasn't sealing on the pallet board. This was due to a spring tension problem. Someone had replaced the spring with one made from a safety pin. I usually make replacement springs out of piano or guitar string wire depending on the gauge of wire required. I decided to try to modify the offending spring in place before disassembling the action to make and install a new one. I made a tool to disconnect the spring. I trimmed the spring and then bent it in place to create tension similar to the original springs still on the other keys.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Psuggmog Volbenz on December 23, 2015, 10:04:34 PM
This box still had the cotton string gasket which was leaking. I made a one piece foam gasket as a replacement. I try to use a color which comes close to the bellows frame color. The last photos shows the repaired button board on the reassembled instrument.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on December 23, 2015, 10:06:12 PM
"The original metal plate" and "I made a new one". You make it sound so easy!  ;D
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 23, 2015, 10:18:22 PM
Thanks for posting that, most interesting. Did you use a piece of ply to fill in the missing web, or did you still have that piece?
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Psuggmog Volbenz on December 23, 2015, 10:20:54 PM
"The original metal plate" and "I made a new one". You make it sound so easy!  ;D
The pictures tell the story. I used an original plate found on the bass strap attachment end for the pattern. The shape was cut out with a tool called a hand nibbler. The final shaping was done with a small file. The holes were punched before forming  the final shape so that less deformation of the metal occurred. A hand punch or an awl will work for this, but the punch makes less of a burr, which should be removed.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Psuggmog Volbenz on December 23, 2015, 10:30:03 PM
Thanks for posting that, most interesting. Did you use a piece of ply to fill in the missing web, or did you still have that piece?
No plywood was used in this repair. I was fortunate to find the missing piece stuck in the metal action near one of the lower pallets. That piece had fallen into the cavity in the button board and then migrated to the pallet board area where it became lodged. When I resort to using plywood for this type of repair, I like to use plywood made for model airplane construction. It is very high quality and comes thicknesses of down to about 1.5mm.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Adam-T on December 24, 2015, 08:24:40 AM
I used two matchsticks to fill the gap on my Club-Too one , glued in with PVA which I also used to glue the cracks in the others.. used a round file to complete the circle of the hole , more PVA underneath to make sure ..

Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Psuggmog Volbenz on December 24, 2015, 09:52:59 AM
I used two matchsticks to fill the gap on my Club-Too one , glued in with PVA which I also used to glue the cracks in the others.. used a round file to complete the circle of the hole , more PVA underneath to make sure ..

I often use pieces of pine cut from paint stirring paddles which are available free for the asking at a nearby hardware store. I used this type of wood for the compression blocks in the repair of Koch shown in previous posts in this thread. I have also used this wood for making new wooden bass and breather valves in the "growler boxes" of one row German style melodeons. I once made an extension piece for a treble board which had been damaged from shrinkage and cracking. The pine in these stirring paddles is a close match to the pine often used in the old prewar Saxony boxes. The wooden match sticks around here are usually made from a variety of poplar. When I glue cracks, such as the ones pictured in your repair, I use dental picks to remove any loose or dislodged wood fibers before glueing, to ensue a tighter fit. The hot hide glue I often use is not a good gap filler.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 24, 2015, 10:14:33 AM
I like to use plywood made for model airplane construction. It is very high quality and comes thicknesses of down to about 1.5mm.

Thinner, in fact; I use 1mm for casework repair reinforcement, and I have some 0.7mm and 0.5mm in my heap stock of materials. All these thicknesses were standard stock in my local model shop in the UK.

Graham
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Lester on December 24, 2015, 11:33:25 AM
My favourite source for thin strip wood is Costa Coffee (other coffee shops are available) their stirrers come in useful for all sorts of things.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Adam-T on December 24, 2015, 11:39:31 AM
Sounds ideal Lester, I don`t like messing with plywood in such small pieces as bits pick off the top or bottom layers . those paint stirrers of P.V`s sound interesting .. PVA is a great gap filler and tough too ....

on a similar subject . Do Acorn do a wooden fingerboard for Coronas - very late German ones came with plastic , it`s OK but I prefer the "Classic-II" wood and celly ones

Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Broadland Boy on December 25, 2015, 12:29:23 AM
Glad you were not collecting stirrers in Westerham Lester - terrible start to Christmas  :(
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 25, 2015, 10:49:40 AM
Chip forks from the chip shop are pretty good, too.
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on December 25, 2015, 01:02:25 PM
Unless you get them from Rlck Steins chippy in Padstow..... They're wooden but shaped like the real thing.  (:)
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Hasse on December 26, 2015, 10:35:00 AM
Of course depending on several factors, but one choice is to do nothing or as little as possible...

On of my old favorite C#/D boxes have a really rough appearance and it got a real worn down keyboard cover, but it simply suites the box as it is. For long I thought about replacing the missing wood, but the thing is that it just looks natural on that old worn out box. With this box it was just the right thing to do nothing or (in honesty) as little as possible to make it sound great and still save all signs of years of playing before my time enjoying box.

Well…  ::)
Title: Re: Repairing Hohner wooden fingerboards
Post by: Psuggmog Volbenz on December 28, 2015, 06:03:25 AM
Of course depending on several factors, but one choice is to do nothing or as little as possible...

On of my old favorite C#/D boxes have a really rough appearance and it got a real worn down keyboard cover, but it simply suites the box as it is. For long I thought about replacing the missing wood, but the thing is that it just looks natural on that old worn out box. With this box it was just the right thing to do nothing or (in honesty) as little as possible to make it sound great and still save all signs of years of playing before my time enjoying box.

Well…  ::)

I had thought about doing nothing to the keyboard on the Koch described above, but there were structural issues and the deterioration of the keyboard was progressing. I decided to repair the cracks and replace the missing piece, and structurally improve the design shortcomings. I left the wear at the edges of the button holes as seen in the reassembled photo above.  I like the patina which comes only from extended usage. The wear patterns can provide insight into an instrument's past.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal