Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: mselic on December 19, 2015, 04:30:10 AM

Title: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: mselic on December 19, 2015, 04:30:10 AM
Forgive me if there is another post regarding this already, but if there is I couldn't find it.  All of the accordions that I have played have had treble buttons that will disappear down the hole when pushed (I DO know that people can limit this type of button travel with a bar or rod installed within the keyboard).  The other style of treble button is the "mushroom"-type that has a positive stop when the wide part of the button makes contact with the keyboard.  I am looking for opinions on the difference between the two.  Would anyone say that button action is faster on one or the other? Does it make any difference? Other things to consider?  I imagine it is a case of personal preference, but I would love to hear feedback from folks here with their experiences.  Thanks.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Theo on December 19, 2015, 07:38:41 AM
I play one of each type and don't notice the difference when playing.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Sebastian on December 19, 2015, 09:49:31 AM
I imagine it is a case of personal preference
Yes, probably. And maybe of playing technique. When I try to play mushroom-type treble buttons, my fingers tend to get caught between the cap of the mushroom and the keyboard, due to my own clumsiness. ;D

Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: benammiswift on December 19, 2015, 10:04:17 AM
I play a D/G/Acc Castagnari that has mushroom buttons and an old CF hohner club that has the buttons that go down into the fingerboard.  If the action is properly limited on the Hohner style buttons I don't notice any difference.

Benammi
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: squeezy on December 19, 2015, 10:45:04 AM
The main difference is with the type of construction of the keyboard associated with both kinds of buttons. 

For the 'disappearing down the holes' type (or not if it is limited) they are normally firmly attached to a metal lever which opens the pallets.  High quality keyboards have these levers made from thick metal (normally aluminium) with some kind of mechanism which means it doesn't flex or rock on the axle.  But on cheaper instruments this assembly is often made of thinner metal and creates a less responsive and noisy action because of the flexibility.

The majority of instruments which have the 'mushroom' type buttons have them screwed to a wooden strip which is fed through a comb at the axle and opens the pallets via a separate piece of metal attached to the wooden strip.  This type of keyboard is often firmer and more responsive ... but can suffer from it's own problems such as friction or sticking buttons at times of high humidity.  It also allows for greater button travel (meaning the pallets can open wider) without the problem of fingers down the holes.  A pallet which opens further will allow a stronger volume and tone to be achieved from the reed than one which can only open a fraction ... a down-side to the practice of restricting Hohner actions!

In terms of playing the actual button shape doesn't make a huge amount of difference - the mushroom type buttons often are on a more stepped keyboard which requires a bit more finger movement in general playing but allows things like triplets to be achieved on the inside row without clattering in to the outside buttons much more easily.  For me, the material the button itself is made from is far more important.  A dense, hard, highly polished button connected to a firm, free action is the best ... most posh boxes come equipped with Italian ones made from a good dense plastic for both kinds of keyboard.  But since receiving my Albrecht which has handmade abalone buttons which are better than any other instrument I have played - I realise this could be improved by using harder materials than plastic (shaped and polished quartz? Expensive!)  One of the down-sides of the otherwise amazingly built Hohners from the 1930s is that their buttons are almost always plastic and have become pitted, creating a friction on the buttons which makes them impossible to play at speed comfortably.

At Button Boxes & Moothies this year I tried one of the new Saltarelle boxes designed to replace the Connemara / Pastourelle II which came with mushroom buttons on a closed stepped keyboard (bizarre that I cannot see them featured on the Saltarelle website yet) ... anyway, these were equipped with a really inferior kind of mushroom button that I hadn't seen before, made from a much lighter material and substantially less smooth than the regular Italian mushroom buttons that Saltarelles have always come with before.  The action was also worse than the one it's predecessors had with much more sideways movement, leading to a decidedly cheap feel.

Anyway ... I've probably gone on too much! But excellent topic - because buttons and actions are often overlooked and they are really important to the playing experience - and at the top end can actually limit what you are able to do on the instruments.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: mselic on December 19, 2015, 03:24:31 PM
Thanks, Squeezy! That's a very informative answer and exactly the kind of information I am looking for!
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: nigelr on December 19, 2015, 07:57:33 PM
...
At Button Boxes & Moothies this year I tried one of the new Saltarelle boxes designed to replace the Connemara / Pastourelle II which came with mushroom buttons on a closed stepped keyboard (bizarre that I cannot see them featured on the Saltarelle website yet) ... anyway, these were equipped with a really inferior kind of mushroom button that I hadn't seen before, made from a much lighter material and substantially less smooth than the regular Italian mushroom buttons that Saltarelles have always come with before.  The action was also worse than the one it's predecessors had with much more sideways movement, leading to a decidedly cheap feel.
...
I hope this sort of feedback has been communicated to Salterelle. As someone who is possibly in the market for a 2.5 row this type of comment would put me off buying from them. Hopefully if they know the opinion of a respected player, they might think again. N
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: melodeon on December 19, 2015, 08:44:30 PM
Saltarelle does not make accordeons.  They send out for bids.. the lowest bid. As of the last few years it has been Dino Baffetti. Perhaps they have found a lower bidder.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Rob2Hook on December 19, 2015, 09:25:04 PM
God forbid that they should follow Hohner into China...

Rob.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: squeezy on December 19, 2015, 11:25:13 PM
The Saltarelle I played in Aberdeen had a distinctly worrying Chinese feel about it ... but the guy selling them was keen to point out that they weren't made in China.  Apart from playing this instrument which bore the Saltarelle badge, I know nothing about this model, not even the name of it.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Matthew Rickard on December 20, 2015, 01:39:52 AM
Excellent post and well timed for me as I'm just now reaching the stage in my beginners playing where I am learning what I like. I have found the "mushrooms" buttons with a closed stepped keyboard to be my preference by far. Squeezy's post is excellent and gives all the technical explanation for all of the playability aspects I've discovered I prefer - the ease of triplets, the increased responsiveness.

But one thing I'm also discovering is that one melodeon and therefore one type of keyboard is never enough... I'm sure my taste will change further as my playing style develops.

Same with you. Go play as many instruments as you can and buy the one you enjoy playing the most, and don't be surprised if in a year you do the same and find yourself enjoying something different.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: melodeon on December 20, 2015, 08:42:59 PM
I like diving buttons and I like mushrooms.

I have no preference for either.

However on a 2 row stepped box I prefer the shrooms  and on flat keyboard boxes I prefer the diving into the rabbit hole type as long as they don't go as deep as a stock Hohner.

Mushrooms seem to be quieter.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Bob Ellis on December 20, 2015, 11:58:08 PM
I have had several boxes of each type over the years and currently have two with mushroom type buttons and three with the cylindrical type. While I have no problem with either, my preference tends to be for mushrooms because I find them more responsive. Having said that, I have found a great deal of variation between boxes with the same type of button. For instance, my Marc Savoy is more responsive than any other box with cylindrical buttons I have ever played and more so than several with mushroom buttons. My Clément Guais, which has mushroom buttons, is the most responsive box of any type that I have ever played. When I asked Clém about this, he said that the most important factors were the quality of the mechanism, the strength of the springs and the accuracy with which the mechanism is set up.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Rob2Hook on December 23, 2015, 11:17:43 AM
Nobody has mentioned it but the really nice boxes have closed, all metal actions with mushroom type buttons.  I never had a look to see how the button attached to the lever as they were never any problem, but I'm sure the hole wasn't anything like the size of the button.

Rob.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Lester on December 23, 2015, 11:29:14 AM
Nobody has mentioned it but the really nice boxes have closed, all metal actions with mushroom type buttons.  I never had a look to see how the button attached to the lever as they were never any problem, but I'm sure the hole wasn't anything like the size of the button.

Rob.

The all metal actions usually have a plastic bit on the button end that the button screws into.

(https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/Po242vlgxpDDD1-bTX4VsrZkCgdXYBJoEhHNzPrJ_CjD4USYxMuPqGNt-tVT4DLQ1lq1ZRRNlpADN1MrMpmdEeF8gG0q5MqED9-7sHoHK16ioljaVx3vNWJYinahS-fYSPpJrZLDrlZFFUUn3DfRP95GlbAd5da0NctYJFi0C9zGdThBB8X2EGis3Gphk_wf5jeUTtZMQzw7Qy7y3i29t1r6ziCgk85IrOb7W-hHEvQmybIKwaRS51CpyXN2d7PQxffuWAAdE5V13KTXTEVy8h-YUf4v2EBhBKFjucfMbsPZ8NM_X7c4hC9byVfeYv3znGzMGDpi046CMYnEfiWPYWmMFmOiPKtJxyZ3DLjqZ6BURzCSD_8Dh3OOynJtZLGyt-uMBpP8nc20k6vyLdjeEEUL2CXITZfBDa937lyMDmYYmQTas7eSGgI5E1yFAAsNJioCMBhFnTB5h5EvUA8n5q1Xra3JJrtMh2x-8_CcMprDqaFdzekC1DvajwE49JcFko9vgiQKlznZWBJYTqE4BYUvDA4uU8r401GwD60ektYRcxuugxXWU52sDG2FYwsgKq75=w1168-h1556-no)

The down side of the mushroom buttons is their tendency to come unscrewed and fall off at inconvenient times
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Rob2Hook on December 23, 2015, 11:38:12 AM
Thanks Lester,

I never tried unscrewing the buttons on the Trilly as I didn't want to start a trend.  Last week I lost a button off the Bouebe three times in a day's playing!  Happily it doesn't stop you playing, though I'm told the facial expressions nearly made the dancers call an ambulance.  In each case, the button was found and quickly screwed back into place.  By the end of the day I was checking them all for tightness between tunes.

Rob.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Lester on December 23, 2015, 11:44:58 AM
Thanks Lester,

I never tried unscrewing the buttons on the Trilly as I didn't want to start a trend.  Last week I lost a button off the Bouebe three times in a day's playing!  Happily it doesn't stop you playing, though I'm told the facial expressions nearly made the dancers call an ambulance.  In each case, the button was found and quickly screwed back into place.  By the end of the day I was checking them all for tightness between tunes.

Rob.

Small amount of super glue in the holes will prevent them unscrewing unless you want to unscrew them.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Helena Handcart on December 23, 2015, 11:52:05 AM
The down side of the mushroom buttons is their tendency to come unscrewed and fall off at inconvenient times

Yep, but surely half the fun of a session or morris stand is the scrabbling around on the floor looking for the button of someone's Lilly/Bouebe/Binci ;)
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: Rob2Hook on December 23, 2015, 05:00:56 PM
Lilly Bouebe - I know that tune!

Must be the sherry for the Christmas trifle...

Rob.
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: KLR on December 23, 2015, 06:41:43 PM
None of the mushroom type buttons on my old Paolo B/C/C# have ever come unscrewed, but keys would become stuck every now and then since the risers that the buttons screw into were made of wood and would swell, apparently, forcing me to take a rat tail file to the stepped keyboard cover.

Does anyone build boxes with mushroom type buttons and a flat keyboard?  All of my mushroom types have stepped keyboards; the conventional ones have flat boards, and are much easier to slide around on, but I'm not sure if it's the flatness or the conventional button type that helps with the sliding. 
Title: Re: "mushroom"-type treble buttons
Post by: squeezy on December 23, 2015, 09:27:11 PM
Well it would be possible if the bit that the buttons are screwed in to could be angled such that the tops of the buttons were all in the same plane.  But I agree - I don't think anyone does that - although there is much variation in the height of the step between models.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal