Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: dino.pafftti on April 15, 2016, 10:10:33 AM
-
Hey people!!!
The new system, treble key lever ,bearing...
What do you think ?? Perhaps a good,, ??? Perhaps the bearing build-up of dirt,,??
-
Yes that looks very strong and stiff. Should make an action with a very positive feel. Is it available from Carini, or somewhere else?
-
That's the system available from Slovenia - I bought a set a few years ago.
I found that the supplied rod was a little loose in the brass ferrules, and I ended up drilling/reaming out to a slightly larger diameter.
It took some tweaking to drill the holes for the springs, but once the springs were there, the system worked pretty well.
I ended up using the 'Carini'-system instead, where the fulcrum-rod fits in the brass clip, rather than through the solid brass nut. It found that the fit around the pivot point was too hard to get 'right', and despite being a good solid construction, I ended up with a slightly wobbly feel. Perhaps you need better tools and/or skills than me to ream out the centre holes, and if you can get that 100% wobble-free, it's a pretty good mechanism.
-
It took some tweaking to drill the holes for the springs, but once the springs were there, the system worked pretty well.
I think I can see holes for springs already in these levers.
What kind of reamer did you use Lars?
-
http://vsezaharmoniko.com/mehanika-za-harmoniko/diskant-mehanika
I have a 3 mm reamer,, and 3 mm silver steel stick,,
There will be a very good (:)
-
looks a bit heavy? Would holes save weight without loss of strength?
-
I made a reamer out of the same hardened steel I used as fulcrum rod. Tapered with a file, and roughed the surface with 1200 grit sandpaper. Took forever, but good results. By using the same rod as base for a reamer, I was sure that the final size of the hole would be perfect.
Not all levers has holes for the spring. Out of a set of just under 40 levers I bought, only 3 had holes for the springs.
-
Surely, if you managed to taper it with a file, you could also have filed in a spiral cutting edge? It would have made the reaming much quicker and easier.
-
Straight cutting edges can work very well, especially in brass, if you go for multiple cutting edges make sure to use an uneven number (5 is traditional for clock / watchwork which tends to mean holes in brass) helically# edged reamers are a comparatively modern tool !
Silver steel* can be filed to shape, water hardened and then oilstoned to attain the cutting edge, easy sharpness test method, try to gently push the cutting edge along a finger or thumbnail, if it digs in then its sharp, if it slides, go back to the oilstone for a while.
A favourite simple reamer for model engineers is made by filing an oblique flat surface of about 30 degrees on the endpart of a bit of silver steel, the face ends up as an elongated oval** - normally for lathe use but if these arms are clamped and the bit run through them from a drill in a stand ought to work, I have never tried one hand held and suspect in a short bush the hole might wander.
Hope the project works out well
#Helix, think screw thread, Spiral, think record groove ;)
* Known as Drill rod in the US of A - High carbon, water quenchable steel, ground to a very close tolerance for making drills reamers punches, chisels and other accurately sized or easily hardened items from.
**A 1/4" reamer of this pattern worn too short for further use is the weapon of choice for cleaning grot from finger nails hereabouts (:)
-
Surely, if you managed to taper it with a file, you could also have filed in a spiral cutting edge? It would have made the reaming much quicker and easier.
Sure, but I found that the tapered end with nothing more than a roughed (with grit 1200) surface gave a nice and very clean inner surface. I only had to take it out from 2.8 mm to 3.0 mm.
-
Mind you, I was only working with rubbishy old wood, as well. I've still got to figure out a way to get the axle out of a no-name 2-row when I get back.
-
Applying heat to the end of the rod often softens the old grub and dirt enough to get it out. And patience, determination, and a few coffee breaks when it's not working:)
-
For the usual 3mm (actually 2.98 or 2.99 mm!) rod as can be obtained from Carini a 3.00 reamer will guarantee a wobbly lever. You must start with a 2.97 reamer and then work your way up with (home made) reaming rods and fine oiled steel wool more or less as described by Lars. Reaming is tricky business and requires quite some practice and patience. Among other things it is vital to continuously remove any brass residue that will inevitably appear on the steel rods during the process.
-
The shaft silver steel 2.98 m
reamer 3.0mm
loose 1 mm .. away from the shaft 130 mm
Is it too much
-
Any lateral movement is too much. You must start with a 2.97 reamer.
-
OK. thank you for doing this to me difficult... :'(
maybe fine Trizact Compound ???
-
http://www.ebay.com/itm/2-98MM-2-99MM-HRC40-CUTTING-SOLID-CARBIDE-REAMERS-SET-/171712963127?hash=item27fae3e237:g:kfkAAOSwBLlU~aW0
opinion about this ?? 2.98-2.99 mm
-
I'd be very unhappy about having to clart-on with reaming brand new gear! Surely they should be a good enough fit from the factory? I'd certainly be asking the manufacturers why they weren't, if they aren't.
Reaming the individual pivots could prove to be very awkward without constructing some sort of jig to keep them perfectly aligned. Considering the length of the arms, it wouldn't take very much of a misalignment at the pivot to render them almost useless by the time they reach the button or the pallet.
Google Translate to Finnish:
Olisin hyvin tyytymättömiä ottaa hyytymään kanssa väljentäminen uusi vaihde! Varmasti ne pitäisi olla tarpeeksi hyvä istuvuus tehtaalta? Olisin varmasti kysyä valmistajilta, miksi ne eivät olleet, jos ne eivät ole.
Väljentäminen yksittäiset kääntyy voi osoittautua erittäin hankala ilman rakentaa jonkinlaista jigi pitää ne täysin suorassa. Ottaen huomioon varsien pituus, se ei ota kovin paljon on vinoutuminen on pivot niiden tekemiseksi lähes hyödytön, kun he saavuttavat painiketta tai lavan.
-
this is difficult, I have Italian bearing hole 3.0 mm shaft 2.98,5 Slovakian bearing, bore 29.8mm,, axis of 2.97 mm..
I think that this axis that I have silver steel, 2.98 m in diameter the same hole Slovakian bearing :M :D
very small grinding,,
-
A close-up of my 2.97mm reamer. I bought this and others quite some years ago in one of Castelfidardo's hardware shops and even after having been used on close to 8000 levers it's still as good as new. It must be used as a hand tool, so don't put it on an electric drill.
Carini too can supply these (reamer =alesatore), price used to be around EUR 100 per piece, probably even more expensive today. There is also a Swiss manufacturer (Wyss).
-
Being a bit taken aback by the 100 Euro price tag, I looked on eBay for a 2.97 mm reamer and was taken almost straight to this:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/GUHRING-H7-496-2-97mm-HSS-E-INTERMEDIATE-SS-CHUCKING-REAMER-MACHINE-/221370323253?hash=item338ab31135:g:KKUAAOxyVLNS9i22
£15 sounds a lot better to me!
-
Thanks for the tip - certainly worth trying! But as a principle I'm always willing to pay a good deal more if it helps me do a better job in less time.
-
A UK company called Rotagrip Ltd supply Swiss made chucking reamers in 0.01mm increments at about £20 or so each:
http://www.rotagriponline.com/index.php?option=com_virtuemart&page=shop.browse&category_id=1111&keyword=&manufacturer_id=0&Itemid=29&orderby=product_name&limitstart=90
Bear in mind though that these (and the ebay example) are machine reamers, which have a different profile to a hand reamer.
It's highly unlikely you'd get a totally true, concentric and accurately sized hole using them by hand!
Making small holes a perfect fit with no friction AND no wobble is not easy at all.
-
Chinese reamer good, 2.98mm,, bearing a highly accurate,
But the dry bearing is not good.. Can I put a little oil in a thin, maybe gun oil ??
I understand that the bearing made of brass sheet metal does not need oil.
but my bearing brass body, a length of 6.5 mm needs a little oil ?? too much friction
if no oil, have a little enlarge the holes ??
-
Out of curiosity I ordered the 2.97 reamer discovered on eBay by Edward. After having tried it out on a few new levers I'm very happy with the result! Thanks again for the tip.
Dino: your 2.98 reamer is just a little too thick. As I've pointed out already: for the usual "3mm" rod begin with a 2.97 reamer, then continue with suitable steel rods-turned-reamers. I use two different such rods, both are (or have become) a fraction thinner than the final rod. After regular treatment with fine sand paper they can be turned into perfect precision reamers. My point is that, if you want to avoid lateral movement, you cannot go straight from your 2.98 (or any other size!) Chinese reamer to the final rod. I don't use oil during reaming, just some lubricant (applied with fine steel wool) on the final rod.
-
I regret, I guess people do not understand my English ::)
but this is an interesting thing ..
but I wonder, I ordered Italy to treble the levers,,+ shaft.. 2.98 mm shaft,, bearing 3.0mm,,Loose :-\
Slovak lever, bearing 2.98mm,,,,, Slovak shaft 2.97mm Loose???
I shaft silver steel, 2.98, but about 1/100 mm throw 2.98-2.99 mm,
Drive is not quite round,, I have a Chinese calvin yes very good, there is no lateral wobble,,
however, I would like to know whether the precision-milled shaft, 2.98mm or 2.99 mm for sale in..
why the Italians are already selling loose bearings ??? 2/100 mm,,
-
Have you tried complaining to the Italian suppliers? Surely they should not be selling mis-matched components?
Oletko yrittänyt valittaa Italian toimittajat? Varmasti niitä ei pitäisi myydä täsmäämättömään komponentteja?
-
I'm sorry it is not possible nor is it desirable to order levers and perfectly fitting rods, just as it is not possible to order perfectly tuned reeds. That's where we box makers/tuners start earning our money...
-
so it certainly is,,, but I think I can get a good enough of these needs (:)