Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: LeFonque on June 11, 2009, 01:30:19 PM
-
I am seeking advice as to what the differences between a Gaillard and a Loffet.
I have a Loffet pro but I am interested in what other more experienced than I can tell me regarding the boxes.
I love my Loffet but I also hear good things about the Gaillard. I have never seen a Gaillard in the flesh only heard some clips of the music or on youtube.
Its a little hard to find a lot of information on Bertrand Gaillard boxes but I know they are held in great esteem a worth the wait. What are the price comparisons between the two makers.
I seek the collective wisdom from others on this forum. Thinking about selling my Soprani and Honer to start saving for a Gaillard.
Any help appreciated.
-
Question: if you love the box you have, why start hankering about something you've never tried? Money burning a hole in your pocket? Yeah, me too ;)
Obviously you want to hear from someone who has played or preferably owned both makes for some time. All I've done is briefly tried boxes of both makers while visiting their workshops a couple of years ago. Plus more recently I got to play a 3-v Gaillard for a few hours that belonged to a friend of a friend.
The Gaillards feel very precise - much more so than anything else I've tried. A bit like driving a very expensive sports car. I liked Loffet's Graet e Breizh instruments although I found the feel of the buttons a little strange.
After my visit and a bit of humming and hawing, I decided to order a Gaillard 21-button 2-v 12-bass model with a wait of 2 years (almost over, drool drool). For a roughly equivalent Graet e Breizh, Bernard Loffet quoted me E300 less with a 3-month wait (which may have been optimistic based on others' experience). For a few weeks I thought I'd get one of each but thankfully snapped out of that in time.
As to objective differences: Loffet's boxes are made for him in Italy except for those in Graet e Breizh line, which he produces in conjunction with a cabinet maker, who makes the bodies while Bernard does the reedwork.
Gaillard's boxes are all made in his own shop, although he uses an outside tuner. He has the mechanisms made in Italy to his own design - laser cut - and the grilles made by a shop somewhere in France. He uses Binci reeds and leather valves. For the latest prices you should drop Bertrand a line and he'll email or fax you back a price list.
Edited to add the following which I posted on the old forum in 2007 ( see http://melodeon.aimoo.com/melodeon-net/Box-builders-in-Brittany-Berna-1-230439.html for a couple of replies).
Holidaying in Brittany last month I made a point of arranging to visit two prominent French makers - Bertrand Gaillard and Bernard Loffet. Well Bertrand Gaillard is actually in Loire-Atlantique but historically the village NW of Nantes where he lives was in Brittany (I think).
Anyway I was given a very pleasant welcome by both. Bertrand Gaillard is the quieter of the two men, which sits well with his style - working mainly on his own, making a small number of highly prized boxes each year. He offers four basic models, from a 21-button 2-voice to a 33-button 3-voice, with a quite a lot of choices in some elements, such as how many basses and registers you want. But if you want a wood other than American walnut or a different design of grille, well don't waste your breath asking! He does all the woodwork (he trained as a cabinet maker before turning his hand to accordions) and final assembly, but sends the reedwork out to one trusted collaborator, and has the bellows and all the metal parts made in Italy to his own design. He doesn't care for plastic valves and uses only carefully selected leather - he said that he discards practically 1 out of every 2 valves! His boxes sound and feel magnificent and it is easy to see why they are so sought-after - the current wait is two years.
Bernard Loffet is in Brittany proper, a few miles outside Lorient, home to the famous festival. His very attractive shop - looking exactly like the photo on his website - is bursting with accordions. I was interested mainly in his "Graet e Breizh" line, which are a newish addition to his range, made entirely in Brittany (unlike other boxes bearing the Loffet logo, which are produced for him in Italy). In this case it's a local cabinet maker who is the outside collaborator, with all the reedwork and tuning being done in Bernard's shop. I liked these boxes a lot. They didn't have quite the same Rolls-Royce look or feel as Bertrand Gaillard's instruments, but they played very handily and the tuning (particularly the style Bernard calls "demi-swing attenué") was exquisite. They cost a few hundred Euros less than equivalent Gaillard models and currently the waiting time is from three to six months.
I tried a few of his other boxes and even briefly a Hohner Morgane that was sitting there, but Graet e Breizh had a little something extra. Bernard was more than happy to demonstrate their possibilities (he's a very fine player) and talk for as long as I wanted. I hope that an accordion from one (both might be too much to hope for) of these very fine and likeable gentlemen may one day end up in my hands, but in the meantime I hope this has been of interest - something to take your minds off floods and droughts, perhaps. Cheers Steve
Edited to make text reappear!
-
Where are you based LeFonque? I've a gaillard 2v in Ireland if you want to try it. Not for sale but probably best way for you to tell difference is to play both yourself
-
Where are you based LeFonque? I've a gaillard 2v in Ireland if you want to try it. Not for sale but probably best way for you to tell difference is to play both yourself
Thanks for the offer I live in Melbourne Australia. I guess that is a little far.
-
Question: if you love the box you have, why start hankering about something you've never tried? Money burning a hole in your pocket? Yeah, me too ;)
Obviously you want to hear from someone who has played or preferably owned both makes for some time. All I've done is briefly tried boxes of both makers while visiting their workshops a couple of years ago. Plus more recently I got to play a 3-v Gaillard for a few hours that belonged to a friend of a friend.
The Gaillards feel very precise - much more so than anything else I've tried. A bit like driving a very expensive sports car. I liked Loffet's Graet e Breizh instruments although I found the feel of the buttons a little strange.
After my visit and a bit of humming and hawing, I decided to order a Gaillard 21-button 2-v 12-bass model with a wait of 2 years (almost over, drool drool). For a roughly equivalent Graet e Breizh, Bernard Loffet quoted me €300 less with a 3-month wait (which may have been optimistic based on others' experience). For a few weeks I thought I'd get one of each but thankfully snapped out of that in time.
As to objective differences: Loffet's boxes are made for him in Italy except for those in Graet e Breizh line, which he produces in conjunction with a cabinet maker, who makes the bodies while Bernard does the reedwork.
Gaillard's boxes are all made in his own shop, although he uses an outside tuner. He has the mechanisms made in Italy to his own design - laser cut - and the grilles made by a shop somewhere in France. He uses Binci reeds and leather valves. For the latest prices you should drop Bertrand a line and he'll email or fax you back a price list.
Edited to add the following which I posted on the old forum in 2007 ( see http://melodeon.aimoo.com/melodeon-net/Box-builders-in-Brittany-Berna-1-230439.html for a couple of replies).
Holidaying in Brittany last month I made a point of arranging to visit two prominent French makers - Bertrand Gaillard and Bernard Loffet. Well Bertrand Gaillard is actually in Loire-Atlantique but historically the village NW of Nantes where he lives was in Brittany (I think).
Anyway I was given a very pleasant welcome by both. Bertrand Gaillard is the quieter of the two men, which sits well with his style - working mainly on his own, making a small number of highly prized boxes each year. He offers four basic models, from a 21-button 2-voice to a 33-button 3-voice, with a quite a lot of choices in some elements, such as how many basses and registers you want. But if you want a wood other than American walnut or a different design of grille, well don't waste your breath asking! He does all the woodwork (he trained as a cabinet maker before turning his hand to accordions) and final assembly, but sends the reedwork out to one trusted collaborator, and has the bellows and all the metal parts made in Italy to his own design. He doesn't care for plastic valves and uses only carefully selected leather - he said that he discards practically 1 out of every 2 valves! His boxes sound and feel magnificent and it is easy to see why they are so sought-after - the current wait is two years.
Bernard Loffet is in Brittany proper, a few miles outside Lorient, home to the famous festival. His very attractive shop - looking exactly like the photo on his website - is bursting with accordions. I was interested mainly in his "Graet e Breizh" line, which are a newish addition to his range, made entirely in Brittany (unlike other boxes bearing the Loffet logo, which are produced for him in Italy). In this case it's a local cabinet maker who is the outside collaborator, with all the reedwork and tuning being done in Bernard's shop. I liked these boxes a lot. They didn't have quite the same Rolls-Royce look or feel as Bertrand Gaillard's instruments, but they played very handily and the tuning (particularly the style Bernard calls "demi-swing attenué") was exquisite. They cost a few hundred Euros less than equivalent Gaillard models and currently the waiting time is from three to six months.
I tried a few of his other boxes and even briefly a Hohner Morgane that was sitting there, but Graet e Breizh had a little something extra. Bernard was more than happy to demonstrate their possibilities (he's a very fine player) and talk for as long as I wanted. I hope that an accordion from one (both might be too much to hope for) of these very fine and likeable gentlemen may one day end up in my hands, but in the meantime I hope this has been of interest - something to take your minds off floods and droughts, perhaps. Cheers Steve
Yep you got it money does burn a hole in my pocket, even money I don't have yet.
Great heads up on the differences. What started my interest in the Gaillard was seeing Yann-Fanch Perroches youtube it sounded so sweet but when hearing quality players I am never sure if it is the box or the player that makes it sound so good. I was thinking of moving the Paolo on which is a B/C and I am settling on G/C. Therefore extra cash tempted me into thinking it would make a good start to a new box, hence the question. Thats me, I started with one Harley Davidson now I have three. I am always thinking of my next project sounds sick doesn't it.
-
[/quote]
Thanks for the offer I live in Melbourne Australia. I guess that is a little far.
[/quote]
Why not try Stormy Hyde - a little nearer to you and the boxes have a great reputation. I think you'd find the prices would be very competive as well.
Simon
-
If you really do have money burning a hole in your pocket, just buy whatever you want and be done with it. Move on. (:)
Thanks for the encouragement I will move on! FIGJAM
-
Why not try Stormy Hyde - a little nearer to you and the boxes have a great reputation. I think you'd find the prices would be very competive as well.
oohh they are pretty boxes(texas rose looks nice *drools*).....*slaps back of hand* naughty...I have stop looking at what I can't afford...plus i'm too impatient...any longer than 6months and i'd be climbing the walls.
-
Stormy does make a nice box and he is a great guy to deal with I had some discussion with him late last year. Good old Salt.
-
The basic differnce between Loffet and Gaillard has already been mentioned
Gaillard actually makes his accordions, Loffet has the Chassis made on the Breizh models in Brittany
All of the rest of his models are made in Italy and not just the hardware and mechanics
Kinda like a banjo assembler... who makes necks and fits all the bits made b others.
Not knocking it,you do what you can and sub the rest, best of both worlds
But I do prefer a box made by the box maker
S to Hyde
I never have played on of his boxes but they look a little precious to me
I tried to order one from him but he was so hung up on the aesthetics and not the mechanics I gave up...
what is so difficult about
" I don't care what wood you use but please don't put your name on the front of the box"
That didn't fly.
-
Comments have been really helpful.
I guess I know a little more that may help my future direction. Have been feeling a little guilty that in these tough economic times my thoughts have been on another box.
I thought about how many dollars over two years waiting period for a Gaillard I could get together, not sure if doing the maths is to alleviate any feelings of guilt. (Thinks)Should I just be satisfied with my current boxes, although my Soprani is silently sitting in its case for over 4 months with no signs of movement.(Thinks) Maybe I am the only one that lives with this type of dilemma.
I will contact Bertrand re prices.
What does the old book say about an two minded man being unstable in all his ways?
Thanks especially to those who have given in depth comment and related their personal experiences.
-
Just got my Gaillard (see other thread) 8) I've played Loffets at French festivals, and recall him saying he didn't actually make them. They were good, if 'standard' boxes, nice voice. Bertrand Gaillard is a slightly obsessive type, who as far as I can tell strives for perfection at all times. A bit like our own dear Colin Dipper it seems he only does impecable work. He is very businesslike. Yes, the comparison with a top sports car was a good one.
My new box is lovely to touch, the finish is perfect, even the straps are more comfortable than other peoples! It's a bit 'square' but the size of the structure probably helps enrich the sound. Keys are quite the fastest I've ever run my fingers over and need very little travel to play a note. The air hole gulps it in like a surfacing whale. Its voicing is the sweetest I've come across and plays true as a nut from very loud down to ... nothing. It can even bend a note!
The 18 bass is really clever and has all notes in both directions. See my post in the other Gaillard thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1652.msg18223.html#msg18223). I took that 'as is' but right end is own layout based on my previous C#DG. I got a definite sense Bertrand though me mad! It set me back €4500, including quite expensive delivery/insurance. Probably a tad more now, though the price you order at is what you'll pay.
Yes, he really does take two years (more or less exactly) to make them. Bertrand does 90% of his trade at St Chartier festival, takes a second deposit next year, and delivers at the third. But he actually starts on your reed block at the time of the order, which is why you have to pay those 2 x 25% deposits. The only sure way to get a Gaillard is to follow that route and wait the 2 years. OK you might get lucky on Ebay, but I suspect 98% of his work is with original owner, which is perhaps another recommendation? D3R
PS ladydetemps (below) (or is it S.Hyde?) is quite right. IMHO Gaillard makes the best boxes in the World (Norbert has the same view) and is quite proud of that. No name = no deal is probably realistic. I don't think they're precious though. The Music Room would sell a second hand Oakwood for nearly what I paid, and Bertand's work is significantly better (I have both). But there are prettier boxes.
.. to get back on topic - BG has really good English (on the remote assumption that an Australian might not have passable French) ;D
-
S to Hyde
I never have played on of his boxes but they look a little precious to me
I tried to order one from him but he was so hung up on the aesthetics and not the mechanics I gave up...
what is so difficult about
" I don't care what wood you use but please don't put your name on the front of the box"
That didn't fly.
Oooh...hung up on astethtics....suits me fine. A box has got to be pretty for me. :) lol!
-
Just got my Gaillard (see other thread) 8) I've played Loffets at French festivals, and recall him saying he didn't actually make them. They were good, if 'standard' boxes, nice voice. Bertrand Gaillard is a slightly obsessive type, who as far as I can tell strives for perfection at all times. A bit like our own dear Colin Dipper it seems he only does impecable work. He is very businesslike. Yes, the comparison with a top sports car was a good one.
My new box is lovely to touch, the finish is perfect, even the straps are more comfortable than other peoples! It's a bit 'square' but the size of the structure probably helps enrich the sound. Keys are quite the fastest I've ever run my fingers over and need very little travel to play a note. The air hole gulps it in like a surfacing whale. Its voicing is the sweetest I've come across and plays true as a nut from very loud down to ... nothing. It can even bend a note!
The 18 bass is really clever and has all notes in both directions. See my post in the other Gaillard thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1652.msg18223.html#msg18223). I took that 'as is' but right end is own layout based on my previous C#DG. I got a definite sense Bertrand though me mad! It set me back €4500, including quite expensive delivery/insurance. Probably a tad more now, though the price you order at is what you'll pay.
Yes, he really does take two years (more or less exactly) to make them. Bertrand does 90% of his trade at St Chartier festival, takes a second deposit next year, and delivers at the third. But he actually starts on your reed block at the time of the order, which is why you have to pay those 2 x 25% deposits. The only sure way to get a Gaillard is to follow that route and wait the 2 years. OK you might get lucky on Ebay, but I suspect 98% of his work is with original owner, which is perhaps another recommendation? D3R
PS ladydetemps (below) (or is it S.Hyde?) is quite right. IMHO Gaillard makes the best boxes in the World (Norbert has the same view) and is quite proud of that. No name = no deal is probably realistic. I don't think they're precious though. The Music Room would sell a second hand Oakwood for nearly what I paid, and Bertand's work is significantly better (I have both). But there are prettier boxes.
.. to get back on topic - BG has really good English (on the remote assumption that an Australian might not have passable French) ;D
DROOL!!
-
I thought about how many dollars over two years waiting period for a Gaillard I could get together, not sure if doing the maths is to alleviate any feelings of guilt. (Thinks)Should I just be satisfied with my current boxes, although my Soprani is silently sitting in its case for over 4 months with no signs of movement.(Thinks) Maybe I am the only one that lives with this type of dilemma.
Not that I would encourage anyone to spend their hard-earned pennies foolishly, but...
There's no point in keeping an unplayed box. Better to move it on to someone who will appreciate it.
If you've got it into your head that you want a Gaillard, best to follow it through, or you'll always be wondering. If you decide to get one, you might find your Loffet is redundant...then you can move that one on too. On the other hand you might find you prefer the Loffet after all, in which case I'm sure you will have no difficulty moving on the Gaillard, and probably get back most of the price you paid for it. (Although I don't know what it costs to ship a box from Australia to the Rest of the World, and vice versa).
And believe me, you are by no means the only one living with this dilemma! ;)
-
Hello Mr. LeFonque....I have no real experience with either of these makers, but I am sure they are tops. For what it is worth, I have included a link to a clip of Finnish player Markku Lepisto visiting the shop of Bertrand Gaillard, accompanied by some of his playing. Perhaps you have already seen this, but if not, enjoy, and best of luck making a decision........best wishes, jwf
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZndS12I4vr0&feature=channel_page
-
I notice that Markku Lepisto plays a Casta, I wonder if he has order a Gaillard? The clip certainly makes you wonder.
-
I notice that Markku Lepisto plays a Casta, I wonder if he has order a Gaillard? The clip certainly makes you wonder.
The urge to shop knows no bounds........... :||:
-
Oooh...hung up on astethtics....suits me fine. A box has got to be pretty for me. :) lol!
[/quote]
He's not really hung up on the way a box looks - but he does a great service to those of us who want something specific in a box. This thread is really all about Gaillard and Loffet boxes - and not about Stormy Hyde's boxes, but as one who owns three of them, I think I'm qualified to state that all of them are amazing boxes to play - and not just to look at. They have lightening fast action and are tuned exactly the way I want them - to fit my playing style. I especially like the fact that each box is one of a kind - and there is not another one exactly like it. Every day, when I pick one of them up to play, a rush of good feelings comes over me - a bit of ecstacy. What more can one ask in a box?
Kay
-
I sent Bertrand an e-mail 2 days ago. I got a lightning response. Most helpful, yes there ink the is awo year wait. My mind is ticking over at a fast rate of knots.
By the way I the discussion re Stormy has been good. Kay certainly would know. I would want to put my two bobs worth. He makes a very good box. He extremely helpful and promptly follows through.
We all look for different things in box, to state the obvious what appeals to one doesn't hold the same attraction for another.
I am thankful for a forum like this that promotes healthy discussion about the different merits of different makers. We are fortunate to have such choices Bernard, Bertrand, Stormy and others all make good boxes and bring there skill and craftsmanship presenting many option for us.
This thread has been very useful to me in finding out from people who have the respective instruments as I have not had the opportunity to see a Gaillard in the flesh so to speak.
-
yes there ink the is awo year wait.
Pardon? ???
My mind is ticking over at a fast rate of knots.
Evidently... slow down a bit and we might be able to understand you ;D
-
yes there ink the is awo year wait.
Pardon? ???
My mind is ticking over at a fast rate of knots.
Evidently... slow down a bit and we might be able to understand you ;D
Attack of Sausage finger plus a very sensitive track pad on my eeepc.
Should read 'Yes, there is a two year wait'.
Strangely enough I often get an attack of sausage finger when I am playing my box. :-[
-
Please don't tell my wife. She is a school teacher and will keep me in after the lunch beel has gone!
-
"beel" don't you mean bell. Nearly finished my Masters Degree and I still can't spell, type use proper grammar. So much for the English school system in the 1950's-1970's.
-
There's the typo and there's a spelling mistake... not to mention grammar mangling! I wouldn't worry unduly...much of what's written on forums is writ like what its spoke.... :P ;D
-
I think that 'lunch beel' has a much better ring to it, don't you?
;D
AL
-
I think that 'lunch beel' has a much better ring to it, don't you?
;D
AL
i thought it was just typed with an accent ;)
-
I liked Loffet's Graet e Breizh instruments although I found the feel of the buttons a little strange.
I might have the answer to this.
I took delivery of a 3 row G/C Graet e Breizh about 3 months ago, and whilst it's absolutely superb in many ways, it felt heavy to play. After some weeks, although I thought I'd got used to it, my fingers were starting to hurt. I wondered if it was too heavily sprung, so with the help of a specially modified cardboard tube filled with assorted coins, I measured the weight needed to depress the keys on the treble end, then did the same for my Dony, Oakwood and Tommy. The Oakwood and Dony came out around 116gms, Tommy around 125gms, and the Loffet a staggering 195gms!
It has since undergone spring-bending surgery, and with the weight down to about 125gms, it plays like a dream!
I believe at least one other person on this forum owns, or has owned, a G e B, and I'd be interested to know what their experience was.
-
Got my Gaillard 10 days ago... Since the instrument database is no more, here's a pic of it.
Great box... but getting used to it. It's teaching me how it wants to be played.
-
nice box! how is it tuned?
-
Quotes of quotes and other bumf edited out Sorry chaps but I've not seen as much acreage of text as in parts of this thread ??? Do you not have a Delete key?
There's no point in keeping an unplayed box. Better to move it on to someone who will appreciate it.
Got four in my dining room/study at present, plus another with a young'n. One of the four is for sale - so I count three.
A problem came unexpectedly when someone posted a (fascinating) add your own bar, chinese whispers, make your own camel, tune writing thread. I just knew it'd head up and down the G scale in first position (as it has, but quite interestingly). But IMHO there's more to a D/G than that...
While I clearly wasn't going to carry the 'salon', I really fancied the challenge of moving on a theme that starts GABCD(twiddle) out of the standard G major scale. Continuation using Eb and F natural sounded nicest (=5th mode melodic C minor it seems). OK I'm weird.
A doddle on the Gaillard. But this 'boeuff' has got to be playable on a standard box with an Eb/F acccidental button. I've nowhere to test that ::) While my UK D/G Oakwood has these notes in correct directions, they are on two different buttons.
If you've got it into your head that you want a Gaillard, best to follow it through, or you'll always be wondering.
Ah, there's the 'rub'. It's said no one was ever sacked for buying IMB (not entirely true)! But in the same way the Gaillard second hand market is non existent (Andy's comment below noted). It's nothing to do with that 2 years - Bertrand has his own 'production line', and that's frankly how long he takes to make one.
So should you get the 'itch' you need to either go to St Chartier (easiest), or his workshop on the Loire. Try the beasts. Convince yourself there's nothing that could be improved in them. If at the festival - try 20 or so competition boxes - which will I'm afraid feel 'not up to scratch'.
You hand over your deposit and you wait. It's worth it. Gaillard's ain't cheap but he was very flexible. I gave Bertrand just €100 (all I had in my purse) and funded the balance by selling the old family mansion and moving to a flat two years later.
I kid you not! But trouble is - now I've nowhere to rack all these bloody melodeons ;D D4½M's
-
But in the same way the Gaillard second hand market is non existent.
That's not entirely accurate. I used to watch French second-hand box listings (several different sites) and there was often at least one Gaillard that was available. I don't recall all the sites now, but this is a good one to monitor if seeking used Gaillards, Castagnaris, etc.:
http://www.mustradem.com/annonces/public/consulterLesAnnonces.php3?type=ventes
In this case, the posting has been up for some time, but there are several other sites with listings like this.
-Andy
-
nice box! how is it tuned?
Dry, unfortunately. I had a long telephone conversation with Bertrand about what I wanted and we settled on what he called "swing fort" - a tad more tremolo than his standard issue tuning, which is swing.
The odd thing is, this is exactly what happened to a friend of mine in the NE US who got a 3-voice Gaillard a few years back. This too arrived dry as a bone, which he attributed to a communication problem, which I attributed to his not speaking French. Having discussed the matter at length with Bertrand, in French, I didn't expect this to happen to me. I can only assume his outside tuner has a blind spot with regard to Irish-tuned boxes.
I'm waiting for BG to get back to me as to what we can do about the problem. The box does sound lovely tuned dry - the absolute precision of the tuning is a novel experience, and not without its pleasures - but it's not what I want. Now here I am in Montreal while he's in Nantes, he invalidates his guarantee if the box is worked on by anyone he doesn't approve of, and I don't really want to spend money having it adjusted. Bit of a drag, really.
If you meant what system it is, it's C#/D, fourth-button "doh".
-
You'll probably never need to call the guarantee - (but who knows). Strangely Bertrand doesn't tune himself (he has 2 out workers for this) yet he has quite strong feelings on the matter. He tried hard to sell me to 'demi-swing' but I held fast on Bandonion. In a sense he was right. The fat reeds in low register are very dark. But the lovely swayable tone on low register over the upper keyboard is worth it. Strangely it's different from the octave-up reed set .. played an octave lower ???
With both gears engaged it's solid as a rock (3 octaves of C/G) and it would seem the higher register wakes up the low reeds up by a resonance. Great Bandonion feel (any lady here care to tango)?
As for your own over dry tuning - well the Great Exponent (and demonstrator for 20 years at St Chartier) of Guillard has been Norbert Pignol - who likes it bone dry. If Bertrand want to cling to his guarantee on tuning issues - email him and ask who his recommended tuner is in Canada. That puts the onus on him. You can suggest your local good fella if you want (it's only a tune FGS). I suspect shipping it back might be cheaper though. I wouldn't worry too much - basically he's a very straight fella. D3R
-
When I got my Gaillard, a few years back, I had been playing a Casta Dinn III, tuned tremolo italiano, so my when my new box arrived (swing-tuned), I liked the sound better, not to mention the action, but I now wish it were more on the real swing side (wetter). And it's a three voice ( a 3-voice tuned too dry doesn't make much sense). So maybe we need a Bertrand-approved tuner on this side of the Pond. It'd also be helpful if we knew exactly how many cents apart the reeds are tuned. That kind of info should arrive in writing with the box, to avoid misunderstandings. Just my two cents (haha).
Andre (I'll gladly give Bertrand a call regarding this, Steve).
-
I think he's just say that wetness of tuning is entirely a decision for his client.
Basically they are mostly bespoke with a few "French" or "système Milleret/Pignol" orders interspersed.
Chris
-
Correct that this thread was not about Hyde , however I responded to posts by Simon W and LeFonque
Just as Hohners and Gaillards and Beltunas and Castagnaris appeal to some .. they do not appeal to all smae goes for Hyde
I found attempting to order a plain box with simple tuning from Hyde was a near impossible effort..
Again.. real simple
I dont care what the wood is..
NO logo on the front
C#/ D with a tremolo just shy of swinng...
That did not fly. I gave up.
I am aware others "love" the Hyde accordions... a subjective matter of taste
And for all that own them, glad you like them.
-
I suspect shipping it back might be cheaper though.
Er, no. It cost me €307 to get it sent over here. For the price of shipping it there and back again, I could hop on a plane and take it there myself!
Thanks for the offer to call him Andrel... but I don't need an intermediary, and even if I did I don't think Bertrand would appreciate anyone else weighing in about it.
-
Steve, I was thinking more in terms of a friendly suggestion, since I am certain there are quite a few Gaillard owners on the North American continent. There has to be a solution (and I also had my own instrument in mind, if I need to have it retuned.) I know to are big enough to take care of yourself (:)
-
Agree- I'd guess that all you need to keep your guarantee is to use someone Bertrand has OK'd in advice, and I suspect he'd OK anyone properly 'professional' for a tuning adjustment. Fiddling with mechanisms might be a different matter - but bear in mind when negotiating that he doesn't tune himself.
As for Gaillard's English - it's good. I corresponded in French for a while but he came back in English and it was clear that on accordéons at least, his vocabulary and usage was well superior to mine in French. When it came to shipping there was the odd 'strange phrase' but nothing I couldn't decontextualise.
Where do you go from here? I guess whatever is cheapest. If it's any comfort - I got a Calabrian style organetto from f. Castagnari about 15 years ago to play Morris (both rows are in G)! It came tuned as wet as a ducks bottom.
I bit the bullet and got the Cleckheaton people to dry it out. Added about 10% to the cost, but I'd saved a lot more already by getting it direct from Sandro rather than in a shop. Caveat emptor, as they used to say in Italy. D3R
-
Andrel, sorry I got the wrong end of the stick. I'll call him myself if I don't get a reply to my email within the next few days - give him a chance to let the dust settle from St-Chartier. Chris, I'll take your word for it that BG has good English but he doesn't need it to communicate with me. Where I go from here will depend on what he has to say. I don't see why I should spend money getting the box tuned to what he and I settled upon, frankly. If we can't agree on getting it tuned locally I can take it back to him next time I'm in Nantes, probably next spring.
Funnily enough, at one point I fancied having "Dedic" or "Normand Miron" style tuning, which BG doesn't offer, so a friend suggested I get the box from Gaillard dry and have Normand tune it when it arrived. Normand talked me out of this, saying that he didn't like the idea of messing with the integrity of a new box from a top maker, and that I should explain what I wanted very clearly to BG instead! Ah well...
It's no catastrophe, anyway, it's not as if I hate the way the box sounds. Far better too dry than being in duck's posterior territory!
-
Apologies Steve for being too free with advice. If you get to central France regularly there's much less of a problem. I had visions of you 3000 km away with the wrong box. When my wet organetto came I defo didn't want the kike back to Italy. Already done that to pick up my Mori (it "wasn't ready", but no one had though to cancel advice to pick it up in May. But Italy is a bit like that and the Apennines were fun).
BG is so businesslike - I think he'll sort it.
-
Agreed, Chris, BG is extremely professional, and courteous, and a pleasure to deal with, and I wouldn't want my grumbles in this thread to suggest otherwise.
Perhaps I shouldn't have mentioned the matter at all, only a) I was asked and b) I remembered that the only other person in North America who has received a box from Bertrand whom I have met (Bob Abrams of New Hampshire) had the same experience. Frankly it's baffling.
But I still have a lovely little instrument and I hold its maker in very high regard.
-
Gaston Nolet of Quebec ordered and received a Gaillard 3 row in A/D/G a few years back.
He told me he ordered it with a fair amount of tremolo and it arrived nearly dry. He had it
retuned locally without expecting Gaillard to participate in the expense.
-
Gaston Nolet of Quebec ordered and received a Gaillard 3 row in A/D/G a few years back.He told me he ordered it with a fair amount of tremolo and it arrived nearly dry. He had it retuned locally without expecting Gaillard to participate in the expense.
Hmmm -we seem to be establishing a pattern here. Glad I ordered 'Bandonion' !
-
Just heard from BG, who has been on holiday. He writes that he did ask his tuner to tune my box with "swing fort" but that he is "not entirely surprised" by my complaint. ???
He says, among other things, that the problem is the lack of a universal reference as to what the various descriptions mean in terms of beats. It seems to me that the problem might be rather that his tuner does what she likes regardless of what the customer has asked for.
I'm not satisfied with Bertrand's answer, and will attempt to take the matter further with him, but won't report any developments here.
Anyway, any of you who have ordered or may order a Gaillard with anything other than a very dry swing - consider yourselves warned...
-
I would be satisfied with his answer as it seems honest and factual.
However I don't see any offer of correcting or accepting responsibility and that is unacceptable.
That, unfortunately, has been my experience with "hand builders".
Good luck.
-
That, unfortunately, has been my experience with "hand builders".
Come up and see me sometime. :-*
-
Hey sailor : )
I have ordered 3 hand built one offs over the years.... 1 Quebec and 2 Cajun
all three .... did not meet my very specific instructions, both spoken and written
Imagine tuning the right side ( treble) to just or "cajun" tuning and leaving the bass in 12 TET and have the maker tell youy it will "break in"....clueless
Or how about NO RED ANYWHERE ON THE ACCORDEON and the damn thing comes with embossed red script...
and NO WHITE ON THE STRAPS ... yup white on the straps,,,
How about 440 and plus a few cents
It arrives and the two middle sets are 5 low and 5 high
How about don;t mix light colored woods with dark... just one wood either maple or walnut
box comes walnut frams and maple inserts....
How about please.. dry tuning.. arrives Americano and 443 at that !
And in not one single case was the maker willing to accept responsibility.... none
that is a track record
And then there was my famous Mory order... though not "custom" it was still supposed to be per my request... naw... and one flake of a dealer......
tried to pass it on to Castagnari and Castagnari told my Italian born 83 year old tuiner and friend of the Castagnari family Americans are crazy and too picky
Ahhh yes then there is the latest fiasco
Ever try a German made Harmona bellows.. now that is a story
Should I offer a public service message ?????? Or keep my mouth shut ?
-
Whatever happened to the old addage "the customer is always right"?
Many years ago I reported to Castagnari that my customers were complaining that the bass block in the Lilly was catching on the inside of the bellows.
Their answer - "Tell them to play more gently" ???
-
That, unfortunately, has been my experience with "hand builders".
Come up and see me sometime. :-*
I can endorse Ree's excellent customer service! My Clipper exceeded my expectations - and a minor problem was resolved in the blink of an eye! (You can pay me later Rees)
Simon
-
Whatever happened to the old addage "the customer is always right"?
Has been replaced by a new maxim - 'The Customer is always right - until parted from their money'
AL ;)
-
Has been replaced by a new maxim - 'The Customer is always right - until parted from their money'
I am a dismayed to see the direction this thread appears to be taking, since comments like the last few are likely to have the effect of tarring Bertrand Gaillard with a brush he does not deserve.
The case regarding the tuning of my box is far from closed as far as I am concerned and I will be putting a number of suggestions to him for resolving my complaint and hopefully making sure that future customers don't suffer the same disappointments.
I have no other complaints regarding my dealings with BG - far from it. He makes it clear what features you can and cannot choose. He is very punctilious in his procedures, and has you review, correct, sign and return a keyboard layout to avoid any confusion. My exchanges with him regarding a number of aspects over the past two years, including delivery options, is that he is always ready to listen to suggestions and takes customer satisfaction very seriously.
So, friends, please avoid careless chatter that could damage a fine maker's justly deserved reputation for excellence.
-
I am a dismayed to see the direction this thread appears to be taking, since comments like the last few are likely to have the effect of tarring Bertrand Gaillard with a brush he does not deserve.
Yes, point taken Steve - although it does seem pretty obvious from this thread that there is an issue - and one of the reasons why a forum like this exists is so that members can exchange their views, experiences and opinions. And if, as seems likely from reading through this thread there is a problem then maybe someone (possbly from this forum) should point Monsieur Gaillard in this direction - surely that would be helpful?
My previous comment about customers only being right until parted from their money was a facetious and unnecessary comment and was a general observation - and in no way was it meant or aimed as a slur upon Ms. Gaillard. Mea Culpa!
AL
-
Thanks, Al.
-
I made no remarks about Gaillard except to pass on a factual circumstance with an accordeon sold to Gaston Nolet
Facts are facts
I think that if you didn't want others to make comments... perhaps you should not have brought it up.
-
I'm very glad you mentioned Gaston Nolet's experience, Jeff. What I didn't like was the thread drifting in a direction that suggested that hand builders generally - and by extension Gaillard - refuse to accept responsibility for ignoring customer's instructions, and ergo once they've got your money, tough luck if it's not what you ordered.
It seems to me that BG goes out of his way to make sure he has a documented, signed record of exactly what the customer wants. Evidently there is a recurrent issue with people getting less tremolo than they expect, and I'm going to suggest to him that he find a way of quantifying and documenting customer's instructions regarding this aspect too.
Cheers,
Steve
-
I'm very glad you mentioned Gaston Nolet's experience, Jeff. What I didn't like was the thread drifting in a direction that suggested that hand builders generally - and by extension Gaillard - refuse to accept responsibility for ignoring customer's instructions, and ergo once they've got your money, tough luck if it's not what you ordered.
It seems to me that BG goes out of his way to make sure he has a documented, signed record of exactly what the customer wants. Evidently there is a recurrent issue with people getting less tremolo than they expect, and I'm going to suggest to him that he find a way of quantifying and documenting customer's instructions regarding this aspect too.
Cheers,
Steve
I can understand having a definition problem between swing and swing-forte but to receive your accordion tuned dry when you ordered swing-forte seems much more like a mistake than a problem with definitions. His comments to you imply that the problem seems to be with his tuner not following his instructions....repeatedly.
-
Quick update: after a series of long and candid emails between me, M. Gaillard and his tuner, a solution has been arrived at. I am to send the r/h reedblocks to the tuner, who will adjust them (in an identical instrument) to my wishes in terms of beats per second.
Clearly the tuner was not disregarding BG's customers' instructions but carrying them out faithfully according to her standards. For example, if a customer asks for swing, she sets the highest notes to 1 beat per second and then goes down the scale, diminishing the beats as she goes. (That isn't how I imagined swing but what do I know.) For "swing fort" she sets the beat rate a fraction higher. I checked my accordion carefully and that is exactly what she has done - a beautiful job. The fact that the overall effect says "dry" to my ear (and to the several experienced players I have shown the box to) is the root of the problem.
As a result of this incident, she and BG are planning to devise a means of ensuring that customers understand what they (BG & tuner) mean by the various terms for tuning schemes. Another result is that my high regard for BG's integrity and professionalism has been reinforced, and that I now have a healthy respect for the tuner and her work. And it seems that ruffled feathers on all sides have been smoothed.
Phew...
-
For example, if a customer asks for swing, she sets the highest notes to 1 beat per second and then goes down the scale, diminishing the beats as she goes.
That's pretty much what I would expect from a French or Italian tuner.
I try to avoid terms like swing and its varieties because there is so much scope for misunderstanding. When I'm discussing a customers requirements I much prefer to talk about beats rates, or differences in Hz or cents. Some players aren't happy with that so then I'll ask the customer for a sound clip of their preferred sound. That usually does the trick.
-
It cost me €307 to get it sent over here. For the price of shipping it there and back again, I could hop on a plane and take it there myself!
Steve,
I know just what you mean, I've taken a trip from Ireland to Louisiana to pick up a box before now - but why not have the pleasure of a trip abroad, instead of paying a courier all that money, and if you collect it yourself, at least you get a chance to try it out before you pay for it...
... at one point I fancied having "Dedic" or "Normand Miron" style tuning, which BG doesn't offer ...
But wouldn't that be +/-5 cents? That'd be twice as strong as "swing" - in fact you'd want "Americano" to achieve the same amount of tremolo, though even that wouldn't be wide enough for me. ;)
... if a customer asks for swing, she sets the highest notes to 1 beat per second and then goes down the scale, diminishing the beats as she goes.
Interesting, so it sounds like she's tuning only the highest notes to what I'd think of as "swing", and the lower ones (that you'd probably use more) drier - I'd have thought they should all be tuned to the same number of beats, or even with a touch more tremolo going down the scale. ???
The fact that the overall effect says "dry" to my ear (and to the several experienced players I have shown the box to) is the root of the problem.
That may be partly because of the tuning, and partly the accoustics of the box/the reeds. My own observation would be that the same amount of tremolo can sound very strong on a Hohner, but considerably milder in a box with Italian reeds, especially with very high quality ones like Binci a mano.
As a result of this incident, she and BG are planning to devise a means of ensuring that customers understand what they (BG & tuner) mean by the various terms for tuning schemes.
Following on from what I just said, I think you'd really need to hear the sound of any given tuning with the same reeds and in one of BG's boxes, to fully appreciate what it's going to be like.
-
Just to say that Bertrand is aware of this thread. I think he'll listen and absorb what we say but perhaps not the time to call him 'tone deaf' :D
-
Steve,
No disparaging remarks or criticism of B Gaillard intended.. and certainly not extending my general beliefs about some makers and dealers.
From all I know about Gaillard and a phone conversation with him and faxes some time back... an honorable guy and a respected builder.
It is only the tuning that ever gets any comments. I have never heard a valid negative comment about him or his accordeons.
Given my experience in ordering custom made and high dollar accordeons... there is a short list and Bertrand Gaillard is high on the "A" list
When I decided to get my first quality accordeon I had spoken with Yann Fanch Perroche who said if you can't get a Gaillard ( 2 1/2 row) get a Castagnari Mory..
and save up for a Gaillard.
I can finally afford a Gaillard ,but do I have the time left ? : )
I will also agree that the terms of Dry and swing and demi-swing and semi-dry and Americano and so on should be applied to adult beverages and not accordeon tuning.
I think it is good that Bertrand is aware of this discussion.. and can only serve to improve an already excellent product.
-
I can finally afford a Gaillard ,but do I have the time left ? : )
Yes, BG's 2 year (was three for me, but not his fault) wait certainly adds piquancy to that ol' "an accordion to die for" phrase ;)
I bought mine 'bandonion' incidentally - so no wet/dry issue whatsoever. As you say everything else is hunky dory, and Tuner Paul in Cleckheaton was well inpressed with its insides.
-
I know just what you mean, I've taken a trip from Ireland to Louisiana to pick up a box before now - but why not have the pleasure of a trip abroad, instead of paying a courier all that money, and if you collect it yourself, at least you get a chance to try it out before you pay for it...
Of course, and I had always planned to pick the box up when it was ready. Unfortunately straitened circumstances led to our cancelling the visit to Europe this year, which was why the €307 shipping bill plus the customs handling charge (I would have had to pay Canadian sales tax anyway) was particularly painful.
What I meant by "Dedic/Normand Miron" tuning was, essentially, the same number of beats all the way down the scale. Not sure now if that's Dedic, but it's definitely Miron.
Interesting what you say about reed quality affecting perception of tremolo. It's surely a strange and arcane subject, all this.
As a result of this incident, she and BG are planning to devise a means of ensuring that customers understand what they (BG & tuner) mean by the various terms for tuning schemes.
Following on from what I just said, I think you'd really need to hear the sound of any given tuning with the same reeds and in one of BG's boxes, to fully appreciate what it's going to be like.
That's one of the suggestions I made to him, to let customers hear clips of the various tunings offered - something that Loffet does on his website, incidentally. But since BG doesn't seem to be in a hurry to put up a website, perhaps this is farther down the modern technology road than he wants to go...
-
Many years ago Len Killick would send you tapes ( pre CD) of the various tunings such as dry Swing etc
to help you in ordering a box.
I think this has merit.. particularly for a "hand builder".
-
Just seen this for anybody interested:
http://www.donedeal.ie/for-sale/instruments/946049
I wonder why is it for sale if its brand new? ???
-
Just seen this for anybody interested:
http://www.donedeal.ie/for-sale/instruments/946049
I wonder why is it for sale if its brand new? ???
This fits the description one that was offered on eBay a couple of months ago. Bids got close to €5K but the reserve wasn't met. I mentioned it to BG at the time and asked him if he knew which instrument it was, but he didn't, and didn't seem particularly interested in the proceedings.
If you look at the enlargement of the l-h pic, you can see the superb "book-matching" of the boards on the l-h cabinet. The grain seems to flow around the corner... On mine, you have to look under a strong light to see the join at all, on both r/h and l/h cabinets.
-
I presume it's the same one that was on e-bay a few weeks ago. He was looking for over 5k for it. A nice profit seeing as the current price from BG is 3380! It didn't sell though but he told me he had a buyer for it if e-bay didn't work out.. obviously the sale fell through.
-
http://www.donedeal.ie/for-sale/instruments/946049
'tis indeed a thing of great beauty!
-
Nice bit of profit taking it would seem. I just paid about Eu
460 4600 for mine incl delivery- got 18 basses - and an extra row for less (not for sale) D3R
-
Nice bit of profit taking it would seem. I just paid about Eu 460 for mine ...
Ahem! That seems remarkably good value - I assume you've probably left out a zero Chris... :o
Or should I get my order in fast, before M. Gaillard notices? ???
-
Quote from melodeon
S to Hyde
I never have played on of his boxes but they look a little precious to me
I tried to order one from him but he was so hung up on the aesthetics and not the mechanics I gave up...
what is so difficult about
" I don't care what wood you use but please don't put your name on the front of the box"
That didn't fly.
[/quote]
I know this posting is not about me personally but within is a comment made about my professional “imbalance” that I would like to respond to.
I normally start my discussion with the customer around the outside of the instrument (normally the customer has already told me the keys they would like.) This takes in the aesthetics it also takes in things like size, weight and keyboard style and lay out. I find this is far less intimidating to a lot of people as there are a lot of decisions for the player to make. This process can take months at times with emails going back and forwards. It is during this process that I might find out that the player has a physical disability that allows me to take that into consideration. In my last batch of 10 instruments I had 6 instruments where I was considering a physical or age related factor within the design.
Please remember, I make my instruments 100% to my customer’s specifications; (I have no off the shelf instruments), thus making an instrument that is totally for the customer. I am not trying to get the customer to change playing style to suit my making. I have to start with a clean slate for each instrument I make, and there is no part that I will ignore or trivialize. I give my customers at least a week with the instrument, if it is then not what they wanted then I will give them 100% refund. If there are things they would like to change then I will do that, with no time limit, until they tell me that they are 100% happy with the instrument. At that point I consider the contract for the customer is over, but for me it never ends (I give a lifetime’s guarantee on all the parts made by me,) I will even do changes free of charge when the instrument is on sold to another person, as my guarantee is on the instrument not the player.
Everybody does have different needs in their instruments; I at least try to meet as many of those needs that I can, I have never built 2 instruments the same. There is an old sea going saying, that I sometimes quote to my customers, “if you want jam; you can have jam, if you want marmalade; you can have marmalade.” You make the choice.
Precious; of course they are! Every instrument has its own identity when you have lain in bed at night spending half the night thinking how I’m going to meet the player’s needs, they then become very, very precious.
Just one other thing; I do have instruments out there without my name on it at the request of the customers; of course you would never know that!
Thank you very much; to my customers and friends who have put up the kind words about my work and instruments, we would not be making if it was not for people like you.
-
Stormy,
"Professional Imbalance" ...... your reference suggests that I may have used that phrase; to my recollection, I did not.
When we had a conversation about an accordeon my request was quite simple:
I don't care what wood you use, and yes dark would be fine
23 button 8 bass 2 reed C#/D and a very slight tremolo
I do not want a logo on front of the accordeon or decoration on the bellows which should be black
Nothing more....seemed simple to me and I found no need for continued back and forth
The conversations got bogged down with repeated suggestions about this wood or that.. I didn't care
After several contacts about the tuning and sound I wanted and a seeming misunderstanding on your part, I gave up
It was my understanding that a box made by Hyde would have a Hyde badge... we could not get beyond that to my recollection..
Precious...you can define that as you will.. to me I look for solid and robust in construction and presentation... after viewing a few of your accordeons... I concluded... "precious".. and I consider the aesthetics in contrast to mine
I have made no comments about the quality of your accordeons or about you personally.. specifically about " professional imbalance"
If you can show me where I said that I'll apologize.. that is not a phrase I normally use.
It is simply not true that a maker of anything can please all potential clients.. and not everyone agrees in their views.
This is obviated by Castagnari and Saltarelle and Briggs and Gaillard and a number of other makers who cater to different tastes.
Our tastes differ.. simple as that and as a maker of goods myself, I understand that and accept observations and criticisms as a simple part of life and business.
I am glad others enjoy your accordeons, and wish you continued succcess.
you can always e mail me privately if you wish
jefe46 at earthlink dot net
-
Calm down boys. While this is a bit off the "Gaillard and Loffet" topic I can personally understand the inner need of a maker to beautify his creation. In fact it's an honourable part of the tradition of box making. Sorry you folk couldn't agree on the particular aesthetic concerned, but that's no criticism of anyone.
I've personally had 3 Castagnari boxes over the years - all of which I bought for their build quality and playability. Some of the decor and fru-fru wasn't to my personal taste, but I just took it as it came. Those guys are Italians after all.
To return to our topic - my son thinks Gaillard's grille is really naff and keeps threatening to make me a new one! But will it then still be a Gaillard?
PS: Gaillards all look the same, at least the right end
-
... my son thinks Gaillard's grille is really naff ...
He's not the only one... I was showing my box to a bit of a connoisseur the other day. He admired it greatly but spent a bit of time chuckling about why BG would put such an ugly grille in such a beautiful instrument.
To me the worst part is the square corners - they look atrocious jammed into the beautifully rounded corners of the cabinet. Rounding them would be a big improvement.
I am sure he has settled on them for acoustic reasons. When I visited him prior to ordering my box I asked if he would do different grilles and he quietly but firmly said no, with a nice smile, as if he'd been asked before, but wasn't going to budge.
-
To me the worst part is the square corners - they look atrocious jammed into the beautifully rounded corners of the cabinet. Rounding them would be a big improvement. I am sure he has settled on them for acoustic reasons. When I visited him prior to ordering my box I asked if he would do different grilles and he quietly but firmly said no, with a nice smile, as if he'd been asked before, but wasn't going to budge.
Ditto - I knew about the grille, but asked if he could round off the corners for me "like you used to"? All Gaillards were so rounded off in the early 80's. A polite but essentially Gallic (Gaullique?) "non". I don't know why he's changed, but it is quite defo final. Pity as I thought the old ones were lovely - a bit like Greyhound buses in wood.
-
Stormy,
"Professional Imbalance" ...... your reference suggests that I may have used that phrase; to my recollection, I did not.
I know you did not use that phase but from the statement you made in the original posting you made a comment on my emphasis on the external aesthetics of my instruments.
When we had a conversation about an accordeon my request was quite simple:
I don't care what wood you use, and yes dark would be fine
23 button 8 bass 2 reed C#/D and a very slight tremolo
I do not want a logo on front of the accordeon or decoration on the bellows which should be black
Nothing more....seemed simple to me and I found no need for continued back and forth The conversations got bogged down with repeated suggestions about this wood or that.. I didn't care
After several contacts about the tuning and sound I wanted and a seeming misunderstanding on your part, I gave up.
This is a little strange as at the time we were talking I had exactly what you wanted to order; within the batch on my workbench. As I recall you were trying to get my price down, or were you just “tire kicking”?
I never put any decoration on the bellows and I will order any colour in to suit the customer’s needs, even if it means placing a one of order from Italy.
Tuning and sound: that is in the ear of the beholder, I can guarantee the tuning but I’m unable to guarantee the sound the customer wants. To resolve this I always say to a customer “take it away and play it for 2 weeks, and if you do not like the sound I will give you 100% refund or I will make another instrument” The last thing I need out there is an unhappy customer.
It was my understanding that a box made by Hyde would have a Hyde badge... we could not get beyond that to my recollection.
You are totally wrong here, the only thing I put on for myself as a trade name is “HYDE” (is that not reasonable as everybody puts their trade name on their product’s) I have even made instruments without that where the customer prefers, without getting offended.
Anything else you see are the customers personal Logos, designed by them or by me on their behalf. All this work is done in 100% solid silver plate cut out using a jeweler’s saw. If you do not know: this is a very Old Italian tradition as they used Sicilian Silver Smiths to do the work. I do not profess to be as good as they were but I’m reviving the tradition in my own way, and my customers love it; as 95% want them on. I do not force the other 5% to have them. I enjoy this work and is a nice change after all the saw dust of the dirty workshop, so I put the time into it at my own cost. There is no reduction in the price of my instruments if you do not want personal Logos.
Precious...you can define that as you will.. to me I look for solid and robust in construction and presentation... after viewing a few of your accordeons... I concluded... "precious".. and I consider the aesthetics in contrast to mine
I have made no comments about the quality of your accordeons or about you personally.. specifically about " professional imbalance" If you can show me where I said that I'll apologize.. that is not a phrase I normally use.
Are you saying that my instruments are not solid and robust? Are you able to judge the quality of my instrument from a photo? If you are referring to the fact that I use foam in some (but not all, again customers choice) instruments then have a look at the wave piercing ships that use the same foam, they take one hell of a thrashing!
Australia has a very wide range of good quality timbers that I use, and again the customer can make the choice that suits them or they can supply their own if they would like to. I will even go to wood yards in search of the obscure timber requested by the customer; under my black instrument I mostly use willow.
As I have mentioned before; I make musical instruments not step ladders so I guarantee if you sit or stand on them they will collapse.
You may not have come out directly saying anything about my instruments, but I feel that you inferred a lot, and you certainly said something that was personal to me.
It is simply not true that a maker of anything can please all potential clients.. and not everyone agrees in their views.
This is obviated by Castagnari and Saltarelle and Briggs and Gaillard and a number of other makers who cater to different tastes.
I totally agree with this, and I have total respect for the work of my Peers as I do know how hard this game is, and it is just as well we all make different instruments, otherwise it would be a total waste of time there being more than 1 maker. And it is fantastic that we all have customers who think “we are the greatest thing since sliced bread”
Our tastes differ. simple as that and as a maker of goods myself, I understand that and accept observations and criticisms as a simple part of life and business.
I’m only too willing to accept positive observations and criticisms, as it is this feed back that has driven my designs, but you made statements on a newsgroup site and not to me personally I only found it as the result of a Google search, so as far as I’m concerned this makes it very negative, as It was a one sided conversation excluding me.
I am glad others enjoy your accordeons, and wish you continued succcess.
you can always e mail me privately if you wish
jefe46 at earthlink dot net
I do not think so, you put it out into the public arena so I will discuss this out there as well, as I have no idea as to who you are or your agenda.
Stormy
-
It saddens me to see that this simple request for info on the Gaillard and Loffet has got a little bit personal at times.
I have nothing but respect for Stormy in my brief dealings with him. He came across as a genuine helpful and sincere person. In no way did I want this to reflect negatively on anyone. I simply wanted to know what were the experiences of those who played either the Loffet or Gaillard.
Having said that I did order the Gaillard and now I am dealing with the waiting bit. I sold my Paolo and happily play my Loffet. I would love to have a Hyde as well but went for a punt on the Gaillard. Maybe in the future a Hyde two row may beckon me.
Takes me at least two or three months to work up the courage to talk to my wife about any new additions to my accordion family.
I have appreciated all the helpful info that has been provided. I am reminded that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. On man trash is another ones treasure and so on.