Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: robotmay on March 01, 2016, 02:12:02 PM
-
The box I built with Emmanuel is an L/M G/C, so it's pretty low-pitched. Pretty much the entire low octave and the bass reeds suffer from quite a lot of valve noise, more so than on other G/C instruments I've tried with a low register. The reeds are Binci a mano, and mostly have the plastic valves, with those faux-leather (vileda?) valves on any reed that has a weight on the tip.
Understandably the valves are pretty massive for some of these reeds on account of how big they are, but is there anything I can do to at least reduce the noise a little? I suspect it could do with a bit of a tune-up sometime later this year anyway as the reeds have settled a bit since it was built.
-
If the lower reeds have vileda valves then they might need to be replaced. It's more likely that they have a grey leather layer with a couple of plastic layers on top. These can be adjusted by putting a slight kink in the plastic layers so that they press a little more in the leather.
-
Ah thanks Theo, you're right; they appear to actually be grey leather now I look closer. One of them also has a kink in it, so I'll test how that one responds vs the others and try adding kinks to the other slow responding ones.
-
There was one course where Emmanuel mistakenly ordered all the reeds without valves. He and I then had to work together in the fortnight leading up to the course to find enough valves and fit them. Usually the reeds used on the course are valved in the traditional way with leather.
-
Oof, that sounds like fun :o
Yeah these ones are leather. I've just added a kink into all of the leather-based ones and they seem to sit a little closer to the plate now, which is good. However I've now figured out that those ones are not the main noise-causers, and instead it's the larger all-plastic valves which are the most audible. There's 4 plates in the lower octave in the L reeds which seem to be the ones making the most valve noise, and I suspect this is true of the higher of the two bass reeds. The plastic on these valves seems very thin and with quite short springs for what are quite large reeds, though my experience with revalving is limited to a couple of boxes so far:
(http://i.imgur.com/SNfNCM8.jpg)
Saying that, they do seem to close fine, they're just really loud. I could experiment with replacing them, though I only have some vileda valves lying around that I could cut to size. I suspect it'd affect the reed response a bit?
-
Big plastic valves are noisy compared with leather, so your experience is typical.
Leather is much better than vileda which can be a bit sluggish to respond. So for the best results replace all the noisy plastic with leather. Leather valves will differ in how easily they open compared with plastic, which can make a small difference to the pitch of the reed. But the lack of plastic rattle will probably outweigh any small changes in tuning.
-
Thanks for the advice Theo. It'll need tuning sometime soon anyway so a pitch change wouldn't be a huge issue. Would the leather valves from Charlie Marshall be suitable (e.g. these (http://cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Reed_Valves.html#4)), or is there somewhere else to order them from?
And yeah I'd really like to reduce the valve noise on this, as it's otherwise a really nice box to play (:)
-
Thanks for the advice Theo. It'll need tuning sometime soon anyway so a pitch change wouldn't be a huge issue. Would the leather valves from Charlie Marshall be suitable (e.g. these (http://cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Reed_Valves.html#4)), or is there somewhere else to order them from?
And yeah I'd really like to reduce the valve noise on this, as it's otherwise a really nice box to play (:)
I've found the leather valves as supplied by Charlie Marshall to be absolutely fine. I measure the lengths of valves required and make a list for Charlie, then add a few extra of each size (to allow for the odd mistake/wastage/accident - whoops! ::) ).
I also order the springs and dots separately (i.e. not fixed to the valves already). It is easy to glue them in place and buying them loose allows you more flexibility in getting the valves/springs exactly the right length for your particular reeds.
-
Yeah I may have already accidentally waxed a valve closed on another box ::)
I need to order some more valves to restore another Erika I picked up (perfect condition Bb/Eb, woop), so might as well do that one with leather at the same time. I haven't used the springs before, are there any guidelines as to what lengths/sizes to use for different sized valves?
-
I like to use plastic valves on about the top octave and a half of a DG. You get slightly more volume and brightness, and the small plastic valves don't make any noise that I can hear. The natural variability of leather can also be a bit of s problem on the smallest reeds.
With the helper springs the principle to stick to is to use only just enough extra force to close the valve smoothly. So use the lightest helper spring you can, and only use them where the valve leather needs help.
-
Aye, I think I'll keep the top octave in plastic, as those don't seem to make any noise that I can hear. I'll probably do the same for the Bb/Eb as well then, and order some more plastic valves to do the upper part of that.
Thanks for the tips! I'll update this when I've had a go at switching them out ;D
-
Just finished revalving the treble side reeds, and it has made a huge difference; I can actually play down the bottom end of it without getting annoyed ;D
Bit of an interesting selection of valves going on now, but it seems to have the same response along the row, which is nice, and no discernable pitch shift.
(http://i.imgur.com/y3jnw2U.jpg)
Think I'll take a stab at the bass end tomorrow.
-
Hmm, I've been adjusting the new valves today, as I seem to get a rattle on some of the helper springs. Is this caused by the spring being too strong for the valve? I seem to have solved it on some of them by switching them for a lighter spring, though I'm not sure if that'll work for the largest ones. It makes a sound a bit like a bee trapped in the reed chamber; I think it's the spring slapping against the valve leather. Alternatively are there any adjustments I should make to the spring (i.e. bending it one way or the other) or the valve itself?
-
Unlikely to be the helper sorry big hitting the valve. It is more likely to be the reed tongue hitting the valve.
Only fit helper springs if the valves misbehave without them. If you do fit springs start with the thinnest available. I think the thinnest is 0.5mm wide.
-
Ah cool, thanks Theo. I've probably wasted a few springs in that case ;D
It mostly only seems to occur when using low airflow, so I thought the valves might not have been sealing correctly, but I guess it'd also be just as likely to be stalling the reed if the spring was too strong?
-
If it's only at low airflow then my diagnosis is probably wrong!
-
Ooh discovered the cause of why one reed, which I hadn't revalved, was making a rattling noise. Because it's a rather large reed, it was transfering quite a lot of vibrations through the screw to the re-valved reedplate next to it, causing the metal spring to vibrate. A downside to the screw method of mounting reeds instead of waxing I guess. I'm going to try insulating the second plate somehow, maybe a small washer.
Edit: Bah, or not. Very frustrating debugging valve issues on this box, I found it much easier on the A/D Hohner I did beforehand ???
Edit 2: Or perhaps my first hunch was correct. Removing this screw solves the rattle:
(http://i.imgur.com/13phcCF.jpg)
I tried insulating it but I think it then caused the plates to rattle against it as it wasn't snug. Might just leave it out for the moment to see if that solves the remaining issues.
-
I'm going to try insulting the second plate somehow
Yep - that'll teach it to behave itself! >:E ;D
-
Haha, I've managed to make that typo twice now! Too much time faffing with valves today :Ph
-
Reed plates have to be held securely so leaving out screws is not to be encouraged.
If the noise come or goes with screw tightening then the probable cause is nothing to do with valves. Too much pressure from screws near the centre of the long side of a reed plate will deform the reed plate sufficiently that the tongue strikes the edge of the vent. If you experiment with how tightly you turn the screw your should be able to fix it. Also check that the reed plate is supported by wood along both long sides. If it is not sitting on a smooth firm surface then it will deform more easily under screw pressure.
-
Bingo, that was it. I didn't realise it could deform the plates to that degree; I knew that overtightening them could do something funky but I didn't realise the tongue would actually start hitting it. I had tried various tightnesses on that removed screw, but I hadn't tried adjusting the one on the other side; I slackened that off slightly and tightened the one I'd removed, and it seems to be rattle free now. Thanks for helping me troubleshoot it Theo (:)
Tempted to replace the screws with wax at some point. Would that mellow the sound of the box slightly?
-
What! Definitely a downgrade.
Think how much harder and more messy the valve job would have been.
-
Hehe, good point! Luckily the revalving of the other box I did recently went much smoother, or I would have been very bored of waxing by now.
I'm curious as to what difference screwing the reeds to the frame makes in terms of sound, but I guess I can make up a test reedblock at some point and try both methods out with the same reeds to see what happens (vaguely recall a thread about that sometime ago).
-
Done some more tweaking today to fix the last of the raspy sounds I could hear. I'm not sure if it's recommended or not, but by bending the metal springs very slightly so they arc downwards towards the tip, it stops them from slapping on the valve and seems to solve the problem. Think I'm finally done with the valve swap on the treble side now, unless any new issues crop up. Gonna leave the bass end for now to see what it's like once they settle down :Ph