Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: gettabettabox on February 13, 2016, 01:07:00 PM
-
i'm sure many of you have used this quick trick to check on individual reed performance, less invasive than 'opening up,' removing and blocking off reed blanks. -but for them that haven't...
i use it post-tuning, say, a couple of weeks after, primarily to check reed response. (most of us will know if a problem is developing)
-remove grill, put safe with screws.
-place block or some kind of firm flat surface against all treble buttons, depress to raise pallets and slide paper strips into place of choice.
-cheap thin photocopying paper seems not to disturb pallet seating.
-check for individual reed response and tuning etc.
helps to identify problem reeds before accessing inners.
not perfect, reed pairs acting in unison can do strange things.
it's also a useful ploy for blocking off a reed bank in a three voice wet box.
-
Hi. My first post on this forum so please bear with me. I have a Corona III which is a bit wet for my liking and I have been wondering about the merits of blocking off a reed bank. The trouble is, I'm not sure which one to blank off. I'm assuming that it's the sharpest of the three that needs to be blanked off and guessing that it's the top one as you look down on the blocks but not sure. I have searched for an exploded drawing but can only find one for a Corona II which, unfortunately, isn't much help. I'd appreciate somebody's help on this if possible. Ta.
-
Hi. My first post on this forum so please bear with me. I have a Corona III which is a bit wet for my liking and I have been wondering about the merits of blocking off a reed bank. The trouble is, I'm not sure which one to blank off. I'm assuming that it's the sharpest of the three that needs to be blanked off and guessing that it's the top one as you look down on the blocks but not sure. I have searched for an exploded drawing but can only find one for a Corona II which, unfortunately, isn't much help. I'd appreciate somebody's help on this if possible. Ta.
Kind of depends on how the box is tuned, Corona IIIs are usually tuned flat/pitch/sharp rather than pitch/sharp/sharper. So if you want to go with blocking a set of reed I would recommend blocking off the flat set.
But I would suggest getting a fettler to tune the box a bit drier then you will get the bnrfit of a three voice box rather than having the weight of a three voice box but with 30% of the reeds just there as dead weight.
-
Apparently we have a greater aural tolerance of slightly sharp to slightly flat, which is why clarinet players get away with so much. And flute players generally don't (with the exception of Jimmy Galway who veered on the sharp side).
-
it's also a useful ploy for blocking off a reed bank in a three voice wet box.
Why would anyone want to do that?
(Only joking! :neigh:)
-
Hi. My first post on this forum so please bear with me. I have a Corona III which is a bit wet for my liking and I have been wondering about the merits of blocking off a reed bank.
But I would suggest getting a fettler to tune the box a bit drier then you will get the benefit of a three voice box rather than having the weight of a three voice box but with 30% of the reeds just there as dead weight.
Definitely agree with what Lester has said. Three voice MMM boxes can sound great and they don't have to be monsoon-wet. Get the box retuned with a bit less tremolo. You've paid for all those extra reeds so you may as well make good use of them. Blocking off a set of reeds would be like making a cuppa with last week's tea bags :o
More seriously, blocking off either the sharp set or the flat set of reeds will totally upset the perceived pitch of the box and (assuming it was reasonably well tuned in the first place) throw the RH treble side out of tune with the LH basses/chords.
-
Many thanks one and all for your comments and advice which are much appreciated. I hadn't realised that the Corona is likely to be tuned flat/pitch/sharp and understand now why blocking off a set of reeds is unlikely to work satisfactorily. If anyone is able to let me know of a good fettler reasonably close to West Norfolk I would be most grateful. Cheers.
-
There is a list of repairers here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,shops_repairers.html)
-
Many thanks Theo - much appreciated.
-
And it is handy if you be happen to be near a repairer, but others are only a phone call and a parcel away. Not fishing for business, just sayin!
-
Many thanks Theo, I'll bear it in mind ;D
-
If you are still interested in playing around with your reeds and don't wanna redo the tuning check out this tutorial.
Don't need to have Spanish skills just need a III voice they call it 5 letters
Fast forward to min 3
https://youtu.be/azvGPZJVnvE
If you wanna change the tuning check this out listen to the sounds the guy is brining it down in hertz
https://youtu.be/KuQD5l91BKg
Hope it helps if u need translation or explaining or feels this is what you are looking for let me know.
I'm not a tuner just a curious ear 😂
-
If you are still interested in playing around with your reeds and don't wanna redo the tuning check out this tutorial.
Don't need to have Spanish skills just need a III voice they call it 5 letters
Fast forward to min 3
https://youtu.be/azvGPZJVnvE
If you wanna change the tuning check this out listen to the sounds the guy is brining it down in hertz
https://youtu.be/KuQD5l91BKg
Hope it helps if u need translation or explaining or feels this is what you are looking for let me know.
I'm not a tuner just a curious ear 😂
Five letters (cinquas letras) refers to accordions in F/Bb/Eb which when written that way contains 5 letters. Also when stamped on the accordion the Hohner German system FBEis also has five letters. It is nothing to do with the number of reed-blocks inside. A/D/G or G/C/F Hohner Coronas are not five letters, only F/Bb/Eb.
-
Cinquas letras.. the first choice of Colombian and Venezuelan players
-
If you are still interested in playing around with your reeds and don't wanna redo the tuning check out this tutorial.
Don't need to have Spanish skills just need a III voice they call it 5 letters
Fast forward to min 3
https://youtu.be/azvGPZJVnvE
If you wanna change the tuning check this out listen to the sounds the guy is brining it down in hertz
https://youtu.be/KuQD5l91BKg
Hope it helps if u need translation or explaining or feels this is what you are looking for let me know.
I'm not a tuner just a curious ear 😂
Five letters (cinquas letras) refers to accordions in F/Bb/Eb which when written that way contains 5 letters. Also when stamped on the accordion the Hohner German system FBEis also has five letters. It is nothing to do with the number of reed-blocks inside. A/D/G or G/C/F Hohner Coronas are not five letters, only F/Bb/Eb.
Hi Rees,
My understanding was that Five letters: BEsAs (Bb Eb Ab)
and that you can also see these stamps:
FBEs (F Bb Eb)
FisHE (F# B E) (also 5 letters stamped on the keyboard)
ADG
GCF
EAD
DGC
GisCisFis (G# C# F#) - rare
PG
-
Ah yes Paul, I think you are right. My memory playing tricks again.