I know all you B/C/C# players will cringe at the very thought but.......................
I have been asked by a customer for a Shand Morino in A/D/G.
Best shoot the bugger ! ::)
george
And even if it did, would it be?
Accordions of London has this Brandoni offering. What is under the hood of this two row? Gold??
http://www.accordionsoflondon.com/index.php?page=shop.product_details&flypage=shop.flypage2&product_id=337&category_id=17&manufacturer_id=0&option=com_virtuemart&Itemid=26
Okay an inherently pointless, meaningless "define your terms" sort of question, but are there any contenders to higher rank on the push-pull accordions tree than the Shand Morino?
(Grey Paolo for one? Any one-rows with legendary status? A Briggs?)
Accordions of London has this Brandoni offering. What is under the hood of this two row? Gold??
http://www.accordionsoflondon.com/index.php?page=shop.product_details&flypage=shop.flypage2&product_id=337&category_id=17&manufacturer_id=0&option=com_virtuemart&Itemid=26
OMG - £5900.00 for that tacky-looking, shamrock-bedecked object... :o(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/BrandoniEmerald.jpg)
...why, it makes my 1930s Baldoni, Bartoli look almost tasteful! ;D(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P1020945.jpg)
To be fair it is a two row with Stradella bass, which is unusual.
If I am reading this thread aright, I don't understand the dissing of the ADG with a stradella bass.
Loads of people only play in these keys and to have a chromatic bass would be fantastic. Part of the point ,as it were, of a stradella bass is not only to be able to accompany the right hand in any key , but also to be able to do runs,counter melodies, tunes etc in whatever key you choose on the left hand. So if you limit your chosen keys to ADG & the minors, it doesn't mean you necessarily want to limit your choice of chords etc.
I often wonder if there were more choices on the market for a 2 1/2 row or three row with a stradella bass, what the current young melodeon whizz bangs would do with it. I think they do incredibly creative stuff with the 8,12 or 18 buttons as it is. To listen to a gifted accordion player is sometimes to be like listening to two players.
Regards
Robin
PS I used to know a Morris Musician ( Dolphin , I think ) who played a Paulo Soprani ADG with a full bass and wonderful music he made.
There is nothing wrong with stradella bass systems for ADG accordions. But you don't need 120 basses for 3 keys. 48 bass could give all the notes you need plus a few extras. With Counter basses, fundementals, majors, minors, 7ths & diminished chords.
OK, so all you Stradella fans: 48 bass boxes appear to come in 12x4 and 8x6 varieties. Which is a better choice as the left hand of a B/C/C# (or even the LH of a mythical 2 1/2 row with Stradella bass). Why?
I do find it very hard to contemplate the idea of a bass that doesn't automatically fall more-or-less right as you play, though.
OK, so all you Stradella fans: 48 bass boxes appear to come in 12x4 and 8x6 varieties. Which is a better choice as the left hand of a B/C/C# (or even the LH of a mythical 2 1/2 row with Stradella bass). Why?Can't claim this is first hand, but I'm told the lack of B minor is a problem for the 8x6 48 bass layout?
I do find it very hard to contemplate the idea of a bass that doesn't automatically fall more-or-less right as you play, though.
Can't claim this is first hand, but I'm told the lack of B minor is a problem for the 8x6 48 bass layout?
Tom
There is however lot to be said for keeping it simple but well played rather than complicated & a bit iffy.
OK, so all you Stradella fans: 48 bass boxes appear to come in 12x4 and 8x6 varieties. Which is a better choice as the left hand of a B/C/C# (or even the LH of a mythical 2 1/2 row with Stradella bass). Why?
I do find it very hard to contemplate the idea of a bass that doesn't automatically fall more-or-less right as you play, though.
- one of my favourite youtube clips is of this guy (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cqno1poU9Io) who certainly knows how to play a classic bass line that counterpoints the melody -
I do find it very hard to contemplate the idea of a bass that doesn't automatically fall more-or-less right as you play, though.
If you're stuck with 8x6 it might be worth moving the reeds around so that instead of going E-flat to E it goes B-flat to B.QuoteCan't claim this is first hand, but I'm told the lack of B minor is a problem for the 8x6 48 bass layout?
Tom
Yes, I would definitely go along with George's argument that the 12 x 4 variety would be much better. Would certainly be more useful to me than an 8 x 6 layout (which is what I use currently and am frustrated with its limitations). When faced with the above difficulty I just doodle around with D when really I need a Bminor chord. It sort of works but it ain't right. The B row with D# counterbass would be really useful.
AL
If you're stuck with 8x6 it might be worth moving the reeds around so that instead of going E-flat to E it goes B-flat to B.
it alll depends on the type of music you want to play. For dance music where the emphasis is on generating good rhythm with reasonable harmony anything more than the facility to play the 3 chord trick is a bonus. As athe bass notes should be played 'short & crisp' and turgidity avoided at all costs then by definition none of the bass notes are going to last more than a fraction of a second so it could be argued that a lot of fancy chords are wasted as the punters will not even notice them being played.
On the other hand for song accompanyment or perhaps for 'sunday best' solo playing of slower stuff playing rich harmony with longish bass notes can ( but doesn't automatically) add to the proceedings and may add to the players ssense of satisfaction. There is however lot to be said for keeping it simple but well played rather than complicated & a bit iffy.
george
Personally I use a massive mix of bass technique. I never really make a conscious decision, but sometimes it ends up being punchy unison bass (bass and chord together) or oompah or else longer notes as Ian describes. The latter is something that I need to work on, as my bass work does tend to be a bit too stabby at times.
If you're stuck with 8x6 it might be worth moving the reeds around so that instead of going E-flat to E it goes B-flat to B.QuoteCan't claim this is first hand, but I'm told the lack of B minor is a problem for the 8x6 48 bass layout?
Tom
Yes, I would definitely go along with George's argument that the 12 x 4 variety would be much better. Would certainly be more useful to me than an 8 x 6 layout (which is what I use currently and am frustrated with its limitations). When faced with the above difficulty I just doodle around with D when really I need a Bminor chord. It sort of works but it ain't right. The B row with D# counterbass would be really useful.
AL
.....then again, would it work to move all the reeds to the next fifth around the circle so that you lose a row from the "flat" end but gain the B row at the "sharp" end.
Too late in the eve to work out in my head whether that would work!
Tom
Edit: If it did work it would mean the C row is one step along from normal etc.
Tom B-R: Trust me, I've looked into this in some detail, it's easier to change the reeds, which are waxed in, than the pins, which are soldered on.
I now recall that you're a bass enthusiast so giving up your E-flat might be more of a blow than it might be to most. Maybe you need two sets of reedblocks. Or to buy my Trichord and my CBA and swap the treble reeds.
I don't quite understand - where do I get the B reeds from?
AL
But since its just the bass reeds you will need it should be quite feasible to retune by adding or removing weights from the reed tips. The reeds in each bank of bass reeds are all the same size, so retuning by this method will not compromise reed response
If you're stuck with 8x6 it might be worth moving the reeds around so that instead of going E-flat to E it goes B-flat to B.which made me think that what was being suggested was that the B row could be obtained by juggling around what is already in situ rather than going out and buying a new set of reeds.
.QuoteI now recall that you're a bass enthusiast so giving up your E-flat might be more of a blow than it might be to most. Maybe you need two sets of reedblocks. Or to buy my Trichord and my CBA and swap the treble reeds.
Have thought about having an interchangeable set of reed blocks - not really feasible for quick changes. Already have the trichord - but am thinking about selling it to help purchase another BCC# instrument rather than try to adapt it.
BTW you're right - Eb is a must for me and all the stuff that I play.
AL
I now recall that you're a bass enthusiast so giving up your E-flat might be more of a blow than it might be to most. Maybe you need two sets of reedblocks. Or to buy my Trichord and my CBA and swap the treble reeds.
Sorry, that should have been brass enthusiast.A weasy mistake to make ;D
That looks like a reasonable price as well, let us know what it's like :P
The Will Starr box that Brandon plays has a fourth row of buttons on the melody side. What do they do and was this a one off.
The Will Starr box that Brandon plays has a fourth row of buttons on the melody side. What do they do and was this a one off.
AFAIK they do nothing, they're dummies.