Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: nicky1971 on June 03, 2009, 09:00:50 AM
-
I am trying to learn these pesky triplets, and although I am making progress i find that the buttons clack noisily as my finger tips leave the button, almost to the point where the buttons make more noise than the reeds. I am playing a castagnari tommy so i figure it's not the instrument and more than likely my technique. Any suggestions? Or is this just normal.
Many thanks
-
The wrath of many is probably going to descend upon me very shortly - but I dare to suggest that it is in fact your instrument? Others who know the instrument well will I am sure be able to advise a remedy - but I'm sure that a castanet castagnari is not the norm. (:)
AL
-
I am trying to learn these pesky triplets, and although I am making progress i find that the buttons clack noisily as my finger tips leave the button, almost to the point where the buttons make more noise than the reeds. I am playing a castagnari tommy so i figure it's not the instrument and more than likely my technique. Any suggestions? Or is this just normal.
Many thanks
A Tommy shouldn't normally have particularly clacky buttons, unless perhaps it's very old and the action is a bit worn and loose. You mention that the clack occurs as your fingers leave the buttons. This suggests it might be the pallets rather than the buttons.
The pallets are the wooden things on the end of the lever arms inside the grille. They are faced with a leather/felt sandwich and they control the airflow in and out of the reed chambers inside the melodeon. Sorry if you know this already. I mention it because sometimes the impact of the pallets returning to their closed position (when you take your fingers off the buttons) can generate a noticeable clack.
Operate the buttons without using the bellows i.e. so there are no reeds sounding. Listen carefully with your ear close to the buttons and grille to try to identify the source of the sound. Is it really due to rattley buttons, or does the sound seem to come from inside the grille?
If it does seem to be the pallets which are generating the sound, one reason could be that the facing material is old and become a bit hard over time. One remedy would be to completely reface the pallets but this is a bit of a fiddly job. Theo (who runs this forum) might be able to offer advice perhaps?
-
i think my tommy is only about 5 years old, but am very grateful for the advice. Will also have a go on my friends spanking new ( and very very beautiful Dino Bafetti) and see if it does the same thing.
-
Well Sharon Shannon doesn't play too much percussion on her Tommy! I think Steve is right, the pallet felts have possibly hardened. I guess the time it takes for this to happen is dependant on how the box is stored - temperature and humidity will vary. There is a felt bush under each button to stop the noise when it bottoms out, but there will always be some noise as the pallet closes - a light touch will lessen this, but I guess the only other thing is to play louder to drown it out!
Rob.
-
I agree with Steve's diagnosis of the most likely cause.
Another less likely possibility is that the levers the buttons sit on are coming into contact with the underside of the top plate of the keyboard. This can happen if the button travel is slightly longer than it should be, and is most noticeable when playing ornaments where the button is released and springs back into position. If it is this then the sound will be quite hard, as its caused by metal hitting bare wood.
-
I've actually found this happens as well when playing 2 or 3 finger triplets on a Tommy - in my case its just the sound of the pallet coming down if your heavy handed with the buttons. I find you can use a much lighter touch than some boxes I've tried. It's never been louder than the reeds though!
-
After much deliberation i took a screwdriver to my castagnari and removed the grille on the treble end. The noise come simply from the sprung plates which normally cover the holes snapping back into place. The leather which forms the seal is still soft so i guess its a trait of the box and my technique, although no matter how i try these triplets is still get the slapping noise.
-
...The noise come simply from the sprung plates which normally cover the holes snapping back into place.
Yes, the 'sprung plates' are the pallets.
The leather which forms the seal is still soft so i guess its a trait of the box and my technique, although no matter how i try these triplets is still get the slapping noise.
It's possible that you have become over-sensitive to the pallet noise which may in fact not be as audible to a listener as you yourself perceive it.
I know this is the case with my Lilium, which also seems to me when playing to have a fair amount of pallet noise, but which is barely noticeable in recordings.
-
It's possible that you have become over-sensitive to the pallet noise which may in fact not be as audible to a listener as you yourself perceive it.
Good point. Try recording a tune by placing the microphone at a distance, say 5 feet, then listen. Being close to the box when you play you will obviously hear noises coming out of the mechanical elements.
Also, if you "leave" a pushed button by sliding the finger away and letting the button come back out on itself, the pallet will obviously clap when reaching its stop point.