Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: gm0lze on January 29, 2016, 05:40:34 PM

Title: Changing Reeds in Saltarelle La Bouebe
Post by: gm0lze on January 29, 2016, 05:40:34 PM
I have a friend who is changing the reeds in his La Bouebe as he is not happy with the sound and would like a change.
He is unsure what type of reed to install in the Bouebe.
Binci,Ciccarelli ,does anybody have any suggestions or recommendations as regards quality or where could one listen to different type reeds.Thank You for any replies.
Title: Re: Changing Reeds in Saltarelle La Bouebe
Post by: Theo on January 29, 2016, 06:19:39 PM
First thing to ask is, when was the Bouebe last tuned and set up? Any box can sound unpleasant if its not accurately in tune and has the reeds set properly. There is also the amount of tremolo to consider.   Dry tuning or wet tuning make a huge difference to the sound. You can't judge a box fairly until you have had someone who knows what they are doing to get it set up to play it's best, and with the amount of tremolo that you prefer.  You will need such a person to install and tune the new reeds, so its a good first step anyway to find such a person.

You also need to bear in mind that the sound of a box is only partially determined by the reeds, the rest of the design of the box has a significant influence too, so your friend would be better advised to try a variety of different instruments to find a sound he likes.

As well as the makes you have mentioned there is also Voci Armoniche and Artigiana.
Title: Re: Changing Reeds in Saltarelle La Bouebe
Post by: Harmonicatunes on January 30, 2016, 02:45:48 AM
I heartily second Theo's comments.

I bought a D/G Le Bouebe from Melnet a few years back. Unusually for a Saltarelle, the tuning was fairly wet, I didn't like it. I sent it to Peter Hyde (I'm in Australia), he tuned it to a dryish 2Hz beat. The instrument was transformed, and has been a delight to play ever since.
Title: Re: Changing Reeds in Saltarelle La Bouebe
Post by: Microbot on January 30, 2016, 09:40:40 AM
Hi GmOlze,

Whilst not disagreeing with any of the above comments on set-up...

why not have a word with 'Phil B' on Melnet ...he recently had the reeds on his Bouebe replaced with a Cagnoni Macchina set in A/D. I know he likes it - they suit the box well and are definitely a fine reed. I think Rees has commented (somewhere) on the quality of Cagnoni Macchinas.

They are responsive with v good dynamic range, and full-toned ... not as 'hard' sounding as Binci's for instance.

cheers

Mike R
Title: Re: Changing Reeds in Saltarelle La Bouebe
Post by: Theo on January 30, 2016, 09:57:29 AM
Ah yes I forgot to include Cagnoni, though I don't think they would be much different from the original reeds in a Bouebe.
Title: Re: Changing Reeds in Saltarelle La Bouebe
Post by: rees on January 30, 2016, 11:57:17 AM
Cagnoni macchina reeds are OK but as Theo says the original Bouebe reeds are probably similar. Cagnoni TAM reeds are very good.

It is surprising how different the Bouebes can be in terms of reed response. I've just sold a second-hand Bouebe in C/F which was very loud and responsive while others have been quite poor.
Title: Re: Changing Reeds in Saltarelle La Bouebe
Post by: Phil B on January 30, 2016, 12:33:14 PM
The AD reeds fitted to my Bouebe were Gagnoni Tams from Charlie Marshall, I changed because I wanted a responsive AD box with a flat keyboard, not an easy animal to find and I have always liked the bouebe button action and the feel of the box in general.   I am delighted with the result Microbot has achieved with these reeds.
I am also the person who bought the CF Bouebe from Rees and it is a real pleasure to play so you may guess I quite like these boxes.
I whole heartily endorse Theo's original advice If you are not changing the key have it looked at and  set up properly by a repairer who understands the sound you want before you buy new reeds.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal