Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: AndyinCombwich on April 08, 2016, 06:49:49 PM
-
Just acquired a 25 year old Swiss made melodeon. Sounds wonderful but the bass keys are old style now obsolete (G#, D# etc.). I'm new to melodeon playing, but was expecting the new format - I did ask before buying, and feel I was a bit misled. Does anyone know the pros and cons of this tuning, and why it was changed? I intend playing mainly Irish folk but I do like playing the occasional bass note and not sure how this works with these chords and notes.
Also, I was watching one of the Derek Hickey tutor videos on you tube, and found that the treble keys were also different, although I think my melodeon is the more usual - i.e. the D is on the 3rd button, not the fourth.
Very interested to hear any opinions about this.
-
You're saying you have a layout that matches this: http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/BC21hohnerbass.gif ?
If so that layout is good for playing in the keys of C and B. This bass layout isn't very good for playing in the keys of D and G which is what ~80% or more of all Irish trad is. If you're playing on your own then it shouldn't be an issue and you can play in whatever key you want but to use the bass and play with others you might run into trouble.
I don't know the Derek Hickey video but if his was a 4th button start it probably is a 23 button accordion instead of the more common 21 button. It'll have the same keys but an extra button on the low end of each row. If you're following the tutorial and he's mentioning numbers you can simply shift each number over once to match your keyboards layout.
-
... the bass keys are old style now obsolete (G#, D# etc.).
... Does anyone know the pros and cons of this tuning, and why it was changed?
...I intend playing mainly Irish folk but I do like playing the occasional bass note and not sure how this works with these chords and notes.
Hohner didn't have any great understanding of how the B/C system was used for Irish music.
That old bass system was designed for playing the B row as the primary row, which of course is not how
Irish music is meant to be played on a B/C box.
Check out these layouts (http://squeezehead.com/keyboard-layouts/basses/LAYOUTS.html) as a better alternative if you decide to have your bass rejigged.
-
the double ray ( not the double ray delux) with 12 stradella was/is a great improvement on the much more common 8 bass version. Bass for CGDA plus a bit for F & E and no need to worry about bellows direct either. Great for Scottish stuff but for some reason never popular in Ireland
george
-
...aye, the old style Hohner Double - Ray Basses aren't terribly good for anything...the C/G basses and chords can be stabbed at for most stuff in G and will sound ok...don't even bother with the other six Bass buttons... 8)
I've lived with this on my Black Dot Double-Ray for years...(and my Deluxe). However I have taken the plunge and sent the Bass Reed Blocks off to a Melodeon fettler of this parish for retuning in the modern layout...
..but don't be too concerned...you'll have plenty to learn on the treble side before worrying about the Basses...
...and enjoy the Double-ray...they're great instruments with a wonderful heritage...plenty players have gone through their whole careers not worrying about the Basses... :D
-
Thanks for all the useful information. I have decided to send it back and try and get one with sensible bass tunings. I know a lot of Irish players don't use the bass keys, but I think they add a lot if not playing with a band (Annette Owens for example). Anyone have any views on a modern Hohner black dot (made in China) as compared with German and Swiss makes?