Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: DoninOhio on March 19, 2016, 12:51:33 PM

Title: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: DoninOhio on March 19, 2016, 12:51:33 PM
I love almost everything about my Hohner HA114 4-stopper. The size, weight, the keyboard being smaller. The only issues being the cheap  wood in the build, the plastic keyboard and  the use of spring clips on the treble rather than the coil spring and lever system found on
hand- made accordions. My question is why are there no builders - with the exception of Rees Wesson - who make a "handmade" that is the same size/dimensions of a HA114, rather than the larger, heavier and bulkier "Cajun-style" accordions. I know a few Quebec builders lean in that direction, but it seems even Quebec builders use the Cajun style similar to the old GLOBES, etc of years past. 
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: benammiswift on March 19, 2016, 12:59:11 PM
It maybe something to do with tradition rather than them not wanting to do it. The Castagnari 'melodeon' or Max is another example of a small 1 row 4 voice but without the coil springs and cheap wood used on the Hohners.

It may also be something to do with how the reeds are seated as the hohner 1 row i have has two upright melodeon reed blocks like a two row whereas a lot of Cajun 1 rows have a single upright reed block and the other 2 reed sets lie flat either side of the upright block and Binci reeds tend to be long scale reeds as well I believe so this could be where the extra depth comes from. This is just a guess though and maybe completely incorrect so take it with a pinch of salt.

Benammi
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: Lester on March 19, 2016, 01:20:34 PM
The Castagnari 'melodeon' or Max is another example of a small 1 row 4 voice but without the coil springs and cheap wood used on the Hohners.
This may have a bearing on the quality differential.

Castagnari Max - £1795
Hohner 114 - £750

Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: triskel on March 19, 2016, 05:05:39 PM
Seeing that I've played on all the boxes your talking about, and have owned all but one of 'em, I'm sitting here scratching me noggin. (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Smileys/ponder2.gif)

A Globe Gold Medal is slightly taller (at 11 1/2") it is true, but Cajun boxes aren't modelled on Globes, they're based on the Sterling and Monarch models that were the best accordions available in their part of the U.S. back in the day.

The Sterling and Monarch, and the modern Cajun copies of them (like my Acadian), are 11" tall, which is exactly the same height as a Hohner 114.

Depthwise they are all 1/4" bigger (at 6 1/4") than the Hohner, but that's not really noticeable and helps accomodate 2 banks of reeds that are "laid flat" for a stronger (and to my mind "proper") melodeon tone.

Whilst, as the very happy owner of a 1920's Globe Gold Medal that's in excellent condition and fully playable, I can vouch that the old melodeons produced by International Accordion had a sound that was streets ahead of anything else (then or now) - including Hohner!
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: Lars on March 20, 2016, 11:00:50 AM
Marcel Messervier used to make some rather small 4 voice LMMH models decades ago, though it seems that he (and his son) now make mostly full size boxes. I had the pleasure of trying out a very small, red and blue 4 voice, a while ago, and it would knock your socks off with power to spare. That being said, the larger more recent Messervier a friend of mine has sounds great too.

Another well known Quebec maker is Reynald Oulliet (sp?), maker of the Melodié brand. The ones I've seen have all been rather small size boxes for a 4 voice LMMH box.

I think it's worth keeping in mind, that the size of a box has a lot to do with how the sound develops before leaving the box. I like the fuller sound of a somewhat large box, though my back and shoulders prefer smaller sizes.
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: mselic on March 20, 2016, 04:27:24 PM
I, too, prefer the size of the HA114s over most other cajun-style boxes.  I used to own a beautiful, Quebec hand-made 4-stop box that was rather large and heavy.  With Binci reeds, it certainly sounded loud and brash.  However, I sold it on and I was happy to return to the compact feel of the HA114, despite its shortcomings.  I don't much like the stiff action of the keyboard on the HA114s, but I like its size, weight and feel.  And I actually love the spoon basses, as opposed to the buttons.

I've also played a Beltuna 4-stopper, and it was considerably quieter and with a more "civilized" sound than the Hohner.  It was a bigger box than the Hohner, but not as loud.  I'm assuming that the type of reeds used make a bigger difference on the volume than the size of the box.

I have to admit that the 1-row box that felt the nicest and most comfortable in my hands was the Hohner Cajun IV model.  It was about $100 cheaper than a new HA114, and I seriously considered getting one, but it had a rather quiet sound and was only available in the key of C.  The action was lightning quick and smooth.  I have toyed with the idea of buying one and having someone replace the reeds with something better (and a different key, such as low G).  Is that at all a reasonable idea? Anyone?
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: Lars on March 20, 2016, 04:35:13 PM
The size of a box will not do much to the volume, but it will have an effect on the tone. I too have seen some modern full-size boxes with a 'dead' sound, but I think it was the fact, that it was very thich hardwood throughout. On the other hand, similar size boxes such as the Acadian belonging to Triskel, are very loud.

I have heard mixed reviews regarding the Cajun IV - it could be a hit or miss, but the general consensus in the opinions I've heard were, that they just about all needed some adjusting to compete with other boxes in the same pricerange. Whatever floats your boat, and if you are going to have the reeds replaced anyways, finding one with an action you like, and good bellows will be a good starting point. Try before you buy, and try as many different brands as you can - affordable or not:)
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: blafleur on March 20, 2016, 07:48:00 PM
In my limited experience, the size of the box did affect volume.  The Cajun style "9 button" boxes are a good bit smaller than the standard Cajun size, and noticeably louder.  I've never quite understood why it's louder, but it is.
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: rees on March 20, 2016, 09:09:53 PM
Thanks for the mention, Don.

Yes, I make the Wesson Windjammer which is a copy of a HA114 including bellows frames and upright reed-blocks.
Also, the Clipper, same size as a Castagnari Max but with Cajun style end-frames and reed orientation.
Finally, the Corvette which is a full-size Cajun accordion.
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: rileycat on March 21, 2016, 06:20:48 PM
And very, very nice too, Rees (v. happy new Corvette owner)
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: melodeon on March 22, 2016, 03:27:17 PM
I had been experimenting with box size and had built a few prototypes, starting with full sized "Cajun" and finally with a smaller size utilizing the 9 button "Cajun" sized bellows.
This proved to be my favorite both in handling,  tone  and volume.

I sold my remaining stocks of reeds and bellows to Bryan which included a "9 button" bellows.

Should I go back to building, this is where I would start.. the smaller "9 button " bellows.
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: tirpous on March 22, 2016, 05:55:39 PM
So standard Cajun bellows are 6-1/4" x 11".  What is the size of bellows for the smaller 9-button type ?

Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: tirpous on March 22, 2016, 06:07:51 PM
I knew I had a picture somewhere: this is the treble end of a Mélodie 4-voice.  They can cut down on the width by using a V-layout for the (no longer) flat blocks.

   
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: melodeon on March 22, 2016, 07:42:43 PM
The 9 button bellows  is shorter by a good inch (25.4mm) if not a little more.
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: gettabettabox on March 22, 2016, 09:36:52 PM
desert island scenario...you can only take one box?...well it's got to be the HA114 i reckon, but which one?... has to be the C box.
the D box is normally ''numero uno'' but it's unlikely that there will be many sessions there.
Title: Re: Builders Don't copy Hohner HA114 Design?
Post by: Rog on March 23, 2016, 07:04:24 AM
I had been experimenting with box size and had built a few prototypes, starting with full sized "Cajun" and finally with a smaller size utilizing the 9 button "Cajun" sized bellows.
This proved to be my favorite both in handling,  tone  and volume.

I sold my remaining stocks of reeds and bellows to Bryan which included a "9 button" bellows.

Should I go back to building, this is where I would start.. the smaller "9 button " bellows.

My idea is to make a Lilliput sized two row... :D
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal