Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: playandteach on December 30, 2015, 08:45:04 AM
-
I'm thinking of going for a reversal on the upper G and A in the C row of my R2D2. As this requires retuning of (I think) on two sets of reeds by up to a tone, rather than a switching of the plates is it worth getting in touch with Serafini and asking for new reed plates for those notes, so that a simple reinstatement of the original notes is straightforward enough at a later date - either for sale or if I find it wasn't such a good idea?
Is this something that is possible, given that he probably buys in his reeds?
Also, having seen the new Star Wars movie last night, does anyone know if Marc Serafini is planning on a new BB8 model?
-
Pete, can you clarify which reversals you mean?
On this diagram here (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20G_C%20-%20with%20accidentals.jpg), it shows there is the G4/A4 button on the C-row. Is this the button you want to reverse?. If so, this is the standard 'Dutch' reversal and is easy to do - it's just a matter of flipping the reed plates. No re-tuning required (other than perhaps a bit of slight spot tuning adjustment).
However, perhaps you are meaning the two buttons G5/F5 and C6/A6 ?
Do you want them to be F5/G5 and A6/C6 ? If so, that's also a matter of flipping the reed plates.
But perhaps you want them to be A6/F5 and C6/G5 ?? This would need new reed plates, as the changes involved would be too severe for the reed tongues simply to be retuned.
I have to say that to make either of the latter changes to G5/F5 and C6/A6 would be very odd indeed and I'm not sure what advantages you think you'd gain. :-\
-
G/A on a C row suggests the standard 'Dutch' inversion, and as Steve says just identify the plate and turn it over (both voices)!
That's what I did in early 2005. But by the end of the year I'd turned it back again :( There was too much to 'unlearn' - but it's a great, logical, useful system if you are new to melodeon.
-
It's replicating the Dutch reversal in the octave above.
-
It's replicating the Dutch reversal in the octave above.
But it doesn't, because there is no single G/A reed plate in the upper octave. You would have to reverse two sets of reed plates, G/F and C/A, which would then give you a probably unwanted push F and a very inadvisable pull C. It would throw the basic playing section of a G/C box completely out of kilter.
Dutch reversal up there? More like Double Dutch, I think...
-
Pete, in answer to your original question I think it is unlikely that Marc would have to reeds you need, they would have to be specially made, or adapted from similar reeds.
-
Pete, can you clarify which reversals you mean?
On this diagram here (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20G_C%20-%20with%20accidentals.jpg), it shows there is the G4/A4 button on the C-row. Is this the button you want to reverse?. If so, this is the standard 'Dutch' reversal and is easy to do - it's just a matter of flipping the reed plates. No re-tuning required (other than perhaps a bit of slight spot tuning adjustment).
However, perhaps you are meaning the two buttons G5/F5 and C6/A6 ?
Do you want them to be F5/G5 and A6/C6 ? If so, that's also a matter of flipping the reed plates.
But perhaps you want them to be A6/F5 and C6/G5 ?? This would need new reed plates, as the changes involved would be too severe for the reed tongues simply to be retuned.
I have to say that to make either of the latter changes to G5/F5 and C6/A6 would be very odd indeed and I'm not sure what advantages you think you'd gain. :-\
Just noted there are two errors on this chart
A6C6. Should be A5/C6
B4/F#5 should be B5/F#5
Lester??
-
I think what Pete is aiming for are A/F and C/G an octave above the standard dutch reversal.
Thanks,
Baron
-
Just noted there are two errors on this chart
A6C6. Should be A5/C6
B4/F#5 should be B5/F#5
Lester??
Thanks Lester, corrected versions received and uploaded
-
Sorry for the delay - been with family over the last 2 days. Still not near my melodeon, but it is to achieve a push A, and a pull G in the upper register, whilst leaving everything else intact. In other words, to avoid the pull duplication of the high A, and the push duplication of the high G. Changes would be on the inside C row, to keep one row more or less original.
I do have the Dutch reversal on the middle A / G and like it.
As yet I have little playing experience in the top register, so not much to unlearn if I go for the change. At the moment I'm trying to keep to playing the outside row As in the tunes I do play, so as to create a habit that will fit.
For D / G players read E for A, and D for G.
I suspect there will be many who don't advocate this change. I don't know what long term effect messing with the tuning on these notes will have either to the sound or on the retro re-conversion, and would consider buying (in the absence of being able to order in specially made reed plates) exact replacements for the ones I'm considering altering, if it means keeping the instrument's sonic integrity at a later date. I don't know what these might cost. I could of course just ask Theo - but then we'd not need a forum if we always went to the experts.