Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Mike Higgins on June 14, 2009, 02:40:55 PM
-
Hi
Does anyone know of musical notation software which will work on Linux platforms? Obviously I could type ABC in a text editor but I was thinking more on the lines of something which will produce a conventional score.
-
There's a list of potential candidates on this site. (http://www.hitsquad.com/smm/linux/NOTATION/)
-
Lilypond is the one I think.
AL
-
Lilypond is the one I think.
AL
That's true. and you can get it to read ABC. There's also Rosegarden. I haven't tried it, but it was mentioned a lot when I was looking at midi software for Linux.
-
I've loaded Lilypond and Rosegarden but have not had time to play yet due to work commitments. I'll report back when I've tried them properly. Thank you Bill and Al for the tip off.
Mike
-
I've loaded Lilypond and Rosegarden but have not had time to play yet due to work commitments. I'll report back when I've tried them properly. Thank you Bill and Al for the tip off.
Mike
I have used Lilypond (compiled for the Mac rather than Linux, but I'm sure it's very similar). I have only scratched the surface, but even as a rank beginner the output is relatively pretty compared to other options. (Our little tunebook at http://www.walthamstowfolk.co.uk/walthamstow-folk-tune-book.pdf (http://www.walthamstowfolk.co.uk/walthamstow-folk-tune-book.pdf) is my main Lilypond output so far). It does not make any concessions to user-friendliness really.
-
I have extreme difficulties getting any kind of midi output from Lilypond - the Jack Server app required does not seem at all useful - possibly beuse I am running under Ubuntu. I may try installing Kubuntu and going from there.
-
I have extreme difficulties getting any kind of midi output from Lilypond - the Jack Server app required does not seem at all useful - possibly beuse I am running under Ubuntu. I may try installing Kubuntu and going from there.
I've just been through that hoop trying to get my melodeon program to work in Ubuntu. I didn't realise that my sound card doesn't have a synthesiser on it before. If you double click on a midi file, totem movie player pops up and prompts you to let it find a plugin to play it. When you say yes, it installs a raft of gstreamer plugins including the one to play midi. Then just putting the pointer over a midi file will play it. None of that helped my program, I ended up using fluidsynth. I couldn't get anywhere with Jack either. I don't think loading Kubuntu will help, the sound back end is probably the same.
I tried lilypond a long time ago when I was looking to see what was available. It produces very high quality output which is a bit over the top if you just want to notate the tune that somebody played at the session last night so the other half can learn it too. Also if, you already know ABC, it's yet another slightly more obscure notation language to learn.
-
Lilypond is definitely top end. More akin music engraving than a simple notation system. I've never really managed to make it work with my windows setup - just not techi enough I guess.
AL
-
I am just re-constructing my Ubuntu system after loading Kubuntu. Kubuntu is not stable, does not happily update itself and does not have anything to offer over and above the Gnome system that is Ubuntu.
My system (apparently) also doe not have a synthesizer. Windows recognises it, Ubuntu does not. Jack cannot find the jack server - which is not available as a manual download. The motherboard has a Realtek sound device on board which IS a midi synthesiser - honest!
I am contemplating loading up Personal Composer (OK - anything for a laugh) under WINE and have got "Timidity" to run - though not with everything. I'd LIKE the time to play - and when I get it I'll report back.
Meantime, if anyone else has anything useful on the subject, please pass it on!!!!