Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Paul Young on December 17, 2007, 05:22:47 PM

Title: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on December 17, 2007, 05:22:47 PM
Hello.

First of all let me say I'm completely clueless about everything to do with amplification, so don't worry about patronizing me. To cut a long story short I'm going to be playing gigs with PA and have decided that playing into microphones on stands is not the way to go, so I'm wanting to fit something to my melodeon (a 2 row, 2 voice Dino Baffetti) so that I can plug it in.

I don't mind spending a bit of money, though obviously less would be nice, but most importantly I want something that's easy to buy, easy to fit, easy to use and gives a decent sound. Can anybody recommend anything? Or even tell me how to fit it / give me a link to some other site or discussion I haven't been able to find that tells me how to?

Thanks in advance,
Paul.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: BruceHenderson on December 17, 2007, 10:51:35 PM
  (snip)  I'm going to be playing gigs with PA and have decided that playing into microphones on stands is not the way to go, so I'm wanting to fit something to my melodeon (a 2 row, 2 voice Dino Baffetti) so that I can plug it in.  (snip) 

__.  I don't know anything about electronics either, but a fiddler friend says "I'd rather have the microphone attached to me rather than having me attached to the microphone."  I think you've got a good plan there.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Theo on December 17, 2007, 11:54:43 PM
I don't mind spending a bit of money, though obviously less would be nice, but most importantly I want something that's easy to buy, easy to fit, easy to use and gives a decent sound.

With mics you get what you pay for, so you have to find your own balance between cost and sound quality.  About the cheapest way is to get a tie-clip mic and use gaffa tape to attach it by the grill.  You used to be able to get these from Maplins for between £10 and £20.

Microvox is best avoided if you want decent sound quality, in my experience they regularly amuse with crackles and pops from poor contacts.   I use a clip-on mic designed for micing percussion.  It is a dynamic mic so needs no battery pack, preamp or phantom power.  Simple is best.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Lester on December 18, 2007, 11:11:44 AM
I must be they only person in the world who is happy with his Microvox setup. I use a M410 and a M400 (http://www.microvox.demon.co.uk/accpage.htm) with a Mini PSU (http://www.microvox.demon.co.uk/psu.htm). Admittedly I have modded mine; I velcro the PSU to the back of the treble end (this would not suit 2 strappers?) I have shortened the treble lead to about 6 inches and it comes over the top of the keyboard. I believe shortening the leads and solidly mounting the PSU removes many causes of pops and crackles. I have also replaced all the phono plugs with better quality gold plated ones. In addition I have fitted a power switch to allow me to nurdle during dance instructions (and to mime when I don't know the tunes) without having to pull the jack lead out.
When I am near my camera in the near future I will take a picture or two.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Bill Young on December 18, 2007, 12:55:40 PM
   I use a clip-on mic designed for micing percussion.  It is a dynamic mic so needs no battery pack, preamp or phantom power.  Simple is best.
Theo, would you mind identifying the exact mic you're using?
I've been experimenting recently with a mic - small amplifier - earpiece set-up for a personal monitoring system, so that I can hear what I'm doing when playing in a group. I usually have the keyboard player's amp right behind my chair. So far I have a very lo-fi rudimentary lash-up starting with a very cheap mic insert blue-tacced to the grille. This is the first weakness of the system, and needs to be replaced with something better.
I'm also working on the amp; it's one I've made from mostly salvaged parts, and, apart from being small (belt pack) and battery powered, is still far from perfect. So if anyone has a good solution to this already worked out, I'd be delighted to hear of it.
The Mark I system had the mic inside by the reed blocks. The system was totally overwhelmed, so it was either the wrong type of mic, or inadequately matched to the amplifier.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Theo on December 18, 2007, 01:25:21 PM
Mic is Beyerdynamic Opus 62

Correction it is designed for brass/woodwind or percussion according to who you read.

My excellent local sound shop  Sounds Live  (http://www.soundslive.co.uk) recommended it, but they don't have it listed any more, but a quick Google shows it is still available.

Some more info here at Beyerdynamic  (http://www.beyerdynamic.co.uk/beyerpages/percussion_mics.html).  Can be bought for about £70.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Bill Young on December 18, 2007, 05:12:45 PM
Mic is Beyerdynamic Opus 62

Correction it is designed for brass/woodwind or percussion according to who you read.

My excellent local sound shop  Sounds Live  (http://www.soundslive.co.uk) recommended it, but they don't have it listed any more, but a quick Google shows it is still available.

Some more info here at Beyerdynamic  (http://www.beyerdynamic.co.uk/beyerpages/percussion_mics.html).  Can be bought for about £70.
Thanks for that, Theo. I'll look into that one.

I agree about Sounds Live; have dealt with them. In fact they recently acted as Santa's agent and delivered my Christmas present (an amplifier for my R*land).
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Theo on December 18, 2007, 06:39:41 PM
I agree about Sounds Live; have dealt with them. In fact they recently acted as Santa's agent and delivered my Christmas present (an amplifier for my R*land).

Fortunately for me their main shop is in Newcastle.  Always got good advice there, and their prices were excellent, even before the days of online buying.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Pete of Ebor on December 18, 2007, 07:20:09 PM
I must be they only person in the world who is happy with his Microvox setup. I use a M410 and a M400 (http://www.microvox.demon.co.uk/accpage.htm) with a Mini PSU (http://www.microvox.demon.co.uk/psu.htm). Admittedly I have modded mine; I velcro the PSU to the back of the treble end (this would not suit 2 strappers?) I have shortened the treble lead to about 6 inches and it comes over the top of the keyboard. I believe shortening the leads and solidly mounting the PSU removes many causes of pops and crackles. I have also replaced all the phono plugs with better quality gold plated ones. In addition I have fitted a power switch to allow me to nurdle during dance instructions (and to mime when I don't know the tunes) without having to pull the jack lead out.
When I am near my camera in the near future I will take a picture or two.

That's the same as I use, but I do sometimes find the sound to be a bit "woolly". I have heard it said that this can be caused by the mics in the pickup bar being too close to the reeds, and therefore being swamped by the sound. Have you ever come across this ?
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on December 18, 2007, 09:04:08 PM
Thanks for all the input.

Theo, I have some questions about the Opus 62s:
I assume you use two of these mics, one for each end? How do you attach them? I've been looking at my melodeon and can't find anywhere I could clip the clips to. Have you added extra brackets or somesuch?
Do you happen to know if they're any good for other instruments? I play a few other things including fiddle and concertina too and if I'd be able to detach these and use them on other things that might make me a bit happier to pay £140 for a pair of them.
What sort of cables do they have coming off them? Will I need to buy something else to plug these into or will I just be able to hand the cable to a soundman and expect him to know what to do with it?
Sorry if any of that should be obvious.

Anybody else have an opinion on Microvox? It seems like the M310 in particular would be a very handy and not too expensive option, but obviously I don't want to get one if the sound's not very good. Also not too keen to have a big velcro strip stuck to my lovely wooden grill...
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Peter Brook on December 18, 2007, 09:19:33 PM
Just to open out the debate, why have you chosen not to go for mikes on stands?  Two SM59s into a decent amp is hard to beat in my opinion for sound and flexibility.

It also saves butchering your instruments and you can use the same set up for different boxes.

Just my two penneth...
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Theo on December 18, 2007, 11:29:45 PM
Theo, I have some questions about the Opus 62s:
I assume you use two of these mics, one for each end? How do you attach them?

No, just one.  I use a stand mic for the left side.  And I attach it to the top of the box with velchro ???

Quote
What sort of cables do they have coming off them?

They have an ELR connector - straight into the mixing desk.

Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on December 19, 2007, 11:24:46 AM
Right, now I'm thoroughly baffled. Unless you're left-handed... I'd heard of people having a mic attached to the left and playing the right into a mic on a stand because (in theory at least, and in practice for some players) the right hand side stays still whereas the left is moving around. What's the advantage of attaching a mic to the right hand side?

Which brings me onto why I don't personally want to play into mics on stands - I'm a one strapper and neither side of my box stays that still at the best of times. Plus I'm a lively and impulsive sort of chap and sometimes like to move around the stage a bit while I'm playing. See Bruce's quote at the top of the discussion. Another thought that occurs is I've recently been experimentally inflicting the melodeon on non-folkies at open mic nights, where there's often only one mic and/or only one stand, but something that plugs in just like a guitar can always be accomodated.

So, back to Theo's Opus 62's - have you (or has anyone else here) ever tried one on the other end? I've been reading about them and similar mics - seems John Spiers uses something similar - and I'm thinking that two of them might be a good solution, assuming of course that they'll work just as well at the other end.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Theo on December 19, 2007, 12:07:50 PM
Right, now I'm thoroughly baffled. Unless you're left-handed...

No, I'm right handed.  My usual band includes plenty of rhythm and bass, so my left hand is not required all the time.  When it is I sidle up to the mic.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on December 19, 2007, 12:18:43 PM
Just to open out the debate, why have you chosen not to go for mikes on stands?  Two SM59s into a decent amp is hard to beat in my opinion for sound and flexibility.

It also saves butchering your instruments and you can use the same set up for different boxes.

Just my two penneth...

Can you buy SM59s anymore?

I use SM57s or an AKG C1000S depending upon the band, PA setup etc.

For the vast majority of occasions I don't mic the bass end at all.  If you're playing with a guitar or guitar and bass then you don't want the melodeon bass getting in there with it's... how do I put it nicely?  There's not exactly a wide range of basses/chords available to the average melodeon.

I tend to agree with Marc Savoy's attitude, sit me down, point a microphone in my direction and let me play.

ps.  oh, yes, and as you say, switching boxes is much easier as well.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on December 19, 2007, 12:31:16 PM
Right, now I'm thoroughly baffled. Unless you're left-handed... I'd heard of people having a mic attached to the left and playing the right into a mic on a stand because (in theory at least, and in practice for some players) the right hand side stays still whereas the left is moving around. What's the advantage of attaching a mic to the right hand side?

Which brings me onto why I don't personally want to play into mics on stands - I'm a one strapper and neither side of my box stays that still at the best of times. Plus I'm a lively and impulsive sort of chap and sometimes like to move around the stage a bit while I'm playing. See Bruce's quote at the top of the discussion. Another thought that occurs is I've recently been experimentally inflicting the melodeon on non-folkies at open mic nights, where there's often only one mic and/or only one stand, but something that plugs in just like a guitar can always be accomodated.

So, back to Theo's Opus 62's - have you (or has anyone else here) ever tried one on the other end? I've been reading about them and similar mics - seems John Spiers uses something similar - and I'm thinking that two of them might be a good solution, assuming of course that they'll work just as well at the other end.

I've done the same thing with these "acoustic music" nights (can you get non-acoustic music?).  What I've found is that PA setups and sound people are very variable.  Even the best know about guitars, but not much else.

I would be inclined to use the stand mike since you at least have some control, you can you away from it, and at least it is something they are already familiar with.  They're confused enough already by the melodeon without throwing other stuff their way.

I just get up there, sit down and stick the microphone above the box, midway between the two ends, tootle a bit for the sound person and then start.  Is the sound always perfect?  No, but then again it will never be.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on December 20, 2007, 09:38:24 PM
So here's the plan - I'm going to buy one Opus 62, try it out on each end and if both seem to work I'll buy another one.

I think all the arguments in favour of mics on stands really just come down to personal choice. I prefer to stand, to be able to move around and I DEFINATELY want both ends of the box to be amplified (I've never really found the melodeon's inability to play a C-sharp-minor-7 to be too much of a limitation  :P).

Thanks again for all the input, and I'll keep you posted on how things work out.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 20, 2007, 11:53:57 PM
I must be they only person in the world who is happy with his Microvox setup.

No you're not - mine give no trouble.  I have them permanently mounted rather than Velcro'd on, so that may make them more reliable.  I used to use an AKG C409 - excellent sound quality but the mounting clips are rubbish; after the third one broke I went back to the Microvox, which is much less prone to damage. As long as you use decent quality leads and plugs and give the contacts an occasional clean they're fine.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on December 21, 2007, 12:04:41 AM
And ..... if you are going to be moving around, for Pete (of Ebor?)'s sake look into getting some kind of radio setup. They're fairly inexpensive and can save you tripping up and damaging your box.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on December 21, 2007, 12:07:28 AM
And ..... if you are going to be moving around, for Pete (of Ebor?)'s sake look into getting some kind of radio setup. They're fairly inexpensive and can save you tripping up and damaging your box.

I'll add it to the Christmas list. ;o)
Next year maybe.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Open_G on December 21, 2007, 05:30:32 PM
And ..... if you are going to be moving around, for Pete (of Ebor?)'s sake look into getting some kind of radio setup. They're fairly inexpensive and can save you tripping up and damaging your box.

And you can go out front and have a listen -but for the local dog's sake, stay away from the speaker cabs ( and why, oh why do callers think that telling me "it sounds a bit boomy" is any help at all? or my personal favourite in empty sports halls- "can you get rid of that echo?" )
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Mike Gott on December 21, 2007, 06:45:56 PM
The tie-clip mic has certainly worked well for me. However - a cautionary tale.......

We were setting up to play at a ceilidh in Scunthorpe. I had a tie clip mic fitted to a 1-row which I had on a fairly long strap which meant that the melodeon was held fairly low down on my body. I'd successfully sound checked and the banjo player - who best remain anonymous - stepped in front of me to sound check his instrument into a mic. He lent slightly forward to do this, and as he did so he, er, broke wind rather violently (we'd all been for a curry earlier). Unfortunately at the moment he did so the mic on my melodeon was only a few inches from the back of his trousers and it picked up and amplified the lot, just as the audience were trooping into the hall...

Mike
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on December 22, 2007, 09:09:12 AM
We were setting up to play at a ceilidh in Scunthorpe.

Wahay! Scunthorpe!
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Gus V on December 27, 2007, 05:14:33 PM
I found this:
http://www.akg.com/site/products/powerslave,id,981,pid,981,nodeid,2,_language,EN.html (http://www.akg.com/site/products/powerslave,id,981,pid,981,nodeid,2,_language,EN.html)
while idly surfing AKG's site one day. The part that jumped out at me was that it is apparently designed for accordions. If you look at the User Manual it has suggestion tips for putting it on a box (a piano box, but it's close enough here). I know that Squeezy uses something similar, does anyone have any experience with this model?
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Bill Young on December 27, 2007, 05:39:40 PM
I found this:
http://www.kdingo.net/champ/pics/main.php?g2_itemId=4020 (http://www.kdingo.net/champ/pics/main.php?g2_itemId=4020)
while idly surfing AKG's site one day.
Wrong link, perhaps? Doesn't seem to have anything to do with mics / accordions.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Gus V on December 27, 2007, 07:48:53 PM
oops, sorry. Fixed it.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on December 27, 2007, 09:47:13 PM
I found this:
http://www.akg.com/site/products/powerslave,id,981,pid,981,nodeid,2,_language,EN.html (http://www.akg.com/site/products/powerslave,id,981,pid,981,nodeid,2,_language,EN.html)
while idly surfing AKG's site one day. The part that jumped out at me was that it is apparently designed for accordions. If you look at the User Manual it has suggestion tips for putting it on a box (a piano box, but it's close enough here). I know that Squeezy uses something similar, does anyone have any experience with this model?

I think I noticed these too when I was browsing for mics. It looks similar to the Opus 62 I've ordered, except the Opus 62 doesn't need phantom power.

I like the fact that this one has an attachment you screw to the instrument, and then slot the mic into that, so they'd be easy to put on and take off. I'm hoping to come up with something similar for the Opus 62. They have clips suitable for attaching them to brass instruments, so I thought maybe I could screw a couple of suitable things onto my box that I could clip them onto. Seems like I might get away with not making any extra holes too -

On the bass side I plan to remove the lower front foot and use the same screw to replace it with something that the clip can attach to (obviously something which is ok to be touching the floor when I put the melodeon down) and on the top of the treble side, right at the corner, near the grill, there's an extra button for sticking the bellows strap to when playing (which I never use), so should be able to use that hole and screw there. That seems like it'd get the mics in the right places. Of course this is all just theory since I'm still waiting for the mic to arrive. When it does and I've checked the sound I'll go and have a rummage through the hardware at a DIY store - heavy picture-hanging brackets and the like - and let you know if I find anything suitable and if it works.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Howard Jones on December 28, 2007, 11:56:25 AM
I found this:
http://www.akg.com/site/products/powerslave,id,981,pid,981,nodeid,2,_language,EN.html (http://www.akg.com/site/products/powerslave,id,981,pid,981,nodeid,2,_language,EN.html)
while idly surfing AKG's site one day. The part that jumped out at me was that it is apparently designed for accordions. If you look at the User Manual it has suggestion tips for putting it on a box (a piano box, but it's close enough here). I know that Squeezy uses something similar, does anyone have any experience with this model?

This looks like a replacement for the C416, which doesn't seem to be listed on AKG's site any longer.  You can either use phantom power (with an adaptor) or a battery pack.

I've been very pleased with the C416, except that they don't seem particularly robust for a mic designed for stage use.  I've broken two - one when it got caught in the lead and broke the plastic barrel, and the second when the plastic spring which clips into the mount on the instrument broke from fatigue.  My insurance paid out both times, though.

The C516 has a slightly different mount, so maybe this will be less vulnerable.

The mount for the C416 can be screwed onto the instrument, but they also supply some sticky "putty", which works fine and can be removed without damaging the instrument.  Unfortunately, AKG only supply one mounting bracket, and getting more of these out of them seems to be next to impossible, so if you want to use it on more than one instrument you've got a problem. 

Squeezy uses a similar model (I forget the number) which is the same mic but with a spring clamp rather than the mounting bracket.  This is easier to switch between instruments, but assumes you've something to clamp it to - my instrument doesn't have anywhere suitable and I didn't want to have to butcher the box to fit something.

For the bass end, I've followed Andy Cutting's suggestion of a Tandy PZM unscrewed from it's base plate and fitted inside the case. A 1/4" jack socket fits neatly into one of the soundholes.  Unfortunately Tandy PSMs are no longer made, but they sometimes come up on Ebay.

Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on January 03, 2008, 08:28:21 AM
Update: the first Opus 62 arrived. I tried it out on each end of the melodeon through my PC and through a guitar amp. The sound seemed pretty good so I've ordered a second one.

So now another question - does anybody know of anything I can get that has 2 XLR inputs that I can control the volumes for independently and that then has one 1/4" output so that from a soundman's perspective it'll just be like plugging in a guitar? This seems like a better option than just handing over the XLR cables, partly so I can adjust the balance of the two mics myself, and partly because the cables don't detach at the mic end, so I can't "unplug" myself.

Radio setups were mentioned. This could be a possibility if anyone knows of one I can plug the 2 XLRs into and that isn't too expensive (since buying the two mics has caused me to slightly run out of money).

Oh and a note on the attaching-to-the-melodeon side of things - as mentioned previously my melodeon has one of those extra buttons for attaching the bellows strap to, to keep it out of the way. I found that when the strap is attached to this, the microphone clips onto it and sits in the right place very conveniently, as illustrated. For testing purposes on the bass side I attached the mic low down on the bass strap. It worked and stayed out of the way of the hand, but some movement would be innevitable so this probably isn't ideal. I'll try to figure something else out.

(http://img32.picoodle.com/img/img32/4/1/2/f_micpicm_75d06e7.jpg)

Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Theo on January 03, 2008, 09:13:13 AM
So now another question - does anybody know of anything I can get that has 2 XLR inputs that I can control the volumes for independently and that then has one 1/4" output so that from a soundman's perspective it'll just be like plugging in a guitar? This seems like a better option than just handing over the XLR cables, partly so I can adjust the balance of the two mics myself, and partly because the cables don't detach at the mic end, so I can't "unplug" myself.

From the soundmands point of view:

Stick with XLR, most mixing desks use xlr connectors for mic inputs.  Guitar inputs with jack connectors generally have different electrical characteristics, so your mics will have the best match to the input of the mixing desk if you stick with xlr

Don't try to find a box to combine the two mic leads.  The soundman is in a much better position than you to judge the balance between your two inputs.  Its also one less bit of kit to go wrong.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 03, 2008, 09:34:57 AM
Speaking with my soundman's hat on, I entirely agree with Theo. You (or someone!) will not only need to determine the balance between the mics, but they'll also need quite different EQ, and it's MUCH easier and better all round to leave that to the soundperson. 

Incidentally, if someone presents me with a jack lead/socket, it goes into a DI box to give me a balanced XLR input to the desk; converting your mic output (which I presume is a balanced signal) to an unbalanced jack would just be adding unnecessary complications and, more importantly, compromising the quality of your signal.

Graham
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: IanD on January 12, 2008, 04:07:35 PM
If you swap between boxes which are significantly different volume (like I do) a stand mic on the treble end means that you can play closer or further away to equalise the volume -- in my case about a foot for the Oakwood, 9" for the 3-row Dony, 6" for the G/C Tommy.

I use a clip-on mic on a short gooseneck for the bass end which clips to the bottom of the strap so it's easy to swap over, and is always a consistent distance from the box (unlike a stand mic, which almost invariably leads to feedback problems as well because it can't be close enough with bass end movement).

JTS CX508  http://tinyurl.com/2ctxpv

It does need phantom power from the desk (XLR connector), but then there's no battery to go flat.

If you don't swap boxes and can find something on the box to fasten it onto I suspect this would also work for the treble end.

Ian
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on January 14, 2008, 02:47:58 PM
Thanks for the most recent batch of information.

Last Saturday I played my first amped-up gig with the two Opus 62's and was generally pleased. As suggested I just plugged the two XLR's straight into the mixing desk. We didn't actually have a soundman, and there wasn't much time for a soundcheck, so i didn't get any time to fiddle with EQ, just left it on medium and adjusted the levels of the two ends. It didn't sound too bad, but hopefully with a proper soundman or some more time to play with the settings it could be better.

I now definately, definately want some sort of wireless radio setup. Whilst not having to play into mics on stands gave me some degree of freedom to stomp around the stage a bit, I was having a little trouble with tripping over my wires, and with getting them tangled when picking up, putting down, and taking off one of the mics to use it on my fiddle (which it also sounded very nice on). So, can anybody recommend anything? The only wireless kit I've found so far is either specifically designed for guitar, with just one jack input, or comes with a mic attached to it. I need something I can plug both my XLR's into. Any ideas??
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: oldclubII on January 14, 2008, 03:14:53 PM
There is a guy across the Channel who might be able to help with sound issues (perhaps you know him already):
Bernard Loffet (http://www.diato.org/sonoacce.htm)

Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on January 14, 2008, 03:19:30 PM
I just found this:

http://www.kksound.com/dualchannel.html

Please correct me if I'm wrong (as I'm sure I probably am) but it seems like this might be really handy. I can plug my two mics into it (I've got XLR-jack adapters for them) there's independent EQ controls for the two channels inside which I can get right at home which will solve problems like the last gig when there's no soundman, and no time for setting EQ on the board, and it has a line level jack output so should be compatible with plugging in like a guitar at open mic nights and possibly using a guitar-style wireless system with it?

If I'm right about all that then it seems like a good buy. If I'm not then do please tell me why. (Don't worry about making me feel stupid.)  :)
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Theo on January 14, 2008, 03:32:16 PM
But you don't need a preamp!  See most recent post by GPS which applies here too.   Forget about jacks.  You now have balanced XLR connectors which are superior.  When I was completely green and buying my first sound system I was fortunate to be advised by Sounds Live (http://www.soundslive.co.uk/) in Newcastle who made it abundantly clear that where there is a choice between jack and XLR connectors that I should avoid jacks.

And, if you don't have time for a soundcheck, a two into one box is only giving you the illusion of EQ/balance  'cos you still can't hear what you sound like from out front.



Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: oldclubII on January 14, 2008, 03:35:30 PM
It looks like it has 1/4-in jacks for the inputs so if your mics have XLR plugs you will need adapters and the signal won't be balanced. The output is also using 1/4-in jacks and doesn't seem balanced either.

Not much of a problem for short cables but it does not look "up-to-date" technically, usually pro-level stuff uses XLR. Judging by the absence of XLR connectors it seems that this box is made for instruments (guitars, keyboards) and not microphones. 

Besides, you would have this box clipped to your belt, which would connect to a wireless box, both with a battery. Twice as many worries that something may go wrong!
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on January 14, 2008, 03:40:15 PM
There is a guy across the Channel who might be able to help with sound issues (perhaps you know him already):
Bernard Loffet (http://www.diato.org/sonoacce.htm)



Thanks for the link. I wasn't aware of this chap. Looks like he makes really nice instruments too. The pickup system looks really slick. Two things about it: 1. It's installed in the melodeon 2. It has two independent outputs. Now if I were in a position where I was certain I was sticking with the melodeon I had long-term, and also I was playing gigs with a good soundman etc. I'd consider these really good points, and if I'm ever in that situation I may look at this system in the future.

Trouble is I'm currently in a position where I'm not sure how long I'll be sticking with my current instrument, and a lot of the gigs I'll be playing in the foreseeable future are going to be along the lines of "here's our PA system, do what you can with it". Plus I just bought those two mics so I want to give them a chance first.  ;) So what I'm looking for at the moment is something that gives me a bit of control myself and that can be moved from instrument to instrument.  ???
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on January 14, 2008, 03:42:13 PM
I should perhaps confess at this point that I don't know what "balanced" means. I'll try to find something on the internet that'll tell me..
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: oldclubII on January 14, 2008, 03:46:07 PM
In a nutshell, a "balanced" connection means that the signal is carried using 3 wires and a noise-suppression technique that cancels any interference that may be picked-up by the cables. In other words: clean sound. All pro sound equipment uses XLR balanced connections.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on January 14, 2008, 03:48:14 PM
In a nutshell, a "balanced" connection means that the signal is carried using 3 wires and a noise-suppression technique that cancels any interference that may be picked-up by the cables. In other words: clean sound. All pro sound equipment uses XLR balanced connections.


Righto. Thanks for that.  :)
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 14, 2008, 03:54:14 PM
Twice as many worries that something may go wrong!


Quite right, except that I think it would be more than twice as likely though.  All those extra leads, boxes and adapters. If something can go wrong, it *will* go wrong.

Here's an article explaining the balanced/unbalanced connections thing:

http://www.roadogz.com/stories/downunder/seriouslyunbalanced.htm

If you're playing professionally (or a sensible amateur) you should have backup mics and leads as well.

Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on January 14, 2008, 04:13:42 PM
Right, I hereby promise I'll now stay well away from anything involving:
*jack connections
*EQ conrols
*combining the two mic outputs

So that pre-amp thing's right out.

Having established that, can anybody reccomend anything I can use to go wireless? Are there any systems capable of sending two signals or am I going to have to buy two seperate ones, one for each mic, that transmit on different frequencies? Or are there reasons why I should stay well away from wireless things as well? Some people recommended it earlier in the thread...
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Clive Williams on January 14, 2008, 05:00:56 PM
Or are there reasons why I should stay well away from wireless things as well? Some people recommended it earlier in the thread...

Well... if you ever play at festivals/large gigs, you may find the sound guys won't let you use a wireless setup, because of the merry fun interference with other people's wireless setups (and indeed local taxi companies!) causes. I've played at a festival which has 10 (count them!) folk dance tents, all of them amplified, and all of them very close to each other. Wireless is an absolute no-no. So if you do go wireless, and it's very convenient I'll grant you, make sure you have a wired backup system - you don't always know what environment you'll be playing in.

Cheers,

Clive

Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Clive Williams on January 14, 2008, 05:05:24 PM
There is a guy across the Channel who might be able to help with sound issues (perhaps you know him already):
Bernard Loffet (http://www.diato.org/sonoacce.htm)



Trouble is I'm currently in a position where I'm not sure how long I'll be sticking with my current instrument, and a lot of the gigs I'll be playing in the foreseeable future are going to be along the lines of "here's our PA system, do what you can with it". Plus I just bought those two mics so I want to give them a chance first.  ;) So what I'm looking for at the moment is something that gives me a bit of control myself and that can be moved from instrument to instrument.  ???

Still worth having a chat with him for advice - he's a really good bloke, and knows the subtleties of miking up melodeons probably better than anyone, being an expert in both melodeons and sound systems. He speaks good English too. Oh, and he's a *fantastic* player.

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on January 14, 2008, 05:16:00 PM

Oh, and he's a *fantastic* player.


No argument there - to soothe myself whilst learning about the complexities of melodeon amplification I've been listening to his "Extraits sonores". The playing and the instruments both sound really lovely.

Good point about the wireless Clive - suppose it's a compromise between the hassle of wires to get tangled up in and the hassle of getting and using the equipment to get rid of them. To be fair at my last gig I'd plugged the mics directly into the PA and the wires weren't quite as long as might be desirable. For next time I think I'll get some XLR cables, plug those into the PA and gaffa tape the other end to the floor roughly where I'll be standing. That'll give me a sort of "anchor point" and a little circle of movement where I'll hopefully not get in too much of a tangle.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Theo on January 14, 2008, 06:14:40 PM
To be fair at my last gig I'd plugged the mics directly into the PA and the wires weren't quite as long as might be desirable.

Another advantage of XLR is that the cables are always male at one end female at the other, so you if your cable is not long enough just plug in to another one to extend the length.  I find it is quite helpful to tuck a loop of cable into my belt.  It stops the cable swinging around from the instrument, and gives a bit of safety slack in case I accidentally put tension on the cable.  Sticking the cable to the floor is not something I would do,  defeats the purpose of having an instrument mic so you can move around! >:(
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: oldclubII on January 14, 2008, 06:23:19 PM
Another important point is to buy the best quality cables you can afford. For durability, and also sound quality.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Luke Hillman on May 11, 2020, 12:04:26 AM
Paul, I've stumbled on this thread about 13 years too late. I see from your excellent videos on YouTube that you've found several mic setups that work well for you. I'm starting off now almost exactly as you described in your original post: I want something minimally complicated; don't want to have to deal with all kinds of supporting peripherals if I don't have to; don't want to make permanent modifications to my instrument; willing to spend a bit but less is better. Main use case will be recording at home.

Do you have current recommendations for a simple double mic setup?
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Paul Young on May 11, 2020, 08:54:08 AM
Hello Luke. I just had a surprising email reminding me that this thread exists. Thanks to everyone who patiently explained things to idiotic 2007 Paul. :)

Two clip-on condenser mics work well. I currently use two Audio Technica Pro 35s, one clipped to the bass strap and one stuck to the treble end with a little bit of industrial Velcro. I've also used the Shure Beta 98 which has the advantage of a long enough goose neck that the treble end one can be clipped onto your bellows. I'd seen French players doing this. Not sure if over time that might harm the bellows at all, but it always seemed fine.

For recording at home I sometimes use large diaphragm condenser mics on stands in stead. Currently having the best results using a mic on a stand for the treble end and the usual clip on for the bass. The stand mics I use are nothing special or fancy - cheap and cheerful Thomann own brand mics.
Title: Re: Need some basic info on pickups please
Post by: Luke Hillman on May 12, 2020, 04:54:38 AM
Thanks so much, Paul; I'm glad to be able to benefit from your decade-plus of experience since the original post. Not often you can reply to a thread this old and get a response at all, let alone a useful one from OP :)

This was exactly the kind of recommendation I needed. I'll give the Pro 35 a shot. I've borrowed a USB condenser mic I can experiment with, too, and go from there. Thanks again; hope you're doing well.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal