Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Myrrh Music on February 04, 2016, 09:35:06 AM
-
Just wanted to share my frustration. Don't think anyone other than a player understands.
I really CAN play The History Man in a simplified version at least 70% of the time without a mistake, as long as no-one is watching! But as I'm getting towards the end, when I do a slightly different ending second time through on the A part, this Gremlin appears on my shoulder and sits watching me, and as I get to that bit he whispers "Oow, here it comes, that bit, you know you often have a problem with this. Now careful, here it comes....Oh dear what a SHAME, you got so near that time didn't you >:E
Does he have any relations staying with anyone else? Would they like him to join them? I tell you I'd squish him if I could catch him.... :'(
Mary
-
For a moment there I thought you were offering a Weltmeister... Neil (Hobgoblin) used to call them either the Gremlin model or the "Ess Aitch One Tee" model - the first because of how often they went wrong and the second because of the way they played (or didn't). I'm sure my Gremlin would be delighted to have some relations come and stay, but as they all have only one topic of conversation (failure) these visits tend to get cut short through sheer boredom. The best way to get them to cut you some slack is to refuse to play for a few days.
Rob.
-
Ah yes! Bore him to death - sure I can manage that...
Mary
-
Aaaaah! I wondered where he'd gone yesterday, but I see that he's back home with me today. (B****r!)
-
I wonder sometimes if my playing is always like that - when you play to yourself, it doesn't matter if you stop and restart, do that bit again, push the wrong button momentarily, because once the moment has gone .. it's gone.
I have wondered if the best way of recording is to just press record and play for an hour or more, capture everything and edit the best performance out. But when the tape's rolling there's always a temptation to stop .."that wasn't too bad, I wonder what it sounds like?"
Steve
(no thanks to the kind offer)
-
In my experience, the gremlin tends to pop up in the complicated parts, and the bits that get practised least (e.g. second time phrases at end of A & B music).
And the answer is repeated practising of just that part, rather than the whole tune, until the fingers know what to do even if the gremlin pops up.
-
Ah, Andy, I think you may have hit it there, because obviously I use the normal pattern more often. I'll try going from usual mode to quirky mode just once each over and over.
Thanks
Mary
-
I wonder sometimes if my playing is always like that - when you play to yourself, it doesn't matter if you stop and restart, do that bit again, push the wrong button momentarily, because once the moment has gone .. it's gone.
I have wondered if the best way of recording is to just press record and play for an hour or more, capture everything and edit the best performance out. But when the tape's rolling there's always a temptation to stop .."that wasn't too bad, I wonder what it sounds like?"
Steve
(no thanks to the kind offer)
I tried this. Trouble is it didn't work for me. Even with the better takes there was a part of me that always thought "it could be just that little bit better". Ended up with more footage than I could be bothered to look at. Never did identify the best bits. Now I make my max number of takes, in one hit, three.
I think the things that help me most are
1. Getting out of the habit of stopping when I make an error
2. Learning to live with things that aren't quite perfect. They probably never will be because my expectations grow with experience.
3. Practising the bits that tend to throw me repeatedly, both in isolation and within that section of the tune.
4. Not worrying about it so much.
5. Not worrying about it so much.
-
Another way to use recording is to forget about trying to get "a good performance" tha hels with 4 and 5. Then just record your first try at playing once or twice through the tune. Then listen back to the recording and pick out three things about the recording that you like, and one thing that you will work on to improve.
Give yourself some praise for the good things, practice the aspect you want to improve, and then next time you play go through the same process.
-
There's a massive difference between recording a tune you're trying to improve and recording one you can still play when the bar closes! Many of us play for either ceilidh or morris and that slow turnover of your repertoire can be used to advantage in learning to quell your nerves once the record button is pressed. I've heard others' recordings of me playing in the morris band and I was relatively happy with the outcome.
Subsequently I was asked to record a tune four times through for a one-off dance by a local school as I wasn't able to attend all the performances. Now I was quite surprised that we got it on one take, nerves helped by the fact that we'd already agreed when to re-convene if we didn't get it in three takes. Next asked to record once through each of the morris medleys as a style guide for new band members. Again, no failures 0 but I became aware that my gaze into the middle distance when playing was completely unfocussed.
I still haven't had the nerve to make any recordings on my own as I suspect that switching the recorder on and off and trying to monitor recording level will be too much for me whilst playing - it's quite safe to offer me a pint in mid-tune as I can't bring myself to reply beyond a cursory nod.
Rob.
-
His distant cousin lives in the Fleece Inn - which is why I can play at home easily but as soon as I'm in the pub the little bugger jumps out of the pewter pots to goad me !!
-
Might take up proper meditation. Might help. It's almost like it isn't it, when you try not to think of anything as the tune comes?
-
It is well known that these gremlins don't like music, that's why they make it difficult to keep playing. You just have to show that you won't stop by playing every day. Eventually the gremlin gives up and goes away.
-
Red and White hanky plus stick for shoulder all packed and ready to go for him - sometime soon I hope!
-
Whose Morris kit is that Myrrh? >:E :M
Chris B.
-
Whose Morris kit is that Myrrh? >:E :M
Chris B.
"Trampton" ? In the Cotswolds . 8)
-
Gremlins can't stand hearing people practice as slowly as needed to play without mistakes. Play the entire tune as slow as required to play the most difficults passeges without error, even if this means playing eighth notes as if they were whole notes. You are creating neural pathways. If you practice playing mistakes, that's what you will improve at. Unlearning mistakes and then learning the correct way takes more time and effort. I never end a practice session at the end of a problem, I stop after repeated successes, even if I can't play a difficult passage up to tempo. The key to playing accurately fast, is to practice slowly and gradually increase the tempo as you develop the "motor memory".
-
Wot 'e said. Frame it, put on the wall and read before practising...
-
(:) Thanks all. I'll do that. Sometimes though, I find that at normal speed I do something that sounds good and I don't know what it is, so when I slow down, I lose it...! Mind you, it doesn't happen often, so I think I'll opt for slow to learn from now on.
Just another quick query while I'm at it and then I'm done. Is there ANY way to get me out of this habit I now seem to have of some fingers staying too far away from the keys and even sometimes forming a right-angle hook, which from watching others I know isn't good. My fingers don't seem to want to do what I tell them :-\ I could try splinting them I suppose :( :(
Mary
-
No no Mary don't splint them. It's a case of just relax them, even caress the keys. Remember it's a simple push not a strike like a piano hammer.
I do understand your problem, with me the Northumbrian Small Pipes, I just couldn't get over gripping the chanter like a pair of mole grips, after five minutes fingers aching like hell.
Imagine you're washing your hair. Keeping close to the scalp and with about the same pressure push a key.
You'll get it in time I know you will. (:)
-
(:) I like your analogy Nick, washing the hair. Yes, I can feel in my fingers how it should be. I'll try to keep it in mind next time.
Well, at least it's working as I tap the top of my head - maybe I should have the melodeon up there!!!!
I'm going to forget the tunes for a bit and just try to get that. :|||:
Many thanks Nick.
Mary
-
A good exercise (not musical, but physical) that works on the piano, is to hold down one finger whilst taking it in turns to play the other 3 (in the case on not using the thumb). So hold down the first finger, then play 2, 3, 4, 3, 2 on your chosen notes. Then hold down 2, whist taking it in turns with 1, 3, 4, 3, 1. Just a good little exercise - only a couple of minutes to do at a time. You can incorporate it into a fragment of a tune such as Amelie: hold the first note of each phrase while doing the filigree stuff. On a G/C it would be D efefe E efeCe B deded A cdedc (the little notes are in the lower octave to the Capital notes. In D/G terms I guess it would be A bcbcb B bcbGb Fsharp ababa E gabag
Just a small thing to work on. Discard if it doesn't help.
-
Thank you for that. I'll definitely give it a go. Time to learn something else anyway and this will be so much more valuable than bashing on with yet another new tune.
Much appreciated.
Mary
-
Play the entire tune as slow as required to play the most difficults passeges without error, even if this means playing eighth notes as if they were whole notes. You are creating neural pathways.
Never helped me. :-[
I can play single bars over and over at a moderately slower pace to get my fingers (and feet) to know what they have to do, but playing overly slow - I hardly ever had the patience to do so, and when I did, I never experienced any progress out of that. (One possible exception was maybe complicated polyphony.)